President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance at a Veterans Day in Arlington National Cemetery on November 11, 2026. | Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images
This story appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.
Remember two weeks ago, when Vice President JD Vance was having a bad week? It’s gotten much, much worse.
Vance has spent most of the last two years as the MAGA movement’s heir apparent — so much so that Secretary of State Marco Rubio, potentially his top rival for the 2028 GOP presidential nomination, told a reporter last year that “If JD Vance runs for president, he’s going to be our nominee, and I’ll be one of the first people to support him.”
Suffice to say, that no longer looks like the case: Vance, more than any other potential Republican candidate in 2028, emerged from the midterms in bad political shape, and President Donald Trump has been putting him through hell ever since.
Specifically, Vance has found himself in a trap of his own making on two issues: The Iran war and immigration. In a long social media post the day after the midterms, he blamed the war for his party’s electoral catastrophe; more recently, he described “bipartisan immigration reform” that would allow undocumented immigrants to stay in the country as “morally and electorally disastrous.”
The problem with those two stances is that he’s still Trump’s vice president, and Trump refuses to admit that the Iran war was the wrong decision (though he’s been willing enough to concede that it was an electoral anchor). Trump is also in the midst of showing occasional, vague interest in the aforementioned bipartisan immigration reform. And he’s reportedly not happy with Vance’s subtweets.
Both of those tensions were on full display Friday in a press conference by Trump, Vance, and Rubio, where Vance dodged a question on whether the war was worth the political fallout — an area where Trump has strongly suggested he’d like more backup from his second-in-command. “The president said he would do it again,” Vance told reporters. “My view is that my goal in my job is to support the president of the United States.”
That answer, you might correctly surmise, is almost certainly not going to do it with Trump over the long run. (This being the same president so bent on conforming the world around him to his views that he dispenses matching too-big shoes to his team, and they wear them.)
Vance’s double bind
Vance’s plight is particularly dire because he doesn’t really have anywhere to run. His options look something like this:
Hug Trump, hope for an endorsement, and see if the president’s reflected goodwill can push him to the nomination (and potentially to a general election wipeout, if Trump’s trajectory with voters stays the same);
Break from Trump more dramatically, forfeiting an endorsement and MAGA enthusiasm, and try to stake out his own brand in the primary and the general;
Or keep on keeping on, cryptically sniping at opponents from social media until Trump gets mad anyway.
Meanwhile, the weaker Vance looks, the more his potential rivals are likely to eye the throne for themselves. In a poll released Thursday by Emerson College, Vance’s potential 2028 support has collapsed from 54 percent this time last year to just 20 percent, while Rubio’s has jumped from 6 percent to 36 percent (more than any other polled candidate, with Vance in second). And Rubio, according to CNN, is leaving some people with the impression that he’s more open to a run.
Other Republicans, including outgoing Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, are also believed to be considering runs, and both would have the advantage of being able to run from outside a Trump administration that seems unlikely to grow more popular over the next two years.
Vance, in other words, already looks like he could be approaching his best-by date — and he still has a very long year-plus until the first votes are cast in the 2028 primary.
One link for later
➨ There’s a whole lot going on in Grand Theft Auto VI, which came out on Thursday to rave reviews after a 13-year wait. You can hijack cars, rob banks — all of the things you’d expect from a game named after a criminal statute. And then there’s the bird-watching, my colleague Neel Dhanesha reports: The game, a shockingly lifelike fictionalized recreation of southern Florida, is host to 62 species of bird and a lush, diverse ecosystem. You can read all about it — and how real-world birdwatchers are reacting to the launch — here.
Before you go…
Did you know…that Uruguay has a remarkably successful national care system covering not just child care, but elder care and care for disabled adults? Part of the secret, my colleague Rachel Cohen Booth reports, is that Uruguay treats its care as a right and its system as public infrastructure, rather than a commercial enterprise.
Today’s trivia: Which independent federal agency is currently chaired by the financier Kevin Warsh? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in Monday’s edition.)
Yesterday’s trivia: Yesterday, we asked which therapy method is influenced by Buddhism. The answer is cognitive behavioral therapy, which also has connections to classical Stoic philosophy.
“Millennial optimism exists because Obama won elections so decisively that they had time to hit the club afterward,” Olivia Julianna, a Democratic strategist and content creator, said. | Elijah Nouvelage/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Millennial optimism is making a comeback online, thanks to the Democrats’ blue tsunami in this month’s midterm election. Social media is filled with videos, songs, and edits celebrating the midterms and linking the feeling to Barack Obama’s victories and the various cultural signifiers of the time, from indie bands to “girlboss” CEOs. Many of them are produced by Gen Z users who have little memory of the era themselves.
To some left-leaning millennials, it’s a teachable moment. On Instagram the day after the election, 37-year-old Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) gave her younger followers a lesson in the roots of “millennial cringe,” that mix of hope and earnestness that Gen Zers often see as cloying and naive.
“Imagine all the seats we flipped last night, that feeling, plus on top of it, electing the first Black president ever. And on top of that, you did it the first time you ever voted? That hits generationally,” Ocasio-Cortez said. “Like, you are chasing that feeling ever since. And because you did it the first time you ever voted, you’re like, ‘Yeah, we can change the world. Yeah, why not. We did it the first time. Why not just do it again?’”
But while some millennials (including many of the victorious candidates) might proudly claim this moment as a restoration of their culture — everyone back to Hamilton! — some of the Gen Z voters and operatives who helped power their wins are also trying to carve out their own lane.
Rather than a straightforward revival, these Gen Z are calling their experience “WhimZ,” which they see as distinct from millennial optimism, and hardened by their own divergent experiences in the Trump era.
Unlike millennial optimism — rooted in the fact that if you believe in change and progress and work to make it possible, it will come — Gen Z liberals know that’s not the case. And indeed, there’s a sharp satirical edge to some of the stomp-clap celebrations making the rounds.
Obama’s young voters struggled to keep up the same energy, urgency, and turnout (the 2014 midterms had historically low participation) when he wasn’t on the ballot, in part — in “WhimZ’s” telling — because they were overly confident that emerging trends in technology, social media, and culture might solve problems and eliminate discrimination for them.
“Gen Z’s ‘WhimZ’ is very different than millennial optimism and the reason why is us as Gen Z know that we still have to fight,” TikToker @bearclawharley explained in one video. “This is no hate to millennials; you guys were promised…follow the rules and you guys will get a good job and yada yada. We as Gen Z know that that’s not going to happen. You guys were just carefree; we are ironically doing this.”
First-time voters in 2026 were born the year Obama was elected and just 8 years old when Trump was elected in 2016. They’ve grown up in a divisive political climate and understand that even when you march, protest, organize, and ultimately vote — you don’t always get the outcome you want.
Lauren Kapp, who co-founded the Democratic digital strategy firm Luminary Strategies and helped with the James Talarico campaign’s social media operation this midterms, said one of her own core political memories was walking into her high school class after the 2016 election and seeing her AP government teacher in tears.
“Political instability has left Gen Z burned,” Kapp said. “We’ve had to cope through our humor as a matter of processing. To me, WhimZ is less about believing things will get better and more about finding moments of joy despite the uncertainty.”
“Political instability has left Gen Z burned. We’ve had to cope through our humor as a matter of processing.”
Lauren Kapp, co-founder of the Democratic digital strategy firm Luminary Strategies
The rising generation is also not as liberal or partisan — in fact, more than half (56 percent) of Zoomers identify as independent, according to Gallup — and those who do tilt left are more comfortable with anti-establishment voices, like the rising socialist movement, than their elders are. They care far less about party labels and far more about results.
According to Olivia Julianna, a Democratic strategist and content creator, millennial optimism is “more institutional than WhimZ.”
“Millennial optimism exists because Obama won elections so decisively that they had time to hit the club afterward. Then they could go to urgent care for IV fluids on their parents’ health insurance the next morning,” she said, alluding to Gen Z’s lack of trust across institutions. “WhimZ comes from a place that’s a little more vengeful. Our greatest victories have largely come from stopping the worst shit from happening instead of witnessing massive moments of inspiration from people in power or elected officials.”
Rather than remembering elections as their touchstones, Gen Z’s core political memories have been direct actions they took themselves: March for Our Lives, Black Lives Matter, climate protests, or more recently, organized action against ICE.
This sentiment comes up repeatedly in conversations and focus groups with younger voters as part of my research work: Voting the right politicians into office is not enough.
“We know that we have a lot to work on and flipping this is a good first step but definitely just a first step,” one 22-year-old woman from Denver told me after the midterms.
“Most of the gains Gen Z has seen in the political atmosphere we’ve grown up amid [and] have come to know have been temporary and marginal,” a 21-year-old woman from New York City told me. “I think we have more cautious optimism about the trajectory of the [country], rather than millennials’ sheer optimism.”
Where the two generations come together perhaps is a shared recognition that anger, nihilism, and retreat are not the answer. In focus groups last spring, I started hearing fed-up young Americans tell me they were looking for candidates who offered a forward-looking vision on issues they care about — the economy, war, corruption, AI — rather than those who lament the opposite party or rationalize the status quo. And as the midterm cycle went on, it became clearer that they were over the culture war, and instead, interested in candidates who unite in service of fighting these core issues, rather than those who try to divide voters along identity or partisan lines.
It sounds cheesy for a generation that’s known for being so wildly jaded. But even jadedness gets old. And having grown up in a political ecosystem dominated by bullying, for Gen Z, a “politics of love” (as Talarico describes it) feels brand new. They may not be ready to let their guard down like their millennial forebears, but there’s a realization that hate, fear, and division haven’t gotten us very far.
Members of Democratic leadership in the House and Senate Democratic walk out of the US Capitol on May 21, 2026. | Aaron Schwartz/Bloomberg via Getty Images
After historic wins in the midterm elections, Democrats now have to decide who will lead their new majorities in the House and the Senate. The House race is expected to be a formality, with current minority leader Hakeem Jeffries as the sole declared candidate for House speaker.
The Senate race, however, is shaping up to be more interesting: In the upper chamber, current minority leader Chuck Schumer is facing a challenge from Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen, who argues that Senate Democrats need new leadership to meet the demands of voters who delivered them a majority.
“The call was really to reject the status quo and to reject business as usual,” Van Hollen said. “And to do that, I think we need new leadership.”
Van Hollen is also the favored candidate of the party’s progressive faction, many members of which have soured on Schumer. Corbin Trent, a former communications director for Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the founder of the super PAC A Fight Worth Having, is one of those: He tells Today, Explained that Schumer’s and Jeffries’s style of leadership is ill-suited for this moment, and he wants to see new Democratic leaders in both chambers. He also argues that Democrats should embrace a more proactive style of governing that harkens back to the New Deal era.
Trent spoke with Today, Explained co-host Sean Rameswaram about who he wants to see lead the Democrats instead, why consensus-building is not enough, and why now is the right time to have this fight.
Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get your podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.
Who do you think should be leading Democrats in the House and Senate in the new year?
I think that this moment calls for some sort of leadership that shows that we have a plan, an agenda, and a vision that’s capable of taking on and meeting this moment. And it’s not Hakeem Jeffries. It’s not Chuck Schumer.
I know that’s the way we do things in the House, that’s the way we do things in the Senate. But look at the popularity of both of those institutions and then think to yourself, maybe we should do things a little differently.
Why not Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer?
Hakeem Jeffries has proven either one of two things. Either he’s incapable of wrangling the caucus, or his priorities are very different than the Democratic Party and the independent voters that voted for the Democrats in this election.
What I mean by that is we’ve had three shots at stripping war powers away from Donald Trump vis-a-vis Iran. And, oh, lo and behold, one, two, three Democrats defected
He is not supporting an arms embargo to Israel. He’s not a guy who is representing the will of the people writ large. He is very much the establishment Democrat that I think led to Donald Trump being elected twice.
Chuck Schumer is a man with a strongly worded letter in his back pocket. He’s the man that wants to pick up a couple of voters in rural Pennsylvania that are Republicans. Neither of them have a vision for building a Democratic supermajority that is akin to the one that was built around the New Deal.
I think that this moment is very similar to that moment in that it is rife with opportunity. People are hopeful, people are ready for change, but the problem with hope is that when it’s dashed, it calcifies and it becomes resentment and anger.
And Democrats seem to miss that every time.
Over and over and over and over. I can remember how inspired I was by Barack Obama during his first presidential campaign — so inspired that I got involved in politics. I went to an event in Asheville to watch him speak. I started raising money for him on his portal, and I had a watch party.
It was not my thing, but he inspired me to do all this stuff. And then several months later, what I’m hearing is a very different thing as a president than as a candidate. So we can’t keep missing these opportunities, in my mind.
Why do Jeffries and Schumer seem so confident in this moment? Schumer has a challenger, Chris Van Hollen. Hakeem kind of has one in Ayanna Pressley, but they don’t seem very worried that their positions might be in jeopardy right now. How come?
Because that’s just not the way things are done in the House, and they I think have faith that things will continue being done the way they are. Momentum, norms, all of these things point to them not having any real problem getting their leadership taken away.
But Joe Crowley also felt that way. And then famously AOC spanked his little bottom in 2018, and now he’s a consultant instead of a congressman. Now we’d be having a very different conversation, because he was the one that was in line to be the next speaker of the House.
AOC is backing Jeffries. How come? What’s your reaction to that?
I mean, is she backing Jeffries? She’s doing this weird little thread-the-needle: “He’s the only one. What can we do?”
But that’s the exact kind of thinking that you’re saying Democrats should rebuff.
Absolutely, they should. And interestingly, the most important thing to learn from Nancy Pelosi in my mind is that power is not given, it is taken. Power is not something that people give you. It is something that you take and then utilize.
The fact is that [the Congressional Progressive Caucus] has 99 members, and it is going to have more. The fact is that these members have the capacity to generate more media than most.
They can either take this moment to build power for the American people that ends up building a super-majoritarian Democratic Party, one that can make the Republican Party small enough to drown in a bathtub, or they can try to do business as usual, work with Hakeem, work with Schumer, try to extract some concessions, which they will not give.
Because like you say, they have no fear. They do not fear these people. They respond to threats and fear, fear of losing their job.
Help us understand why someone like AOC doesn’t want this job. I mean, she’s one of the most visible Democrats in the country, and surely she’d be a popular candidate, right?
I can’t explain why people do what they do. Even I can’t explain why I do what I do, let alone other people.
It doesn’t sound like a fun job. I can understand not wanting it. There is a lot of potential downside. You’re going to get ire because you’ve got to either deliver, which is going to be very difficult with Donald Trump still in the White House, or you’ve got to be really good at working to show that you’re attempting to deliver something big and you’re being blocked and by whom.
The problem is a lot of people that are going to be standing in your way are going to be Democratic representatives and Democratic senators. Because the thing that I have come to understand is that there is a team of people that want to make this country fundamentally different, fundamentally more fair: Look at the healthcare system that we have and fundamentally rethink it. Look at the economy we have with AI and robotics burgeoning and fundamentally rethink it.
But that team right now isn’t very big and it’s not like, oh, all Democrats are on board with this vision. They’re not.
You point at something that I think is relevant here, which is that this job of speaker of the House, Senate majority leader, it isn’t a walk in the park. It takes a certain type, perhaps. Maybe it takes a consensus builder.
We had Rahm Emanuel on the show after the midterms and he said that Hakeem Jeffries was that. Do you think it takes someone in the middle of all of this to suss out where the caucus is and that’s why maybe we’re not getting the most exciting people, but we’re getting people who’ve been around for a while?
Well, according to [incoming Rep.] Don Leonard, there’s a different tactic that this particular leadership uses to bring consensus. And it’s not the hand-holding, middle-of-the-road consensus-building. It’s threats: threats of making your life a living hell for two years, threats of not getting any committee assignments, threats of not getting gavels.
Ultimately, this gave us Romneycare. This kind of middle-of-the-road nonsense gave us something that got rebranded as Obamacare, and it has not slowed down the increase of our costs. It saved lives.
And here’s the problem with that: You had a Democratic caucus with 59 or 60 votes in the Senate and a majority in the House. And you had Barack Obama in there on a wave election of change. People like me got in there. And what the reasonable people were able to tell you as a new member or as a member that wanted, say, a public option or something else is that 50,000 to 60,000 people a year die from lack of healthcare. This can save 4,000 to 5,000 of those lives. Are you willing to let 4,000 or 5,000 people a year die just to stand and fight for this other thing that will save the whole 50,000?
Because ultimately when you’re put in these positions, you’re given these choices and the choice is: Fight for the thing that can actually do the most good. Build power toward that thing and then at least make your compromise better. The compromise should have been the public option, but that means you got to fight for something bigger.
You don’t have names, per se…
[Rep.] Ayanna Pressley. I think Ayanna Pressley and [Chris] Van Hollen. That’s where I would go right now.
Van Hollen, not exactly a bastion of progressivism…
No.
But you think he could do the job?
I think he could do the job.
And I think part of the thing here that’s just as important as getting a speaker that’s better or a leader that’s better is beating those people, flexing the power of the people. I’m not going to let the perfect be the enemy of the good here. I am going to let good be the enemy of bad. And I think that’s where we’re at right here.
My politics are definitely to the left of Van Hollen or whatever spectrum you want to look at. But I think the fight in and of itself is worth it, and winning is worth it.
Sens.-elect Annie Andrews (D-SC) and James Talarico (D-TX) walk through the US Capitol as they arrive for new member orientation meetings for the 120th Congress, in Washington, DC, on November 9, 2026. | Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images
If you want to own a gun, there are few places better to do it than South Carolina. As the gun rights organization the National Rifle Association (NRA) notes on its database of state gun laws, the Palmetto State has no restrictions on the class of guns dubbed assault weapons or large-capacity magazines; there is no permit required to openly carry firearms.
Its outgoing governor, Republican Henry McMaster, was supported by the NRA’s political wing, which noted that he netted an “A” rating in their 2018 scores. None of this is surprising. It’s located in the Deep South, after all — that’s the headquarters of America’s gun culture.
But what is surprising is that the NRA lost a key election this midterms, when its candidate, the incumbent Republican Sen. Darline Graham, lost to Democratic nominee Annie Andrews.
“I hate the NRA,” Andrews wrote on her X page in September 2024. In another previous missive, she blamed the NRA for creating a “hellscape” at her child’s school where a police officer stands guard during recess.
The pediatrician-turned-senator-elect was not shy about her view on America’s easy access to guns. She had previously held a job at Everytown for Gun Safety, a group that organizes for more strict gun laws. Her campaign website this cycle included a call to ban “weapons of war from our streets” — an allusion to assault weapons.
In 2013, 15 Democratic senators voted against one such proposed ban on assault weapons, including lawmakers from significantly more liberal states like Virginia and Colorado. That year, Georgia’s Democratic gubernatorial candidate Jason Carter (the grandson of former president Jimmy Carter) campaigned on his proud support for gun rights — one story noted that he held a 92 percent rating from the NRA.
And yet starting in January, an even more conservative state will be sending an avowed opponent of the NRA to the Senate.
And it’s not just guns where Andrews is much more liberal than the traditional Southern or red-state Democrat. If her X page is any indication, her ideal president is Elizabeth Warren. She finds Israel’s conduct toward the Palestinians to be “morally unconscionable” and she pledged to never take money from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC). She’s ardently pro-choice. She posed with a sticker reading “protect trans kids.” She wants to dramatically expand tax credits for families with kids. And her old Resistance-style social media videos have become an object of popular fascination.
Andrews is part of a wave of Southern and red-state Democrats who are redefining what it means to be a Democrat in these traditionally conservative environments. While these Democrats don’t have the politics of, say, your average member of the Democratic Socialists of America or Vermont’s independent Sen. Bernie Sanders, they represent a significant departure from the conservative Democrats who dominated the region the last time they represented these states.
How the changing South explains the new candidates
For years, it was assumed that Democrats who hail from the South and other conservative-leaning states would only be viable if they matched a certain traditional motif — think a white guy who poses with his gun and speaks in a thick accent in his ads.
But this crop of Democrats is leaning into a new, millennial era of voters who are significantly more progressive than the Dixiecrats of old.
The South’s booming economies have attracted an influx of Black voters — who turned out in huge numbers for Democrats this cycle — and grown its diverse cities and suburbs in multiple states, which have become more favorable territory for Democrats. “The white population keeps getting better in Mississippi,” Democratic Senate leader Chuck Schumer bluntly told skeptics of his party’s candidates, according to The Atlantic, pointing to new tech workers with more progressive views. Pair those trends with a new openness among rural voters to Democrats’ increasingly populist message — and depressed turnout from some upset with President Donald Trump’s record — and that’s a coalition that can elect some very different candidates.
You have, for instance, Georgia’s Sen. Jon Ossoff. Ossoff, a graduate of Georgetown University and the London School of Economics, leaned into his identity as a booksmart critic of corruption and a rigged economy. Unlike the Joe Manchins and Kyrsten Sinemas of yesteryear, he supported most major Democratic policies in Congress. He earned the ire of AIPAC for his votes to curb some arms sales to Israel. His victory speech following the election included zero Clintonian rhetoric about curbing government deficits or cracking down on street crime; instead, he pledged to fight corporate money, end endless wars, and establish universal health care.
He campaigned proudly as an opponent of bigotry and racism. One of his main lines of attack on his opponent, Republican Rep. Mike Collins, was that he had surrounded himself with racist and white nationalist staffers and family members.
“If John Lewis were marching today from Selma to Montgomery, Mike Collins would be grabbing a billy club,” he said during one debate with Collins.
Although he courted Republicans through his strong constituent services and support for community services, he also maintained his progressive cultural commitments. Despite prognostication from Republicans that his refusal to compromise on transgender issues would serve as a vulnerability, it had no apparent impact on his landslide victory.
And he wasn’t the only statewide Democrat in Georgia who donned a populist mantle. Across the state, the newly elected Democrats plan to take on corporate power, a departure from the state’s traditionally big business-friendly regulatory environment. Lt. Gov.-elect Josh McLaurin campaigned against the state’s anti-union “right-to-work” law and against the power of “oligarchs and billionaires.” Insurance Commissioner-elect Keisha Waites is proposing banning insurers from using zip codes to discriminate on price. Attorney General-elect Tanya Miller is taking aim at grocery price gouging and utility rate increases. Like Ossoff, Miller refused to compromise on her principles when it comes to transgender people; as a member of the Georgia House, she walked out of the chamberto protest a GOP effort to ban gender-affirming care for transgender people in Georgia prisons, defending her stance in a debate with her opponent.
Who are the new Southern progressives?
Arguably the most strident incoming House members are, paradoxically, in some of the most conservative districts — often protest candidates who ran with little expectation of winning and felt less pressure to adjust their message to please strategists or donors. In Tennessee, eight-term GOP incumbent Rep. Scott DesJarlais fell to Democratic candidate Victoria Broderick, a progressive who campaigned on raising corporate taxes as well as establishing Medicare-for-all. She will also be the first openly queer person to serve in the state’s congressional delegation.
Not just the rich. Not just the folks lucky enough to have a good job with benefits. EVERYBODY.
Put the bill on the floor. Let’s see who’s willing to look working families in the eye and tell them they don’t deserve to see a… https://t.co/M7TDg2jOjc
Texas’s James Talarico, who will become the first Democratic senator to represent the state in almost 40 years, ran a campaign railing against the power of billionaires in the American political and economic system — sounding at times more like Bernie Sanders than a Blue Dog Democrat.
“The billionaires who own the social media algorithms, who own the cable news networks, who own the politicians fighting on the screens, they want us at each other’s throats,” he told the assembled crowd after his victory.
His platform included raising taxes on the ultra-rich, a departure from the tax-skeptical climate of the American South. And he warned that “the real fight in this country is not left versus right. It is top versus bottom.”
“We see that things are so stacked against working people in this country….if I were to pick a label to describe what are my politics, it is economic populism,” she told the New York Times.
Even Scott Colom, the Democrat who won notoriously conservative Mississippi with a comparatively more moderate platform, has sounded a few progressive notes. He has rejected money from AIPAC and he campaigned not just on prosecuting violent crime but also on reforming the criminal justice system to make it more humane.
In a poetic twist, Colom was blocked from becoming a federal judge by incumbent Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith, who cited his purported opposition to restrictions on transgender athletes’ participation in girls’ and women’s sports; now she has found herself soon to be replaced by Colom.
And while factionalist debates between avowed progressives and centrists roil social media, Colom’s coalition was cross-ideological — Morris Katz, a consultant who previously worked for New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, helped make ads that attacked his GOP opponent. Colom also credited a former Bernie Sanders and Jeremy Corbyn operative with helping craft his video strategy.
This isn’t to say that these Democrats don’t have their own peculiarities that distinguish them from progressives on the coasts. They do, after all, represent states with their own unique culture and interests. Ossoff voted to toughen immigration enforcement after the murder of his constituent Laken Riley. Talarico made a point to support Texas’s local oil and gas industry. Andrews, despite her general support for transgender rights, opposed allowing gender surgery for kids and what she called “men in women’s sports.”
But one thing is certain. For decades, Southern states were used to sending Democrats to Congress who in many ways resembled their Republican colleagues more than they did Democrats elsewhere in the country. But this new crop of red-state Democrats are much more unabashedly populist, focused on fighting corporate power, and culturally liberal than their most recent ancestors were.
Newly elected members of Congress pose for a group photograph on the steps of the US Capitol Building on November 12, 2026, in Washington, DC | Andrew Harnik/Getty Images
Everyone from party insiders to the pundits have now parsed the results from the midterm elections, and few races are left to call. Soon, the political world will turn its sights to the 2028 presidential election — but first, America, Actually is taking a moment to reflect on eight months of reporting across the country.
That included anger about the construction of a data center in southern New Jersey; Democratic hopes for a governing trifecta in Wisconsin, understanding the “Trump slump” — a combination of the pain from tariffs and the fear of immigration enforcement — in Las Vegas; and hearing voters in a crucial swing district in Pennsylvania connect the war in Iran with high gas prices.
No one votes for president in 2027, but the issues that we saw on the road are a reminder that politics doesn’t only live in the voting booth (and, of course, they’ll have implications for 2028).
This week on America, Actually, I spoke with host Astead Herndon about the moments that we just can’t stop thinking about from our reporting.
Below is an excerpt from that conversation, focusing on two aspects of this year’s midterms: how the results could reverberate in the GOP presidential race and what Angie Nixon’s close loss in her Senate race in Florida says about who the Democratic Party establishment will choose to support as the 2028 presidential primary gets underway in 2027. It has been edited for length and clarity.
There’s much more in the full show, including a discussion of Trump’s declining cultural cachet, an evolving Democratic base, and the rise of the lefty boomer resistance. You can listen to full episodes of America, Actually wherever you get your podcasts or watch on Vox’s YouTube channel.
We reported that there were really two strategies that Republicans were using going into this year’s midterm. The first one was basically ignore Trump or distance yourself from Trump, and the other one was to throw money at the polling problem.
Now, obviously, neither of those worked. I don’t really want to flatten that analysis too much, but there are plenty of examples of those who had actually distanced themselves from Trump who ended up losing, right? I’m thinking about Mike Lawler from New York. Obviously, Vivek Ramaswamy in his Ohio governor’s race crashed and burned. We’ve had a lot of really high-profile races where going away from Trump didn’t really work.
One foot in and one foot out doesn’t help when something is this universally disliked.
And also, the Republican Party didn’t use the levers of power at any point to push back against what Trump has been doing in the last couple years. I think the Iran war is the big one. Like, it was time to shine and to say something, and they didn’t.
But what does that mean for 2027? Is the Trump era over?
I don’t like that question because at the same time, we’ve seen him use executive power. I don’t think he’s going to back off of his agenda. Steven Miller’s the new chief of staff. Obviously, that represents a double down in itself. But it’s up to Congress to do its job to reassert itself, right?
Which they have abdicated completely.
Yeah, they’ve abdicated on their own. And so I think it remains to be seen how they even go about the work of holding [Trump] accountable.
The other piece is that Trump remains the most popular figure within the Republican Party. And the one thing we know about Republicans is that they circle around him as he’s embattled. And so I just don’t think we can assume that even a mass rejection from the public now means he does not have the most important role in choosing their nominee for the future. I think that’s going to be a big question that 2027 plays out.
His popularity generally is waning. His popularity specifically with them is intact. Does that change?
Do you think that the distancing or playing the blame game that we’re seeing from Vice President JD Vance or Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, does that signal anything for 2027, or it’s too early?
It means that Vance has some challengers. It means DeSantis is probably running, and Ted Cruz and all these others.
And I do think that that coronation that might have seemed like a cakewalk three weeks ago is less so now. But I think we’ve got some more twists and turns to come.
Okay.
My last one, honestly, is an answer I’ve thought about a lot when we talked to Angie Nixon, the Senate Democratic candidate in Florida, and it was actually when I asked her about her joining the Democratic Socialists of America, that became such a way that national politics was defining her race.
And one of the things I remember is the way that she shrugged off the idea that she should be defined by that label. and I think it really came through in that interview that this was someone who had their own political brand, that was kind of marching to the beat of their own drum, and that was what drove that primary win in Florida.
I think this matters a lot for 2027: The gap between how national politics and our kind of media ecosystem sees these fights, particularly between moderate, progressive, DSA, the center, is not how the country’s engaging.
The fuzziness.
The fuzziness is so important, and I think a candidate like that — who now data’s telling us won counties like Miami-Dade [in Florida] — I think speaks to the idea that people are ingesting individuals and their ideas rather than the labels that sometimes we put them in.
The other thing I was thinking about when thinking about Angie Nixon — obviously there’s been a huge discussion about whether the Democratic Party missed a chance to invest in her race and win in Florida.
I think we’re entering a period where those types of insiders’ decisions matter a lot. When we talk about the 2027 presidential race, there’ll be no primaries decided. This will be a lot of polling. This will be a lot of donor decisions. This will be a lot of community group endorsements and access, handshaking, and stuff like that.
And so sometimes those presumptions of who’s electable and who’s not may not actually matter to the public but they matter in terms of shaping who gets to Iowa, shaping who gets to New Hampshire.
I think that’s a huge thing for next year. Those kinds of insider discussions about who can win and who not, or what they presume the public wants or not — I don’t think that actually changes people’s votes. I think that crowd has kind of had a credibility loss with the Democratic base. But I do think it can shape some of the early markers that help a candidate rise and fall in the next six to eight months.
Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-MS) speaks during a victory celebration for Mississippi Sen.-elect Scott Colom at Tougaloo College in Tougaloo, Mississippi, on November 11, 2026. | Aron Smith/Jackson State University via Getty Images
On Wednesday, Mississippi’s Senate race was officially called for Democrat Scott Colom, who will become the first Black person to represent the state in the US Senate since Reconstruction, more than 140 years ago. Colom’s win is a stunning, historic upset — and for many Black Democrats, like Rep. Bennie Thompson, it’s been a long time coming.
Thompson, who also won his race last week, has represented Mississippi’s majority-Black Second Congressional District since 1993. Over the years, the 78-year-old lawmaker has frequently invoked the story of his father, who was never able to cast a vote because of racist Jim Crow laws that enforced segregation until the mid-1960s.
I sat down with Thompson for Today, Explained to talk about Colom’s run for Senate, how he won, what it means for Thompson personally.
Below is an excerpt of our conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.
Your dad was never able to cast a vote during his lifetime because of Jim Crow laws. And I wonder, growing up in Mississippi, what did you learn about who was allowed to participate in democracy?
You were a second-class citizen. That means you could go to school, but you couldn’t go to school with the white kids. Or the one swimming pool in town was for white kids, and the Black kids had to swim in the creeks or the ponds around the community. No lifeguard, no anything. My mama and daddy paid taxes, but they weren’t allowed to vote. My uncle fought in World War II; defended democracy all over the world, but when he came back home, he had to ride a segregated train behind the white German prisoners.
Jesus.
So you had the white soldiers, the white German prisoners, and the Black soldiers. And that was the order of the day. It was something that we grew up with.
When you were young, I wonder, did you associate the right to vote with the ability to change things? Like, if we get to cast a ballot, then we get to fix this mess?
The best thing that I can say is I went to Tougaloo College [near Jackson, Mississippi]. And on that college campus, I met Martin Luther King Jr., I met Stokely Carmichael, I met Harry Belafonte, I met Sammy Davis Jr. — all of the major civil rights icons of the day.
That was how we cut our teeth into civil rights and voting rights. The first campaign I worked on was Mrs. Hamer’s campaign for Congress.
Fannie Lou Hamer, the civil rights icon.
And I now represent that district.
But I remember telling my mother that, oh, I had gone to Ruleville, Mississippi, to help register Black people to vote for Congress. And my mama said, “Well, I don’t know why you way up there.” Said, “Black people don’t vote here in Bolton.” And so it hit me. And Lord have mercy. In my own hometown, you know, I was in the same situation. And we did voter registration. We did all kind of things.
“For me, having gone through those life experiences and now to see a Scott come along, you know, it not only brings tears to your eye, but it also says that there’s hope.”
We brought Head Start to the community, and started understanding that real freedom comes with political freedom. And so we started holding meetings about what we wanted to do. We decided to run three people for the board and the three African Americans won.
But it really wasn’t a good four years on that term because the current mayor didn’t want any progress. So we ran an all-Black slate: mayor, clerk, alderman. We won every position.
We’re talking about 50 years ago, and all these challenges that you faced, all these challenges to being able to vote, being able to assume office, being able to function as a mayor in a town that is so segregated. Fifty years later, Scott Colom is winning in Mississippi.
I want to ask you to reflect on when you became aware of his candidacy and what you thought about the potential there.
One of the challenges that I’ve had to deal with is that every time I run for public office, I’ve always been the first. But I wanted to create some kind of vehicle to get other people engaged. So we formed the Mississippi Black Leadership Institute. Well, Scott Colom was in the first class. And he really said, “I want to run for something. I don’t know what it is.” He said, “But there’s a district attorney’s position that’s available. It’s three counties.”
We helped Scott put his campaign together. We hooked him up with various people, and he beat a 28-year incumbent as district attorney.
Why do you think he won?
Well, because he had the fire in the belly. And he never met a stranger. And so we prepared him, and he’s one of our star pupils of that class. And look, uh, when the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee would not support him, they—
They would not support him.
They would not support him. But this was my — Bennie Thompson’s position is that Northeasterners were still looking down on Southerners.
Well, did you call them up and scream at Chuck Schumer or somebody and say, “Guys, I am telling you, we got one here who can win?”
Look, we did everything that the system says you should do. We gave the demographics. That district [Colom] represented was not a majority-African American district. He beat that sitting district attorney in a majority-white district because he had a plan and he had a message. We had a rich message, but a poor campaign. Because we couldn’t get our DSCC to help.
Have you called any of those people in national leadership and said, “I told you so?”
Oh yeah. All of a sudden, the week before the election, they’re going to say, “Well, we’re going to be able to do this, but we’re going to shoot the spot and we’ll send it to you.” So you really didn’t give us the money. You know what I’m saying?
So that’s all right. We’re going to keep doing our low budget, social media-attractive thing. And so it took off.
You are 78 years old? Do I have that right?
Yep.
This has been most of your life. The fight for this has been most of your life.
Yep.
You sit here today, we sit here today. Where is your head at in all of this? Did you lock yourself in the bathroom and cry for 10 minutes?
No question. I’m happy for Scott personally. His trajectory is tremendous. But you know, it’s been a tough journey. We had a poll tax put on us that we had to pay money to be a registered voter. We had to interpret sections of the Constitution. In many instances when my mama registered — my mama had a college degree, she was a teacher — but the person who asked her to interpret the Constitution was an elementary school graduate. You see what I’m saying?
I sure do.
And so for me, having gone through those life experiences and now to see a Scott come along, you know, it not only brings tears to your eye, but it also says that there’s hope. There’s hope for young African Americans that at some point, the choice will be, do I stay or leave? It won’t be, “Well, when I get an education, I have to go somewhere else to seek a career.”
And so that’s the exciting part. I’m just really happy. And for a guy who’s been in it over 50 years and been called everything but a child of God, because I’m trying to elevate people who look like me to where I know if they have it, they’ll do a great job. So for Bennie Thompson, Scott’s victory is a dream come true.
An under-construction data center in Saline, Michigan, on October 6, 2026. | Jim West/UCG/Universal Images Group via Getty Images
Republicans weren’t the only big losers in last week’s midterms: Across the country, voters also backed restrictions on data centers and elected candidates promising tougher oversight of AI companies. Out of 41 local ballot initiatives limiting the data center buildout, 40 of them passed, according to the New York Times.
The AI industry knows it was a tough cycle: Chris Lehane, the chief global affairs officer for OpenAI, told Today, Explained co-host Sean Rameswaram that “I could take my shirt off and show you my [metaphorical] bruises if you want.”
Now, OpenAI is figuring out how to move forward. Lehane talked with Sean from rural Texas, where he said he was on a “listening and learning” tour of communities around the site of a massive OpenAI data center. They discussed the lessons of the midterm election, why OpenAI would prefer that we call data centers “compute campuses,” and why Lehane thinks the 2028 presidential election will largely revolve around AI — just not in the same way that 2026 did.
“I just don’t think it’s going to be good enough for a candidate from either party to emerge from their primary by simply being the person who’s against things,” Lehane said.
Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.
You guys at OpenAI, in the wake of this shellacking, put out this big document saying that you’re going to be listening, you’re going to be learning, you’re going to be empowering local people and bringing jobs.
You’re also, in this document, rebranding data centers to “compute campuses,” which when I say it, I have trouble not laughing because it sounds like a bit of a joke to meet everyone’s concerns with a rebrand. Please tell us why you think this could work or why it’s a good idea.
We were very intentional in actually using that phrase. And we did it with the full knowledge that people would potentially be skeptical of it. But I do think there’s an intent behind provoking this conversation.
Data centers have existed for 20-odd years and at some level they’re the proverbial empty box in a pasture. And they’re called data centers because that’s in fact what they were. When people talked about the cloud, this is actually where the cloud was housed, where you would load data if you were streaming a video, if you were ordering something from a delivery service. These AI facilities are really fundamentally different.
What is being generated at these facilities is something called compute. And compute is just the raw computing power that it takes to train AI systems and then run AI tools and products when you’re using them.
Second of all, they’re different because [of] the amount of jobs that do get created directly. This is not half a dozen people in that empty box. These are real jobs, these are six-figure jobs. They are also huge opportunities for economic transformation if a community approaches it in a really strategic way and companies like ours do our part to work with those communities. We’re not just building in the communities, we’re building with the communities.
You’re out there in Texas because essentially, data centers and artificial intelligence have a PR problem. Seventy percent of the country, maybe more than that, says that they’re against data centers, or “compute campuses,” as you’re now calling them.
Why do you think it is that data centers have such a public relations issue in this country right now?
There’s a variety of factors, but before even jumping into those, I do think it’s worth noting and worth emphasizing that we have roughly six of these projects up and running in the country. They’re in different stages of being built out and developed, but each and every one of them is moving forward. I do think that there is a right way to build these and perhaps a wrong way and we can get into that.
Do you think that you guys were doing it the wrong way before?
This goes to why I think we’ve actually been able to get approvals for each of the projects that we are doing.
I think each of the individual projects themselves have been some version of a laboratory of democracy, where you actually learn from each project and apply those learnings to the next project. But I do think we got the fundamental insight right at the beginning, which is to actually go on the ground, listen, learn, hold yourself accountable and take the feedback and build your facility with the community.
I think that for a lot of communities, folks were coming in, they were building data centers, they were then transferring the electricity costs to the public, they were potentially impacting their water, they weren’t necessarily doing the type of community investments that you should do if you’re going to be building with a community.
Where we’ve really tried to differ ourselves — and again, we’re not perfect, we’re learning every step of the way — but I do think that we have successfully applied the baseline as we’ve gone through this, which is, we make sure we’re paying for our own electricity, our own energy.
Point two is that we make sure we’re preserving water. We have something called closed water loops. I know this is getting a little bit technical, but think of these as sort of large radiators. You fill it up once and therefore you’re able to preserve the water.
One thing that seems clear from the election results is that there’s just not a lot of trust. Now there’s going to be a new Congress, and various components of said Congress are pledging to do more to regulate AI and tech.
It wasn’t so long ago that the head of your company, Sam Altman, was calling for Congress to get more involved. Does that call still stand now that it’s a different Congress that might be more inclined to come down hard on AI?
When it comes to data centers, these are typically state or local issues. We envisioned that as state legislation that would actually make these requirements for folks who are building data centers to help give the public confidence that there’s going to be a real material benefit for them.
I think what you’re referring to was our call as OpenAI for there to be national-level mandatory safety requirements for the frontier labs who are building AI. We thought about that and called for it before the election. We think it’s more important than ever.
Back in early September, I had a blog post out there that talked about this idea that the policy window was opening up to create a real opportunity to pass those mandatory safety requirements. And the reason I talked about the policy window being opened up is that you could clearly see where the politics were going, what was likely to happen with the election.
You’re in Washington, DC. At some level, you have to be a romanticist to believe that you can actually get legislation passed. But what is happening is the politics are coming into alignment with the policy. I actually think both parties do recognize the importance of having mandatory national safety standards that would be good for the country. It would also put us in a position to be able to create international standards, which we also think is very important.
It’s funny, because we just had New York [state] assemblyman Alex Bores on the show. He was trying to be a congressperson, but a super PAC partly funded by OpenAI co-founders and some other Silicon Valley tech types spent a lot of money — millions — to defeat him.
We asked him, if Democrats in Congress could do one thing to regulate AI, what would it be? And he said banning full recursive self-improvement, ban the practice of letting AIs build the next AIs without any human in the loop. Would OpenAI be open to that kind of regulation immediately?
The version that we have talked about is some version of broadly defined speed limits. I’ll use an analogy: As we were building out the automobile, ultimately we built out speed limits. Now, those speed limits changed over time, but the idea was to make sure that humans could actually have both hands on the wheel and be able to control the car and the car should not be able to go at a speed where a human would not be able to control it.
Our north star in everything when it comes to AI is that people should be in control of this technology. The technology itself is accelerating, the capabilities are becoming stronger. And so I think there is a world here where we do need to build out a framework, potentially a regulatory framework, through legislation that effectively imposes some version of a speed limit.
If you think of speed limits being applied in the context of your question about recursive self-improvement, that’s a place where you could see the speed of the technology getting so strong that actually humans do lose control over it.
I’m not sure it’s quite as binary as saying you do or do not do RSI. But I think spiritually, a similar concept, which is making sure that at the end of the day we have a lot of confidence that humans are actually in control of this, able to monitor it, able to make sure that it is not getting out of their control.
Before you worked with companies like OpenAI or Coinbase or Airbnb, you worked in government and you worked specifically in [the] Clinton White House.
I wonder, in the wake of this election — which people are calling the first big American AI election, and are saying that AI is going to be an even bigger issue for the presidential election in 2028 — what do you think companies like yours and all the other big-frontier AI companies need to be doing to flip the script in the United States, maybe around the world?
I think of 2026 as the trailer to 2028. AI was an issue. It wasn’t a top issue, but it was certainly an issue and an issue that was moving up the charts as we got closer and closer to the election. I think there is a decent chance, maybe even a strong chance, that AI is the issue in 2028.
First and foremost, how do we make sure that people are actually in control of this technology? Who’s actually putting out an idea and a vision and approach to give people confidence that they’re going to actually be able to control this?
I do think the 2026 election now sets up 2028, frankly for both parties, to have a conversation that I just don’t think we’ve had in this country for a long, long, long time. And that is, what does this social contract look like? Who actually has a big idea about how we’re going to make sure that the American dream actually exists in this country? And as part of that big idea, what is the role of AI going to be in that?
I just don’t think it’s going to be good enough for a candidate from either party to emerge from their primary by simply being the person who’s against things. I think they’re actually going to have to have some real ideas of what they are for. And at the core of that is, how are they going to address this anxiety that the American people have? And at the center of that anxiety is their ability to control their lives and make decisions about their lives.
Voters arrive to cast their ballots at a polling location inside St. Patrick Parish Center in White Lake, Michigan on Election Day. | Emily Elconin/Bloomberg via Getty Images
One of the most eye-opening aspects of last week’s midterms was the new cohort of religious politicians it sent to Congress — many of them part of a wave of Democratic-leaning Christians.
Another striking feature was the dramatic shift among many religious voters.
For years, American politics has seemed stuck on a partisan track, with religious-identified voters shifting more firmly to the right, and the nonreligious tacking to the left. There are a few exceptions, of course — Jewish voters, Latino Catholics, and Black Protestants, who have stayed firmly Democratic — but the broader tide has flowed clearly one way.
Key takeaways
This year’s blue tsunami carried voters everywhere to the left; it also scrambled voting trends in America’s religious electorate.
Catholics shifted hard to the left after Donald Trump won their vote by a double-digit margin in 2024.
Jewish voters were still strongly Democratic, though there are clear signs of lower support than in previous electoral cycles.
Other religious groups, mainline Protestants and Muslims, contributed to a diverse Democratic coalition — while evangelicals appeared less enthusiastic to turn out.
The 2026 vote, for the first time in a while, makes that picture look less certain. Based on exit polls, county-level data, and some post-election analysis, we already have a handful of intriguing signs of change. The data is still early and patchy, but it appears thatCatholic voters around the country moved left, evangelical Christians stayed home, and some Jewish voters dug in against the anti-Israel rhetoric and moved rightward. And in Utah, generational differences, particularly among Mormons, may be starting to change the political makeup of a rock-ribbed conservative state.
There are caveats: Wave elections, especially when they’re of the historic proportions of last week’s Democratic tsunami, can obscure and cloud these changes. When everyone moves in one direction, it can be hard to distinguish specific storylines. And with religion, as with any single voterattribute, it can be difficult to tease out just how much faith and religious identity influenced vote choice, as opposed to working in combination with race, class, and concerns about issues like affordability and immigration.
And better data is still to come; the gold standard of voter roll-validated studies, like the Pew Research Center’s, won’t be available until next year.
Yet that combination of factors also suggests a new possibility for our politics: that religious voters of all creeds can come to function as swing voters too, cracking up old alliances, like on the religiousright, and offering the hint of new winning coalitions, as Catholics and mainline Protestant Christians seem to have done for the Democrats.
The largest shift: Catholic voters swung against the GOP
Catholics play a special role in American politics. They spent much of the last century operating as a solid Democratic bloc, reaching a peak in the 1960s when John F. Kennedy, the first Catholic president, won about 80 percent of their vote. Since then, they’ve gradually become more Republican, due to assimilation of former European Catholic immigrants, the rise of conservative activism over abortion and social issues, and the rise of the religious right.
In the last two decades, Catholics have tended to reflect the views of the median American voter, evenly split in the 2012, 2016, and 2020 presidential elections. But that changed in 2024. Across different polls and surveys, Catholics shifted decisivelyto the right: backing Trump 59-39 according to exit polls, and 55-43, according to the Pew Research Center.
Now, in a year in which Trump and Republicans frequently clashedwithPope Leo XIV and his bishops — over the Iran war, mass deportations, and immigration policy — Catholic voters again turned into a wild card.
This year, according to exit polls, they swung left, with the margin shifting by more than 20 points. Democrats narrowly won the Catholic vote this time, 50-49. As a subgroup, that put Catholics up there with Asian voters, Latinos, urban and suburban voters, Gen Z and millennials as being the top groups that swung to the left this year.
Other estimates from the religion and politics scholar Ryan Burge show particularly noticeable shifts among white Catholics, swinging about 9 points toward Democrats, even if a majority of them still voted for Republican congressional candidates. In Texas, his analysis showed that counties with higher shares of Latino Catholics were much more likely to support the winning Democratic Senate candidate, James Talarico.
The results were even more dramatic in the most Catholic House districts. Of the 12 districts with the highest share of Catholics, the average swing in the vote was about 15 points, and Democrats won eight of these seats, while gaining in all 12.
Catholics have tended to basically operate like the median voter — swinging in the same direction as the overall popular vote. That makes it harder to pinpoint any unique motivators that caused Catholics to move against the GOP: Trump’s fights with Catholic leaders, the lack of a mobilized anti-abortion movement this year, or the affordability concerns that moved all voters.
One notable exception here are Latino Catholics, who tend to be the most Democratic of the Catholic electorate, and most opposed to Trump’s immigration and deportation policies this cycle. It’s no coincidence that they’re concentrated in the Southwest, including those parts of Texas that swung toward Talarico and Democratic gubernatorial candidate Gina Hinojosa over both economic stress and anger over immigration enforcement.
Does this all suggest the rise of a newCatholic swing vote? Potentially — combined with the decline in abortion politics in the US, and a more active Vatican. For the first time, the Church has an American pope, one who isn’t afraid to get involved with current affairs and push harder on Catholic social teachings (which align more with the Democratic Party’s views of society and the economy). That could have meaningful repercussions heading into 2028.
Though still very blue, some Jewish voters broke with the Democrats
Jewish Americans, though they only make up about 2 percent of the American population, became a huge focus of political attention this year — in large part because of how central they are to Democratic coalitions (along with Black Americans, they are some of the most loyal Democratic voters), and because Israel became a flashpoint in American politics.
As Democrats made a dramatic shift in the last two years in how they talk about Israel and AIPAC, with increasingly open criticism of the Israeli government’s actions,some Jewish Democrats and Republicans responded with charges of antisemitism — and some Republicans started leaning into overt Islamophobia, particularly in Michigan. In turn, Republicans made bold predictions that Democrats would see a large drop in support this year, especiallyinMichigan (with an anti-Israel Senate candidate)and New York, where they counted on Jewish voters to rally to the more pro-Israel party.
In the end, there was no mass exodus of Jewish voters — but the exit polls did report a slight shift toward the GOP this year: 68-31, compared to 78-22 in 2024. Other post-election surveys show similar dynamics. (The numbers can vary, in part because different pollsters use different metrics for measuring Jewish support and identity, and also because exit polls can be imprecise.) The Jewish Electorate Institute’s polling from the Mellman Group, for example, shows that while Democrats still held a large, 44-point advantage at the end of the day, (69 percent to the 25 percent that backed the GOP) that was smaller than the margin in 2024, and nearly 20 points smaller than their margin in 2018’s blue wave. That’s an anomaly, given the scale of the tsunami this year.
Even the most Democratic-friendly poll, from GBAO Strategies, had a kind of rightward signal, though a longer-horizon one: It showed nearly identical levels of Democratic support among Jewish voters this year as in 2024 — but both those figures, about 70 percent, are lower than Jewish Democratic support in 2022 (74 percent) and 2020 (77 percent), noted The Forward.
This shift away from Democrats looked especially dramatic in Michigan, where The Forward also noted last week that the winning Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed underperformed other Democratic candidates in precincts with large Jewish populations. In another piece of data, a Michigan exit poll from the NORC-Civic Health and Elections Project, there was a more dramatic result, albeit with a tiny sample size of about 100 people: Republican Senate candidate Mike Rogers winning a majority of Jewish voters, 52-47, a much worse result than it found for House Democratic candidates, who won the demographic by more than 30 points. Though small, it adds to other evidence of Democratic underperformance with Jewish voters in the Senate contest.
In surveys about their views, Jewish voters are sending signals that should put both parties on notice. A quarter of Republican Jews in the Mellman Group’s poll reported being concerned their party is “too accepting of antisemitic rhetoric within the Party” while a third said it’s “becoming too much of a home for White nationalists and the far right.”
More than a third of Jewish Democrats, similarly, said they worry the party is becoming “too accepting of antisemitic rhetoric within the Party,” while a quarter think it’s “becoming too much of a home for socialists and the far left.” Given how much larger the Jewish Democratic base is than the Republican one, and how central it is to winning coalitions in battlegrounds, these concerns pose a bigger electoral risk for the Democrats, particularly if the anti-Israel left grows into an even larger and more vocal wing of the party.
Protestants, and evangelicals, showed weaker Republican support
When it comes to evangelical Christians, the data suggests there was a different change afoot in the electorate.
They are perhaps the most important, or at least influential, religious group in American politics, given their strong and stable support for the Republican Party for the last 50 years. That loyalty has delivered them tremendous influence within party politics, while Trump, in particular, seems to have had a unique ability to turn these voters out during presidential elections. And at least in this year’s elections, that level of support for the GOP did not drop: they backed Republicans 82-16, consistent with their support for Trump in 2024.
What they didn’t do in 2026 is show up.
Exit polls suggest they made up a smaller share of the electorate when compared to 2026. That suggests a combination of lower turnout and lower enthusiasm may have contributed to Republican losses — even if those who did vote remained firmly Republican.
Still, the national results obscure one other notable trend that Burge, the religion scholar, noted from the 10 congressional districts with the highest share of evangelical voters — notably concentrated in the South (Alabama, Arkansas, Louisiana, Oklahoma, and Tennessee). Each of these districts swung left, by an average of 23 points — more than in Catholic or nonevangelical mainline Protestant districts. This suggests stronger turnout and enthusiasm from the non-evangelical portion of these local electorates, which skews more Democratic — and in turn a weaker ability by Republican candidates to turn out evangelical voters in the way that Trump seems like he uniquely can.
In sharp contrast to evangelicals, the oldest but least-healthy strain of American Christianity — the mainline Protestant denominations like Episcopalians, Presbyterians, and Methodists — seems to have delivered a more politically interesting result this year. Many of the House and Senate seats that flipped for the Democrats this year were won by mainline Protestants in Iowa, Kansas, and Texas. They represent what used to be the dominant Christian electorate — which this year demonstrated it could still be a decisive part of a winning Democratic majority.
Heavily mainline districts swung by an average of 15 points toward Democrats, and each of the top eight districts ended up flipping to the Democratic column. The exit polls showed a Democratic gain among Protestants and nonevangelical Christians in general — moving from backing Republicans 63-36 in 2024 to 60-39 this year, a 6-point swing on the margins that can explain these flips.
As these numbers suggest, this is a demographic that seems more ripe for moderate Democratic appeals in the future — though they have been neglected by the establishment left over the last few decades.
We have less data and reliable post-election polling so far on what happened with other parts of the electorate, like Muslim voters, Hindus, and Mormons. What data we do have suggests they all played a part in forming the tidal wave that carried Democrats to their stunning victory last week. But above it all, this year’s results suggest that religious voters can function as swing voters in the post-Trump future, play an influential role in forming winning coalitions, and are not solely the domain of the Republican Party.
Boxes containing the Electoral College votes are carried into the House Chamber during a joint session of Congress to ratify the 2024 presidential election. | Andrew Harnik/Getty Images
This story appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.
I don’t know how much time you spend in the more feverish right-wing corners of the internet, but some conservative commentators are growing very alarmed about a specific Democratic policy proposal that could be nearing fruition.
NPV isn’t quite as nefarious as that (Trump won the popular vote just two years ago!), though it would revolutionize how the United States conducts presidential elections. The compact is basically an agreement between states to award their electors to the winner of the national popular vote, regardless of how their own state voted. Once enough states sign on, their combined electoral votes would guarantee the presidency to whoever wins the national popular vote.
The compact has laid dormant for two decades, however, while its backers lobby to sign on more states and their electoral votes. Eighteen states and Washington, DC, have signed on thus far, representing 222 votes.
But with Democrats soon controlling state governments in Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, NPV could finally gain the critical mass to become reality. Politico reported on Tuesday that lawmakers in several states, including Pennsylvania, are already discussing the possibility.
There’s just one problem: Conservative influencers aren’t the only ones worried about the plan. In fact, even one of its architects has come to regard NPV as a “doomsday machine” that could trigger gigantic constitutional problems.
My colleague Andrew Prokop called up this conflicted architect, the Yale University professor Akhil Amar, earlier this week. Andrew has been writing and thinking about NPV for years. But Amar has been thinking about it even longer — since the aftermath of the 2000 election that made George W. Bush president.
Famously, Bush was elected even though he lost the popular vote, which Al Gore won by roughly half a percentage point. Amar thought the Electoral College was historically and inherently flawed, but only a constitutional amendment could abolish it.
Recognizing the long odds there, Amar and his brother instead sketched out a quick thought experiment — the broad strokes of what is now the NPV compact. The concept was later picked up and championed by the computer scientist John Koza and his group National Popular Vote Inc.
Koza has had quite a lot of success getting states to sign on to this workaround. But all the signees so far have leaned Democratic, which concerns Amar. The institution of the Electoral College doesn’t inherently favor one party over the other (in fact, both parties nearly got rid of it after the 1968 election), and the NPV wasn’t designed to tilt the scales, either. But as the discourse on right-wing social media suggests, Trump’s 2016 victory with a popular vote minority has only further hardened views on each side, and all the Democratic signatories have made it look like a partisan proposition.
There’s another problem too, Amar says. The compact leaves each participating state to calculate the national total, without a centralized body to oversee a nationwide count or recount. A very close election could leave states disagreeing over who won. But in the current environment, it’s actually hard to imagine a centralized body that both parties would find credible: People just don’t trust institutions the way they did in, say, 2000.
That puts NPV advocates in a tricky spot: The political process may finally favor the compact, but it faces significant cultural problems that could undermine its legitimacy.
Amar, for his part, thinks that even the small risk of electoral disruption outweighs the benefits of NPV. Especially since the Electoral College does actually work, whatever its shortcomings.
“The one thing we really do need to avoid as the stabilizing superpower in the world is constitutional chaos,” he told Vox. “And because this is sort of a new plan, even if it’s in principle likely to be better in all sorts of scenarios, if in a certain small percentage of cases it would lead to chaos, that’s something we need [to] seriously consider.”
One link for later
➨ Stop subway scrolling. If social media feels exhausting and overwhelming to you — which it does to me, often — try to stop logging on from public places. “People feel more lonely when they use social media while in transit, around people they have close relationships with, and when they are in nature,” says Vox contributor Shayla Love. “In contrast, when people use social media for shorter periods when they are alone at home or in study locations, it doesn’t have as much of a negative effect.”
Before you go…
Did you know…that the invention of fabrics like Spandex and Lycra changed not only what we wear — but when and how we wear it? With the advent of stretchy fabrics, Parisian fashion houses and the silhouettes they designed lost some of their influence.
Today’s trivia: What type of nymphs live in trees, as opposed to water, caves or clouds? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in tomorrow’s edition.)
Yesterday’s trivia: Yesterday we asked you what type of music Leontyne Price performed. That would be opera: Price, now 99, was among the first Black American opera singers to achieve acclaim around the world.
Even in the event of a caucus led by Chuck Schumer, left, and Hakeem Jeffries, the pressure on congressional Democrats to meet the moment of voter anger won't disappear. | Win McNamee/Getty Images
Welcome to The Midterms, Actually, where every week I write about two things: one big idea or trend I see and one thing I’m hearing from a voice on the ground. We’ll be taking a break for the rest of this year, but will be back to cover the key issues and people leading up to the 2028 election in the new year. Stay tuned!
One big idea
This Tuesday, just a week after voters delivered Democrats resounding midterm victories across the country behind a message of accountability and anti-corruption, Washington’s aversion to listening to voters reared its ugly head.
But the missed vote, which was condemned by progressives and moderates alike, also highlights a divide in the party beyond the traditional ideological camps. While “moderate” and “progressive” Democrats fight over which candidates performed better in last week’s midterms, and project those fights onto the congressional leadership debate, I’d say the bigger gap is between an anti-establishment electorate and a Washington blob stuck in the old ways of doing business.
I’ve been a broken record on this point, but this is why I find it more helpful to see this election through the lens of top versus bottom, not right versus left. That is not just a framework that can help you see how Democrats succeeded electorally, but also explains how you get candidates like Colom in Mississippi or Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan now calling for a change in leadership.
Slotkin made the case for a bolder version of Democratic “moderates” on our podcast in October. “I don’t think the divide is moderate versus progressive, particularly in the era of Trump,” she told me. “I think it is fight versus flight.”
Then, at a press conference with Bernie Sanders on Tuesday, she called for a “new generation of leadership.” She wants a leader who will govern for the whole caucus — blue, purple, and red states — and has asked for a full plan on the new majority’s priorities. Until then: “I’m a no until and unless I see that from anyone,” the Associated Press reported.
And here’s what said on this point back in March: “Leader Schumer, Leader Hakeem Jeffries, they’re both from the same borough,” Colom told Semafor, arguing the party needs leadership that understands rural America. Since the election, he has stayed noncommittal on Schumer, calling instead for more geographic diversity among party leaders, per the AP.
The charge for Democrats going forward wasn’t only about issues like anti-war, AI regulation, and lowering the cost of living, it was also to more robustly use the levers of power to frontally oppose this administration. One of Schumer’s biggest points of tension with Democrats was his refusal to shut down the government early in Trump’s term to challenge DOGE, and, later on, his failure to keep moderates united behind a shutdown that appeared to be putting real pressure on the administration to change its policies. That isn’t about right or left — that’s a call for more creativity on how politics are done.
I’m skeptical of the efforts to find a Jeffries or Schumer replacement in the short term. Washington works on access and relationships, first and foremost, and the uncomfortable reality is that, by the very nature of so many fresh faces, the anti-establishment wing of Democrats is at a deficit of options.
However, I’m fairly sure that even in the event of a Schumer- and Jeffries-led caucus, the pressure on congressional Democrats to meet the moment of voter anger won’t disappear. Because the Election Day win wasn’t just about the Democratic left, or its moderates, or arguments about electability — it was about change, and a voter-led outcry that is driven by backlash to this administration, but not solely defined by it.
It reminds me of what David Axelrod said on our show after the election. He reminded people that Democrats’ most successful electoral period — the Obama era — was built off an anti-establishment message, one that rejected the timidity, partisanship, and small-minded infighting between special interests that voters had come to loathe:
Barack Obama…was really fundamentally an anti-establishment candidacy. He was challenging the politics of both parties and the incumbent politics of Washington. … And I think that is the mood of the American people right now.
And here’s what he said about Jeffries/Schumer:
I’m not sure that they will take this advice, but I would be humble if I were them, because this victory was delivered by the American people. This victory wasn’t engineered in Washington. … They’re not sending people there to affirm status quo politics for Washington. They’re sending people there to change it.
Exactly.
What I’m hearing
Democrats won big around the country last week, but perhaps no state was more important — symbolically, politically, and substantively— than Texas. We asked the Texas Tribune’s Gabby Birenbaumto help walk us through just how an iconic red state swept Democrats into office up and down the ticket.
Texas has delivered Democratic wins for both Senate and governor. What are you hearing from people this morning, and was there a conversation or moment in your reporting that helped you understand how this happened?
I think there was very much an awareness that Talarico was in the driver’s seat for Senate, with cautious optimism from Democrats and concern from Republicans. But the idea of a statewide sweep was on the absolute far edge of people’s models, if on their radar at all. I think one of the biggest things I’ve been returning to today is what I heard from lifelong, more Bush/Cornyn-aligned Republicans on the trail this year. They couldn’t get there on Paxton. But more than that, a lot of them wanted to teach their party a lesson — that they should stop bullying them and then taking their votes for granted.
“People will be watching closely to see if their lives improve in the ways Democrats have promised.”
Talarico made his Christian faith central to his campaign, and there’s already talk of a resurgent religious left. How did that message land with the voters you spoke with? Did you see it reach people who wouldn’t ordinarily consider voting for a Democrat?
I think it worked in two ways. It gave a permission structure to nondenominational, more mainline Christians, especially soft Republicans and independents, to support him. And interestingly, Catholic Latino voters raised Talarico’s faith to me frequently. They said they appreciated that he was open about his faith.
Gina Hinojosa also defeated Greg Abbott. In your reporting, what connected these two victories? Were voters responding to the Democrats’ messages, turning against Republican leadership, or some combination—and which issues kept coming up?
I think asking for a fourth term is always difficult — especially so when people are frustrated about the economy. At the statewide level, one Republican described it to me as there being a Republican liability for every voter. Suburban moms were mad about Texas’s embrace of school vouchers. Seniors, veterans, and young people were mad about the THC ban. Rural voters were angry about data centers and the costs they felt in their communities of growth. And I think Hinojosa gave a lot of independents and soft Rs permission to vote for her by focusing on a populist, economic vision, jettisoning anything that could fall under culture wars.
The headline this morning is that Texas “turned blue.” From what you’re seeing locally, what does that description capture, and what does it miss? What are voters expecting these wins to change in their lives?
It undeniably did turn blue — it wasn’t one just one race, it was uniform. But I think what’s worth noting is that there are scores of Republicans and independents who decided, for the first time, to give Democrats a chance at the statewide level, for governor, or attorney general or even agriculture commissioner. People will be watching closely to see if their lives improve in the ways Democrats have promised — lower costs, better schools, rooting out corruption.
Sens.-elect Annie Andrews, James Talarico, and Troy Jackson — all Democrats — walk through the US Capitol as they arrive for new member orientation meetings on November 9, 2026. | Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images
This story appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.
We’re a week past the midterms now and the dust has largely settled. Sure, you still have some uncalled House races in a handful of states, and we’re still waiting with bated breath to meet the next senators from Mississippi and Alaska.
This week, the incoming members of Congress — roughly seven weeks out from their official debut — are in Washington, DC, to set up their offices and meet their new coworkers. Democrats still have to choose new leaders or stick with their old ones. And once they’ve reached some sort of consensus on that, they’ll start to confront the final boss: President Donald Trump.
“They’re in control, but they’re really not in control,” Trump told Fox News last week, of the Democrats’ prospects in a split government. “Because they can send over, you know, 50 different great bills that they’re all excited about and I send them back with a nice stamp.”
Fortunately, amid all this jockeying and post-election euphoria, we do have some precedent to fall back on. After all, this blue wave was historically big — but not totally unheard-of. Midterm elections also ushered in huge partisan majorities in the early 1970s and 1990s. And that history suggests that Democrats have won a chance…not a guarantee.
You have to go back to the Watergate era to find a blue wave as big as last week’s. The year was 1974, the vibes were alternatingly grim and groovy, and American voters were looking for change after the scandals of Richard Nixon’s presidency.
Democrats already controlled the House and the Senate, but that year’s midterms ushered in a class of even younger and more liberal lawmakers. And these so-called Watergate babies came to play: They helped extend a run of post-Watergate reforms that opened up congressional proceedings, required financial disclosures from senior officials, and strengthened oversight of federal agencies.
But 52 years later, the 1974 blue wave isn’t exactly remembered as an unrivaled success — for the Dems or for democracy. Ronald Reagan became president just six years later, and both he and other presidents since have weakened the reforms of the mid-’70s.
The push to make government more transparent — by inviting television cameras into hearings, for example — also arguably made Congress a more polarized and confrontational place as lawmakers were newly incentivized to be less candid, more performative, and more rigid in their ideology.
Other, more conservative waves have also run up against the limits of congressional power. The political scientist Robert A. Strong points to Newt Gingrich’s 1994 “revolution,” which ended four decades of Democratic House control.
But that Republican sweep, far from delivering Gingrich’s vision of a dramatically smaller government in one fell swoop, triggered bitter confrontations with President Bill Clinton, including debt-ceiling standoffs and government shutdowns. When major legislation did become law, it required compromise: A sweeping welfare overhaul only passed after Clinton vetoed prior versions twice.
In some ways, these challenges are fairly intuitive. Even when one party controls the White House and both chambers of Congress, it still has to reconcile competing factions and navigate procedural hurdles in the Senate. And when control of those branches is split between parties, as it will be soon, you end up with even bigger obstacles — like a veto-happy president.
Given that, Democratic voters might want to temper their expectations just a little. As my colleague Andrew Prokop laid out earlier this month, Democratic bills will — even in this new, blue environment — likely only pass through compromise or fierce confrontation.
Making electoral history is one thing, as history itself shows. But making legislative history is an altogether tougher proposition.
One link for later
➨ Reconsider convenience. “Friction-maxxing” is all the rage these days, and while I don’t endorse hassle for its own sake…it’s certainly wise to scrutinize the trade-offs of any new time-saving technology. Gabe Bullard, the author of the new book Against Convenience, suggests the following prompts: What does this tool save me? What does it cost me? And what problem does it solve?
Before you go…
Did you know…that the word “computer” originally described people? Before they were machines, computers were workers (often, women) who completed tedious mathematical programs by hand or on analog calculators.
Today’s trivia: The singer Leontyne Price is renowned for her work in which musical genre? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in tomorrow’s edition.)
Yesterday’s trivia: Yesterday we asked you for the botanist supervillain in Batman. That would be Poison Ivy, who first debuted 60 years ago in 1966.
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) speak to reporters alongside other House and Senate Appropriation Democratic committee members in the US Capitol on July 22, 2025, in Washington, DC. | Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
The Democratic Party just won its largest congressional majorities in more than a decade. In the House specifically, if current vote tallies hold, it will boast more seats next year than at any time since 1992.
Now what do they do with that power?
In the near term, the extraordinary scale of the Democrats’ midterm victory might be of little consequence. So long as President Donald Trump holds veto power over legislation, a 254-seat House majority may be no better at advancing the Democratic agenda than a 218-seat one would be.
Key takeaways
Democrats’ midterm landslide makes it likely that if they win the White House in 2028, they’ll also have comfortable congressional majorities to pass their economic agenda.
The party has promised to expand the welfare state, cut taxes for everyone but the rich, and bring down inflation and interest rates, but those goals will likely prove incompatible.
Taxing the rich alone probably can’t fund a massive new safety net, yet even this year’s unusually Democratic electorate rejected broader tax hikes.
To ease the tension between their priorities, Democrats should embrace policies that boost the economy’s productive capacity.
Two years from now, however, the blue tsunami’s size could matter enormously. Democrats are unlikely to do quite as well in the 2028 election as they did this year, when the Republican base largely abstained. But Democratic Senate leader Chuck Schumer’s party now has plenty of seats to spare. For this reason, if Democrats win the presidency in 2028, they are now extremely likely to also secure full control of Congress — and by comfortable margins.
This is no small thing. Under President Joe Biden, Democrats held only a bare Senate majority, enabling any individual senator to dictate the terms of their policymaking. A Democratic president has not had the chance to govern with robust congressional support since 2010.
Democrats are therefore within striking distance of a rare opportunity — a chance to enact their economic agenda without asking Republicans or their party’s mostunreliable centrists for permission.
To seize this historic opening, Democrats will need to formulate a platform that effectively advances their core goals. Unfortunately, this will be harder than it sounds — because the party’s current economic priorities appear incompatible with each other.
During the midterm campaign, Democrats promised to:
Democrats have good reason for embracing all of these objectives. In the last three federal elections, voters punished incumbents for presiding over a rising cost of living. So any governing party would be eager to reduce inflation and borrowing costs, both of which continue to trend in the wrong direction.
“This was the biggest change election in any of our lifetimes,” Democratic Rep. Greg Casar, chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, told me. “And Americans are demanding that we take on these high prices, root out corruption, and make their lives better.”
Democrats’ desire to expand the welfare state is similarly understandable. Americans lack many forms of social insurance that are common in wealthier countries, such as truly universal healthcare.
Finally, the party’s embrace of middle-class tax cuts reflects the US electorate’s growing antipathy for taxation. Indeed, last Tuesday, a historically Democratic electorate voted to restrict or cut taxes in states across the country.
If Democrats’ goals are understandable, however, they aren’t necessarily coherent. In economic conditions similar to today’s, it probably won’t be possible to create large new social programs, avoid tax hikes on anyone but the rich, and drive down inflation and interest rates.
For now, the party can skirt these questions; so long as Trump is in the White House, Democrats can simply agitate for an end to the Iran war and tariff relief, while denying full responsibility for the economy.
To govern effectively when and if they win full control of the government, however, Democrats need to recognize the tension between their economic priorities early on — and try their best to reduce that friction.
Americans are warming up to Democrats — but not to taxes
On election night, Democratic proponents of a more robust safety net prevailed in battleground races across the country.
But the Democratic Party’s economic reformers face a fundamental challenge: The large welfare states they admire have traditionally been financed by broad-based taxes. In nations like Sweden, Denmark, and Norway, high taxes on the middle class suppress consumer spending, clearing fiscal space for large social programs. This is how social democracies are able to have their comprehensive welfare states and stable prices too.
But that model does not seem to be politically viable in the United States. To the contrary, America is currently witnessing a vast and growing tax revolt.
That rebellion has been visible in polling and state-level policymaking for some time. Between 2020 and 2025, the share of Americans who considered their federal tax burden “too high” jumped from 46 percent to 59 percent in Gallup’s surveys. Meanwhile, states slashed taxes by tens of billions of dollars.
But the 2026 midterm results may be the starkest illustration yet of America’s anti-tax mood. This year’s electorate was America’s most Democratic in more than five decades. We essentially saw what a US election looks like when a large share of the Republican base stays home. It turns out that, once you subtract tens of millions of conservatives from the American electorate, Mississippi, South Carolina, and Texas become blue states.
And yet, even this historically Democratic voting public mostly rejected “tax-and-spend” liberalism at the ballot box.
In North Carolina, voters backed Democratic Senate candidate Roy Cooper — and lower income taxes. In Iowa, they rallied behind Democrat Josh Turek for Senate, while also forbidding the legislature from increasing income taxes without a two-thirds majority. In Florida, an atypically Democratic (if still majority Republican) electorate voted to slash property taxes by nearly $5 billion a year.
In Illinois and Virginia, most localities shot down referendums on new property or sales taxes; in the Old Dominion’s case, municipalities largely rejected a 1 percent sales tax hike to fund school construction and renovation. Likewise, on a good night for Democrats in the Grand Canyon State, Arizonans voted to cap the sales tax on grocery purchases and constitutionally prohibit the taxation of vehicle miles traveled to fund road maintenance. (Today, road construction is often financed with a tax on gasoline, which ensures that those who use the roads contribute to their maintenance. As more drivers switch to electric vehicles, however, an alternative means of measuring road use has become necessary.)
Finally, in deep blue California, a proposal for a one-time wealth tax on billionaires appears to have failed.
This is not to say that the 2026 electorate took the anti-tax side of every ballot measure. There were manyimportant exceptions to this rule. Nevertheless, the fact remains that an exceptionally Democratic electorate opposed higher taxes in a remarkably wide array of cases.
And this anti-tax mood was not lost on Democrats. Virtually all of the party’s battleground Senate and gubernatorial candidates campaigned on tax cuts. In Texas, Sen.-elect James Talarico promised to deliver a “cost-of-living tax cut for the middle class,” while Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa pledged to pursue the goal of “eliminating residential property taxes.” In Mississippi, Democrats’ unlikeliest new senator, Scott Colom, called for ending all income taxes on teachers and cops. Even Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed, one of the Democrats’ most progressive candidates, who wrote a book on Medicare-for-all, vowed to help freeze property taxes on senior citizens.
Notably, this large, bipartisan tax revolt has emerged at a time when federal tax rates are unusually low; the bottom 80 percent of workers pay much lower federal taxes today than they did three decades ago.
Large welfare states can’t live on the rich alone
As I’ve already suggested, the Democrats’ growing appetite for tax cuts has not dampened their enthusiasm for new public spending.
The party’s congressional leaders have signaled support for a social welfare agenda at least as ambitious as President Joe Biden’s unpassed Build Back Better Act, which contained $4.73 trillion of new spending (assuming that all its programs were made permanent, as its authors intended).
Add up the estimated fiscal costs of all these programs and the bill comes out to nearly $5 trillion. Repealing all of Trump’s tariffs, as Democratic leaders have also promised, costs another $1.4 trillion (although, tariff relief has more complicated implications for inflation than other kinds of tax cuts).
Critically, America is already on track to run an average annual deficit of $2.4 trillion over the coming decade. It is impossible to know with certainty what the macroeconomic conditions of 2029 will be like. But all else equal, a greater than $2 trillion deficit will put upward pressure on interest rates and prices.
For this reason, there’s a good chance that the next Democratic government won’t be able to inject trillions more dollars into the economy without undermining its own goals on inflation and borrowing costs.
To be sure, Democrats aren’t saying that they will deficit-finance their proposed spending. Rather, the party generally suggests that it will pay for its new programs (and working-class tax cuts) by soaking the wealthy and corporations.
But that approach probably won’t be sufficient to offset the inflationary impact of the party’s full social welfare agenda. For one thing, congressional Democrats’ appetite for new taxes on the rich has its limits.
In 2021, the House version of Biden’s Build Back Better Act contained only $1.47 trillion worth of taxes on companies and high earners. And that sum proved too much for multiple Democratic senators. The fiscal policy that actually made it into law — the Inflation Reduction Act — included a mere $349 billion in such taxes.
As noted above, if a Democrat wins the presidency in 2028, he or she will probably have larger majorities than Biden ever did. But it seems unlikely that Senate Democrats in 2029 will be eager to raise taxes on the rich by trillions more than their Biden-era counterparts were.
This is because middle-class families spend a higher percentage of their earnings than millionaires and billionaires do. If you take $2,000 out of every middle-class family’s annual income, many will be forced to consume fewer goods and services, which will reduce consumer demand — and thus, inflationary pressure — throughout the economy.
By contrast, even if you reduce Jeff Bezos’s post-tax income by $200,000, he will feel no need to moderate his spending. His savings might marginally decline. But his consumption is liable to stay about the same, since he will still have more money than he could spend in a lifetime. For this reason, taking money from billionaires — and giving it to working-class families — will tend to nudge inflation upward, all else equal.
“Tax increases on those at the absolute top can address wealth or income inequality, but probably won’t do much to manage demand,” Skanda Amarnath, executive director of the economic research organization Employ America, told me. “If you want to fund big new social programs, the most robust version of that has historically involved broad, regressive taxes, which don’t leave you dependent on the support and compliance of rich people.”
If you don’t want to constrain demand, at least increase supply
It’s possible that inflation will cease to be a pressing concern by 2029. Merely ending the Iran war could cool prices significantly. And if the AI buildout falters, that would also reduce our economy’s demand for labor, chips, and electricity (albeit, perhaps by causing a recession). Alternatively, if Anthropic or ChatGPT builds a machine God in the next couple of years — and puts tens of millions of Americans out of work — we might even see deflation.
But it would be imprudent for Democrats to bank on any of these scenarios. In all likelihood, they will need to scale back their ambitions for the welfare state, grow more comfortable with broad-based taxes, or make peace with pushing up inflation and interest rates.
This said, the party can work to reduce the tension between its objectives. Inflation is what happens when demand for goods and services rises faster than their supply. If Democrats are hellbent on pushing up demand through high social spending and low taxes, they should think seriously about how to make the economy more productive and efficient (and thus, able to generate a larger supply of goods and services).
Massachusetts Rep. Jake Auchincloss is among the Democrats focused on this dimension of the “affordability” challenge.
“Healthcare, home ownership and taxes now consume more than half the middle-class wallet,” Auchincloss told me. “And housing construction, healthcare and government are all very low labor productivity industries.” Therefore, in Auchincloss’s view, delivering on affordability requires increasing the productivity of the construction, medical, and public sectors.
With respect to housing, this entails new subsidies and regulatory changes that encourage modular construction — the manufacture of new homes in factories, where productivity gains are easier to achieve — along with zoning reforms.
In healthcare and government, the path to progress is less clear, but Auchincloss believes that a concerted push for greater efficiency — and the thoughtful deployment of AI — can drive down the unit costs of medical treatment and social service provision in the US(at least, if Democrats prove willing to challenge the interests of healthcare providers, many of whom benefit from the existing system’s inefficiencies).
More straightforwardly, Congress is presently considering legislation that would erode permitting obstacles to new energy infrastructure. That bill is expected to eventually reduce Americans’ electricity costs by expanding the nation’s supply of both green and carbon power. The more committed Democrats are to growing the welfare state and avoiding middle-class tax hikes, the less they can afford to pass up these kinds of opportunities to increase the economy’s productive capacity.
The great perk of powerlessness is the freedom to ignore trade-offs. When crafting campaign rhetoric, a political party can conjure a world where voters will enjoy a robust safety net, large tax cuts, and low prices — so long as the government ends “corporate subsidies,” or cuts aid to Israel, or deports all the undocumented immigrants, or whatever else its base is already eager to do.
When it’s time to actually govern, however, a party ignores inconvenient truths at its own peril, as Trump’s GOP just ably demonstrated. Democrats must therefore recognize their agenda’s internal contradictions as soon as possible. To execute a coherent economic strategy in 2029 — or whenever they next secure full federal power — the party will need to know what it actually cares about most.
An aerial view of a Flock camera on September 14, 2026, in Burbank, California. | Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
As Flock cameras have quietly multiplied across the country in recent years, public concern about privacy, surveillance, and abuse of the technology by law enforcement has sparked nationwide backlash. This led to a number of cities pausing, not renewing, or canceling their contracts with Flock Safety, the leading company behind the controversial AI-enabled automated license plate readers, this year.
And now, citizens have voted on the issue.
Towns in two states, Texas and Maine, voted on midterm ballot measures concerning Flock. And in both cases, the people ruled against the tech.
While these are just two communities out of the thousands that use the cameras — hardly enough to dismantle the nationwide surveillance network — these results show the real possibility of taking on mass surveillance and winning.
But one issue remains: Even if the initiatives that passed on Tuesday inspire similar civic resistance in future elections, the fight against the problem that Flock represents is just beginning for those who don’t want their every move tracked.
Nongovernmental entities — such as college campuses, homeowners associations, even supermarkets — have started purchasing and deploying Flock cameras of their own and sharing the data with law enforcement.
Now, the fight will need to go beyond the ballot box.
An end to the status quo?
While some advocates for Flock systems argue that the company’s AI-enabled automated license plate readers (ALPRs) may make solving certain crimes easier, public attention has been drawn to overt misuse of the technology by current and former law-enforcement officers. Even some police leaders have expressed concerns about Flock’s ability to target people who have not been accused of a crime, potentially raising serious constitutional issues.
Both York, Maine, a small city of about 14,000, and the midsize League City, Texas, took the issue to the ballot box.
In York, residents were asked to consider a citizen initiative called the “Stop ALPRs Ordinance” that made the ballot after receiving over 100 residents’ signatures. Its residents decisively rejected the surveillance cameras, with 5,386 votes (73 percent of the vote) in favor of the ordinance and only 2,043 votes (27 percent) against. Effective immediately, the measure bans ALPRs in the town of more than 14,000 and requires voter approval before the town installs any such tech in the future.
Meanwhile, in League City, Texas, voters decided on an advisory question, Proposition A, which asked: “As a nonbinding statement of voter preference, should the League City Police Department continue using automated license plate reader cameras at fixed locations on public roadways for law enforcement purposes?”
Voting “yes” on the measure meant approving the use of ALPRs at fixed locations on public roadways for law enforcement purposes, while a “no” vote would oppose such uses. Though the ballot question was technically non-binding, League City’s City Council committed to act on the vote’s outcome. The measure passed with 54 percent of the vote.
In response to a request for comment about these two measures, a Flock spokesperson told Vox, “We’re grateful to both York and League City elected leaders and community members who engaged in this conversation. Flock technology has had a real impact helping to solve crime in those cities and across the country.” The company added, “While we’re disappointed in the outcome, we respect the decision voters made and will work directly with the city on next steps.”
To privacy advocates working in the surveillance space, these wins signify a shift.
“The status quo for the longest time has been that cities and law enforcement agencies have been able to approve and award massive contracts for surveillance tech and rarely have any sort of trouble passing them,” said Reem Suleiman of the digital rights group Fight for the Future, which advocates against mass surveillance and hosts the site StopALPRs.com. “In 2026, this isn’t the case.”
“People feel and understand that they do actually have a stake when it comes to surveillance tech and how it’s used.”
Reem Suleiman, Fight for the Future
The backlash has been building for some time, Suleiman said, pointing to the nonprofit Secure Justice’s tracker of nearly 500 actions by cities over the past year to pause or terminate Flock contracts. She also noted that the fight has moved beyond city councils — a Senate Judiciary hearing in late September showed bipartisan interest in reining in license plate readers, and federal and state proposals are multiplying.
Because these decisions to employ ALPRs and other surveillance technologies have typically been made without public input, Suleiman said, putting the question to voters reflects a meaningful change: “People feel and understand that they do actually have a stake when it comes to surveillance tech and how it’s used.”
Voting against local city use of Flock cameras, however, may be just the tip of the iceberg.
Where the fight goes next
The uptake of Flock cameras by nongovernment actors presents a separate accountability challenge that may complicate the efforts of anti-surveillance activists. Homeowners associations, hospitals, schools, and big retailers are contracting for the same technology, with no council meetings for citizens to pack and no ballots to vote on.
According to reporting by Inc., of the approximately 12,000 customers using Flock cameras, 5,000 are private-sector entities. These private buyers can opt to have the data generated by their cameras automatically shared with law enforcement. Many of them do just that, including commercial chains such as Home Depot and Lowe’s, and Simon Properties, the US’s largest network of shopping malls.
According to Flock’s website, if these private customers choose to share data with local law enforcement, they can allow the system “to notify authorities when a flagged license plate is detected, without requiring action from the camera owner.”
One of Fight for the Future’s current targets is Lowe’s, which Suleiman described as one of the largest commercial buyers of Flock cameras. “I don’t want anybody to live under a false sense of security because, unfortunately, there are so many different ways we are exposed to surveillance and to these cameras,” she said.
Critics of license plate readers also fear that cities are swapping out one vendor for another without addressing underlying concerns about data privacy and surveillance. For instance, Axon, a $48 billion company that produces a slew of law enforcement technology, has capitalized on Flock’s recent PR challenges by swooping in to replace its competitor in at least seven municipalities across five states.
In that context, even more ballot measures might not be enough to address the concerns of privacy advocates. Suleiman still has thoughts about what ordinary people can do to push back against increasingly privatized networks of surveillance technology.
“Get involved in those fights,” Suleiman said. “There is a lot of power that consumers have in terms of voicing their values and insisting from the places they shop and the brands that they love that they’re not going to be complicit in the surveillance network.”
Vice President JD Vance gestures as he takes the stage at a campaign rally in Swanton, Ohio, on November 2, 2026. | Tom Brenner/Getty Images
In 2015, Donald Trump descended a golden escalator and launched a presidential campaign that reshaped American politics. More than a decade later, with his record-low approval ratings and the US embroiled in a war with Iran, he asked voters to treat the 2026 midterms as a referendum on him.
“Please pretend I’m on the ballot. Because in a way, I am on the ballot,” Trump told a crowd in North Carolina last month.
As it turns out, voters did as Trump asked: Democrats won in a landslide, taking control of both chambers of Congress with victories in Republican strongholds like South Carolina and Kansas. Now, Republicans have to decide what those losses mean for the future of the movement Trump built.
As Vox’s Andrew Prokop reported, there are already competing explanations for the losses that are taking shape on the right. “The reason we lost is the war,” Vice President JD Vance posted on social media. The conservative commentator Erick Erickson offered a longer list of reasons for the GOP’s failure: “It was also the corruption. The incompetence. The tariffs. The playing nice with Russia. The impression of cruelty. The overly aggressive deportations.” Others emphasized affordability. “Life is too expensive,” right-wing commentator Benny Johnson wrote. “Especially for young people.”
Whoever defines what went wrong will likely help determine which parts of Trump’s politics survive, and who gets to lead the presidential ticket in 2028.
The conservative writer Rod Dreher has a stake in that debate. He supported Trump in 2024. He’s friends with Vance, and he shares the vice president’s interest in combining social conservatism with economic policies that support families. His critiques come from someone who wanted this administration to succeed.
Today, Explained co-host Noel King spoke with Dreher about whether the midterms mean the end of MAGA, what might replace it, and whether Republicans can move past a president who still has two years left in office.
Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.
Before the midterm results even came in, you wrote that Republicans were likely to be shellacked and that they had nobody to blame but Donald Trump and themselves. What do you think it is your fellow conservatives need to admit today?
That MAGA is over. It’s done. It’s been a failure. It brought Trump to power twice. I think there were some good ideas in MAGA and certainly the old Republican establishment, the pre-Trump establishment, needed to go.
But MAGA couldn’t deliver on good government. And if you can’t deliver on good government, it doesn’t matter how charismatic the leader is. It’s not going to work. And I think that there can be no doubt after this week’s election that it was a complete referendum on Donald Trump and he failed. And we have to build from there.
You supported Trump in 2024. At the time you wrote that you were aware of some of his failings. I think many people who voted for Trump were aware of some of his failings, but he had a mandate.
He had the popular vote, he had the House, he had the Senate. Why couldn’t MAGA, his movement, deliver on good government?
“But MAGA couldn’t deliver on good government. And if you can’t deliver on good government, it doesn’t matter how charismatic the leader is.”
I think that it all comes down to the fact that Trump made decisions based not on rational calculation, by listening to expert advice, but on gut instinct.
I think that the wheels began to fall off of the Trump train on April 2, 2025. That was the so-called Liberation Day when Trump announced these wide tariffs. They weren’t thought out at all. They just came out of his gut. And that set a pattern for the way that Trump made decisions. Plus. he promoted people not based on competence, but based on loyalty to him, personal loyalty.
I think this administration has gone from one crisis to another because of that, because Trump doesn’t have a theory or practice of governance. When he came into office, he signed a bunch of executive orders. Some of them did things that I thought were really good, but he didn’t turn them into legislation. This is a guy whose party held both houses of Congress and the White House, yet he just sailed right along as if he was going to be president forever.
And then of course, this gets us to the Iran war, which was another gut instinct thing by Trump, which became the symbol for all of the disasters of Trumpism.
Can MAGA be divorced from Donald Trump? Can it exist without Donald Trump?
No, MAGA is Donald Trump. Donald Trump himself said so. The challenge is going to be, how does the Republican Party rebuild and regroup for 2028 with Trump still in the White House?
I mean, think about it. They’re fighting a two-front battle now. You’re going to have to fight the Democrats, who are energized, who are going to come in and make the next two years — justifiably, I would say — about investigating Trump administration corruption.
But they’re also going to have to fight Donald Trump himself. Sitting in the White House, he’s not going to shut up. He’s not going to do what is best for his party. He’s going to try to salvage his legacy.
What is the next conservative movement? Where do conservatives go from here?
The next few months are going to be really interesting in this respect. Until now, everybody on the right has thought that JD Vance, the vice president, is Trump’s natural successor, even though he hasn’t announced whether or not he’s going to run. I think that has now been called severely into question.
I say this as someone who’s a personal friend of the vice president and would like to see him be president one day. Nevertheless, even though he strongly opposed the Iran war from behind the scenes, he and Marco Rubio and everyone else in this administration are tied to it and all the other failures of Trumpism.
So who does that leave on the outside? I was very surprised, in the past 24 hours, to see and hear Gov. Ron DeSantis, the outgoing governor of Florida, who as we all remember, ran against Trump for the Republican nomination and never stood a chance. He’s not charismatic. He’s super competent, but not charismatic. And so Trump won the 2024 nomination.
Well, now DeSantis is coming out making strong, clear, rational critiques of MAGA and Trumpism. And I think that DeSantis could be the outside candidate who has the best [chance] because he’s the only national Republican politician not tainted by Trumpism.
JD Vance is a friend of yours. He’s credited you with getting him involved in politics. You say you’d like to see him be president. I think a legitimate question following what we’ve seen over the past two years and then last night is why?
Why do you want JD Vance to be president?
JD Vance has been associated with the national conservatism movement, as have I — the movement started by Yoram Hazony, which has been about prioritizing national sovereignty, national interest, a cultural conservatism that is also in favor of economic reforms to make it easier to raise families.
JD Vance has been the avatar for that sort of conservatism. I see the bones of this kind of conservatism within Trump and MAGA, but it got completely crushed by Trump’s own obsessions. If JD can go back to the man I think he is deep down and start to champion this sort of thing — more of a pro-family economic liberalism with social conservatism and no new wars — if it’s possible for any Republican to claim that now, then I think that he could have a chance.
I think he is a good man. I have criticized him publicly, in print, as a friend for not separating himself from the bigots on the dissident right — the antisemites and the white nationalists. This extremist crowd is going to make a bid for power in the rubble of MAGA. And I think whether it’s JD or whoever becomes a Republican standard bearer is going to have to face them down.
We’ve talked about JD Vance. We have talked about Ron DeSantis. They represent different things within conservatism. Tucker Carlson represents something else within conservatism. I think it’s something you don’t like very much. And, um, and then there’s Marco Rubio, who represents something that we were all familiar with from the early aughts.
What do you think of these two other boldface names as we head into 2028?
Tucker Carlson has beclowned himself, and it’s really sad. As someone who used to be friends with him, I thought he was a sensible, interesting commentator who often said a lot of common-sense things. But sometime in the last couple of years, he lost his mind and became antisemitic and just a crazy conspiracy theorist.
A lot of people are worried about his influence on the vice president because they’ve been close for years. Tucker was key in getting Donald Trump to choose JD Vance as vice president. I have no inside knowledge of that at all, but it worries me as well. I think JD is his own man, but it’s going to be very hard for JD going forward to maintain viability as a potential Republican Party leader until and unless he addresses the Tucker Carlson problem.
I don’t think Tucker’s going to run for president. If he did that, he could only be a spoiler, and I don’t think he actually wants it.
In Marco Rubio’s case, he’s been a real chameleon. He was against MAGA. He was the neocon’s neocon for a while, but he has been a faithful servant and executor of Trump’s foreign policy. And for some reason, it doesn’t seem to have stuck to him the way it has stuck to JD Vance. I’m not sure why that is, but with all of these guys who have been part of the Trump administration, it’s gonna be very, very hard to cut that albatross from around their neck.
One of the dynamics that we’ve seen in the Trump era over the last decade is that Republicans in Congress don’t want to stand up to Donald Trump. They don’t want to cross him.
What should Republicans in Congress do? Should they finally grow a spine and say, “Look, we don’t have to obey every single thing that President Trump says”?
Absolutely. I mean, what do they have to lose now?
Trump has never been loyal to anybody who’s pledged loyalty to him. Greg Abbott, the three-term governor of Texas who lost his bid for reelection — no sooner had the election been called and Trump put out a statement calling him a RINO.
Trump is not loyal. And so there is nothing in it left for Republicans to stick with him. He’s not going to be a factor in 2028. Maybe they want his endorsement in the 2028 primaries. Really? After this? That would be the kiss of death.
Republicans are now, and Congress is now, going to have to find a spine and stand up and establish some independence. If they had done that earlier, we might not be in the situation today.
Vice President JD Vance and Stephen Miller in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building on August 5, 2026. | Alex Wong/Getty Images
This story appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.
Hi readers, happy Friday! What a week, right?
My colleague Caitlin Dewey has spent the last two days unpacking some of the midterm results and their implications for you, and there will be lots more of that to come. But before we head into the weekend, I’m going to take a quick second to look ahead — to 2028.
Specifically, to the future of the Republican Party, which just found itself on the wrong end of what may be the biggest electoral landslide since 1976. It’s a comprehensive, crushing repudiation — and one that has already cast the future of MAGA’s heir apparent, Vice President JD Vance, into doubt.
Vance has long looked like the presumptive Republican presidential nominee in 2028, with the clearest claim to President Donald Trump’s legacy. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, also considered a potential 2028 candidate, has previously said he would defer to Vance were Vance to run.
But that may be changing. The downside to being so closely linked to the president, after all, is that it’s hard to run very far when the president gets hit with Electoral Ragnarok. Vance didn’t help his case on Wednesday, with a strange and lengthy post on the social media site X blaming the Iran war for his party’s electoral woes.
Also implicated in questions about Vance and the 2028 primary is a bigger question about the future of the MAGA movement. Specifically: Is MAGA dead?
No more MAGA? No, more MAGA!
If you ask conservative writer and Vance ally Rod Dreher — and we did! — the answer is easy: Yes, after a historic electoral thrashing, MAGA as a political movement is dead. And it is possible that, as a vote-getting enterprise, MAGA is at the end of the road. But the Trump White House has no plans to let up on the MAGA agenda.
We got our clearest post-midterms sign of that fact on Friday afternoon, in the form of one Stephen Miller. Trump, in a post to Truth Social, announced that Miller would take over as White House chief of staff starting Monday, replacing current chief of staff Susie Wiles.
Miller’s ascension is a foreboding sign: Through one and a half Trump terms, he’s been the driving force behind many of Trump’s cruelest and least popular policies — some of the same policies, particularly around immigration, that helped Republicans lose the midterms in a blowout.
Trump’s decision to promote Miller, with just a little over two years left in the White House, means that we can expect the administration to double down on those same policies, with predictably unpopular results.
That all spells more bad news for Vance, already limping out of the midterms after tying himself tightly to failed Ohio gubernatorial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy, who was behind one of the ugliest attack ads in recent political memory.
And it may embolden other potential contenders, like Rubio (who is reportedly eyeing an exit from the administration in an attempt to save face) and even outgoing Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, who Dreher described to Vox as “the only national Republican politician not tainted by Trumpism.” (Mostly because he got flattened by Trump in the 2024 Republican presidential primary, but never mind that now.)
One link for later
➨ Here’s how to protect your family from convincing AI scams. “As AI gets better and cheaper,” my colleague Adam Clark Estes writes, “we’re all becoming easier targets” — even if you think of yourself as skeptical, tech-savvy, and hard to fool. But there are some straightforward steps you can take to keep yourself and your family safe, including setting up a verification system to confirm when you’re actually talking to a family member and not an eerily accurate AI replica of their voice.
Before you go…
Did you know…that Sweden is really, really good at assembling modular homes out of prebuilt components? (Think Ikea, but for the whole house and not just a bed frame.) Unfortunately, Marina Bolotnikova reports, US building and zoning codes stand in the way of doing the same thing here.
Today’s trivia: What’s the title of Puerto Rican singer-songwriter Ricky Martin’s biggest hit? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in Monday’s edition.)
Yesterday’s trivia: Yesterday, we asked you which planet takes about 165 Earth years to orbit around the sun. That would be Neptune, where one year is a little more than 60,000 days.
US Sen.-elect James Talarico (D-TX) speaks during a midterm election night event on November 3, 2026 in Austin, Texas. | Brandon Bell/Getty Images
Just days after big wins in the midterms, Democrats are celebrating historic victories. But what can we actually learn from these wins?
David Axelrod is a Democratic strategist and the man behind Barack Obama’s two presidential victories. He’s not a senior political commentator at CNN. He’s spent decades figuring out how Democrats can win.
On Wednesday, Axelrod joined America, Actually for a conversation with host Astead Herndon about what the blue wave in the midterms reveals about voters in the US right now, the powerful demographic shifts that are underway, and what Democrats need to do next to make good on the promises they made in their campaigns, all while Trump is still in the White House.
Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full show, so listen to America, Actually wherever you get your podcasts or watch it on Vox’s YouTube channel.
Is this all about Trump’s unpopularity, or an endorsement of Democrats? I heard Rahm Emanuel say that he doesn’t read this as a vindication of Democrats, but as a repudiation of Republicans.
Does that distinction matter? And do we know if people were voting for Democrats or just against the administration?
I think every midterm election in some ways is a referendum on the incumbent party. That’s been true forever. And it’s almost always the case that the verdict is: not as good as we’d like. You know, this election is the one where the people in power have to put on a button saying, “How am I doing?”
And people get to tell them, and the answer was: really, really bad.
Horrible! Two thumbs down.
Really, really bad. And obviously it was a repudiation of the president. I think it was a real response to the same thing that drove the election as much as anything in 2024, which is costs and the fact that people are struggling in this economy. The thing that made this unusual was Trump was elected to lower these costs, and instead he made decisions that palpably raised them — the war, the tariffs.
I think it’s given Democrats a chance to prove that they are who they say they are and work on these issues of cost. And they’re crippled in the sense that if they don’t have a partner in the president, all they can do is try and pass legislation and do things to reduce those costs, but they need a partner to do it.
I don’t discount the fact that Trump may do a 180 on some things and be that partner.
It is an open question who the president becomes after all of this, considering he’s, you know, the nicest way to say it is ideologically flexible. Should Democrats come in thinking accountability? Should they come in thinking, find places of bipartisan alignment? Is the answer both?
Yeah, I think the answer is both. And it’s very tricky to strike that balance. And if the price of cooperation is to lay off of accountability, I don’t think that’s a deal they can make.
But I look at the way Mayor Mamdani has handled his relationship with Trump. And there may be some instructive elements to that, because he’s certainly critical of the president. But he’s also found areas around housing, for example, on which they can work together.
Here’s what I would say to Democrats: Be willing to work with him. And I think you’ll pay a price if you don’t. If he’s willing to help you, for example, on rolling back some of these cuts to the affordable healthcare subsidies or to Medicaid cuts. I think the country would actually embrace that kind of deal.
And for that reason, I think Trump may take it because I don’t think he gives a damn about the Republican Party. The Republican Party was just a vehicle for him, and now he’s mad at them — because he’s not going to blame himself for what happened on Tuesday.
You’ve mentioned the demographic shifts. They were universal. You talk about men, Latinos, Asian voters, young people, working-class people generally moving towards Democrats in numbers that were even larger than some polls expected. I was wondering: Did we write the obituary on the Obama coalition too early? Is it back?
I’m so allergic to this because I remember when we won. I remember people talking about the coalition of the ascendant. This is the coalition that’s going to govern.
Yeah, the governing majority to come.
The message is: It matters what you do.
Democrats took Hispanic voters, for example, for granted. And they paid a big price in 2024. Republicans took Hispanic voters for granted. And in each case they’re a constituency that is deeply responsive to economic circumstances. They’re getting hammered in this economy, as they were in 2024. They are also — in the main — socially conservative communities. I think both parties have been guilty sequentially in misreading this.
By the way, everybody’s talking about who’s responsible for the Republican performance this year? I don’t think Stephen Miller is getting the credit that he deserved.
Yes! There was a vote for decency here. Decency had a big day on Tuesday, and in that vein, it’s so interesting to me that Talarico, Hamilton, candidates like that, who very much preached the gospel of the brotherhood of man and of decency, wound up triumphing in places that you never thought Democrats could triumph.
So that’s a long way of answering: I think what the Democratic coalition is and can be depends on what Democrats do now.
Los Angeles Mayor-elect Nithya Raman at an election night party, November 3, 2026. | Sarah Reingewirtz/MediaNews Group/Los Angeles Daily News via Getty Images
It’s notoriously hard to govern Los Angeles, a city that gives its mayor less direct authority over the government than in a city like New York or Chicago. But even so, it’d be hard to do much worse than Karen Bass.
Elected mayor of LA in 2022, Bass campaigned onpromises to solve the city’s homelessness and housing affordability crises (which are really part of the same underlying crisis). She then spent her term undermining her own administration’s affordable housing policy and fighting the state of California’s efforts to compel cities to allow more housing production. She lost her bid for reelection this week to Nithya Raman, an LA City Council member, rising progressive star, and nationally prominent YIMBY.
Los Angeles has the highest ratio of home price to household income of any large city in America, and the second fewest homes per adult of any major city. It has a highly suburbanized and car-oriented fabric, like much of the rest of the country — all of which makes it a kind of proving ground for whether America’s sprawling cities can build their way out of their housing shortages.
Everyone in the city’s political leadership notionally agrees that LA needs to permit a lot more homes to meet demand — the only true way to make housing affordable — but not all of them have evidently had the policy discipline to follow through.
Raman may be different. She has gained a following in housing reform circles over the last few years with her brisk, direct-to-camera socialvideos explaining how LA’s housing shortage drives up rents and criticizing city policies that make it so difficult to build more homes (perhaps it’s no surprise that she has plenty of friends in Hollywood).
“There has been an overall lack of urgency in addressing housing supply in [Bass’s] administration,” Raman told me in an interview in July. How best to accommodate LA’s need for more housing, she said, is “a question that the city has actually turned away from.”
Even given LA’s relatively weak mayoralty, Bass’s failures on housing were often a matter of political choice. As The Atlantic’s Marc Novicoff put it, “Bass seems to have gone out of her way to exercise as little power as possible.” Where she did go out of her way to wield her influence, it was often to stop denser housing from being built. Some of her bewildering housing policy choices while in office include:
Days into her term, Bass signed her first executive order, known as ED1, to fast-track housing developments where 100 percent of the apartments are affordable. Applications for these projects were to get approvals within 60 days instead of being dragged through excruciating permitting processes. It was a good idea — and it seemed to be working, quickly attracting developer applications to build thousands of affordable apartments. It was working so well, in fact, that a backlash from vocal NIMBYs followed. Less than six months after signing ED1, in June 2023, Bass weakened it to exclude projects in single-family neighborhoods — which make up three-quarters of LA’s residential land — from the fast-track approval process. Her administration even tried to apply that restriction retroactively to developments that had already applied to build in single-family areas under ED1, a breathtaking display of bureaucratic dysfunction; a judge later ruled that this violated California law. Bass has since added more restrictions to the ED1, and one observer has described it as “functionally gutted” for many developers. To be fair to Bass, even after she weakened it, the program has still resulted in more than 7,700 affordable apartments under construction, according to her campaign.
Bass opposed SB 79, a landmark California law that passed in 2025 requiring cities and suburbs to allow construction of denser housing near transit stops. Permitting apartments near public transit is one of the most basic principles of sensible urban planning. But in LA, it was controversial enough that Bass urged Gov. Gavin Newsom to veto it. After he signed SB 79 into law anyway, Bass worked with LA’s city council to delay much of the law’s most ambitious upzoning until 2030, while permitting smaller apartment buildings near some transit stops.
After the devastating January 2025 fires, some property owners whose homes had burned down in the Pacific Palisades had applied to rebuild under SB 9, another important California law that allows single-family lots to be modestly densified into up to four housing units. In response to backlash from some neighbors, Bass reportedly pressed Newsom to restrict SB 9 in fire-damaged areas; she then banned SB 9 applications in parts of the Palisades. (There are certainly legitimate questions about whether rebuilding in such a fire-prone area is a good idea at all. But Bass offered no publicly available analysis that the modest increase in density allowed by SB 9 posed a special danger, even as she worked to accelerate the rebuilding of single-family homes.)
All of these point to a leader who is not serious about changing the conditions that led to LA’s housing shortage, and lacks the courage to take on what is arguably the city’s most defining political challenge.
Raman has promised to fundamentally break from that approach. That will make her mayoralty an important experiment for the rest of the country. Even modest progress in a city as resistant to housing as LA could help crack open a way forward for new approaches to housing in the many other cities that face affordability crises.
This won’t be easy for her — she’ll face the same anti-building political pressures, and will need to maintain a cooperative relationship with the city council. When I spoke to Raman over the summer, I noticed that she treaded gingerly around the topic of adding density to single-family neighborhoods. Because of the uniquely American obsession with keeping single-family homes segregated from other types of development, it can be a real political third rail in LA and nationwide. But research has suggested the city can’t fill its housing shortage without building more in those neighborhoods. Raman will, at least, have an important ally in California’s newly elected governor, Xavier Becerra, who is also a strong YIMBY.
Raman’s affiliation with the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) makes her emblematic of a fusion that’s been emerging in Democratic politics, between supply-side abundance and left-wing economic populism. It’s also evident in politicians like Zohran Mamdani and some of the young Democrats who won elections across the country this week.
I think this is right.
It's not just that Talarico (et al) combines elements of left populism, abundance pragmatism, and cultural moderation. It's also that the definitions of "left" and "moderate" are in flux.
From talking to Raman, I have the sense that she’s more at home with the YIMBY part of her politics than the DSA part. Her relationship with the DSA’s LA chapter has been strained (though it did endorse her candidacy). But her social-democratic commitments are also sincere — she’s been a strong champion of rent control and tenant protections in LA, for example, and helped shape a stronger rent stabilization law the city adopted last year.
The new political syntheses taking shape on the American left are exciting and intriguing. Whether it will finally make a breakthrough in LA’s — and California’s, and America’s — housing crisis, of course, remains to be tested. But it’s a welcome sign that American politics need not remain trapped in the same orthodoxies and failures.
As various factions try to make the case about what won the midterms — moderation or progressivism, populism or the establishment — perhaps the easiest and most universal way to describe 2026 was as a contest between decency and cruelty.
For nearly a decade, bullying, scape-goating, and just plain meanness have been the dominant tone of Republican politics. From Donald Trump relentlessly picking on minority groups in the 2016 campaign, through family separations in 2018 — all while demeaning political rivals and journalists and anyone who criticized him — a generation of Republican politicians have seen the president reach new levels of nastiness in politics and be rewarded for it. Other candidates picked up on it, often attempting their own imitations: Vice President JD Vance mocked “childless cat ladies” in 2021, while other Republicans joked about political violence against Democrats or critics, their physical appearances, or theirethnicities.
And yet somehow, in the 2026 midterm campaigns, the MAGA right went even harder on cruelty up and down the ballot. Pivotal campaign moments, particularly in the closing weeks of the cycle, weren’t just about bare-knuckle politics and nasty campaigning, but actually punching down at the weak and vulnerable. Republican Ohio gubernatorial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy trotted out his opponent’s estranged mother to suggest the candidate was lying about childhood abuse. Trump and GOP Sen. Tim Scott used a transphobic slur to to mock a candidate while campaigning for Darline Graham. Michigan GOP senatorial candidate Mike Rogers fanned the flames of Islamophobia, accusing his opponent of “pledging” his support to Islamist extremism, something other Republicans echoed. And in Texas, a statewide candidate doubled down on racist anti-Indian-American tweets.
In 2018, the writer Adam Serwer coined the phrase, and concept, that “the cruelty is the point” — that the easiest way to understand the MAGA movement was as a desire to inflict pain and suffering on marginalized people, specific minorities, and political opponents through political power. Cruelty wasn’t incidental; it was intentional.
For Republican candidates and campaigners this cycle, cruelty became almost a central campaign tactic. Many of them struggled to mount a serious policy case, and found themselves stuck with a historically unpopular president as party leader, so they fell back on the tried-and-true maneuver of beating up on the weak, hoping it would work as well as it seemed to throughout the Trump era.
Yet on Tuesday night, voters delivered a verdict: They were fed up with that cruelty in both the administration and Republican campaigns. Instead, decency — or, at least, voters’ impression of it — won.
Even some conservatives, as they try to sort through the wreckage and blame game post-Election Day, made that case.The Christian broadcaster Erick Erickson noted that in addition to the Iran war and affordability crisis, Republicans lost because of“the impression of cruelty. The overly aggressive deportations. The accidental arrests of American citizens who were Hispanic. The arrogance.”
And, of course, many Democrats agreed, too.
“The American people were loud and clear [Tuesday] night that they want to like their neighbor, that their neighbor is not the enemy from within, and even if they disagree politically with their neighbor, they want them to do well and they want their kids to do very well,” Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear, who led the party’s efforts to elect Democratic governors around the country, told me. “People [Tuesday] night showed us that they want decency in the White House and they want decency in Congress.”
All the Republicans above lost their races. The set of people who won — and especially those who flipped seats from red to blue – noticeably embraced amore compassionate tone of politics.
Republicans centered cruelty; Democratic candidates chose decency and won
It’s hard to summarize just how nasty the 2026 GOP campaign strategy was. Hate, racism, and xenophobia were the go-to tools used on the right this cycle — on top of a year of hardline immigration policies and spending cuts pushed by the Trump administration. And it all came up short, Joe Walsh, the former GOP member of Congress and current anti-Trump activist, told me.
“Republicans tried to win again this year by being as cruel and fearful and divisive as they could. That’s generally worked in the past, but there were extenuating circumstances this year,” Walsh said. “People [on the trail] would tell me, ‘This is not the kind of country we are. This is not who we are.’” They were referring, he said, to masked ICE agents, the targeting of Black and brown people, and talk of white Christian nationalism.
“There was something more profound at stake here,” Walsh continued. “And I think it was the American people recoiling against the cruelty they’ve seen.”
It was all a sharp contrast to the way Democrats talked and the policies they supported on the trail. Take Texas Sen.-elect James Talarico’s words in his Tuesday night victory speech:
We didn’t win by alienating our neighbors, or by shaming our neighbors, or by ridiculing our neighbors. We embodied a new kind of politics. A politics rooted in a deep love — for our state, for our country, and for all of our neighbors. My faith teaches me that love is the strongest force in the universe…love requires that we stand between the bullies and the bullied. Love requires that we look evil in the eye and not blink.
Beshear told me that beyond concerns about gas prices, the Iran war, and tariffs, voters’ frustrations reflected a rejection of the fear and divisiveness that Trump embodies. He said he saw this rejection of cruelty while stumping for candidates in red states, and he saw the opposite coming from the Democratic candidates who won.
“Everywhere I traveled, our gubernatorial candidates were talking about being a good neighbor,” he said. “[Iowa Gov.-elect] Rob Sand talked about it at every one of his town halls, and you could see people nodding about it. [Ohio Gov.-elect] Amy Acton talked about it in each of her speeches. People are craving decency, especially given the cruelty that this president governs with.”
This contrast was apparent in some data and focus group research, too. In polling conducted by The Argument before the election, Democrats had a 20-point advantage when voters were asked which party they thought was more “compassionate,” a 12-point lead when they were asked which party “cared” for voters, and a 10-point lead when they were asked which party was more moderate.
“The party of compassion won,” the writer Jerusalem Demsas wrote for The Argument. Republicans just couldn’t shake the association, their polling showed, with “words like ‘bold,’ “strong,’ and ‘extreme.’”
And in Ohio, perhaps the most obvious example of cruelty becoming the closing message of a Republican campaign, focus groups conducted by the political strategist Sarah Longwell for The Bulwark before the election showed how quickly the infamous ad became associated with the Republican brand. Longwell wrote about the session:
The first thing to note is that everyone in the group had heard about Ramaswamy’s ad already. The second thing to note is that several of the Ramaswamy-curious voters in the group said it was pushing them toward either supporting a third-party candidate or sitting out the election altogether. The fact that everyone had heard of or seen the ad and the universal revulsion to it suggest that this could be an all-time backfire for Ramaswamy — and it raises the possibility that Trump and Vance will also suffer politically for rushing to defend it.
In follow-up focus group conversations on Wednesday, the day after the election, voters told Longwell they wanted a hard break from this era of politics.
This rejection of cruelty was also most evident in backlash to the Trump administration’s immigration policies — in places that saw ICE raids or which saw stricter enforcement in heavily Hispanic areas of Florida, Kansas, and Texas, voters swung hard against the GOP.
“These are voters who were very supportive of securing the border, very supportive of Border Patrol, which is a huge employer down there,” the Democratic strategist Lis Smith told me. “But the cruelty of what ICE was doing, tearing apart families and communities was just a bridge too far. That’s in part why you saw a big backlash in the Hispanic community because there’s a huge element of racial profiling with it.”
In contrast, the most successful candidates this week were not the ones that tried to match Republicans by being more combative or extreme. They were those who embraced themes of decency and compassion. They seemed to offer an antidote, Smith said.
“There’s sometimes this idea, a theory in the Democratic Party, that to beat Trump, you need to be Trump,” Smith said. “And so you see Democrats going out on Twitter and calling Republicans cucks and engaging in the same sort of race to the bottom of name-calling that Trump and the Republicans do. But if you look at the top Democratic over-performers, people like [Sen.-elect] Adam Hamilton in Kansas, like Rob Sand in Iowa, like James Talarico in Texas, these were people who were going out and preaching love.” Smith pointed to a Talarico interview where he called his opponent, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, a “child of God.”
“Yes, Americans were fed up with corruption, et cetera, but you can’t watch those candidates and say the defining feature of these campaigns was anger.”
Michael Wear, Center for Christianity and Public Life who once advised the Obama administration on faith outreach
A kind of broad-based compassion was specifically a hallmark of some more explicitly religious campaigns, said Michael Wear, the head of the Center for Christianity and Public Life who once advised the Obama administration on faith outreach. He pointed to Talarico in Texas, and Hamilton, a megachurch pastor poised to become Kansas’s first Democratic senator in nearly a century.
To Wear, that should offer some lessons for other Democrats as they think about preserving and expanding the new national coalition they built as they move into the 2028 election cycle.
“Yes, Americans were fed up with corruption, et cetera, but you can’t watch those candidates and say the defining feature of these campaigns was anger,” Wear said.
And that’s also how they talked about voters themselves, Smith said: trying to expand the tent by welcoming Republicans or even former Trump supporters who were fed up with this style of politics.
“They explicitly asked for their vote and said that, ‘We don’t judge you. I’m not going to judge you for how you voted in the past. And you’re welcome in my tent, you’re welcome in my coalition,’” Smith said. “That’s a different tone than you hear from a lot of Democrats.”
Smith said it was a risk — the most liberal of the Democratic base might enjoy “the sick warfare,” she said, “but most other people are really exhausted by it. … They’re really exhausted by just seeing neighbors turn against neighbors and find this approach of turning the temperature down refreshing.”
President Donald Trump, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth at a news conference during the NATO Summit in Ankara, Turkey, on July 8, 2026. | Krisztian Bocsi/Bloomberg via Getty Images
This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.
Welcome to The Logoff: It’s a whole new world for President Donald Trump.
What’s happening? So far, surprisingly little: As we wrote yesterday, Trump has largely stayed quiet since his shellacking in Tuesday’s midterms (ballroom tour aside), and that continued on Thursday.
With the days counting down until Democrats take control of Congress, though, there are signs that things could begin to shift in his administration.
What could happen? A Cabinet shakeup, whether that means firings, resignations, or something in between. It’s not unusual after any midterm, and especially not after a loss this seismic (Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld stepped down the day after the 2006 midterms amid voter anger about Iraq).
Whatever happens, though, might need to happen fairly soon: It’s always possible that Trump could skate by with acting secretaries (he’s previously said he’s a fan), but if he wants to get replacements confirmed, he’ll likely need to do it in the final two months of the current Republican Senate majority.
Who’s eyeing the exits? Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, potentially — but for very different reasons.
In Rubio’s case, it would give him a chance to distance himself from a radioactively unpopular presidency ahead of a potential 2028 presidential run — particularly as Vice President JD Vance is stuck writing social media posts about why the Iran war was maybe a bad idea.
Hegseth, meanwhile, is one of the public faces of the war. Trump has — for now — denied any designs on replacing Hegseth, but the secretary faces the prospect of impeachment as soon as next week. He’s also reportedly interested in being appointed to a soon-to-be-vacant US Senate seat for Tennessee, which would provide him a convenient escape (though based on Tuesday’s results, he might be an underdog to win an election anywhere in America).
What’s the big picture? We don’t yet know anything for sure about what’s next, but the chatter is reflective of the new world Trump and his administration are facing: dismally unpopular, deprived of easy confirmation hearings and cover from Republicans in Congress, and facing an aggressive oversight agenda.
And with that, it’s time to log off…
Hi readers, here’s a very cool story about an atmospheric phenomenon I’d never heard of before — transient luminous events, a type of lightning occurring in the upper atmosphere. You can read all about them — and see them! — here with a gift link.
Democratic Senate candidate Adam Hamilton speaks to reporters at a canvassing event in Kansas City, Kansas on October 31, 2026. | Jim Vondruska/Getty Images
This story appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.
As the dust from Tuesday’s elections continues to settle, Republicans are looking around their shrunken ranks and wondering precisely where they went wrong on this one.
President Donald Trump, who’s been generally (and surprisingly) mellow about his party’s loss, said it was because he wasn’t on the ballot.
Vice President JD Vance, who hopes to lead MAGA into its post-Trump future, squarely blamed the war in Iran.
Multiple things can be true at once, of course — and, in this case, they plainly are. It’s hard to look at the more than 44,000 races that played out across the country Tuesday and come away with a single unified theory of Democrats’ blowout.
But if you wanted to try, why not go with a theory that will make you feel better about other people? My colleague Christian Paz surveyed the landscape and came away with the conclusion that voters finally turned on cruelty this election.
Christian reports on politics and religion for Vox, and even before the midterms, he had some firsthand experience with the anti-cruelty camp. In October, he flew to Kansas to spend some time on the campaign trail with Democratic Senate candidate Adam Hamilton, a Methodist megachurch pastor who ran on a platform of “radical love,” mercy and kindness.
Hamilton’s chances looked remote when he launched his campaign: Kansas hadn’t elected a Democratic senator in almost a century. But on the trail, Christian met a lot of people — including registered Republicans — who liked the generous, neighborly way that Hamilton talked about politics and morality.
On Tuesday, Hamilton won his Senate seat by roughly 5 points. And he celebrated in a characteristically gracious manner: “I want us to model what it looks like when thoughtful people actually work together to solve problems,” he said, “instead of slinging mud at each other.”
For much of American history, that would have been a fairly anodyne comment. But this isn’t much of American history: We’re living in the age of Trump and Vance.
Meanness, incivility, and outright cruelty have been the political mode for the past 10 years, not just in how lawmakers speak and campaign (with insults, curses, epithets, innuendos, and undisguised racial animus) but also in how they legislate (namely, by pursuing and celebrating policies that cause distress to their political opponents and marginalized groups).
The clearest, cruelest example of both is probably Trump’s mass deportation campaign, which has seen almost 1 million largely law-abiding people ejected from the US. As part of that campaign, the Trump administration also regularly mocks and humiliates its targets in social media posts.
As Christian explains in a forthcoming article for Vox, however, the midterms suggest that many voters find this nastiness off-putting, even if they’re concerned about immigration. In Colorado, where roughly half of residents surveyed last year called illegal immigration a “very serious” problem, 55 percent of voters nevertheless rejected a measure that would have required law enforcement to coordinate with federal immigration agents.
Voters also swung hard against the GOP in places that saw ICE raids or stricter enforcement, including heavily Hispanic areas of Florida, Kansas, and Texas.
“These are voters who were very supportive of securing the border, very supportive of Border Patrol. … But the cruelty of what ICE was doing, tearing apart families and communities, was just a bridge too far” for them, the Democratic strategist Lis Smith told Vox.
Elsewhere, candidates like Hamilton, Texas Sen.-elect James Talarico, and Ohio Gov.-elect Amy Acton prevailed over opponents known for their morally dubious pasts or ugly attack ads.
Does this mean we’ve entered a new political era? A world where the nice guys…do sometimes win?! The midterms weren’t all sunshine and drum circles, after all: Some bona-fide jerks were also elected.
“I do anticipate a more conciliatory tone from the new voices heading into Congress — but when the 2028 primary season starts, I wonder how much these calmer heads will prevail,” Christian told me. “And at least for the GOP, everyone I’ve talked to seems to hope a new page will turn and a calmer politics will be embodied by the right — but at least not until Trump leaves office.”
One link for later
➨ Life is too short to finish bad books. So…don’t do it! I wish I’d taken this advice before slogging through a creepy, underplotted historical romance for a book club I probably won’t even stick with. Other tips to help you read more, even in our era of boundless distractions: Experiment with different formats — print, ebooks, audio — and take breaks to help shore up your attention span.
Before you go…
Did you know…that the original Pledge of Allegiance didn’t include the words “under God”? President Dwight D. Eisenhower made that little edit during the anti-communist fervor of the 1950s.
Today’s trivia: Which planet takes 165 Earth years to orbit around the sun? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in tomorrow’s edition.)
Yesterday’s trivia: Yesterday we asked you which e-commerce site bars users from selling their souls. That would be eBay, which first confronted this thorny metaphysical problem more than 25 years ago.