❌

Normal view

Spanish election: How bad is the housing crisis? 

11 November 2026 at 04:00

Spain will grind to a halt in its first general strike in 14 years on Wednesday, just weeks before voters head to the polls in a snap election. At the center of both the strike and vote, one issue looms especially large: unaffordable housing.

Anger over the crisis boiled over in September, following the eviction of an elderly woman from the Madrid home in which she had lived since 1956. Hundreds of thousands of people took to the streets in nationwide protests, prompting Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez to submit a long-delayed housing bill to the Spanish parliament. When lawmakers rejected the legislation, he decided to send voters to the polls. 

“Every generation has its struggle,” Sánchez said during a rally shortly after calling the snap vote. “Ours is housing, and we will solve it, backed by the strength of the people.”

“We must look upwards at those in the penthouses and those who run vulture funds and put an end to their speculative practices and abuses,” he added, calling for voters to unite to protect “small property owners and tenants.”

It is no wonder Sánchez has attempted to seize on the topic of housing in a bid to be reelected. The high price of homes is at the forefront of voters’ minds: the most recent data shows house prices are double what they were at the same time in 2015; the average Spaniard doesn’t leave their parental home until after their 30th birthday; and in some historic centers tourist accommodation accounts for 45% of the rental market.  

His big challenge, however, is that he could end up blamed for the problem exploding during his more than eight years in office. Between 2015 and 2025, average home prices in Spain rose by 80%, while salaries increased by only 30%. A pledge to use “all state resources” to provide 184,000 public and affordable rental homes has been difficult to realize.

And yet, on many metrics, Spain’s housing struggles are not even the worst in Europe. Rising rents and home prices across the bloc are fueling discontent and setting the stage for affordability to become a key issue in a string of elections set for the coming year. 

Here’s everything you need to know:  

Between 2015 and 2025, house prices in Spain rose 80%, according to Eurostat’s house price index. The first half of 2026 made this figure even starker: by the second quarter of this year, prices were around double what they were at the same time in 2015. 

Rents have also risen across the country, with urban regions and tourist hotspots seeing some of the biggest rent hikes over the past 10 years. 

Academics trace the roots of Spain’s housing crisis to the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis: while ordinary homebuyers struggled to get mortgages, large-scale investors began buying up property, speculating and driving up prices.  

“The cash didn’t disappear from the market; it just ended up in the hands of investors,” said Spanish National Research Council housing expert Javier Gil. “What we see in Spain is a new cycle led by speculative, non-residential demand.”

Combine that with growing populations in major cities, social housing stock issues, and tourist housing, which the national bank estimates accounts for about 10% of the already small rental market, and Spaniards really feel the pinch.  

Young people make up one of the key groups struggling to find their place in the Spanish housing market. In 2025, 67% of people aged between 18 and 34 still lived with their parents and almost half of the 26-34-year-olds in this position cited the inability to afford to rent or buy as the principal reason for their living situation.  

“The prices just keep rising and rising, and landlords take advantage of the system to take advantage of tenants,” said Jorge Collado, a 26-year-old who took part in a massive protest encampment housing demonstrators set up in Madrid’s central Puerta del Sol square.  

The university student said he had been forced to move back to his family’s home after his former landlord dramatically raised the monthly rent when he requested a legal rental contract. “We’re fed up with this situation, and the politicians aren’t doing anything to solve this.” 

Although stark, Spain’s house price increases are not even the highest in Europe, Research Director at Housing Europe Alice Pittini warns, pointing to Eastern European countries that have seen “tremendous increases” in recent years. 

Similarly, rents increased in every EU member state between 2025 and the first half of this year. In fact, rent rises across Spain during this period were relatively modest compared with most other EU countries, when national averages are considered.  

While Sánchez has bet his career on converting public anger over housing into votes for his party, it will be a difficult sell given the price rises during his time in office. 

“Changes in housing policy have the tendency to see the impact of the policies […] much, much later. So it’s something that I think is always a tricky field for politicians,” Pittini points out.  

Given that the housing problem is plaguing various other European countries and has already taken center stage in local elections in Berlin and national elections in the Netherlands, it seems set to remain at the top of the agenda as many Europeans prepare to go to the polls next year. 

Can this progressive YIMBY fix one city’s ludicrous housing prices?

9 November 2026 at 22:20
Nithya Raman speaks into a microphone with her fist raised behind a bright yellow “Nithya for LA Mayor” campaign sign against a blue-lit backdrop.
Los Angeles Mayor-elect Nithya Raman at an election night party, November 3, 2026. | Sarah Reingewirtz/MediaNews Group/Los Angeles Daily News via Getty Images

It’s notoriously hard to govern Los Angeles, a city that gives its mayor less direct authority over the government than in a city like New York or Chicago. But even so, it’d be hard to do much worse than Karen Bass. 

Elected mayor of LA in 2022, Bass campaigned on promises to solve the city’s homelessness and housing affordability crises (which are really part of the same underlying crisis). She then spent her term undermining her own administration’s affordable housing policy and fighting the state of California’s efforts to compel cities to allow more housing production. She lost her bid for reelection this week to Nithya Raman, an LA City Council member, rising progressive star, and nationally prominent YIMBY. 

Los Angeles has the highest ratio of home price to household income of any large city in America, and the second fewest homes per adult of any major city. It has a highly suburbanized and car-oriented fabric, like much of the rest of the country — all of which makes it a kind of proving ground for whether America’s sprawling cities can build their way out of their housing shortages. 

Everyone in the city’s political leadership notionally agrees that LA needs to permit a lot more homes to meet demand — the only true way to make housing affordable — but not all of them have evidently had the policy discipline to follow through. 

Raman may be different. She has gained a following in housing reform circles over the last few years with her brisk, direct-to-camera social videos explaining how LA’s housing shortage drives up rents and criticizing city policies that make it so difficult to build more homes (perhaps it’s no surprise that she has plenty of friends in Hollywood).

“There has been an overall lack of urgency in addressing housing supply in [Bass’s] administration,” Raman told me in an interview in July. How best to accommodate LA’s need for more housing, she said, is “a question that the city has actually turned away from.”

Even given LA’s relatively weak mayoralty, Bass’s failures on housing were often a matter of political choice. As The Atlantic’s Marc Novicoff put it, “Bass seems to have gone out of her way to exercise as little power as possible.” Where she did go out of her way to wield her influence, it was often to stop denser housing from being built. Some of her bewildering housing policy choices while in office include: 

  • Days into her term, Bass signed her first executive order, known as ED1, to fast-track housing developments where 100 percent of the apartments are affordable. Applications for these projects were to get approvals within 60 days instead of being dragged through excruciating permitting processes. It was a good idea — and it seemed to be working, quickly attracting developer applications to build thousands of affordable apartments. It was working so well, in fact, that a backlash from vocal NIMBYs followed. Less than six months after signing ED1, in June 2023, Bass weakened it to exclude projects in single-family neighborhoods — which make up three-quarters of LA’s residential land — from the fast-track approval process. Her administration even tried to apply that restriction retroactively to developments that had already applied to build in single-family areas under ED1, a breathtaking display of bureaucratic dysfunction; a judge later ruled that this violated California law. Bass has since added more restrictions to the ED1, and one observer has described it as “functionally gutted” for many developers. To be fair to Bass, even after she weakened it, the program has still resulted in more than 7,700 affordable apartments under construction, according to her campaign.  
  • Bass opposed SB 79, a landmark California law that passed in 2025 requiring cities and suburbs to allow construction of denser housing near transit stops. Permitting apartments near public transit is one of the most basic principles of sensible urban planning. But in LA, it was controversial enough that Bass urged Gov. Gavin Newsom to veto it. After he signed SB 79 into law anyway, Bass worked with LA’s city council to delay much of the law’s most ambitious upzoning until 2030, while permitting smaller apartment buildings near some transit stops. 
  • After the devastating January 2025 fires, some property owners whose homes had burned down in the Pacific Palisades had applied to rebuild under SB 9, another important California law that allows single-family lots to be modestly densified into up to four housing units. In response to backlash from some neighbors, Bass reportedly pressed Newsom to restrict SB 9 in fire-damaged areas; she then banned SB 9 applications in parts of the Palisades. (There are certainly legitimate questions about whether rebuilding in such a fire-prone area is a good idea at all. But Bass offered no publicly available analysis that the modest increase in density allowed by SB 9 posed a special danger, even as she worked to accelerate the rebuilding of single-family homes.) 

All of these point to a leader who is not serious about changing the conditions that led to LA’s housing shortage, and lacks the courage to take on what is arguably the city’s most defining political challenge.

Raman has promised to fundamentally break from that approach. That will make her mayoralty an important experiment for the rest of the country. Even modest progress in a city as resistant to housing as LA could help crack open a way forward for new approaches to housing in the many other cities that face affordability crises.

This won’t be easy for her — she’ll face the same anti-building political pressures, and will need to maintain a cooperative relationship with the city council. When I spoke to Raman over the summer, I noticed that she treaded gingerly around the topic of adding density to single-family neighborhoods. Because of the uniquely American obsession with keeping single-family homes segregated from other types of development, it can be a real political third rail in LA and nationwide. But research has suggested the city can’t fill its housing shortage without building more in those neighborhoods. Raman will, at least, have an important ally in California’s newly elected governor, Xavier Becerra, who is also a strong YIMBY. 

Raman’s affiliation with the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) makes her emblematic of a fusion that’s been emerging in Democratic politics, between supply-side abundance and left-wing economic populism. It’s also evident in politicians like Zohran Mamdani and some of the young Democrats who won elections across the country this week. 

I think this is right.

It's not just that Talarico (et al) combines elements of left populism, abundance pragmatism, and cultural moderation. It's also that the definitions of "left" and "moderate" are in flux.

Take "left." Talarico's all-of-the-above position on energy, eg,… https://t.co/elbUP9vT11

— Derek Thompson (@DKThomp) November 5, 2026

From talking to Raman, I have the sense that she’s more at home with the YIMBY part of her politics than the DSA part. Her relationship with the DSA’s LA chapter has been strained (though it did endorse her candidacy). But her social-democratic commitments are also sincere — she’s been a strong champion of rent control and tenant protections in LA, for example, and helped shape a stronger rent stabilization law the city adopted last year. 

The new political syntheses taking shape on the American left are exciting and intriguing. Whether it will finally make a breakthrough in LA’s — and California’s, and America’s — housing crisis, of course, remains to be tested. But it’s a welcome sign that American politics need not remain trapped in the same orthodoxies and failures. 

Sweden builds houses and apartments like Lego sets. Why don’t we?

6 November 2026 at 12:00
a bright red silhouetted man on a ladder is working on a prefabricated home

Sweden has given the world many wonderful gifts. Zara Larsson, obviously. Spotify and social democracy. And Ikea, the company that showed us you can furnish your apartment, stylishly and affordably, with the contents of a few flatpack boxes. 

Sweden’s talent for mass-producing clever, easy-to-assemble home fixtures also extends to something much bigger than bookshelves and bed frames: building entire houses and apartments. Ikea has become one of the biggest furniture retailers in the US (and perhaps our top purveyor of vegan meatballs). But those factory-built Swedish homes? Americans can’t have them. Yet. 

In factories throughout Sweden, workers assemble modular rooms that will become components of new homes — kitchens and bathrooms, for example, complete with counters, sinks, windows, electric wiring and plumbing, and even dishwashers and washing machines. The modules are then trucked to their final destinations, hoisted up by crane, and arranged into place to form whole single-family or multifamily buildings — like a giant Lego set, as Lindbäcks, one of the country’s top manufacturers of factory-built housing, describes it. One modular development with 114 apartments was assembled on-site from its component parts in about five weeks. (Perhaps it comes as little surprise that Ikea was even a founder of one of Sweden’s prefabricated housing ventures.)  

Sweden has earned a reputation as one of the world’s leaders in prefabricated, off-site housing construction. About a year ago, when I asked Joseph Gyourko, one of America’s top housing economists, which underrated housing policy stories he thinks I should write about, he had a ready answer: Look into how Nordic countries have figured out how to efficiently build high-quality homes in factories at far greater rates than the US does. “It’s not trailer parks,” he told me then. “It’s nice housing.” 

a row of white, multifamily apartment buildings with red roofs and uniform, prefabricated structural frames

Estimates vary (in part because “prefabrication” is a fuzzy term to define), but experts on Sweden’s housing industry say a very large share of its homes are built using some form of prefabrication. Susanne Rudenstam, managing director of the Swedish Wood Building Council, told me about 90 percent of the country’s new single-family homes are built with prefabricated timber systems, which is consistent with other estimates. According to Sweden’s national statistics agency, 43 percent of new multifamily apartments are constructed with fully prefabricated structural frames. Another 46 percent are partially prefabricated.

“Why don’t we do this?” Gyourko asked in astonishment. Why, indeed, hasn’t the United States, the land of free markets and capitalist innovation, embraced the Ikea method of home construction? 

Modular? Prefab? What’s up with all these confusing terms?

There are a lot of intimidating-looking words for what we’re talking about here — but they’re much simpler than they seem!

Off-site construction is exactly what it sounds like — any building methods that occur in a factory or other site that’s not the construction site where a home will eventually end up. It can be as simple as pre-drilling holes into elevator parts, or as comprehensive as manufacturing an entire family house and shipping it intact on a semitruck.

Industrialized construction (IC), as one report recently defined it, means “a form of construction that utilizes processes and technologies typical of industrial manufacturing.” Think standardization, mechanization, and assembly lines — systems that take advantage of economies of scale. This often refers to off-site construction methods, but can apply to on-site ones, too.

Prefabrication, or prefab, is the practice of manufacturing parts of a building in advance and transporting them to the construction site for assembly — similar to the concept of off-site construction.

Panelized construction: A form of prefabrication in which walls, floors, and ceilings are made in a factory as flat panels, then assembled at the construction site.

Volumetric modular: A form of prefabrication where entire rooms or parts of rooms are built in a factory, with their floors and walls assembled. Fixtures like sinks, toilets, and electric wiring are often included. They’re then transported and assembled at the construction site.

Manufactured home: A specific term used in the US for factory-built homes built under the HUD Code, a national building code run by the federal government. These are sometimes known as “mobile” or “trailer” homes and represent the vast majority of prefabricated housing in the US.

One framework I like for thinking about these is the concept of one- , two-, and three-dimensional prefabrication. One-dimensional prefab means preparing single pieces of a building — beams, lengths of piping — before they’re brought to the construction site. Two-dimensional prefab is essentially the same as panelized construction — preparing walls and floors. And three-dimensional corresponds to volumetric modular — pre-assembling whole rooms.

Now that I’ve been investigating this question, I’ve learned how much more complicated it is than it might seem. The Swedes indeed build homes in ways that make our construction methods — predominantly building homes on-site, one by one, piece by piece — look embarrassingly archaic, as if every washing machine were assembled from different parts inside the consumer’s home. As the US battles an acute housing shortage, Sweden’s success has helped inspire efforts to accelerate factory-built housing here; Oregon, for example, has invested $20 million in modular housing manufacturers. 

But several experts I spoke to for this story cautioned that Americans risk learning the wrong lessons from Sweden. 

Rather than fixating on the end product, they argue — the futuristic house factories — we have to focus on the less glitzy task of fixing our kludgy building and zoning codes. Doing this would give builders more freedom to innovate and reduce costs, which could lead to a boom in American factory-built housing, or simply to different advances that improve and streamline homebuilding stateside. Stephen Smith, executive director of the nonprofit Center for Building in North America, told me that striving to leap straight to modular construction in the US would be the wrong goal.

“I don’t think the places that succeed with off-site construction do it because they were seeking off-site construction,” he said. “I think it’s the reward from getting all the details right.”

So what can we learn from the Swedes’ dreamy, high-tech housing industry — and what would it take to bring about an American version of that success? 

The great global experiment in mass-produced housing

Many comparisons of housing in Sweden and the US begin in the same period: the 1960s, the heyday of government-sponsored mass-building programs around the world. Many countries, including the US, were facing significant housing shortages driven by a postwar baby boom, a rapidly urbanizing population, and, in some cases, the destruction of much of their housing stock during World War II. Japan, today another one of the world’s leaders in prefabricated housing, built 6.7 million homes between 1966 and 1970 — about a quarter of its entire housing stock at the time. The Soviet Union’s command economy famously churned out millions of inexpensive apartment mega-blocks during the same period, many of them assembled in just a few weeks. The secret was panelized construction — a type of prefabrication where the walls and floors are made in a factory and assembled by crane at the construction site. 

Sweden’s version of this mass building push, the Million Homes Program, was set up in 1965 to build 100,000 homes per year over a decade. It created incentives for builders to use innovative methods and take on large projects. And it worked, producing over a million homes by 1974 and a kind of laboratory for industrialized construction (IC) methods widely used in Sweden today. Industrialized construction is the umbrella term for building techniques that incorporate some degree of mechanization and standardization, including panelized construction and fully modular rooms; many people in Sweden’s housing industry compare the philosophy to a car assembly line. But Sweden had also been a pioneer in prefabricated housing long before the postwar age of industrialized homebuilding; it experimented with factory-made wooden houses as early as the 1820s, according to a recent paper published in the journal Urban Studies by researchers Tyler Pullen, Jerker Lessing, and Santiago Ossa.  

The US, too, experimented with accelerating prefabricated building in this period. In 1969, then-Secretary of the US Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), George Romney (the father of Mitt Romney), championed Operation Breakthrough, a program that sought to speed up and lower the costs of housing construction with innovative, factory-based building methods. It ultimately led to the construction of more than 30,000 housing units, but the program itself disbanded in the mid-1970s; a report from the US Government Accountability Office concluded that it had not demonstrated it could build more affordably than conventional construction methods. Operation Breakthrough “ultimately failed to achieve its original transformative ambition of establishing a healthy IC market” in the US, Pullen and his co-authors wrote.

Though the program didn’t make prefabrication a normal and widespread part of American homebuilding, it did achieve something very important. It helped pave the way for a uniform national building code for manufactured homes, the paper notes, which are factory-built houses that make up about 10 percent of single-family home construction in the US today. (Outside that separately regulated market, around 3 percent of US single-family homes and 3 percent of multifamily buildings are built with modular or panelized prefabrication.) These represent the vast majority of the US factory-based housing industry, and they also happen to be some of the most affordable housing in the country. Many Americans know manufactured homes by the stigmatizing and somewhat misleading terms “mobile” or “trailer” homes. But our manufactured housing industry actually offers a promising path to scaling higher-quality, prefabricated homes more widely across the US. 

In Sweden, industrialized construction does not carry the same baggage. Many of its prefabricated apartment buildings have the sleek, ultramodern aesthetic that Americans associate with Scandinavian furniture stores, while others resemble more traditional architecture, with colorful siding and details like charming mansard-style roofs. They tend to look strikingly different from the boxy buildings that dominate contemporary multifamily housing in the US — proof that mass-produced housing doesn’t have to look, well, mass-produced. 

The secret to Sweden’s housing factories isn’t the factories

The most decisive factor behind Sweden’s advanced off-site construction industry is probably not its midcentury housing incubator, however. Every expert I spoke to stressed the importance of building codes — the set of regulations that govern how buildings must be designed and constructed to ensure that they’re safe to occupy. 

American building codes have been heavily criticized by housing abundance advocates, who argue that a dysfunctional rulemaking process has piled on unnecessary requirements — especially for apartment buildings — that drive up construction costs in the US without meaningfully improving safety. (I previously covered these issues at length here.) Our codes tend to be prescriptive, meaning that they specify the precise materials and tools that must be used to meet safety standards. In some cases, it’s not at all clear that those rules do much to make dwellings safer. (Perhaps the most notorious of these is the requirement in most of the US that apartment buildings greater than a few stories tall have two staircases.) 

The difference in Sweden is that, like other European countries, it has embraced a “performance-based” building code, meaning that its rules mandate certain safety outcomes, like walls that must be fire-resistant for an hour, or that buildings be able to withstand heavy winds. Developers can then figure out their own way of meeting those requirements. That doesn’t mean it’s a free-for-all — builders still have to prove that their designs comply. This gives them room to innovate, which has encouraged an R&D culture in Sweden’s housing industry.

Performance-based regulation has enabled the Swedes, with their centuries-old tradition of timber construction, to do things with wood that Americans would never believe. Like this beautiful development in Stockholm of 10-to-13-story apartment buildings built with prefabricated wooden panels and clad in cedar shingles. That project, called Cederhusen, was designed with extensive fire-safety protections to meet Sweden’s standards. But it would be unlikely to be approved in the US for many reasons, including restrictions on combustible materials on the exterior of tall buildings, Edward Palka, an architect, US building code expert, and director of AKA Urban, told me in an email. (US codes do have alternative performance-based paths, but they can be so cumbersome and expensive that most builders don’t use them.)

tall wooden apartment buildings in a row in front of a public park and playgrounda close-up view of an apartment building constructed from timber

Performance-based fire safety tests may not be infallible, however, and are likely to continue to evolve. In 2025, another new building with a wooden exterior was destroyed in a fire (no one was injured). A subsequent investigation found that its fire protections were insufficient, which has prompted debate about the adequacy of Sweden’s fire safety testing for wooden facades.   

The US also has a fragmented patchwork of different building codes across different states and cities. “We have 20,000-plus individual jurisdictions, with exactly as many slightly unique building codes or zoning codes,” Pullen, a researcher for UC Berkeley’s Terner Center for Housing Innovation, told me. That makes it harder for factory-based homebuilders to sell the same standardized designs across the country, undermining the economies of scale that make prefabricated construction worthwhile. Sweden’s more nationally consistent building code, conversely, may have helped make off-site homebuilding more viable. 

And there are more deeply embedded issues throughout American codes that bias them against prefabrication, according to a forthcoming report by Edward Palka for the Center for Building in North America, which advocates for building code reform in the US. Palka writes:

While the code is ostensibly method-neutral and only concerned with specific materials and their properties, the language was developed with traditional construction methods in mind, creating unintended barriers for innovative approaches…Requirements that make perfect sense for stick-built construction often become nonsensical, redundant, or impossibly burdensome when applied to volumetric modules or panelized systems.

In Sweden, meanwhile, the environment for housing innovation seems to be an emergent property of its regulatory system — the cumulative result of many rules and practices, rather than any one or two policies that can be singled out. Inside Swedish home factories, “it really feels both like a production space and a laboratory,” Ivan Rupnik, an architecture professor at Northeastern University who has studied Sweden’s prefabricated home sector, told me. It may also help that Sweden is a higher-trust society than the US; maybe regulators there are less likely to obstruct builders using innovative construction methods.

If all that sounds like tedious minutiae, what it enables in Sweden’s home factories is anything but boring. 

At Podcomp, a company in Piteå, in Sweden’s far north, that makes modular bathrooms for some of the country’s largest prefabricated homebuilders, a tireless robotic arm lays tiles — one every three seconds. Podcomp’s factory can complete roughly 25 bathroom pods in the span of two eight-to-nine-hour shifts, Ulf Johansson, the company’s business manager, told me. 

“It goes faster,” Johansson said. “You don’t need the plumber, the electrician guy, the tiling guy.” 

a mostly-white bathroom with compact storage, a glass shower, a washing machine, and a dryer a row of in-progress prefabricated bathrooms in a large warehouse space

The time savings is, of course, crucial — both because it reduces costs, and because the US and other countries facing a housing shortage need to build a lot of housing quickly. Studies have found widely varying time savings from prefabrication, though the available research generally suggests it can shave significant time off construction schedules. And workers can spend their days in more comfortable, climate-controlled environments instead of enduring extreme heat and cold (the latter a particular concern in Sweden, and the former in the US).

Alan Gibson, the principal at Go Logic, a US company that makes high-end homes with panelized construction, told me the business is modeled on the Swedish industry. “They are able to produce homes of similar quality to ours using significantly less labor,” he wrote in an email. But because these methods have never become the norm in the US, the industry hasn’t gained much of a foothold. “It’s a chicken and egg situation, but it’s slowly changing as people understand the value of prefabricated component building,” he wrote.

Can we bring it here?

After ingesting all this reporting, a basic question still kept nagging at me. Why did the American regulatory environment become so seemingly inhospitable to innovation in the housing sector? Aren’t we the country that perfected the assembly line, the land of inventors and entrepreneurs? 

Stephen Smith, of the Center for Building in North America, gave me the most satisfying answer I’ve been able to find: “I think it is because of our abundant wealth and resources,” he said. “It’s let us get a bit fat and lazy and inefficient. We can afford a lot of inefficiencies that other countries cannot.” He reminded me that the zenith of modular housing construction was, after all, in postwar Europe, as it was struggling to recover from such intense devastation. 

Now that the US is mired in a housing crisis, it’s no surprise that there’s renewed interest in prefabrication. American policymakers, researchers, and housing industry professionals have gone on trips — what Smith archly called “the junket to Sweden” — to tour Swedish housing factories and learn from the prevailing industrialized construction methods there. Sweden certainly offers invaluable proof that radically different ways of building housing are possible — but expecting to replicate its factories here would be kind of like visiting Amsterdam, marveling at all the cyclists there, and concluding that the secret is to import lots of Dutch bicycles to the US. A few sources pointed me to the Silicon Valley startup Katerra as a cautionary tale. Founded in 2015 with ambitions to revolutionize US construction through prefabrication, it raised over $2 billion and invested massively in factories and acquisitions before proving it could build profitably. By 2021, it was bankrupt.  

Instead, Smith stressed, Americans who are interested in fixing our housing market have to concern themselves with reforming the zillions of boring, technical rules that make our buildings inefficient. He pointed me to a few examples: According to a 2024 report by the Center for Building, some labor union agreements in the US forbid elevator manufacturers from drilling certain holes into elevator parts at the factory — a rudimentary form of prefabrication — and instead require that they be drilled at the construction site, which is out of step with the rest of the world. US plumbing codes require complicated layouts with a lot of piping, which makes it harder to build with prefabricated housing. New York City heavily restricts plastic piping, and also makes it very hard to use tower cranes, a key tool for lifting prefabricated housing modules into place. 

An even more foundational problem, Smith added, is not building codes but zoning codes — the rules that dictate, in exacting detail, what kind of things can be built where. Zoning is the reason that apartment buildings are illegal on most residential land in the US, and it’s also common for affluent neighborhoods to require large lot sizes, making it economically impractical to build smaller, cheaper homes. If these affordable housing types can’t be built in the first place, it hardly matters what the building codes say.

“None of these things are really what people have in mind when they imagine policy for ‘prefab’ or ‘modular’ — they’re imagining one neat trick” that would bring it to the US, Smith told me in an email. But “the reason we have never succeeded in prefab is that we’ve never sweated the details.”

If the US addresses these barriers, it might eventually lead to significantly greater off-site construction. Or it might lead our housing industry to devise better, more affordable building methods in other ways — and that would be fine. “You don’t want to prejudge the outcome, but you want to create a favorable environment” for innovation, Smith said. 

Prefabrication isn’t a silver bullet for affordability, and Sweden hasn’t necessarily cracked the code on cheap construction. Its building industry has faced stagnating productivity in the last few decades, just like other wealthy countries. And it faces a significant housing shortage of its own. Construction expert Brian Potter, a senior fellow at the Institute for Progress, has thrown cold water on the idea that imitating Sweden will fix America’s housing troubles, arguing that there’s little evidence widespread prefabrication has meaningfully lowered Swedish construction costs. 

As it happens, the US does already have a substantial factory-based housing industry of its own — manufactured homes. Unlike all other homes in the country, these are regulated under a nationally consistent, already performance-based federal code, known as the HUD Code. (Meaning that when a developer builds under this code, it’s exempt from having to comply with local building codes, though it’s not exempt from zoning requirements.) The affordability of these homes offers perhaps the strongest evidence in the US of the cost savings that come with prefabrication and a uniform building code.

Contrary to the stereotypes still widely held about them, they can be quite nice and almost indistinguishable from conventional single-family homes. But they still face significant barriers to cultural acceptance, as well as widespread discrimination in zoning codes that make them illegal to place in many residential neighborhoods. And it’s harder to get a mortgage for them. 

A beige single-story home with a large covered front porch, white picket fencing, and neatly landscaped flower beds and lawn under a clear blue sky.

Recent changes to federal law, however, might help manufactured homes shed that stigma and expand the market for prefabricated housing in the US. 

The recent federal ROAD to Housing Act removed a longstanding requirement that manufactured houses be built on a permanent steel chassis — the trailer-like frames that are used to transport them from the factory to the building site. That had been the most conspicuous physical feature setting them apart from conventional homes. “Removing the chassis means that this can be treated as more normal housing, and it will be more difficult to discriminate against it,” Amy Egerter, a senior research associate at the Terner Center, told me. It’ll also allow for more flexible designs.  

Back in 2024, the HUD Code was also updated to allow manufactured duplexes, triplexes, and fourplexes for the first time — not just single-family homes. The chassis’s removal will make it easier to vertically stack these units, Egerter said. Meanwhile, HUD is now exploring expanding the code to buildings of five or more units — potentially a very big deal for manufactured housing in America. Perhaps, Egerter suggested, a developer will soon be able to choose to build a six-unit prefab apartment building under the HUD Code, and bypass the headache of the local building code patchwork altogether. 

A long, single-story home with dark blue siding, white trim, two red front doors, and a shared front porch with stairs and white railings. An American flag hangs above the porch.

The US undoubtedly needs to modernize the chaotic labyrinth of building rules that regulate the vast majority of our houses and apartments, outside the HUD Code. In the meantime, one route to more affordable, more industrialized construction in the US might run through this unshowy, uniquely American manufactured homes industry. We may not need to import the future of housing from Sweden, the way we do with its modular shelves and sofas. But we can learn from the conditions that made its success possible, and perhaps unleash the potential of a form of housing Americans have looked down on for so long. 

This story was supported by a grant from Arnold Ventures. Vox had full discretion over the content of this reporting.

America’s empty bedrooms are up for grabs

19 October 2026 at 12:16
Illustration of three buildings: one in the center with three people living cozily in a shared space, and one on either side with darkened windows and overgrown, thorny vines

This story was originally published in The Highlight. To get access to member-exclusive stories like this every month, become a Vox Member today.

Todd Waller wasn’t expecting to spend the latter half of his 30s living with roommates. But in late 2022, following a breakup with his girlfriend, he needed to find a new place to live, quickly. 

A social worker based in the Atlanta metro, Waller started googling “efficiency apartments” and stumbled onto an ad for PadSplit, a company founded in 2017 that lets property owners rent out individual furnished bedrooms in single-family homes by the week. “It said I could get approved right away and move in tomorrow,” he recalled. There was no security deposit required.

All of a sudden, Waller found himself living with six other people and able to save a lot of money. His rent was just $180 per week, or less than $800 per month. Though he earned a decent salary, he never really had anything left over after all his bills were paid, and the new financial breathing room made the tradeoff of housemates feel worth it.

Key takeaways

  • Cities spent much of the 20th century banning cheap rented rooms, and a 1974 Supreme Court ruling still lets them decide who counts as a “family” under zoning law. That’s now being challenged on two fronts.
  • A Kansas lawsuit asking the Supreme Court to revisit that precedent, and “Golden Girls” bills that have already passed in four states and are spreading.
  • The next few years will determine whether co-living stays a niche workaround or becomes a normal option, with more states set to take up the issue in 2027.

After a while, Waller decided he would be willing to upgrade to a nicer PadSplit unit, one with more amenities but still with roommates. Now he pays $1,250 a month to live on one side of a 2,000-square-foot home, with access to his own private bathroom, a private entrance, and a renovated kitchen. Three other people live on the other side of the house, and he rarely interacts with them.

“My house is awesome; I pay $500 less a month than I would if I were renting [a place of my own] without roommates, and I just was able to buy a new car,” he told me. He knows one day he’ll move somewhere else and perhaps even buy his own home, but he likes that he feels he can make that decision comfortably at his own pace.

With rents outpacing wages in most of the country, legislators are increasingly looking at co-living — sometimes called house-sharing or adult dorm rooms — as an overlooked piece of America’s housing stock. Zillow counts roughly 21 million “empty nest households” — or homes where older residents living with no children have at least two extra bedrooms. Some lawmakers want to make it easier for those homeowners to rent them out, which could put workers closer to their jobs and help seniors stay in houses they can no longer afford alone. Others are eyeing a different kind of vacancy: Post-pandemic remote work has left about a fifth of American office space empty, and there’s growing interest in turning some of it into apartments. 

Many advocates for people experiencing homelessness also argue that co-living is a needed solution, something that could help people going through emergencies avoid the scary slide into shelter living, especially models where you can move in almost immediately and without a deposit. PadSplit surveyed its renters in December and found a population that mostly works (83 percent were employed) and mostly hadn’t been to college. The median income was $32,500.

That co-living needs advocates at all is a legacy of the last century. Renting a single room in a boarding house or residential hotel was once an ordinary way to live in an American city, but in the decades after World War II those rooms became shorthand for poverty and vice, and cities responded by banning new ones and paying landlords to get rid of the old. Half a century later, many people still see sharing space with strangers as a last resort, or feel embarrassed about having roommates past a certain age. And discriminatory zoning codes written in that era are still on the books in most communities, enforcing traditional nuclear family arrangements when it comes to single-family housing, by defining “family” as people related by blood, marriage, or adoption. Those rules can be wielded against home-sharing, and against specific renters neighbors want to keep out.

But these longstanding barriers are starting to finally give. Doubling up with people you aren’t related to is less unusual than it used to be. Between 2017 and 2022, the number of households sharing space with nonrelatives grew by more than 500,000. Lawmakers desperate for anything that adds more housing supply also seem less picky about where it comes from. Companies like PadSplit are putting private capital behind the model, and a wave of new laws and litigation — much of it led by conservative legal groups arguing on property-rights grounds — is making it harder for cities to tell homeowners who can and cannot sleep in their spare rooms. 

For the first time since cities banned cheap rooms, the people trying to bring them back have the momentum, and the next couple of years will go a long way toward deciding whether co-living stays a niche workaround for people like Waller or becomes something a lot more people are able to consider.

The return of SROs

At the turn of the 20th century, as American cities swelled, immigrants, day laborers, and factory workers crowded into downtowns looking for somewhere cheap and temporary to sleep. A small room could be rented by the day, the week, or however long someone needed it. Some “boarded” in private homes while others took beds in bottom-rung hotels known as flophouses. These arrangements varied widely, but became broadly known as single-room occupancies (SROs).

The turn against them came after World War II, as middle-class white families decamped for roomy new houses in the suburbs, and SROs grew more closely associated with shoddy housing for the poor and the deviant. New York and other cities started banning SRO construction in the 1950s. By the 1970s, SROs were a regular media villain, even as they still housed hundreds of thousands of people, including the mentally ill who had been turned out by the closing of state asylums. Cities started to offer landlords incentives to convert their SROs into luxury rentals. Between the mid-1970s and the 1990s, roughly a million of these affordable market-rate units disappeared from the market across the country.

The idea that perhaps cities made a mistake in banning these lower-cost housing options has been simmering in urbanist policy circles for the last 15 years, particularly as the homelessness crisis has gotten worse. The Furman Center at NYU argued in 2018 that reintroducing SROs could help address the housing shortage. The architecture critic Karrie Jacobs argued in 2021 that cities had blamed a kind of housing for problems that belonged to the people living in it. “The notion took hold that if you eliminated the housing, the marginal people would simply vanish,” she wrote in Curbed.

Still, lawmakers have dragged their feet on actually making it easier to rent these kinds of units again, and until recently the people pushing for it had little to show beyond op-eds and white papers. What’s different now is that the fight has moved out of the world of policy papers and into places where it can produce actual results, including a lawsuit that could reach the Supreme Court.

Suing over who counts as family

In early 2022, a home-sharing startup called HomeRoom was renting out two houses in Shawnee, Kansas, a suburb of Kansas City. The company rented rooms one at a time to unrelated adults who wanted cheaper housing, and at a local city council meeting that year, Shawnee’s community development director asked whether the city should support such arrangements in single-family neighborhoods at all. Two months later, the council passed an ordinance banning “co-living groups,” which it defined as four or more unrelated adults sharing a home. 

Under the ordinance, if even one adult in a house wasn’t related to the others by blood, marriage, or adoption, the whole household counted as unrelated.

While the new law forced HomeRoom to evict its tenants, it also put Val French, a Shawnee homeowner, in a bad situation. She lived with her husband, their two adult sons, and one son’s girlfriend. Because the girlfriend was related to no one, the house was now deemed in violation of the city’s occupancy rules. Her son and his girlfriend had to move out, and French couldn’t rent the empty room to anyone else.

French and HomeRoom sued in federal court in May 2023, with assistance from the libertarian Pacific Legal Foundation. They argued that their right to choose who they live with is protected under the 14th Amendment, but they ran into legal precedent from a 1974 Supreme Court case, Village of Belle Terre v. Boraas, which upheld a Long Island village’s nearly identical rule against six college students sharing a house.

The decision came down in the same years cities were clearing out their SROs, and it has given local governments cover to decide who counts as a family ever since.

A small bedroom with queen bed, ceiling fan, and a TV hanging above a dresser.

A federal judge dismissed the Shawnee suit in September 2023, citing Belle Terre, and this past April the US Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit upheld the dismissal. A few months later, the Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) petitioned the US Supreme Court to hear the case and reconsider Belle Terre once and for all. The precedent has already frayed in places — state courts in California, Michigan, New Jersey, and New York have struck down local “unrelated occupants” limits under their own laws — but it still governs everywhere else. 

There is “a fundamental liberty right to choose household living companions — whether as an articulation of the right of intimate association or independently — that is deeply rooted in American history and tradition,” PLF’s lead attorney on the case, David Deerson, told me. 

The Supreme Court hears only about 1 percent of the cases it’s asked to take, and even if it took this one, the plaintiffs would be asking a conservative majority to recognize a new constitutional right, which that majority has spent the past few years insisting courts should almost never do. 

Deerson’s argument is aimed at that skepticism, though. When the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022, it held that an unwritten right counts only if it is “deeply rooted in history and tradition.” Deerson and his allies are arguing that living with people you aren’t related to qualifies as such because, for most of American history, boarding houses and lodgers were typical staples of family life. Belle Terre is also a short opinion written by William O. Douglas, a liberal justice whose legacy has little connection to today’s conservative justices. 

The legislative front

A Supreme Court reversal would be the cleanest fix for co-living, but advocates aren’t waiting on it. State legislatures have already shown they’ll act: Iowa barred cities from enforcing relationship-based occupancy limits in 2017, Oregon and Washington followed in 2021, and in 2024, Colorado lawmakers passed a law prohibiting cities from restricting how many unrelated roommates can live under one roof absent a clear health or safety reason. 

The Pacific Legal Foundation worked on that last bill too, and has since turned it into model legislation for other states. They colloquially call it the “Golden Girls bill” since occupancy caps like these would have prevented the four unrelated women of the hit 1980s sitcom from sharing a house. 

This year Pennsylvania lawmakers introduced their own version, with supporters citing not private property rights but the potential to ease the state’s affordable housing shortage. As legislators considered the proposal, Pacific Legal Foundation published research showing that nine of the 10 most populous cities in Pennsylvania capped the number of unrelated adults who could live together. The state House passed the Golden Girls bill this summer, though the Pennsylvania Senate version has not yet received a vote. 

The objection lawmakers hear most is the same one that animated Belle Terre — that lifting occupancy caps could turn quiet, orderly, neighborhood homes into de facto frat houses. That college partying concern killed Connecticut’s proposed Golden Girls bill this year. While the bill cleared the state Senate, it never got a vote in the House, amid reported concerns from the speaker about college students moving into wealthy neighborhoods. “What if a neighbor is unhappy about four unrelated people who are 19 years old or 22 years old living in the house?” state House Speaker Matt Ritter asked in an interview with the Connecticut Mirror. 

Pennsylvania’s sponsors tried to head off those fears by amending the bill to exclude protections where someone is enrolled at a college or university. In other words, the law would have covered Blanche, Dorothy, Rose, and Sophia from Golden Girls unless one of them signed up for a class at their community college.

Nevertheless, advocates are expanding their push. Jim Manley, state policy director for the Pacific Legal Foundation, told me he expects Texas, Florida, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Rhode Island and Utah to take up new versions of the legislation in 2027.

And occupancy caps aren’t the only co-living target. Sam Hooper, a lawyer who has been lobbying state legislatures to re-legalize SROs, and his former colleagues at the Institute for Justice are now focused on the ROOM Act, model legislation that would bar cities from restricting SROs and other co-living arrangements, including rules that make it hard to convert offices into apartments. A version was first introduced in Rhode Island earlier this year. 

For Meagan Forbes, Institute for Justice’s director of legislation, the goal is for co-living to be treated like any other form of housing. “Other local laws can regulate things like noise and fire safety, but current regulations just go way too overboard in preventing this kind of housing,” she told me. 

Hooper, who drafted the ROOM Act, says he wanted to “take a massive sledgehammer” to existing restrictions. The resistance he runs into isn’t only the frat-house worry, but older cultural fears that SROs would recreate the poor tenement conditions of the early 20th century. “I think there’s this real problem of letting the perfect be the enemy of the good in housing policy,” he told me. “People accuse us of wanting people to live in undignified housing, but they just struggle to understand that it can be a perfectly fine option for many people at different points in their life.” Hooper credits his own London co-living experience in his 20s with introducing him to some of his best friends and his wife. 

Even so, he cited a broad political coalition backing him up, from property rights champions in conservative states to Democrats and progressive YIMBYs drawn to the housing justice and homelessness angles. There are business leaders interested in workforce housing, he said, and he noted that the AARP testified for the ROOM Act in Rhode Island. “I’m hopeful we’ll be able to keep this bipartisan coalition that hasn’t succumbed to the culture wars,” Hooper added.

Not every co-living proposal is about removing rules. DC’s Senior Co-Living Program Establishment Act, also nicknamed the Golden Girls bill, would pay senior homeowners $300 a month to rent a room to another senior, plus up to $2,500 for home modifications. 

The 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, the federal housing package that became law in July, doesn’t touch occupancy rules. But it does fund a pilot program for converting vacant commercial buildings into housing, which could make adult dorm office conversions easier.

The demand question

While momentum for co-living is real, demand is also complicated. Americans are doubling up more than they were before the pandemic — about 8.2 million households in 2024, up 4.3 percent since 2019, according to analysis shared by Zillow. Yet the share made up of unrelated adults living together actually fell slightly, by roughly 50,000 households, while homes shared with couples or families grew by nearly 400,000. In other words, when Americans need to save on rent, they still mostly turn to people they already know.

PadSplit is betting that changes. Atticus LeBlanc recently announced his company is expanding into New York, Chicago, and San Francisco, three of the most expensive rental markets in the country.

“Does that mean things have gotten more desperate, that it’s forcing this cultural acceptance?” he asked me in an interview. “I think there’s certainly an argument to be made there. But you could just as easily make the argument that, holy cow, we are really, really wasteful with space.”

❌