❌

Reading view

The Coalition of the Willing’s chance to deliver

European leaders gather in Berlin for a high-stakes meeting on Ukraine, just as Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping hold talks in China. With Washington and Moscow sending conflicting signals about Europe’s role in peace negotiations, can the Coalition of the Willing secure a seat at the table — and find the money to keep Ukraine fighting?

Also on the podcast: Host Zoya Sheftalovich and Kathryn Carlson discuss the upcoming EU–UK summit in Brussels, where British Prime Minister Andy Burnham is promising a fresh start after Brexit.

And mysterious cyber incidents disrupt the European Commission’s internal systems.

Questions? Comments? Message us on WhatsApp here or at +32 491 05 06 29.

  •  

EU lawmakers accuse Chinese officials of intimidation over Taiwan

BRUSSELS — EU lawmakers from across the political spectrum say they have come under pressure from the Chinese government for traveling to or communicating with Taiwan.

Eight MEPs gave accounts of what some described as intimidation inside the European Parliament — including a senior Chinese diplomat turning up unannounced at one MEP’s office — detentions at the Chinese border and threatening letters.

The incidents come a little over a year after the European Parliament and Beijing restored ties following years of fraught relations over European criticism of China’s treatment of ethnic and religious minorities, and against the backdrop of European manufacturers creaking under the competitive pressure of Chinese imports.

Taiwan has been politically separate from China since 1949, but Beijing views the island, home to 23 million people, as part of its territory and has long criticized Western governments for maintaining relations with Taipei — although the EU and its member countries do not recognize Taiwan as a separate country.

But MEPs allege they have faced more than just criticism for taking a pro-Taiwanese independence stance.

“I have never encountered such behavior from foreign diplomats,” said Engin Eroglu, a German liberal MEP who chairs the Parliament’s delegation to China. Eroglu said he had received “fierce” pushback from Beijing, without specifying what that entailed, and that he was troubled by Chinese officials’ actions toward other members of Parliament. 

The Chinese mission to the EU did not reply to requests for comment for this article.

Markéta Gregorová, vice-chair of the China delegation — which manages relations between the European Parliament and China’s National People’s Congress — said she would ask Parliament President Roberta Metsola to bar Chinese officials from Parliament if Beijing doesn’t explain why she was stopped at the border during a recent visit.

Metsola, who helped broker the deal to lift sanctions and restart diplomatic engagements with China, has been in close contact with the MEPs concerned and “has conveyed our questions and concerns directly to the Chinese authorities,” her spokesperson, Juri Laas, said. “Diplomatic contacts are ongoing in an effort to ensure that further incidents can be avoided.”

“MEPs concerned must be able to exercise their freedom of mandate, and the Parliament expects that members traveling with an official European Parliament delegation should not have problems when entering their host country,” he added. 

Escalating pushback

The far-right Patriots group vice-chair António Tânger Corrêa said that, before a June 2025 visit to Taiwan, a senior Chinese diplomat visited his office unannounced, warning that they “could not ensure” his safety and “didn’t know what could happen” if he made the trip. He said Metsola offered to warn the Chinese mission to the EU or take tougher action, but he urged her to pursue diplomacy first.

Lawmakers who attended a forum in Taipei in October this year received letters, seen by POLITICO, from China’s EU mission urging them to “refrain from any official exchange in whatever form with the Taiwan authorities.”

Chinese ships patrol as military drills take place on Pingtan Island on Dec. 30, 2025. | Adek Berry/AFP via Getty Images

“China has no right to intimidate elected representatives or interfere with their parliamentary work,” said one of the MEPs who received the letter, Czechia’s Ondřej Krutílek. “We should make it clear that no one can dictate where MEPs travel, whom they meet or whom they engage with. These are decisions for elected representatives themselves, not for Beijing.”

Others who also received the letter include Polish liberal MEP Michal Kobosko, Latvian conservative Rihard Kols, French liberal Bernard Guetta, and German center-right MEP Michael Gahler.

“We cannot accept acts of direct pressure against us,” said Kobosko, calling the letter “bizarre.” 

Meetings with China are usually “completely polite,” said Guetta, but the letter was sent “to try pressure.”

“There’s nothing particularly new about the approach,” said Kols. “The tone is quite aggressive, but then the message comes from a generic email address, with no named official attached to it. You could quite reasonably mistake it for spam. I don’t know whether that’s deliberate, but it makes the letter easier to dismiss.”

He added that “coming from Latvia, there is something distinctly Soviet about the tone” but “MEPs deal with attempts to put pressure on us every day, in one form or another. We can handle a letter like this ourselves. I don’t see it as grounds to tighten access rules for Chinese officials or ask President Metsola to intervene.”

Border incident

Gregorová, a member of the Greens, said that on Sept. 26 she had an uncomfortable encounter with Chinese officials when she landed in Beijing as part of the Parliament’s trade committee delegation to China. The Czech MEP said she was stopped at border control, had her passport confiscated, and was forbidden from using her phone. 

“I was surrounded by police officers and held for approximately an hour and a half,” she told POLITICO. “It was an extremely unpleasant experience and, without my colleagues there to help me, it would have been frightening.” 

Gregorová is the lead MEP on the revision of the Cybersecurity Act, a legal proposal that could see Chinese telecom suppliers excluded from European networks. It has drawn Beijing’s ire, and Chinese officials have threatened “countermeasures” if the bill is passed.   

Gregorová said she didn’t know whether what happened to her was an administrative error or a “deliberate intimidation tactic.” She said she was sending a letter to the Chinese National People’s Congress — the national legislature — demanding an explanation, and that she’d ask Metsola to bar Chinese representatives from entering the Parliament unless an explanation is provided. 

Earlier this year, POLITICO reported that Chinese officials had told MEPs in the Socialists and Democrats group not to vote for a report critical of Beijing, warning there could be consequences.

A troubled relationship 

In 2021, Beijing sanctioned five MEPs following EU sanctions targeting alleged Uyghur rights abuses. Parliament responded by freezing ratification of an EU-China investment deal and halting diplomatic contact with Beijing.

The outer wall of a complex that includes what is believed to be a reeducation camp where mostly Muslim ethnic minorities are detained, outside Hotan, China, on May 31, 2019. | Greg Baker/AFP via Getty Images

Beijing and the Parliament lifted those sanctions in April 2025. The Parliament will host the 44th EU-China interparliamentary meeting in Strasbourg in June, the second such meeting since relations were unfrozen, according to an internal note.

The Chinese Mission to the EU organized a briefing on Taiwan in Brussels on Tuesday. As attendees entered, they had their invitations checked by staff sitting at a table decorated with panda bear plushies. Neatly stacked beside them were copies of Chinese President Xi Jinping’s tome, “The Governance of China.”

Liu Jieyi, the former director of China’s Taiwan Affairs Office, spoke for most of the session, flanked by Ambassador Cai Run, head of the EU mission.

Liu, who is now vice-chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee of China’s top political advisory body, spent much of the session discussing the historical intricacies of China’s claim over Taiwan.

While Beijing preferred to pursue peaceful reunification with Taiwan, Liu said China “will not renounce the use of non-peaceful means or the option to take all necessary measures to safeguard our sovereignty and territorial integrity.”

The Chinese official also obliquely addressed some of the recent tensions with the European Parliament.

“Certain institutions have adopted Taiwan-related resolutions and provided a venue for political theatrics staged by Taiwan independence secessionists, sending wrong signals to these elements,” he said. Liu added that the EU “must realize that such statements and actions severely erode China–EU relations and mutual political trust.”

Beijing’s diplomatic push comes as Chinese President Xi Jinping on Nov. 12 called for “reunification” with Taiwan. In October, the Parliament passed a resolution condemning any attempt to change the situation in Taiwan by force.

German MEP Eroglu said Beijing’s pressure was linked to warming ties between the Parliament and Taiwan, calling it “unimaginable” that China could dictate who lawmakers meet.

“If we were to allow that, [Russian President Vladimir] Putin would probably be next to tell us that we should or can no longer meet,” he said.

  •  

France pushes for rapid EU sanctions on Iran for supermarket hacks

Paris is pushing for the European Union to issue sanctions by next month against Iran for its alleged cyberattacks against supermarket fridges, the French foreign minister said on Monday.

Jean-Noël Barrot said on the sidelines of a Monday meeting of EU foreign ministers that he will share evidence with his counterparts demonstrating that Iran was behind the October attacks that remotely hacked refrigerators in 700 supermarkets across France, raising temperatures and causing large amounts of food to spoil. 

France last week officially blamed Iran’s Revolutionary Guards for those attacks, specifically a unit dubbed Shahid Kaveh, which carries out offensive cyber operations.

“I came here to provide my colleagues with the proof,” Barrot said. “I am asking for European sanctions on the main people and entities responsible for this attack.”

He added that he has received a “wide array of support” on the issue and so is confident that sanctions will have been issued by the time foreign ministers meet again in Brussels in mid-December. A “very large majority” of EU member countries support the sanctions, he said.

No country has yet pinned blame on Iran, or anyone else, for the follow-up attacks two weeks later on supermarket fridges across Europe. 

  •  

Estonia has a plan for Russian occupation: Run its government from the cloud

TALLINN — Imagine French General Charles de Gaulle, exiled in London during World War II, running his Free France government by logging into the cloud.

Officials in Estonia are preparing for exactly such a scenario with a new strategy to boost doomsday resilience — hukukindlus in Estonian — that would allow the government’s digital services to be run entirely from abroad if its territory is occupied by a foreign enemy.

The Baltic country of  1.3 million, which shares a 294-kilometer border with Russia, fears it is a prime target if Moscow were to invade a European Union country. Security services have already warned that Russia is waging a hybrid war on Europe, and Estonia has blamed Moscow for everything from cyberattacks to arson plots to cuts to undersea data cables.

Now, Tallinn is preparing to move its public services to the cloud “either when data centers are destroyed or there’s boots on the ground and we cannot operate,” said Tõnu Grünberg, an architect of the new strategy and former deputy secretary general for digital infrastructure and cybersecurity at Estonia’s Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs.

Estonia already has a data backup in its “digital embassy” in Luxembourg, effectively a copy of the country’s blueprint that includes everything from citizen registries to land registries and its legal code.

“Now we want to really be online, whatever happens,” Grünberg said. “All critical services stay online … Everything needs to stay operational.”

The Estonian government is building secure applications on cloud providers including Microsoft Azure and Amazon Web Services as well as its own state cloud platform. The country is shipping the system to its data embassy and other places in Europe, said Grünberg, who started a job as CEO of tech infrastructure provider Levira this month.

Allan Allmere, an adviser for IT architecture and infrastructure at the Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs, said in comments to POLITICO that Estonia wants to minimize the impact of the worst-case scenario.

“Ideally, we would like to build systems that can withstand every possible crisis, but in reality no country can predict or eliminate every risk,” he said. “In the most severe scenarios, we also need to preserve a trusted foundation from which Estonia’s digital state can be rebuilt.”

The danger to digital services has been apparent for Estonians ever since 2007 when the country faced a wave of cyberattacks lasting 22 days that brought down large swathes of commercial and government services. The country’s authorities later attributed the attacks to Russia.

The incident was in many ways the first large-scale modern cyberattack targeting a country. It prompted Tallinn to overhaul its entire digital infrastructure, making Estonia what some consider the world’s most digitized state.

“They have taken a remarkably forward-leaning approach in terms of digitizing government services,” said Joseph Jarnecki, senior research fellow at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) think tank in London.

Allmere said the doomsday planning seeks to ensure that “we should never have to start again from zero.”

Digital resilience

Recent attacks on data centers in Russia underlined how critical digital services have become for countries at war. Ukraine struck three data centers belonging to Russian provider Yandex last month, showing how targeting compute power had become akin to striking a power plant supplying the electricity, heating and fuel that militaries and civilians depend on.

The Estonian national plan for doomsday resilience is a notable example of how countries are looking to protect their citizens and services from those risks through delocalization. Until recently, the debate on digital security tended to focus on keeping control close to home by storing data locally and building technologies and data centers inside a state’s territory.

Now states — especially those facing heightened risks of conflict — are rethinking their approach, making sure they are also spreading the risks to digital infrastructure.

On Thursday, the United Kingdom and Norway announced they are looking at ways to host each others’ secure data by setting up their own “data embassies.”

Estonia, too, is investing in “partnerships and alliances with safe third countries” for security and resilience, “rather than saying ‘we are most sovereign and most resilient when we have everything physically under our control, within our territory,'” said Jarnecki.

The Microsoft outage that struck companies and countries worldwide last week illustrated again how states should diversify cloud and digital service providers in case key providers are struck by cyberattacks, disruptions or technical failures.

Allmere, the Estonian official managing the doomsday resilience plan, said the country was also working to prepare for the next challenge: “The first question was how to make sure Estonia’s state data would not disappear,” he said, referring to its existing data embassy in Luxembourg as a backup. “The next [challenge] is how to ensure that the state can continue functioning with that data during a crisis,” he said.

Tallinn won’t stop there. “We also need to ensure that the same data remains understandable and usable decades from now,” Allmere said.

  •  

China’s diaspora crackdown reaches deep into Europe, report finds

THE HAGUE — Beijing is overseeing nearly 1,250 overseas policing outposts in more than 90 countries to crack down on dissidents, according to a report by a human rights advocacy organization.

The report described Europe as a hotspot with hundreds of Beijing’s policing offices across some two dozen European countries, which it said exposed China’s growing attempts to control its diaspora.

Researchers at the Spain-based organization, Safeguard Defenders, gathered open-source evidence from the Chinese Party-state to examine the extent to which the Chinese diaspora is monitored, surveilled and policed around the world.

These policing outposts “act as the Chinese Communist Party operatives for community surveillance and enforcement abroad,” according to the report.

The report lands at an awkward time for Europe’s trade officials. Ditte Juul Jørgensen, head of the EU’s trade department — which has been working to balance the trade relationship with Beijing — will meet with China’s Vice Minister of Commerce Ling Ji in Brussels on Thursday.

Europe is attempting to walk a fine line with its relations with Beijing. EU legislation proposed in January seeks to kick risky Chinese suppliers out of Europe’s most critical industries over cybersecurity concerns, while supply chain dependencies and political coercion remain ongoing challenges. The EU’s top diplomat Kaja Kallas has also raised concerns about what she said was China’s enabling of Russia’s war in Ukraine and credible reports of China training Russia’s military.

Overseas outposts

The report builds on initial revelations from Safeguard Defenders in 2022 that identified more than 100 facilities around the world, which the NGO described as overseas outposts of China’s security apparatus. Back then, that report said Beijing announced its “first batch” of “30 overseas police service stations in 25 cities in 21 countries.” 

Following the revelations, some governments denounced the overseas police stations as illegal, and some pursued criminal investigations, the NGO said in its latest report. In response, Beijing claimed the stations had been closed, it added.

“Far from closing, the evidence shows expansion: today more than 10 police forces from five Chinese provinces work through a global network of Chinese Communist Party operatives abroad,” the new report says.

The latest paper was presented at a conference hosted by the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China (IPAC), a gathering of 52 cross-party lawmakers from 30 countries that campaigns for a more coordinated response to the Chinese Communist Party. Policymakers raised numerous concerns at the event in The Hague earlier this month — about what they considered security threats of critical infrastructure, trade dependencies and potential risks from a future conflict between China and Taiwan that would disrupt shipping.

The Chinese foreign ministry and state media have previously called IPAC an “anti-China” group and accused it of spreading disinformation and interfering in China’s internal affairs, particularly over Taiwan.

China’s Ministry for Foreign Affairs and its European Union mission didn’t respond to requests for comment on the report. China has previously denied running overseas police stations and says it doesn’t interfere in other countries’ internal affairs and that it respects international law.

In 2023, a Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson rejected the term “police stations,” saying the “institutions helped overseas Chinese who could not return to China due to the pandemic, renew their driving licence and perform physical examination.” 

Tip of the iceberg

These 1,250 offices were “the tip of the iceberg,” according to the NGO, which said it was conservative in how it mapped and linked them to China’s policing system. To be counted, they had to be officially connected to China’s police or prosecutors and have open-source evidence of overseas activities, report author Laura Harth said. This meant broader influence or interference operations were excluded.

“All of them serve to control and instill fear in diaspora communities … all of them represent a standing national security risk,” she said.

Slovakian MEP Miriam Lexmann, who is part of the European Parliament’s trade committee and China delegation — lawmakers tasked with maintaining and managing legislative ties between the EU and China — said people needed to become more aware of the security threats posed by China.

“It means that our free countries are no longer free anymore for everyone because they are not able to guarantee freedom of speech, freedom of behavior to people who are in our country,” she told POLITICO in reference to the operations.

China’s surveillance through facial recognition and interference in communications was “the exact behavior of the former Soviet Stasi,” she said, but worse since the technology is now much more sophisticated.

The main concern expressed by lawmakers attending the IPAC conference was China’s relationship with Russia, and its help in propping up the Kremlin’s war in Ukraine. Their discussions included what this could mean for a future conflict and war on two fronts if Beijing were to try and take Taiwan militarily while NATO countries were attacked by Russia.

“The road to escalation in the Taiwan Strait can run right through what’s happening in Ukraine and in Kyiv,” said Dutch lawmaker Jan Paternotte, who co-chaired the IPAC conference.

  •  

The summit Europe loves to hate

Over 50 leaders are descending on Dublin today for the European Political Community summit — but it’s not a popular one.

Today on the show, Zoya Sheftalovich and Kathryn Carlson discuss why insiders don’t find the forum particularly useful, and some even hope it will end once French President Emmanuel Macron — who spearheaded the initiative — leaves office.

One meeting leaders are more eager to attend, however, is Friday’s informal European Council, also taking place in Dublin. High on the agenda is the thorny question of who should represent Europe in future Ukraine peace talks, as Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy ups the pressure with a November deadline. Plus, AI will be a crucial topic: from Europe’s place in the global AI race to cybersecurity concerns.

Finally, Finland’s embassy in Canberra is going viral … and no one quite knows why.

Questions? Comments? Message us on WhatsApp here or at +32 491 05 06 29.

Articles mentioned in this episode:

  •  
❌