❌

Reading view

Climate advisers warn UK ministers: Don’t meddle with electric vehicle rules

LONDON — The U.K. government could miss legally-binding net-zero goals and undermine its push to protect voters from rising prices if ministers water down electric vehicle targets, the government’s top climate adviser said.

In a letter to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander, published on Wednesday, Climate Change Committee Chair Nigel Topping warned that weakening the zero-emissions vehicle (ZEV) mandate would increase the country’s exposure to fossil fuel markets and “damage long-term competitiveness as our major export markets rapidly transition to electric vehicles.” 

Maintaining the existing rules was an opportunity to “reduce costs for a typical household by around £800 a year” by encouraging people to shift from petrol to electric cars, Topping wrote.

The committee has published its advice as the government mulls changes to the mandate — which requires the automotive industry to increase the proportion of new car sales that are zero emission, reaching 100% by 2035.

Ministers have been consulting on changes to interim targets since August. They are preparing to reduce an interim target requiring 80% of sales to be electric by 2030. 

Climate Minister Katie White told POLITICO last week that the government is “committed to the ZEV mandate” but that “no decisions have been taken in terms of the trajectory.”

Topping warned that, if ministers weaken the mandate, they would miss the opportunity to lower driving costs by exposing the U.K. to fossil fuel markets. His letter cited a government impact assessment which “implies that cutting the headline ZEV targets would increase fuel consumption in the U.K. by an equivalent of up to 15 million barrels of oil per year by 2030.” 

He added: “At current prices, this would cost the U.K. more than £1 billion.”

The CCC also warned that changes to the mandate could leave van drivers exposed to the high cost of diesel, and jeopardize investment in the U.K. auto sector where EV sales are already lagging behind countries including Germany and France. 

A government spokesperson said: “We remain committed to the phase out of all new petrol and diesel cars by 2030 and to all new car and van sales being zero emission by 2035, as well as to our legally-binding net zero targets.

“Our consultation on the mandate will not change this and will ensure we are taking a pragmatic and balanced approach to the ZEV transition.”

Charlie Cooper contributed reporting from Antalya.

  •  

Europeans court China’s help to keep climate action on track

ANTALYA, Turkey — European governments will hold crunch talks with China this week, in a last-ditch bid to preserve the role of scientific advice in global climate summits. 

On the sidelines of the U.N. climate conference in Turkey’s Antalya, senior officials from several European delegations are meeting with their Chinese counterparts to get Beijing onside in a messy fight over scientific reports, five negotiators told POLITICO. 

“There’s a big diplomatic move,” said Francesco Corvaro, Italy’s climate envoy. “We’re working to create pressure.” 

The dispute ensnares the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a body which produces scientific assessments every five to seven years, and whose advice is considered the ultimate authority on the state of knowledge on global warming — and how to fight it. 

The IPCC’s scientists hope to release their next series of reports in 2028. But the timeline is set by consensus among world governments, and a small group of countries led by India and Saudi Arabia are seeking to postpone publication. 

As part of the dispute, they’re also blocking the body’s budget, throwing the IPCC into a funding crisis that could impede its work. 

Any delay to the next reports would deprive climate negotiators of fresh scientific input at the pivotal COP conference in 2028, when countries must assess their progress toward the Paris Agreement and take remedial action to fix shortfalls. (The exercise is known as the second global stocktake, or GST2).

“We have this issue with the IPCC — the alliance of Saudi Arabia and India that wants to postpone the reports,” said Corvaro. “Without the reports of the IPCC, it’s tough to have a good global stocktake. We need to know the details of how far we’re falling short if we want to respond.” 

European countries see China as key to resolving the impasse. If they manage to pull Beijing onside, the diplomats said, the blocking countries may fold. 

Finding time

The IPCC is due to publish three reports. The first will focus on the science, the second on how to prepare for the effects of climate change, and the third on how to ensure warming doesn’t get worse. The latter in particular is key for the global stocktake. 

Most countries want the body to deliver its reports in 2028, so that the stocktake at COP33 can draw on the latest scientific research. 

“It is essential that the IPCC continues its work and that the seventh assessment report can be delivered in good time to inform GST2,” EU chief negotiator Diana Acconcia told reporters last week. “Europe stands on the side of science.”

But India and Saudi Arabia want more time, arguing this will allow authors and governments from developing countries to review and approve the reports. 

“You have to give adequate time” to developing countries’ scientists, said an official from a developing country opposing the 2028 timeline. “It’s more of a principled position … not to stonewall or delay any studies.” The official spoke on condition his country not be identified. 

Countries pushing for the 2028 timeline — which include not only European governments but many developing countries highly vulnerable to climate change — disagree. 

“We have seen efforts to undermine the IPCC and to block its reports informing the next global stocktake,” said Marshall Islands President Hilda Heine last week. “Our Pacific scientists tell us the work can and should be completed on time.” 

The leaders of Norway and Brazil also backed the IPCC’s role in their speeches in Antalya last week. A French official told reporters that the Indian and Saudi Arabian efforts are “absolutely unacceptable because, in a way, it’s questioning science.” 

India and Saudi Arabia have suggested an alternate timeline that would deliver the first, science-only report in time for the stocktake — but push the other two, which focus on actions for countries to take, out to 2029. 

The process is highly political. The last stocktake, in 2023, produced a hard-fought decision signed by all governments to transition away from fossil fuels — the first time the need to do so was acknowledged in a conference decision. Saudi Arabia has since sought to walk back that outcome. 

This time, the timeline debate has also dragged in questions about IPCC funding, which is already under pressure due to the exit of the United States. Without a budget, the body’s work cannot continue. 

The result is a diplomatic deadlock over what used to be a technical detail. 

For six consecutive meetings, the IPCC’s assembly has failed to reach an agreement. Last month’s gathering in Ethiopia was suspended without result. Countries are due to meet again on Dec. 1. — the final chance to settle on a budget for the coming year.

“It’s not blocking,” the developing country official insisted. “A consensus has to be found. You can’t pass the budget in a non-transparent way.” 

India and Saudi Arabia also have the backing of Kenya and Russia, and diplomats say China has also objected to a fast publication timeline. But they believe that Beijing can be swayed. 

“China is in the middle — not completely aligned with Saudi Arabia and India,” said Corvaro. “We hope it’s possible to get a common understanding with them to underline the importance of science and data.” 

‘Everything is polarized’

As the Antalya summit brings together ministers from across the world, countries are hopeful the dispute could be resolved this week. But the stakes are high. 

“We have an opportunity here to get consensus on the IPCC with ministers here,” said one European diplomat, who was not authorized to speak on the record. “If they manage that, I can’t see next month’s IPCC meeting fail. Otherwise, it might be doomed.” 

Countries are mindful about not dragging the IPCC into a political debate at the COP — the two bodies fall under separate U.N. procedures — but say finding a resolution is a matter of urgency. 

“We have to be careful here. We don’t want to make things more difficult for the IPCC,” said a second European diplomat. “But if they don’t agree on a budget in December, it will delay and disrupt work on the next reports. That’s unacceptable.” 

The governments of India and Saudi Arabia did not respond to requests for comment. The developing country official said his country would oppose any attempt to address the IPCC issue in the Antalya summit’s decision text. 

A first draft of the final conference decision, released Monday, suggests countries note the “importance of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change for the global stocktake.” 

The IPCC, for its part, has welcomed government talks in Antalya. 

“I think governments talking here in this space [at COP] is extremely helpful,” said IPCC Vice Chair Diana Ürge-Vorsatz. “It’s crucial that we have a decision very soon, because it’s very difficult for the scientists involved, it’s difficult for the institution. It’s very difficult for everyone to be in this uncertainty.” 

The fact that the IPCC’s bureaucratic procedures had become so political was “difficult to watch,” she added. 

“Why has it become polarized? Because, unfortunately, at the moment everything is polarized. And because there are some parties that are trying to undermine what science is telling us, because they don’t want to do what it takes to address climate change,” said Acconcia, the EU negotiator. 

The bloc would strive for a resolution in Antalya, she added. “We will fight for this outcome to be there.”

  •  

Draft COP31 text suggests ‘immediate’ fossil fuel transition

ANTALYA, Turkey — Australia’s first stab at a final text for this year’s U.N. climate conference is meant to be a conversation starter. It’s certainly getting diplomats talking.

The Australians, who are chairing the negotiations at the COP31 summit in Antalya, dropped an 18-page draft decision text Monday. It contains a wide variety of strong positions, including a call for an “immediate” exit from fossil fuels in the energy sector.

European diplomats who messaged POLITICO were baffled at the suggestion that the text “recognizes” a call made by some developing countries that rich nations should “achieve net-zero emissions by 2030.” That goal is decades ahead of the EU and U.K. climate neutrality targets in 2050.

Tripling funding for developing countries to prepare for climate disasters to $120 billion a year will also be a difficult pill to swallow for developed countries, which are struggling with budgetary pressures at home.

Petrostates, meanwhile, are being asked to get on board with a call for a faster fossil fuel phase-out, including “through the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems.”

“No doubt people will need a little bit of time to digest … It’s very comprehensive,” Chris Bowen, Australia’s climate minister, told reporters. “And the strong views that have been raised, that’s as intended. It begins a conversation about what the final draft that we put [to] the parties will look like later in the week.”

The proposal by the Turkish co-hosts to set a voluntary global electrification target, which Ankara said on Saturday has the backing of around 30 countries, has also been added to the draft decision. Several countries have objected to the idea of new goals.

Any final COP decision requires consensus from all governments.

“This first draft will look different to the final draft, that is what the process is designed to do,” said Bowen. “So I expect there will be at least one more draft before the end of the week, but we will keep working until we have a document which receives a consensus.”

  •  

EU climate chief hints bloc may drop clean power push at COP31

ANTALYA, Turkey — The EU climate chief has signaled the bloc is prepared to give up on a key clean energy demand at this year’s COP conference, in a bid to get more countries on board with an electrification push.

A global agreement on accelerating electrification — by increasing electricity’s share in energy use — has been touted as a way to address both worsening climate change and soaring fuel prices resulting from the Iran war.

Countries at the COP31 climate summit in Antalya are currently debating whether they can reach a consensus on the issue in the conference’s final decision. The Turkish-Australian hosts have also urged countries to sign a voluntary pledge to boost electrification.

The EU began the conference wanting any electrification agreement to refer explicitly to “clean” power, generated from renewables or nuclear, a position enshrined in the negotiating mandate agreed by its 27 member governments last month.

But Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra, who will co-lead negotiations for the EU from Monday, suggested in an interview that the bloc could drop that condition.

“The world needs much more radical, much faster electrification. Ideally, that comes for the overwhelming part from solar, from wind, and from nuclear sources,” he told POLITICO and other media outlets Friday.

“But at the same time, let’s also acknowledge that a certain degree of pragmatism is probably warranted and needed, to also make sure that the group of countries signing up is as large as possible.”

He added that even electrification using polluting sources — known as gray electricity — was better than burning fossil fuels straight up, as the switch from combustion to more efficient power by itself reduces energy demand and thus emissions.

“Of course we need to have a high degree of solar, wind and nuclear — and at the same time, if we embark on more electrification and part of that is gray, it is still much better to have someone charging their car with gray electricity than to continue to drive on fossil fuels, right?” said Hoekstra. “It would be a tactical mistake to seek absolutes in this.”

He nevertheless hoped electrification would act as a “unifier” in the talks that could help deliver on a previous, more contentious agreement to transition away from fossil fuels. Even China held a similar view to the EU on electrification, he said.

“The good thing about electrification is that there is a certain degree of ambiguity to it, which will probably make it easier to unite a larger group behind that thing,” he said.

Hoekstra also admitted he had “low expectations” for the Antalya summit.

“The geopolitics of the moment are extremely difficult. … Secondly, the whole pushback on climate action from various corners of the globe, the fact that the Americans have completely checked out of this, if you add all of that up … that combination shapes expectations,” he said.

Still, he insisted: “I do think we have a chance of success in the domain of electrification.”

  •  

Climate science says 1.5C is dead. No one wants to bury it. 

ANTALYA, Turkey — “Anything is possible if you believe,” croons Turkish pop megastar Tarkan in his theme song for this year’s global COP31 climate conference.

Attendees appear to have taken his words to heart.

The Antalya summit marks the first climate talks since the United Nations told the world global warming would soon exceed 1.5C, effectively burying the totemic Paris Agreement target that has steered COP negotiations for more than a decade.

Yet leaders here are straining to keep the goal on life support.

“We are on course to overshoot the 1.5 degree target, and every fraction of a degree matters. So we must double down,” said European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen in her speech to fellow leaders on Wednesday.

“Let’s show that the fight for 1.5C is not over,” Hilda Heine, president of the Marshall Islands told leaders.

Even before the talks began, Danish Climate Minister Samira Nawa told POLITICO her country’s priority at COP31 was “to push for keeping the 1.5C target in the heart of global climate ambitions.”

Other leaders and ministers, reviving slogans from COPs past, have exhorted their colleagues to “keep 1.5 alive” or ensure the target remains “within reach.”

But scientists say that dream is over.

The U.N. last month said that, even if countries dramatically slash planet-warming emissions starting right now, the best outcome would be a rise in global temperatures of 1.8 degrees. If they also deploy vast amounts of carbon removal tech to clean up the atmosphere, there’s a chance of getting back to 1.5 degrees after surpassing it — in theory.

In reality, though, greenhouse gas emissions are still rising and the carbon-hoovering technologies needed to achieve that reversal are unproven at scale.

The risk

The collective ambition of national climate plans, already insufficient before the U.N.’s announcement, is even weaker than projected last year. Countries that have been among the strongest proponents of meeting the 1.5-degree target are watering down efforts to achieve it.

But at the same time, many countries (and climate scientists) fear that publicly dumping the rhetoric around 1.5C will open the door to weakening global ambitions even further. Highlighting other possible targets, such as the 1.8C mentioned by the U.N., would be a “slippery slope,” warned one European climate negotiator.

Johan Rockström speaks at an event in Berlin on May 9, 2025. | Sebastian Reuter/Getty Images for Billie Eilish and Support+Feed Present: OVERHEATED Berlin

“I do not support the political messaging of keeping 1.5C alive — but on the other hand, I don’t want to lose it,” said Johan Rockström, a leading climate scientist and director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research.

“Politicians, when they say that, may naively think that we somehow still are on this linear, incremental journey that can simply take us to safety, which is not the case,” he added. “On the other hand, if we scientifically criticize it, the risk is that they do indeed say: ‘OK, let’s just drop it and aim for 2 degrees instead,’ which would be a big mistake.”

Beyond symbolism

For island nations already losing land and livelihoods to rising oceans, the 1.5 degree target is not merely symbolic. It represents their very survival.

“Our response to the threat of overshoot must be overwhelming, or the world we know is over,” said Heine, the Marshall Islands president. “Overshoot means waves eating away our shores, flooding that destroys towns, schools, hospitals. It destroys our land and ocean.”

The temperature target was not chosen arbitrarily. It represents the level of warming scientists say the planet can endure before the heat trapped in the atmosphere unleashes exponentially greater dangers.

In the Paris accord, countries vowed to limit warming to below 2 degrees and “ideally” 1.5 degrees. The second target has become so dominant that the International Court of Justice last year declared it the primary goal.

A group of developed and highly vulnerable nations, known as the High Ambition Coalition, have called for a credible response to the overshoot as one key COP31 outcome.

“There is no way we can lose that anchor, out of our moral responsibility toward the people who have contributed the least and are the most impacted,” said Christiana Figueres, who headed the U.N. climate body when the Paris Agreement was adopted.

Words vs. action

But promises have not aligned with reality.

“Leaders, and in particular those from developed countries, cannot keep expanding fossil fuel production while claiming to be committed to 1.5 degrees,” U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres told world leaders in his opening speech on Wednesday.

Yet immediately after his speech, leaders did just that.

Chris Bowen speaks during COP31 in Antalya, Turkey on Nov. 11, 2026. | Ozan Kose/AFP via Getty Images

Australia, COP31 co-hosts with Turkey, is expanding investments in coal and natural gas, even as its Climate and Energy Minister Chris Bowen urges leaders in Antalya to act with “urgency, solidarity and resolve.”

“With every minute that we fail to achieve the targets set out in the Paris Agreement, the risks and costs we face continue to grow,” said Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. Two days earlier, he had celebrated the discovery of two new oil fields.

“The science is clear. Breaching 1.5 isn’t where we down tools and give up,” Katie White, the U.K.’s climate minister, said in response to the U.N. findings. White promised COP31 was the place to double down on action — but a day later, her own department approved a major natural gas project in the North Sea.

Meanwhile the United States, the largest polluter in world history, has withdrawn from the Paris Agreement and is no longer part of COP talks. Donald Trump’s abandonment of efforts to address global warming has left a large gap in the world’s collective efforts to cut emissions.

There’s always next year

Tina Stege, the Marshall Islands’ climate envoy, acknowledged the difficulty of the challenge. But she was unbending.

“That’s not a reason to not do everything that we absolutely can,” she told reporters. “Every country that showed up at this talk to do the work needs to do that work and more.”

Doing more means ramping up clean electrification and alternative fuels, say experts.

It also means dramatically curbing short-term climate pollutants, such as methane. That’s emerging as a possible response to the overshoot declaration in the final agreement from this year’s negotiations, according to the European diplomat cited above.

“If we cut methane by nearly half by 2030, we could avoid almost 0.3 degrees of warming by the 2040s and save 250,000 lives every year,” said Mia Mottley, the prime minister of Barbados, on Wednesday. “This buys us the time to get back to the 1.5 degrees.”

The politics are tricky. Even as technological advances have allowed for better detection of the potent pollutant, the U.S. and Europe have weakened regulations aimed at curbing methane emissions.

Mottley was adamant nonetheless that flagging global ambitions were no reason to give up.

“I call for a global movement: 1.5 billion voices for 1.5 degrees,” she said. “We need to do this before we meet at COP32 next year. … Make 1.5 impossible to ignore on the planet Earth.”

  •  

Trump’s snubbed COP — but he’s on everyone’s lips

ANTALYA, Turkey — Donald Trump is not at the COP31 climate summit but almost everyone is talking about him — and not in the way he’d like.

The U.S. president’s fateful decision to attack Iran earlier this year, sending global oil and gas prices soaring and compounding an international cost of living crisis, has been invoked — directly or indirectly — by leader after leader in Turkey as a reason to accelerate the transition away from fossil fuels.

European Commission President Ursula Von der Leyen said disruptions on the Strait of Hormuz are “shaking global energy markets.” The U.K. Prime Minister Andy Burnham invoked the specter of “wars across two continents” that “have sent fuel prices and gas bills soaring for families and businesses across the world.” U.N. Secretary General António Guterres noted how “recent conflicts made clear” that countries’ dependence on imported fossil fuels “is a recipe for chronic insecurity and a cost-of-living meltdown.”

“The case for fossil fuels is collapsing,” Gutteres said.

Trump is the name on everyone’s lips for another reason, too.

For the first time since he was reelected two years ago — and promptly announced that the U.S. would withdraw from the U.N. climate process and double down on fossil fuels — delegates at COP are starting to picture life without him in the White House.

U.S. President Donald Trump speaks at the White House in Washington on Nov. 9, 2026. | Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

“His shadow is still here. His shadow is here because of the midterm elections,” said London Mayor Sadiq Khan, co-chair of the C40 group of city mayors who back stronger climate action. People could “see now, on the horizon, a world without President Trump” or “one of Trump’s protégés” he told POLITICO.

Shadows and dust

Notwithstanding the Republicans’ crushing midterms defeat — itself in part down to the war’s impact on international fuel prices — Trump still looms large.

“The shadow of Trump” is also present at COP because “everyone is struggling with the cost of living,” added Khan — who has form in beefing with the U.S. president.

“Whether you speak to people from the Middle East, from sub-Saharan Africa, from Europe … all these fingers are pointed at President Trump and what he did in Iran. More so ironically — perversely — than Putin in Ukraine. President Trump has got Putin off the hook.”

The rhetoric on display in Turkey has not gone unnoticed in Washington, which has not sent a delegation to COP31. The U.S. withdrawal from the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change treaty that underpins COP talks will be completed early next year.

“President Trump is ensuring Iran can never have or use a nuclear weapon—a threat that would have a catastrophic impact on the entire world,” said White House spokesperson Taylor Rogers. “The conflict in Iran has underscored the importance of having access to reliable, affordable, and secure energy sources.

“Nations around the world are now turning to the United States as both an example and a partner in pursuing common-sense energy dominance policies,” she argued.

Nonetheless, Khan’s criticisms of Trump — and a cautious optimism about post-2028 American climate policy — are echoed by other diplomats and campaigners in Turkey.

The U.S. midterms and even more importantly for most diplomats the reelection in Brazil of Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva offer a “more positive vibe at COP31,” said founder of the E3G climate think tank Nick Mabey, “as countries see a move away from populism and the possibility of positive U.S. engagement on climate.”

“After Lula’s win and what we learned from the U.S. midterms,” agreed one European diplomat, “there’s a bit of a sense of tails up here now.”

  •  

Climate action must work for ‘people on all incomes,’ Burnham tells COP31

ANTALYA, Turkey — World leaders and industry must make electric cars and heat pumps affordable if they are to ensure “people on all incomes” can “make the green transition,” U.K. Prime Minister Andy Burnham told the COP31 climate summit.

During a flying visit to this year’s U.N. conference in Turkey, Burnham — who has made affordability his core domestic political focus — reaffirmed the U.K.’s commitment to the goal of net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.

But he warned that the world had “not moved as quick as I had hoped in the past five years” to show citizens that climate action and electrification have cost-of-living upsides.

“The last of these meetings I attended was COP26 as the mayor of Greater Manchester,” Burnham said, referring to the 2021 summit hosted by the U.K. He warned at the time that the climate movement must not lose sight of the “struggles of ordinary families.”

“The world feels very different now, and we need to adapt,” Burnham said. “Electrification in transport, heat and industry is how we make clean power, cheap power.”

While voicing support for COP31 hosts Turkey and Australia’s electrification push, Burnham stopped short of backing the specific target of 35% of global energy use shifting to electricity by 2035.

But he emphasized the benefits the switch could bring, while urging industry to help ensure it helped all consumers.

“If you drive a new electric car today in the U.K., it costs less than a petrol equivalent. Get on the right tariff and a heat pump can be cheaper to run than a gas boiler. These technologies are becoming cheaper, but they are not available to everybody on all incomes,” he said.

“As a government, we are doing our bit by investing in innovation and subsidizing upfront costs for the public. But we need industry to play their part too, and help people on all incomes to make the green transition.”

The focus on EVs and heat pumps comes despite Burnham’s government cutting the subsidy pot for heat pumps at last month’s budget. Ministers are also weighing proposals to water down industry EV quotas.

Nonetheless, Burnham reiterated the U.K.’s over-arching strategy to cut dependence on fossil fuels.  

“The climate crisis is not a distant threat. It is upon us all now, devastating lives and livelihoods everywhere. Meanwhile, two wars across two continents have sent fuel prices and gas bills soaring for families and businesses across the world,” he said. “The common thread running through all of this: our dependence on fossil fuels.”

He announced the U.K. would use its G20 presidency next year to “put climate resilience back on the agenda, with debt, development, and insurance as key issues.”

Burnham’s government has also created a new role of special representative for climate security, appointing former head of the Joint Intelligence Committee Chair Madeline Alessandri to the post.

  •  
❌