Are the Polls Accurate? (Are We Doing This Again?)
![]()
This is the weekly, free edition of The Backchannel. If youβd like to receive the free edition of The Backchannel in your inbox, you can subscribe here. If youβd like to upgrade to the membersβ edition for full-access to The Backchannel and everything else we publish at TPM, this is the final week we are offering a special promotion for 50% off an annual Prime membership.
This wonβt come as huge news to most. But Iβm getting asked about it a lot: can the polls be wrong? What do you think?
So let me put an answer here. They can obviously be wrong and you should be prepared for them to be wrong. If youβre running a campaign or SuperPAC, they can give you intel about where to deploy resources. If youβre just observing, theyβre more about human nature and anxiety management. But whether you get excited or pushed into despair, weβll know the actual results in about six weeks. Watch them or donβt. Itβll will be fine either way. There are no poll hubris gods. They canβt strike you down.
Letβs talk specifics.
The polls weβre seeing now are almost certainly directionally accurate. But they could be overshooting on their margins, which are quite large now. If they are we should expect to see that most in red states. (Even for someone like me whoβs been bullish about this midterm cycle since mid-2025, some of these numbers are hard to believe.) States have partisan muscle memory that polls can miss. So for instance, yesterday Sabatoβs Crystal Ball changed the Kansas Senate race from Likely Republican to Leans Republican, an astonishing development. The polls there are pretty close given that itβs Kansas, and the most recent, an Emerson poll, has Democratic challenger Adam Hamilton up by 1 point. But this is a classic case where you have to weigh a substantial amount of GOP muscle memory into the equation. Polls can miss that, or it can simply mean that undecideds break heavily for the stateβs dominant party. To be clear, if I were a Kansas Democrat canvassing Iβd be pretty pumped right now. A win is possible. But this is the cautious/realistic way to look at it. The same applies to the handful of other seemingly competitive races in deep red states.