❌

Reading view

The case for new Democratic leadership

From left to right: Democrats Rep. Katherine Clark, Sen. Chuck Schumer, and Rep. Hakeem Jeffries walk out of the US Capitol.
Members of Democratic leadership in the House and Senate Democratic walk out of the US Capitol on May 21, 2026. | Aaron Schwartz/Bloomberg via Getty Images

After historic wins in the midterm elections, Democrats now have to decide who will lead their new majorities in the House and the Senate. The House race is expected to be a formality, with current minority leader Hakeem Jeffries as the sole declared candidate for House speaker. 

The Senate race, however, is shaping up to be more interesting: In the upper chamber, current minority leader Chuck Schumer is facing a challenge from Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen, who argues that Senate Democrats need new leadership to meet the demands of voters who delivered them a majority.

“The call was really to reject the status quo and to reject business as usual,” Van Hollen said. “And to do that, I think we need new leadership.” 

Van Hollen is also the favored candidate of the party’s progressive faction, many members of which have soured on Schumer. Corbin Trent, a former communications director for Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the founder of the super PAC A Fight Worth Having, is one of those: He tells Today, Explained that Schumer’s and Jeffries’s style of leadership is ill-suited for this moment, and he wants to see new Democratic leaders in both chambers. He also argues that Democrats should embrace a more proactive style of governing that harkens back to the New Deal era. 

Trent spoke with Today, Explained co-host Sean Rameswaram about who he wants to see lead the Democrats instead, why consensus-building is not enough, and why now is the right time to have this fight. 

Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get your podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.

Who do you think should be leading Democrats in the House and Senate in the new year?

I think that this moment calls for some sort of leadership that shows that we have a plan, an agenda, and a vision that’s capable of taking on and meeting this moment. And it’s not Hakeem Jeffries. It’s not Chuck Schumer. 

I know that’s the way we do things in the House, that’s the way we do things in the Senate. But look at the popularity of both of those institutions and then think to yourself, maybe we should do things a little differently.

Why not Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer?

Hakeem Jeffries has proven either one of two things. Either he’s incapable of wrangling the caucus, or his priorities are very different than the Democratic Party and the independent voters that voted for the Democrats in this election. 

What I mean by that is we’ve had three shots at stripping war powers away from Donald Trump vis-a-vis Iran. And, oh, lo and behold, one, two, three Democrats defected

He is not supporting an arms embargo to Israel. He’s not a guy who is representing the will of the people writ large. He is very much the establishment Democrat that I think led to Donald Trump being elected twice. 

Chuck Schumer is a man with a strongly worded letter in his back pocket. He’s the man that wants to pick up a couple of voters in rural Pennsylvania that are Republicans. Neither of them have a vision for building a Democratic supermajority that is akin to the one that was built around the New Deal. 

I think that this moment is very similar to that moment in that it is rife with opportunity. People are hopeful, people are ready for change, but the problem with hope is that when it’s dashed, it calcifies and it becomes resentment and anger.

And Democrats seem to miss that every time.

Over and over and over and over. I can remember how inspired I was by Barack Obama during his first presidential campaign — so inspired that I got involved in politics. I went to an event in Asheville to watch him speak. I started raising money for him on his portal, and I had a watch party. 

It was not my thing, but he inspired me to do all this stuff. And then several months later, what I’m hearing is a very different thing as a president than as a candidate. So we can’t keep missing these opportunities, in my mind.

Why do Jeffries and Schumer seem so confident in this moment? Schumer has a challenger, Chris Van Hollen. Hakeem kind of has one in Ayanna Pressley, but they don’t seem very worried that their positions might be in jeopardy right now. How come?

Because that’s just not the way things are done in the House, and they I think have faith that things will continue being done the way they are. Momentum, norms, all of these things point to them not having any real problem getting their leadership taken away. 

But Joe Crowley also felt that way. And then famously AOC spanked his little bottom in 2018, and now he’s a consultant instead of a congressman. Now we’d be having a very different conversation, because he was the one that was in line to be the next speaker of the House.

AOC is backing Jeffries. How come? What’s your reaction to that?

I mean, is she backing Jeffries? She’s doing this weird little thread-the-needle: “He’s the only one. What can we do?” 

But that’s the exact kind of thinking that you’re saying Democrats should rebuff.

Absolutely, they should. And interestingly, the most important thing to learn from Nancy Pelosi in my mind is that power is not given, it is taken. Power is not something that people give you. It is something that you take and then utilize. 

The fact is that [the Congressional Progressive Caucus] has 99 members, and it is going to have more. The fact is that these members have the capacity to generate more media than most. 

They can either take this moment to build power for the American people that ends up building a super-majoritarian Democratic Party, one that can make the Republican Party small enough to drown in a bathtub, or they can try to do business as usual, work with Hakeem, work with Schumer, try to extract some concessions, which they will not give. 

Because like you say, they have no fear. They do not fear these people. They respond to threats and fear, fear of losing their job.

Help us understand why someone like AOC doesn’t want this job. I mean, she’s one of the most visible Democrats in the country, and surely she’d be a popular candidate, right?

I can’t explain why people do what they do. Even I can’t explain why I do what I do, let alone other people. 

It doesn’t sound like a fun job. I can understand not wanting it. There is a lot of potential downside. You’re going to get ire because you’ve got to either deliver, which is going to be very difficult with Donald Trump still in the White House, or you’ve got to be really good at working to show that you’re attempting to deliver something big and you’re being blocked and by whom. 

The problem is a lot of people that are going to be standing in your way are going to be Democratic representatives and Democratic senators. Because the thing that I have come to understand is that there is a team of people that want to make this country fundamentally different, fundamentally more fair: Look at the healthcare system that we have and fundamentally rethink it. Look at the economy we have with AI and robotics burgeoning and fundamentally rethink it. 

But that team right now isn’t very big and it’s not like, oh, all Democrats are on board with this vision. They’re not.

You point at something that I think is relevant here, which is that this job of speaker of the House, Senate majority leader, it isn’t a walk in the park. It takes a certain type, perhaps. Maybe it takes a consensus builder. 

We had Rahm Emanuel on the show after the midterms and he said that Hakeem Jeffries was that. Do you think it takes someone in the middle of all of this to suss out where the caucus is and that’s why maybe we’re not getting the most exciting people, but we’re getting people who’ve been around for a while?

Well, according to [incoming Rep.] Don Leonard, there’s a different tactic that this particular leadership uses to bring consensus. And it’s not the hand-holding, middle-of-the-road consensus-building. It’s threats: threats of making your life a living hell for two years, threats of not getting any committee assignments, threats of not getting gavels.

Ultimately, this gave us Romneycare. This kind of middle-of-the-road nonsense gave us something that got rebranded as Obamacare, and it has not slowed down the increase of our costs. It saved lives. 

And here’s the problem with that: You had a Democratic caucus with 59 or 60 votes in the Senate and a majority in the House. And you had Barack Obama in there on a wave election of change. People like me got in there. And what the reasonable people were able to tell you as a new member or as a member that wanted, say, a public option or something else is that 50,000 to 60,000 people a year die from lack of healthcare. This can save 4,000 to 5,000 of those lives. Are you willing to let 4,000 or 5,000 people a year die just to stand and fight for this other thing that will save the whole 50,000? 

Because ultimately when you’re put in these positions, you’re given these choices and the choice is: Fight for the thing that can actually do the most good. Build power toward that thing and then at least make your compromise better. The compromise should have been the public option, but that means you got to fight for something bigger. 

You don’t have names, per se…

[Rep.] Ayanna Pressley. I think Ayanna Pressley and [Chris] Van Hollen. That’s where I would go right now.

Van Hollen, not exactly a bastion of progressivism… 

No.

But you think he could do the job?

I think he could do the job. 

And I think part of the thing here that’s just as important as getting a speaker that’s better or a leader that’s better is beating those people, flexing the power of the people. I’m not going to let the perfect be the enemy of the good here. I am going to let good be the enemy of bad. And I think that’s where we’re at right here. 

My politics are definitely to the left of Van Hollen or whatever spectrum you want to look at. But I think the fight in and of itself is worth it, and winning is worth it.

  •  

The secret of the new Southern Democrats: They’re super liberal

Annie Andrews, left, in a light blue blazer, and James Talarico, right in a navy blue blazer and tie.
Sens.-elect Annie Andrews (D-SC) and James Talarico (D-TX) walk through the US Capitol as they arrive for new member orientation meetings for the 120th Congress, in Washington, DC, on November 9, 2026. | Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images

If you want to own a gun, there are few places better to do it than South Carolina. As the gun rights organization the National Rifle Association (NRA) notes on its database of state gun laws, the Palmetto State has no restrictions on the class of guns dubbed assault weapons or large-capacity magazines; there is no permit required to openly carry firearms. 

Its outgoing governor, Republican Henry McMaster, was supported by the NRA’s political wing, which noted that he netted an “A” rating in their 2018 scores. None of this is surprising. It’s located in the Deep South, after all — that’s the headquarters of America’s gun culture.

But what is surprising is that the NRA lost a key election this midterms, when its candidate, the incumbent Republican Sen. Darline Graham, lost to Democratic nominee Annie Andrews.

“I hate the NRA,” Andrews wrote on her X page in September 2024. In another previous missive, she blamed the NRA for creating a “hellscape” at her child’s school where a police officer stands guard during recess. 

The pediatrician-turned-senator-elect was not shy about her view on America’s easy access to guns. She had previously held a job at Everytown for Gun Safety, a group that organizes for more strict gun laws. Her campaign website this cycle included a call to ban “weapons of war from our streets” — an allusion to assault weapons. 

In 2013, 15 Democratic senators voted against one such proposed ban on assault weapons, including lawmakers from significantly more liberal states like Virginia and Colorado. That year, Georgia’s Democratic gubernatorial candidate Jason Carter (the grandson of former president Jimmy Carter) campaigned on his proud support for gun rights — one story noted that he held a 92 percent rating from the NRA.

And yet starting in January, an even more conservative state will be sending an avowed opponent of the NRA to the Senate. 

And it’s not just guns where Andrews is much more liberal than the traditional Southern or red-state Democrat. If her X page is any indication, her ideal president is Elizabeth Warren. She finds Israel’s conduct toward the Palestinians to be “morally unconscionable” and she pledged to never take money from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC). She’s ardently pro-choice. She posed with a sticker reading “protect trans kids.” She wants to dramatically expand tax credits for families with kids. And her old Resistance-style social media videos have become an object of popular fascination.

“We’re Republican Women Politicians” pic.twitter.com/w1VZqsLOCZ

— Dr. Annie Andrews (@AnnieAndrewsMD) April 26, 2024


Andrews is part of a wave of Southern and red-state Democrats who are redefining what it means to be a Democrat in these traditionally conservative environments. While these Democrats don’t have the politics of, say, your average member of the Democratic Socialists of America or Vermont’s independent Sen. Bernie Sanders, they represent a significant departure from the conservative Democrats who dominated the region the last time they represented these states. 

How the changing South explains the new candidates

For years, it was assumed that Democrats who hail from the South and other conservative-leaning states would only be viable if they matched a certain traditional motif — think a white guy who poses with his gun and speaks in a thick accent in his ads.

But this crop of Democrats is leaning into a new, millennial era of voters who are significantly more progressive than the Dixiecrats of old. 

The South’s booming economies have attracted an influx of Black voters — who turned out in huge numbers for Democrats this cycle — and grown its diverse cities and suburbs in multiple states, which have become more favorable territory for Democrats. “The white population keeps getting better in Mississippi,” Democratic Senate leader Chuck Schumer bluntly told skeptics of his party’s candidates, according to The Atlantic, pointing to new tech workers with more progressive views. Pair those trends with a new openness among rural voters to Democrats’ increasingly populist message — and depressed turnout from some upset with President Donald Trump’s record — and that’s a coalition that can elect some very different candidates.

You have, for instance, Georgia’s Sen. Jon Ossoff. Ossoff, a graduate of Georgetown University and the London School of Economics, leaned into his identity as a booksmart critic of corruption and a rigged economy. Unlike the Joe Manchins and Kyrsten Sinemas of yesteryear, he supported most major Democratic policies in Congress. He earned the ire of AIPAC for his votes to curb some arms sales to Israel. His victory speech following the election included zero Clintonian rhetoric about curbing government deficits or cracking down on street crime; instead, he pledged to fight corporate money, end endless wars, and establish universal health care. 

He campaigned proudly as an opponent of bigotry and racism. One of his main lines of attack on his opponent, Republican Rep. Mike Collins, was that he had surrounded himself with racist and white nationalist staffers and family members. 

“If John Lewis were marching today from Selma to Montgomery, Mike Collins would be grabbing a billy club,” he said during one debate with Collins.

Although he courted Republicans through his strong constituent services and support for community services, he also maintained his progressive cultural commitments. Despite prognostication from Republicans that his refusal to compromise on transgender issues would serve as a vulnerability, it had no apparent impact on his landslide victory.

And he wasn’t the only statewide Democrat in Georgia who donned a populist mantle. Across the state, the newly elected Democrats plan to take on corporate power, a departure from the state’s traditionally big business-friendly regulatory environment. Lt. Gov.-elect Josh McLaurin campaigned against the state’s anti-union “right-to-work” law and against the power of “oligarchs and billionaires.” Insurance Commissioner-elect Keisha Waites is proposing banning insurers from using zip codes to discriminate on price. Attorney General-elect Tanya Miller is taking aim at grocery price gouging and utility rate increases. Like Ossoff, Miller refused to compromise on her principles when it comes to transgender people; as a member of the Georgia House, she walked out of the chamber to protest a GOP effort to ban gender-affirming care for transgender people in Georgia prisons, defending her stance in a debate with her opponent.

Who are the new Southern progressives?

Arguably the most strident incoming House members are, paradoxically, in some of the most conservative districts — often protest candidates who ran with little expectation of winning and felt less pressure to adjust their message to please strategists or donors. In Tennessee, eight-term GOP incumbent Rep. Scott DesJarlais fell to Democratic candidate Victoria Broderick, a progressive who campaigned on raising corporate taxes as well as establishing Medicare-for-all. She will also be the first openly queer person to serve in the state’s congressional delegation.

In North Carolina, 24-year Army veteran Richard Ojeda won a seat for Democrats in a narrow victory over the Republican incumbent; Ojeda, who was an outspoken opponent of Trump in his first term, is no less fiery now. He’s defending immigrants, denouncing the war in Iran, and making it his personal mission to remove Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth. 

Every damn American deserves healthcare. PERIOD.

Not just the rich. Not just the folks lucky enough to have a good job with benefits. EVERYBODY.

Put the bill on the floor. Let’s see who’s willing to look working families in the eye and tell them they don’t deserve to see a… https://t.co/M7TDg2jOjc

— Maj. (Ret.) Richard Ojeda (@Ojeda4America) November 16, 2026

Texas’s James Talarico, who will become the first Democratic senator to represent the state in almost 40 years, ran a campaign railing against the power of billionaires in the American political and economic system — sounding at times more like Bernie Sanders than a Blue Dog Democrat. 

“The billionaires who own the social media algorithms, who own the cable news networks, who own the politicians fighting on the screens, they want us at each other’s throats,” he told the assembled crowd after his victory. 

His platform included raising taxes on the ultra-rich, a departure from the tax-skeptical climate of the American South. And he warned that “the real fight in this country is not left versus right. It is top versus bottom.” 

Texas Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa, who wants to freeze electricity rates, sounded similar notes. 

“We see that things are so stacked against working people in this country….if I were to pick a label to describe what are my politics, it is economic populism,” she told the New York Times. 

Even Scott Colom, the Democrat who won notoriously conservative Mississippi with a comparatively more moderate platform, has sounded a few progressive notes. He has rejected money from AIPAC and he campaigned not just on prosecuting violent crime but also on reforming the criminal justice system to make it more humane. 

In a poetic twist, Colom was blocked from becoming a federal judge by incumbent Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith, who cited his purported opposition to restrictions on transgender athletes’ participation in girls’ and women’s sports; now she has found herself soon to be replaced by Colom. 

And while factionalist debates between avowed progressives and centrists roil social media, Colom’s coalition was cross-ideological — Morris Katz, a consultant who previously worked for New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, helped make ads that attacked his GOP opponent. Colom also credited a former Bernie Sanders and Jeremy Corbyn operative with helping craft his video strategy.

This isn’t to say that these Democrats don’t have their own peculiarities that distinguish them from progressives on the coasts. They do, after all, represent states with their own unique culture and interests. Ossoff voted to toughen immigration enforcement after the murder of his constituent Laken Riley. Talarico made a point to support Texas’s local oil and gas industry. Andrews, despite her general support for transgender rights, opposed allowing gender surgery for kids and what she called “men in women’s sports.”

But one thing is certain. For decades, Southern states were used to sending Democrats to Congress who in many ways resembled their Republican colleagues more than they did Democrats elsewhere in the country. But this new crop of red-state Democrats are much more unabashedly populist, focused on fighting corporate power, and culturally liberal than their most recent ancestors were.

  •  

Jeffries Secures Path To Becoming First Black Speaker in History

Current House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) won the internal Dem leadership election Wednesday morning, securing his path to the gavel. The win will likely set Jeffries up to be the first Black House Speaker in history in January.

Democrat Mary Peltola defeated incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-AK) late Tuesday night, flipping yet another seat for Senate Democrats. Peltola’s win will officially bring Senate Democrats to a 56 seat majority in the 120th Congress.

Meanwhile, Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) made the rounds on cable TV over the weekend, saying he believes he has “a path to” defeating current Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY), who has led Senate Democrats for the past 10 years. Schumer has been relentlessly insisting he has the votes and will be the next majority leader.

And President Donald Trump’s last minute pick to lead the Government Accountability Office (GAO) is facing what looks like an uncertain path to confirmation.

Trump nominated Eric Ueland, a top deputy for Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Director Russ Vought, for the position on Monday. Most, if not all Democrats, are expected to oppose Ueland and some Republican senators are already questioning if he is the right guy to lead the independent watchdog agency, housed within the legislative branch.

Ueland’s confirmation hearing is scheduled for Thursday morning.

Follow along with us as we navigate the lame-duck session:

  •  

Democrats could raise the minimum wage next year. How high should they go?

People holding signs at a rally to raise the minimum wage
A decade after the Democratic Party rallied around the Fight for 15 movement, how high to raise the minimum wage — and how fast — is becoming a defining economic question for the new majority. | Erik McGregor/LightRocket via Getty Images

In the wake of the midterm elections in which Democrats won control of both the House and the Senate, a growing number of politicians and activists have begun calling, publicly and privately, for Congress to seize the moment and pass the first federal minimum wage increase in 17 years. 

After running campaigns centered on the cost of living, Democrats and their allies say raising the $7.25 federal minimum closer to a “living wage” — i.e., enough for a full-time worker to cover basics like rent, food, and healthcare — is the obvious next step for their affordability mandate. A minimum wage increase also has a political advantage because businesses, not the government, cover the cost, meaning it has little effect on the deficit and doesn’t compete with other priorities for federal dollars.

“I’ve been talking with a lot of different Democrats on the Hill and they’ve been calling it a first 100-day issue,” said Jared Bernstein, who chaired President Joe Biden’s Council of Economic Advisers and is now at the liberal Center for American Progress. 

Rahm Emanuel, who is widely expected to run for president in 2028, has been urging Democrats to act, and it was a top issue for the party when he ran its campaign arm in 2006. “Pass a minimum wage $20 by 2030,” he said on Vox’s Today, Explained podcast after the election. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) has also been making media rounds calling for raising the wage to “at least $20 bucks an hour.” On Thursday, Hakeem Jeffries, who’s expected to be the House speaker, identified raising the wage as a priority, but ducked press questions about specifics.

Key takeaways

  • Many Democrats want to raise the federal minimum wage from $7.25 to about $20 an hour by 2030. Sen. Chris Murphy’s bill would go to $25.
  • Most research finds past increases raised pay without costing many jobs. But few places have set a minimum that high relative to local wages, so economists don’t know where the limit is.
  • Critics warn a high national minimum could hurt lower-wage states the most and lead employers to raise prices or cut hours, benefits, and training.
  • Raising the minimum wage is popular across party lines, and because the cost falls on businesses and their customers rather than taxpayers, it adds little to the federal deficit.

A decade after the party rallied around the “Fight for 15” movement, how high to raise the minimum wage — and how fast — is becoming a defining economic question for the new Democratic majority, as well as in states where they have new governing trifectas. In Pennsylvania, Gov. Josh Shapiro has pledged to sign a $15 minimum wage bill, while in Wisconsin, Gov.-elect David Crowley has targeted a gradual increase to $20. 

In recent years, a wave of research built on the 30 states that raised their own minimums has convinced many economists that modest increases cost few, if any, jobs. That evidence, plus voters’ anger about the cost of living, has rallied progressive experts around a new federal benchmark equal to two-thirds of the hourly median wage, or roughly $20 by 2030. 

But that threshold is also near the upper end of what researchers have actually studied, and even economists who support it acknowledge that no one knows how high the minimum wage can go before it starts costing a significant number of jobs or increasing prices at a time when inflation is a major concern. Skeptics warn that a national minimum that high could hit the country’s lowest-wage places hardest, just as AI introduces new threats to the jobs young and less-experienced workers depend on.

Still, raising the minimum wage is popular with voters, and even some Republicans have expressed openness to cutting a deal. “You want to raise the minimum wage? I’m for that,” Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO) told reporters last week. The last wage increase was signed by a Republican president after Democrats won both chambers of Congress in the 2006 midterms, much as they did this month. Trump, who has previously called the $7.25 minimum wage “a very low number” recently told Politico he doesn’t want to “just be sitting there for two years vetoing everything.”

Some Democrats want to go even further, like Sen. Chris Murphy of Connecticut, whose bill introduced over the summer would require big companies to pay $25 within about five years and smaller ones by the late 2030s. Murphy makes the case for his bill less on labor-market research and more on economic fairness.

“It’s not like we can’t pay a $25 minimum wage,” Murphy said after announcing his legislation. “We just choose not to.” And in New York City, Mayor Zohran Mamdani ran on a $30 minimum wage by 2030, though the plan hasn’t gotten traction in the state legislature, which would have to approve it.

As Democrats look to act in 2027 and beyond, the empirical debate over how high the minimum wage can safely go is getting entangled with the populist one over how high the party should aim. These debates are especially important because the party may have far more power to raise wages than they expected before their midterm wins, both in Congress and in states and cities around the country. While previous efforts in Congress have been stymied by procedural barriers, Senate Democrats are now within reach of a filibuster-proof majority as soon as 2029. 

Far from a messaging exercise, the question of how high wages should be at the bottom is now a live policy issue that the party needs to take seriously — with potentially severe consequences if they misstep. How Democrats work through these tensions will shape both how much low-wage workers might gain, and what they might lose, and how much of the party’s answer to the cost of living rests on the minimum wage at all.

From $15 to $20 (and beyond)

Beginning in 2012 and backed by the Service Employees International Union, fast-food workers walked off their jobs, demanding $15 an hour and the right to form a union. The Fight for 15 became a national movement, spreading to other sectors like academia, airports, and childcare, and it pushed past the position of President Barack Obama and congressional Democrats, who were calling then for a $10.10 minimum.

In 2015, congressional Democrats introduced the Raise the Wage Act, which would have increased the federal minimum wage to $12 an hour by 2020. Hillary Clinton campaigned on a $12 minimum in the 2016 primary, while Sanders leaned into the $15 standard. By the time the general election rolled around, even with Clinton as the nominee, the Democratic Party platform had embraced $15, and by 2017, Democrats, now with Sanders as the Senate’s lead sponsor, updated the Raise the Wage Act to a $15 target.

The House passed the $15 bill in 2019, but it died in the Republican-controlled Senate. In 2021, the Senate parliamentarian blocked Democrats from adding it to Biden’s pandemic relief package, though it’s possible a future Congress might feature a different parliamentarian with a different perspective. In July 2023, Sanders and Rep. Bobby Scott raised the bill’s target again, this time to $17 an hour.

But while progress in Washington stalled, leaders around the country took action. Since 2014, 28 states and Washington, DC, have passed laws raising their minimum wages, and nearly 70 cities and counties now have minimums higher than their state’s. Some of the increases came through legislation, while others came from ballot measure campaigns, including in red states like Arkansas, Florida, Missouri, and Nebraska. Eighteen states and DC now have minimums of $15 or more.

Though raising the minimum wage has long drawn support across party lines, in June, Oklahoma voters decisively rejected a measure that would have raised the state’s minimum from $7.25 to $15 by 2029. Opponents argued that the raise, plus automatic yearly increases tied to inflation, would have driven up prices and hurt small businesses. (The vote also came during a low-turnout June primary, when only about a quarter of registered voters cast ballots.)

That same month, Murphy introduced the Living Wage for All Act, outflanking Sanders’s Raise the Wage Act from the left. Murphy, who is also widely expected to run for president, has argued that Democrats should lean harder into economic populism to win back the working class. A $25 minimum wage is “the bare minimum of what workers deserve — and of what workers should expect from their leaders,” he declared in an essay accompanying his bill’s release. “It’s also what’s best for the health of our economy and country.”

Murphy and Sanders discussed the Living Wage for All Act earlier this year, a Murphy spokesperson told me, adding that “conversations among the caucus are ongoing as to how best raise the minimum wage across the nation.”

What the research says

A generation ago, efforts to boost the minimum wage ran into a recurring problem: a widespread consensus among economists that increases came with serious trade-offs, like fewer jobs and higher prices. And not just free-market conservatives, but more liberal economists like former New York Times columnist Paul Krugman, who in 1998 chastised activists who believed wages “can be set based on considerations of justice, not supply and demand, without unpleasant side effects.”

But that consensus quietly shifted over the years as more states and cities experimented with ambitious wage increases — and ran into fewer difficulties than expected. Proponents of a federal minimum wage of $20 or more often point to the work of Arin Dube, an economist at the University of Massachusetts Amherst and one of the most widely cited researchers on the topic. In a 2024 meta-analysis co-authored with Ben Zipperer from the left-leaning Economic Policy Institute, Dube reviewed nearly 90 studies and found that most showed minimum-wage increases raised workers’ total pay with little job loss.

Critics still point to places like Seattle and California as warnings, where studies have found that Seattle’s minimum-wage increase cut hours for low-wage workers and California’s $20 fast-food wage cost jobs, though other researchers dispute those findings. But in general, there were few glaring cautionary tales in a sea of state and local increases. 

Dube says years of minimum-wage research, including comparisons of the 30 states that raised their minimums with the 20 that didn’t, have changed how economists understand the labor market. Economics 101 would suggest that raising labor costs means employers hire fewer workers. But many employers have enough power in their local job market to pay less than workers would earn elsewhere, so a higher minimum can raise pay without making those jobs unprofitable. “The idea is employers have some choice when it comes to setting pay,” Dube told me. 

Paying workers more can also make it easier to hire and retain staff, and workers tend to be more productive when they’re paid more, he added. Dube said this helps explain why pay has grown faster in the 30 states that raised their minimums than in the 20 that didn’t, while job growth has been “virtually identical” across both groups, including in low-wage industries like restaurants and retail.

Some of the higher cost does get passed on to customers, Dube acknowledged, but not by much. “Maybe middle-class and higher-income families pay a little bit more for the burger,” he said.

In light of the research, progressive economists have begun rallying around a new federal target, to raise the federal minimum to two-thirds of the median hourly wage, or roughly $17 today and about $20 by 2030.

That would be “a fairly reasonable but strong minimum wage policy,” Dube told me, meaning a big enough increase to help millions of workers, but not so high that it would go “far outside of our evidence base.”

I asked Dube about Murphy’s bill, which mostly tracks the path he describes but would require big companies, those with at least 500 workers or $1 billion in revenue, to pay $25 an hour within five years. He said that could push their minimum above the two-thirds benchmark for a while, a “temporary overshooting” before it eventually lines back up with two-thirds of the median.

Murphy’s $25 figure is drawn from MIT’s living wage calculations, and his office also points to what the minimum would be worth if it had kept pace with inflation and productivity since 1968. “A minimum wage in the United States of America should be a living wage,” Murphy said when he introduced the bill.

In an interview, Patrick Oakford, the director of the Worker Power and Economic Security program at the Roosevelt Institute, a progressive think tank, told me supporters of a $20 wage were not working backward from a clear number, but instead chose the target based on the available evidence.

“Any rational person who looks fairly at this body of research can really only come to one conclusion, which is that raising the minimum wage does not lead to significant job loss,” he told me, even at two-thirds of the median.

Earlier this year, though, in a report Oakford authored, he also grounded the two-thirds target in what the minimum wage should accomplish: At that level, he wrote, a full-time minimum wage would get much closer to what it actually costs a single adult to live, and it would match the target the United Kingdom set and reached in 2024. As for critics who note that most US studies looked at minimums well below two-thirds of the median, Oakford argues that the studies that went higher, including of California’s $20 fast-food wage, haven’t found a cliff, a point where job losses suddenly spike.

“My read of the research is that two-thirds of the median is a legitimate upper bound, but more cautious approaches are also defensible,” Bernstein, of the Center for American Progress, told me.

How high is too high?

Other economists I spoke with were less supportive.

“Two-thirds of the median makes me pretty nervous, and numbers like $20 and $25 an hour are entirely ungrounded,” said Jason Furman, who chaired the Council of Economic Advisers in the Obama administration.

Furman agrees that small increases in the minimum wage haven’t cost many jobs, but in his view there’s little good evidence on bigger increases, and the federal floor should be built for the lowest-wage states, like Mississippi, since higher-wage states can always go further on their own. In lower-wage states, the concern is that the same $20 minimum would be a much bigger shock to employers, who would have to raise pay for a far larger share of their workers, and that’s where economists worry job losses are most likely to show up. Employers also may cut back on worker benefits — a major concern at the moment as health premiums soar — and job training. With AI threatening entry-level jobs, past evidence about whether employers turn to automation to replace low-wage workers may be a poor guide to what comes next. 

Every economist I spoke with said there’s a point at which a federal minimum wage could be increased too much.

“To me all of this doesn’t say don’t do it, but to be careful and moderate,” Furman said.

Michael Strain, the director of Economic Policy Studies at the American Enterprise Institute, a conservative think tank, told me he thinks the employment effects of the minimum wage are “genuinely contested,” and he’s “skeptical of excessive certainty,” both from those who insist higher minimums cost no jobs and from those who warn of a surge in unemployment. Strain favors expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit  — which costs the government money, but doesn’t affect employers — to help workers with the least experience and fewest options, and argues that the minimum wage  is “counterproductive” for those individuals, since it can price them out of jobs.

Ryan Bourne, an economist at the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank, would prefer no federal minimum wage at all, but says that if there has to be one, it’s best set locally, where policymakers have a clearer sense of their own labor markets. He argues that even if some employers do have the power to hold down wages, that power varies by industry and region, so it doesn’t justify one national number. 

“If you’re talking about Eagle Pass, Texas; or Hot Springs, Arkansas; or Gadsden, Alabama, this is going to be a really, really big deal,” he said of a $20 or $25 federal standard.

There are examples abroad, too. In 2018 and 2019, South Korea raised its minimum wage nearly 30 percent, taking it from 53 percent to 63 percent of the median wage, close to the two-thirds benchmark. A Kansas City Fed study estimated the increases cut employment at manufacturing firms by about 3 percent. But the United Kingdom, by contrast, moved more gradually to around two-thirds of the median, and research has found no robust evidence that it hurt jobs, suggesting the pace of an increase may matter.  

Every economist I spoke with said there’s a point at which a federal minimum wage could be increased too much. “There would definitely be a point where if the minimum wage is high enough, you would start to see more substantial changes on employment,” Dube told me. When I asked Dube what that too-high point is, he said no one knows, because no state has raised its minimum high enough to find it. 

One option is to build guardrails into the legislation, like New York did. Under a 2023 law, New York’s minimum wage law has been indexed to rise with inflation, beginning in 2027, unless the economy shows signs of trouble. Earlier this fall, a small decline in jobs triggered that “off-ramp” for the first time, freezing the state’s minimum at $17 downstate and $16 upstate for 2027. (Gov. Kathy Hochul now calls the trigger too sensitive, and has proposed loosening it.)

Bernstein of the Center for American Progress summed up the dilemma. “It’s hard to know where the line is,” he said, “until you cross it.”

  •  

“A rich message, but a poor campaign”: How Scott Colom beat the odds in Mississippi

Rep. Bennie Thompson, a Black man with a white beard and black glasses, holds a microphone in one hand as he speaks from a podium with a sign reading “Picked another senator.”
Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-MS) speaks during a victory celebration for Mississippi Sen.-elect Scott Colom at Tougaloo College in Tougaloo, Mississippi, on November 11, 2026. | Aron Smith/Jackson State University via Getty Images

On Wednesday, Mississippi’s Senate race was officially called for Democrat Scott Colom, who will become the first Black person to represent the state in the US Senate since Reconstruction, more than 140 years ago. Colom’s win is a stunning, historic upset — and for many Black Democrats, like Rep. Bennie Thompson, it’s been a long time coming.

Thompson, who also won his race last week, has represented Mississippi’s majority-Black Second Congressional District since 1993. Over the years, the 78-year-old lawmaker has frequently invoked the story of his father, who was never able to cast a vote because of racist Jim Crow laws that enforced segregation until the mid-1960s.

I sat down with Thompson for Today, Explained to talk about Colom’s run for Senate, how he won, what it means for Thompson personally. 

Below is an excerpt of our conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.

Your dad was never able to cast a vote during his lifetime because of Jim Crow laws. And I wonder, growing up in Mississippi, what did you learn about who was allowed to participate in democracy?

You were a second-class citizen. That means you could go to school, but you couldn’t go to school with the white kids. Or the one swimming pool in town was for white kids, and the Black kids had to swim in the creeks or the ponds around the community. No lifeguard, no anything. My mama and daddy paid taxes, but they weren’t allowed to vote. My uncle fought in World War II; defended democracy all over the world, but when he came back home, he had to ride a segregated train behind the white German prisoners.

Jesus. 

So you had the white soldiers, the white German prisoners, and the Black soldiers. And that was the order of the day. It was something that we grew up with. 

When you were young, I wonder, did you associate the right to vote with the ability to change things? Like, if we get to cast a ballot, then we get to fix this mess? 

The best thing that I can say is I went to Tougaloo College [near Jackson, Mississippi]. And on that college campus, I met Martin Luther King Jr., I met Stokely Carmichael, I met Harry Belafonte, I met Sammy Davis Jr. — all of the major civil rights icons of the day. 

That was how we cut our teeth into civil rights and voting rights. The first campaign I worked on was Mrs. Hamer’s campaign for Congress. 

Fannie Lou Hamer, the civil rights icon. 

And I now represent that district. 

But I remember telling my mother that, oh, I had gone to Ruleville, Mississippi, to help register Black people to vote for Congress. And my mama said, “Well, I don’t know why you way up there.” Said, “Black people don’t vote here in Bolton.” And so it hit me. And Lord have mercy. In my own hometown, you know, I was in the same situation. And we did voter registration. We did all kind of things. 

“For me, having gone through those life experiences and now to see a Scott come along, you know, it not only brings tears to your eye, but it also says that there’s hope.”

We brought Head Start to the community, and started understanding that real freedom comes with political freedom. And so we started holding meetings about what we wanted to do. We decided to run three people for the board and the three African Americans won.

But it really wasn’t a good four years on that term because the current mayor didn’t want any progress. So we ran an all-Black slate: mayor, clerk, alderman. We won every position. 

We’re talking about 50 years ago, and all these challenges that you faced, all these challenges to being able to vote, being able to assume office, being able to function as a mayor in a town that is so segregated. Fifty years later, Scott Colom is winning in Mississippi. 

I want to ask you to reflect on when you became aware of his candidacy and what you thought about the potential there.

One of the challenges that I’ve had to deal with is that every time I run for public office, I’ve always been the first. But I wanted to create some kind of vehicle to get other people engaged. So we formed the Mississippi Black Leadership Institute. Well, Scott Colom was in the first class. And he really said, “I want to run for something. I don’t know what it is.” He said, “But there’s a district attorney’s position that’s available. It’s three counties.” 

We helped Scott put his campaign together. We hooked him up with various people, and he beat a 28-year incumbent as district attorney. 

Why do you think he won? 

Well, because he had the fire in the belly. And he never met a stranger. And so we prepared him, and he’s one of our star pupils of that class. And look, uh, when the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee would not support him, they—

They would not support him.

They would not support him. But this was my — Bennie Thompson’s position is that Northeasterners were still looking down on Southerners.

Well, did you call them up and scream at Chuck Schumer or somebody and say, “Guys, I am telling you, we got one here who can win?”

Look, we did everything that the system says you should do. We gave the demographics. That district [Colom] represented was not a majority-African American district. He beat that sitting district attorney in a majority-white district because he had a plan and he had a message. We had a rich message, but a poor campaign. Because we couldn’t get our DSCC to help. 

Have you called any of those people in national leadership and said, “I told you so?”

Oh yeah. All of a sudden, the week before the election, they’re going to say, “Well, we’re going to be able to do this, but we’re going to shoot the spot and we’ll send it to you.” So you really didn’t give us the money. You know what I’m saying? 

So that’s all right. We’re going to keep doing our low budget, social media-attractive thing. And so it took off.

You are 78 years old? Do I have that right? 

Yep. 

This has been most of your life. The fight for this has been most of your life. 

Yep. 

You sit here today, we sit here today. Where is your head at in all of this? Did you lock yourself in the bathroom and cry for 10 minutes?

No question. I’m happy for Scott personally. His trajectory is tremendous. But you know, it’s been a tough journey. We had a poll tax put on us that we had to pay money to be a registered voter. We had to interpret sections of the Constitution. In many instances when my mama registered — my mama had a college degree, she was a teacher — but the person who asked her to interpret the Constitution was an elementary school graduate. You see what I’m saying? 

I sure do. 

And so for me, having gone through those life experiences and now to see a Scott come along, you know, it not only brings tears to your eye, but it also says that there’s hope. There’s hope for young African Americans that at some point, the choice will be, do I stay or leave? It won’t be, “Well, when I get an education, I have to go somewhere else to seek a career.”

And so that’s the exciting part. I’m just really happy. And for a guy who’s been in it over 50 years and been called everything but a child of God, because I’m trying to elevate people who look like me to where I know if they have it, they’ll do a great job. So for Bennie Thompson, Scott’s victory is a dream come true.

  •  

Do the Dems need new leadership?

Sen. Chris Van Hollen, a clean-shaven white-haired man wearing a navy suit and tie, gestures with both hands from behind a podium.
Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) speaks during a news conference on Capitol Hill in June 2026. | Graeme Sloan/Bloomberg via Getty Images

This story appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.

Hi readers, happy Friday! Today, we’re saying farewell — for now — to “Democrats in array.” Not quite two weeks after winning the 2026 midterms by a historic margin, the party has a leadership fight on its hands. 

On Thursday evening, Sen. Chris Van Hollen, a Democrat from Maryland, made it official: He’s challenging current Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer for the title of majority leader next year, promising a bolder and more aggressive agenda for the party. 

“It is about answering the call of the American people,” Van Hollen told MS NOW host Jen Psaki when he announced his candidacy on her show. “The call was really to reject the status quo and to reject business as usual. And to do that, I think we need new leadership.”

Newly elected Democrats Abdul El-Sayed (D-MI) and Peggy Flanagan (D-MN), each of whom defeated more leadership-aligned Democrats in their Senate primaries, are backing his bid. But Van Hollen will have an uphill climb to win the job, which is set to be decided in a closed-door vote early next month. Schumer, 75, has led Senate Democrats for nearly a decade, starting in 2017, and says he’s confident he will have the votes to be reelected in December.

Searching for “fighters”

The Senate is the only chamber currently dealing with an active leadership fight, but it’s not the only one with some leadership angst. In the House, current Democratic minority leader Hakeem Jeffries is the overwhelming favorite to become the new speaker in January (he currently lacks any Democratic challengers). But not everyone is happy about it, as my colleague Astead Herndon reported on Thursday. 

The divide, he argues — both in the Schumer-Van Hollen showdown and frustrations with Jeffries — is not really about progressive versus moderate. Instead, he says, it’s about an energized, angry Democratic base looking for fighters to lead the party into what’s almost certain to be a combative final two years of the Trump administration, and a sense that neither Schumer nor Jeffries are ready to meet the moment. 

It’s not just a problem for this cycle, either: Democrats won so widely last week that they’re very likely to hang onto their majorities at least through the 2028 election, Eric Levitz points out. 

There’s nothing to say that Democrats will have the same leaders in two years (particularly Schumer, who’s up for reelection in 2028 but may either retire or face a serious primary challenge). 

But the intra-party debate that we’re watching play out right now is effectively a preview of the higher-stakes fight to come in 2028, when Democrats could also have control of the presidency — and their freest legislative hand since the 2008 election. 

As Eric writes, that will come with some real challenges, not least that Democrats currently appear to be facing an impossible trio of economic promises, one of which they’ll likely need to break. But it will also be a moment of opportunity — if the party’s leaders are ready for it.

One link for later

➨ Science fictional: Vox’s Unexplainable podcast spoke with best-selling author Emily St. John Mandel about her new book, Exit Party, how she uses science to inform her fiction, and why she’s so fascinated with the idea of “counter life,” for people and countries alike. Plus: How she finds hope in Exit Party’s dystopian universe(s). You can read an excerpt of her conversation with Unexplainable host Byrd Pinkerton here.

Before you go…

  • Did you know…that table tennis, of all sports, is a fixation for many online gamblers? But unlike simple sports bets, Jack Meserve reports for Vox — things like “who will win the game?” — gambling companies have transformed table tennis into something approximating a slot machine.
  • Today’s trivia: Which 19th-century infrastructure project was derided as “Clinton’s Big Ditch” during its construction? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in Monday’s edition.)
  • Yesterday’s trivia: Yesterday, we asked you what type of nymphs live in trees, as opposed to water, caves, or clouds. That would be dryads, a type of spirit that in Greek myth were specifically affiliated with oak trees. 
  •  

Democrats made three big economic promises. They’ll need to break one.

Chuck Schumer standing next to Hakeem Jeffries.
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) speak to reporters alongside other House and Senate Appropriation Democratic committee members in the US Capitol on July 22, 2025, in Washington, DC. | Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images

The Democratic Party just won its largest congressional majorities in more than a decade. In the House specifically, if current vote tallies hold, it will boast more seats next year than at any time since 1992.

Now what do they do with that power? 

In the near term, the extraordinary scale of the Democrats’ midterm victory might be of little consequence. So long as President Donald Trump holds veto power over legislation, a 254-seat House majority may be no better at advancing the Democratic agenda than a 218-seat one would be. 

Key takeaways

  • Democrats’ midterm landslide makes it likely that if they win the White House in 2028, they’ll also have comfortable congressional majorities to pass their economic agenda.
  • The party has promised to expand the welfare state, cut taxes for everyone but the rich, and bring down inflation and interest rates, but those goals will likely prove incompatible.
  • Taxing the rich alone probably can’t fund a massive new safety net, yet even this year’s unusually Democratic electorate rejected broader tax hikes.
  • To ease the tension between their priorities, Democrats should embrace policies that boost the economy’s productive capacity.

Two years from now, however, the blue tsunami’s size could matter enormously. Democrats are unlikely to do quite as well in the 2028 election as they did this year, when the Republican base largely abstained. But Democratic Senate leader Chuck Schumer’s party now has plenty of seats to spare. For this reason, if Democrats win the presidency in 2028, they are now extremely likely to also secure full control of Congress — and by comfortable margins. 

This is no small thing. Under President Joe Biden, Democrats held only a bare Senate majority, enabling any individual senator to dictate the terms of their policymaking. A Democratic president has not had the chance to govern with robust congressional support since 2010.

Democrats are therefore within striking distance of a rare opportunity — a chance to enact their economic agenda without asking Republicans or their party’s most unreliable centrists for permission.

To seize this historic opening, Democrats will need to formulate a platform that effectively advances their core goals. Unfortunately, this will be harder than it sounds — because the party’s current economic priorities appear incompatible with each other.

During the midterm campaign, Democrats promised to:

Democrats have good reason for embracing all of these objectives. In the last three federal elections, voters punished incumbents for presiding over a rising cost of living. So any governing party would be eager to reduce inflation and borrowing costs, both of which continue to trend in the wrong direction.

“This was the biggest change election in any of our lifetimes,” Democratic Rep. Greg Casar, chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, told me. “And Americans are demanding that we take on these high prices, root out corruption, and make their lives better.” 

Democrats’ desire to expand the welfare state is similarly understandable. Americans lack many forms of social insurance that are common in wealthier countries, such as truly universal healthcare. 

Finally, the party’s embrace of middle-class tax cuts reflects the US electorate’s growing antipathy for taxation. Indeed, last Tuesday, a historically Democratic electorate voted to restrict or cut taxes in states across the country. 

If Democrats’ goals are understandable, however, they aren’t necessarily coherent. In economic conditions similar to today’s, it probably won’t be possible to create large new social programs, avoid tax hikes on anyone but the rich, and drive down inflation and interest rates. 

For now, the party can skirt these questions; so long as Trump is in the White House, Democrats can simply agitate for an end to the Iran war and tariff relief, while denying full responsibility for the economy. 

To govern effectively when and if they win full control of the government, however, Democrats need to recognize the tension between their economic priorities early on — and try their best to reduce that friction. 

Americans are warming up to Democrats — but not to taxes

On election night, Democratic proponents of a more robust safety net prevailed in battleground races across the country.

But the Democratic Party’s economic reformers face a fundamental challenge: The large welfare states they admire have traditionally been financed by broad-based taxes. In nations like Sweden, Denmark, and Norway, high taxes on the middle class suppress consumer spending, clearing fiscal space for large social programs. This is how social democracies are able to have their comprehensive welfare states and stable prices too. 

But that model does not seem to be politically viable in the United States. To the contrary, America is currently witnessing a vast and growing tax revolt. 

That rebellion has been visible in polling and state-level policymaking for some time. Between 2020 and 2025, the share of Americans who considered their federal tax burden “too high” jumped from 46 percent to 59 percent in Gallup’s surveys. Meanwhile, states slashed taxes by tens of billions of dollars. 

But the 2026 midterm results may be the starkest illustration yet of America’s anti-tax mood. This year’s electorate was America’s most Democratic in more than five decades. We essentially saw what a US election looks like when a large share of the Republican base stays home. It turns out that, once you subtract tens of millions of conservatives from the American electorate, Mississippi, South Carolina, and Texas become blue states.

And yet, even this historically Democratic voting public mostly rejected “tax-and-spend” liberalism at the ballot box.

In North Carolina, voters backed Democratic Senate candidate Roy Cooper — and lower income taxes. In Iowa, they rallied behind Democrat Josh Turek for Senate, while also forbidding the legislature from increasing income taxes without a two-thirds majority. In Florida, an atypically Democratic (if still majority Republican) electorate voted to slash property taxes by nearly $5 billion a year. 

In Illinois and Virginia, most localities shot down referendums on new property or sales taxes; in the Old Dominion’s case, municipalities largely rejected a 1 percent sales tax hike to fund school construction and renovation. Likewise, on a good night for Democrats in the Grand Canyon State, Arizonans voted to cap the sales tax on grocery purchases and constitutionally prohibit the taxation of vehicle miles traveled to fund road maintenance. (Today, road construction is often financed with a tax on gasoline, which ensures that those who use the roads contribute to their maintenance. As more drivers switch to electric vehicles, however, an alternative means of measuring road use has become necessary.)

Finally, in deep blue California, a proposal for a one-time wealth tax on billionaires appears to have failed.

This is not to say that the 2026 electorate took the anti-tax side of every ballot measure. There were many important exceptions to this rule. Nevertheless, the fact remains that an exceptionally Democratic electorate opposed higher taxes in a remarkably wide array of cases.

And this anti-tax mood was not lost on Democrats. Virtually all of the party’s battleground Senate and gubernatorial candidates campaigned on tax cuts. In Texas, Sen.-elect James Talarico promised to deliver a “cost-of-living tax cut for the middle class,” while Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa pledged to pursue the goal of “eliminating residential property taxes.” In Mississippi, Democrats’ unlikeliest new senator, Scott Colom, called for ending all income taxes on teachers and cops. Even Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed, one of the Democrats’ most progressive candidates, who wrote a book on Medicare-for-all, vowed to help freeze property taxes on senior citizens.

Notably, this large, bipartisan tax revolt has emerged at a time when federal tax rates are unusually low; the bottom 80 percent of workers pay much lower federal taxes today than they did three decades ago.

Large welfare states can’t live on the rich alone

As I’ve already suggested, the Democrats’ growing appetite for tax cuts has not dampened their enthusiasm for new public spending. 

The party’s congressional leaders have signaled support for a social welfare agenda at least as ambitious as President Joe Biden’s unpassed Build Back Better Act, which contained $4.73 trillion of new spending (assuming that all its programs were made permanent, as its authors intended). 

Democratic leaders have recently endorsed reversing Trump’s Medicaid and SNAP cuts; restoring enhanced Affordable Care Act subsidies; expanding the child tax credit and earned-income tax credit; adding dental, vision, and hearing coverage to Medicare; establishing universal childcare; capping Medicare enrollees’ out-of-pocket costs; and expanding Medicaid funding for long-term care, among other things. 

Add up the estimated fiscal costs of all these programs and the bill comes out to nearly $5 trillion. Repealing all of Trump’s tariffs, as Democratic leaders have also promised, costs another $1.4 trillion (although, tariff relief has more complicated implications for inflation than other kinds of tax cuts). 

Critically, America is already on track to run an average annual deficit of $2.4 trillion over the coming decade. It is impossible to know with certainty what the macroeconomic conditions of 2029 will be like. But all else equal, a greater than $2 trillion deficit will put upward pressure on interest rates and prices.

For this reason, there’s a good chance that the next Democratic government won’t be able to inject trillions more dollars into the economy without undermining its own goals on inflation and borrowing costs. 

To be sure, Democrats aren’t saying that they will deficit-finance their proposed spending. Rather, the party generally suggests that it will pay for its new programs (and working-class tax cuts) by soaking the wealthy and corporations.

But that approach probably won’t be sufficient to offset the inflationary impact of the party’s full social welfare agenda. For one thing, congressional Democrats’ appetite for new taxes on the rich has its limits. 

In 2021, the House version of Biden’s Build Back Better Act contained only $1.47 trillion worth of taxes on companies and high earners. And that sum proved too much for multiple Democratic senators. The fiscal policy that actually made it into law — the Inflation Reduction Act — included a mere $349 billion in such taxes.

As noted above, if a Democrat wins the presidency in 2028, he or she will probably have larger majorities than Biden ever did. But it seems unlikely that Senate Democrats in 2029 will be eager to raise taxes on the rich by trillions more than their Biden-era counterparts were.

Regardless, there is a more fundamental problem: Taxes on the rich do not suppress inflation as effectively as taxes on the middle class. 

This is because middle-class families spend a higher percentage of their earnings than millionaires and billionaires do. If you take $2,000 out of every middle-class family’s annual income, many will be forced to consume fewer goods and services, which will reduce consumer demand — and thus, inflationary pressure — throughout the economy.

By contrast, even if you reduce Jeff Bezos’s post-tax income by $200,000, he will feel no need to moderate his spending. His savings might marginally decline. But his consumption is liable to stay about the same, since he will still have more money than he could spend in a lifetime. For this reason, taking money from billionaires — and giving it to working-class families — will tend to nudge inflation upward, all else equal.

“Tax increases on those at the absolute top can address wealth or income inequality, but probably won’t do much to manage demand,” Skanda Amarnath, executive director of the economic research organization Employ America, told me. “If you want to fund big new social programs, the most robust version of that has historically involved broad, regressive taxes, which don’t leave you dependent on the support and compliance of rich people.”

If you don’t want to constrain demand, at least increase supply

It’s possible that inflation will cease to be a pressing concern by 2029. Merely ending the Iran war could cool prices significantly. And if the AI buildout falters, that would also reduce our economy’s demand for labor, chips, and electricity (albeit, perhaps by causing a recession). Alternatively, if Anthropic or ChatGPT builds a machine God in the next couple of years — and puts tens of millions of Americans out of work — we might even see deflation.

But it would be imprudent for Democrats to bank on any of these scenarios. In all likelihood, they will need to scale back their ambitions for the welfare state, grow more comfortable with broad-based taxes, or make peace with pushing up inflation and interest rates.

This said, the party can work to reduce the tension between its objectives. Inflation is what happens when demand for goods and services rises faster than their supply. If Democrats are hellbent on pushing up demand through high social spending and low taxes, they should think seriously about how to make the economy more productive and efficient (and thus, able to generate a larger supply of goods and services).

Massachusetts Rep. Jake Auchincloss is among the Democrats focused on this dimension of the “affordability” challenge. 

“Healthcare, home ownership and taxes now consume more than half the middle-class wallet,” Auchincloss told me. “And housing construction, healthcare and government are all very low labor productivity industries.” Therefore, in Auchincloss’s view, delivering on affordability requires increasing the productivity of the construction, medical, and public sectors. 

With respect to housing, this entails new subsidies and regulatory changes that encourage modular construction — the manufacture of new homes in factories, where productivity gains are easier to achieve — along with zoning reforms. 

In healthcare and government, the path to progress is less clear, but Auchincloss believes that a concerted push for greater efficiency — and the thoughtful deployment of AI — can drive down the unit costs of medical treatment and social service provision in the US (at least, if Democrats prove willing to challenge the interests of healthcare providers, many of whom benefit from the existing system’s inefficiencies). 

More straightforwardly, Congress is presently considering legislation that would erode permitting obstacles to new energy infrastructure. That bill is expected to eventually reduce Americans’ electricity costs by expanding the nation’s supply of both green and carbon power. The more committed Democrats are to growing the welfare state and avoiding middle-class tax hikes, the less they can afford to pass up these kinds of opportunities to increase the economy’s productive capacity.

The great perk of powerlessness is the freedom to ignore trade-offs. When crafting campaign rhetoric, a political party can conjure a world where voters will enjoy a robust safety net, large tax cuts, and low prices — so long as the government ends “corporate subsidies,” or cuts aid to Israel, or deports all the undocumented immigrants, or whatever else its base is already eager to do. 

When it’s time to actually govern, however, a party ignores inconvenient truths at its own peril, as Trump’s GOP just ably demonstrated. Democrats must therefore recognize their agenda’s internal contradictions as soon as possible. To execute a coherent economic strategy in 2029 — or whenever they next secure full federal power — the party will need to know what it actually cares about most. 

  •  

Hegseth escapes impeachment — for now

Pete Hegseth, wearing a suit, walks toward a stage past a blue curtain as reporters look on.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth arrives to a news conference at the Pentagon on November 10, 2026. | Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.

Welcome to The Logoff: Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has narrowly escaped impeachment — for now. 

What’s happening? On Tuesday evening, the House voted to refer an impeachment resolution against Hegseth to committee, functionally dooming it. 

The vote, which fell along party lines with the exception of Republican Rep. Thomas Massie, who joined Democrats in voting against the referral, is a victory for Hegseth. The defense secretary’s future at the Pentagon has been under intense speculation since voters resoundingly repudiated President Donald Trump and the war with Iran in last week’s midterm elections. 

Prior to Tuesday’s vote, Hegseth had been facing impeachment as early as tomorrow on eight articles filed against him by Massie on Monday.

Why did Massie want to impeach Hegseth? Broadly speaking, it’s because Hegseth is the public face of the extremely unpopular war with Iran, now in its eighth month, and he appeared vulnerable as even some Republicans voiced their dissatisfaction (though not, evidently, enough dissatisfaction for them to support impeachment). 

Specifically, Massie charged Hegseth with:

  1. Waging war in Iran in violation of the War Powers Resolution (three total charges); 
  2. Disregarding laws intended to minimize civilian casualties; 
  3. Committing extrajudicial killings by carrying out missile strikes on alleged drug boats in the Caribbean and the Pacific; 
  4. Suppressing free speech by trying to retaliate against Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ), a retired Navy captain, for a video by Kelly and other Democratic lawmakers reminding service members that they have a responsibility to refuse illegal orders; 
  5. Kidnapping former Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and his wife earlier this year; and 
  6. Waging an unlawful war in Yemen last year.

What’s the big picture? Hegseth escaped, for now, with the support of Trump and Vice President JD Vance, as well as newly installed White House chief of staff Stephen Miller. 

But he could face another impeachment effort in the new year, with more than enough votes in the incoming Democratic House majority to see it pass (though not enough in the Senate for conviction and removal). 

If that occurs, Hegseth will become the third Cabinet secretary in history to be impeached — and the second in less than three years.

And with that, it’s time to log off…

Vox’s Unexplainable podcast sat down with author Emily St. John Mandel (of Station Eleven fame) to talk about how she deploys science in her fiction. It’s a great conversation, and you can listen to it here. 

Plus, a quick programming note: I’ll be off tomorrow for Veterans Day! One of my excellent colleagues will be standing in here, and I’ll be back Thursday. Have a great evening!

  •  

What to know about the Republican-led effort to impeach Pete Hegseth

Rep. Thomas Massie speaks from behind a podium with a sign reading “IMPEACH HEGSETH”; behind him, the dome of the US Capitol is visible.
Rep. Thomas Massie (R-KY) speaks during a press conference on articles of impeachment against Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, outside the US Capitol in Washington, DC, on November 9, 2026. | Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth may be on track to become just the third Cabinet member in history to be impeached, after Republican Rep. Thomas Massie introduced eight articles of impeachment against him on Monday. 

Some articles of impeachment, which accuse Hegseth of high crimes and misdemeanors, focus on Hegseth’s conduct during the Iran war, including waging war without congressional authorization. Others accuse Hegseth of carrying out unlawful military strikes against boats carrying alleged drug traffickers in the Caribbean and the Pacific, suppressing free speech, kidnapping former Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro, and waging unlawful war in Yemen. 

The articles are poised to move quickly in the House, with a procedural vote set for Tuesday evening and impeachment votes following as soon as Wednesday. Republicans still hold a slim House majority until January following last week’s Democratic tsunami in the midterm elections — but it’s possible that enough of them could join with Massie and House Democrats to impeach Hegseth anyway. 

Hegseth, so far, has been defiant. On Tuesday, he defended his tenure atop the Pentagon in a rare press conference, calling the impeachment effort a “political spectacle, a personal manifesto driven by ego and resentment.” 

Following the press conference, President Donald Trump posted online that Hegseth deserves an “A PLUS PLUS PLUS” for defending himself.

To figure out what awaits for Hegseth and what it could mean for the Iran war, Today, Explained co-host Sean Rameswaram spoke with the Washington Post’s Dan Lamothe about the impeachment effort, how the Pentagon is feeling after eight months of the Iran war, and whether there’s an off-ramp in sight.

Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.

What are the vibes in the Pentagon in Washington, DC? Did the Iran war lose Republicans these midterms?

I don’t think it is the only deciding factor, but I think it is a significant factor in two ways. 

One, there is a group of Republicans who voted for Donald Trump because he said he would not get us into any more protracted wars. The Iran war is eight months and counting. There seems to be no easy off-ramps even now. We’re not really fully at war. We’re certainly not at peace. 

And as a result, the second issue — affordability, cost of living — a significant deciding factor in that is the price of gasoline, which then affects the price of groceries and everything else. So yes, there is a direct line between the war and a lot of the issues that were a factor.

A lot of Democrats have been saying that they want to impeach Pete Hegseth if they take control. Now they will. Future [House] Speaker Hakeem Jeffries came out this weekend and said that he’s into the idea. Remind us, why Hegseth? 

I think there’s a couple of things going on. One, you’re likely to see an impeachment vote this week: the Rep. Thomas Massie-led effort to impeach.

There are a lot of angry Democrats, obviously, but there are a number of Republicans likely to cross the aisle on this and it may very well pass the House. I don’t know if it’s going to pass the Senate. That seems like a much bigger leap. 

Either way, you’ve got an on-the-record rebuke, and you also have a forcing function to get every single member either on the record voting for it or on the record that they avoided voting for it. So that’s going to be a messy situation.

What are the actual grounds for impeachment of Hegseth?

On the Iran issue, it’s a little more complicated because you can think the policy of going into the war with Iran is problematic, detrimental to the national security of the country based on the amount of munitions we’re using, a variety of things. There’s not necessarily anything straight-up illegal in that. 

Where I think they’re going to dig in is, they’re going to say that Iran went [on] longer than you’re allowed without having any kind of authorization. 

Hegseth appears to be kicking off some sort of PR campaign in defense of his tenure. Is that just for the president or is that for Congress as well?

I think it’s primarily for the president. I do think there is a secondary audience of members on the Hill — Republicans on the Hill in particular — who are not sure how to handle this going forward. But I think foremost, this was meant for the president. It was very Trump-esque in terms of its feel. It had a defiance to it. It had a grievance in it and it had the feel of, they’re coming after me and I’m not going anywhere.

I initially was like, this feels like that scene in Wolf of Wall Street where Leonardo DiCaprio says, “I’m not leaving.”

And then within a day — I guess I should have seen it coming — the White House put out a video with a series of clips in it and sure enough, that was one of the clips. So that’s the vibe. 

Even last week, when we saw Susie Wiles get pushed out at the White House as President Trump’s [new] chief of staff — Stephen Miller is much closer with Hegseth and you saw messaging from both sides, both the Pentagon and the White House, making the point that Hegseth continues to enjoy the support of both Stephen Miller and Donald Trump.

And I think we’re all left wondering, does that continue into the new year with Democratic majorities in both chambers of the Congress at that point?

How does it feel inside the Pentagon right now? What is the state of the war at this point?

I think there’s exhaustion. 

Not unlike some of the other earlier wars that we’ve covered, you go in with good intentions, you go in with a goal, there’s markers up on the board, there’s a campaign plan. And then at some point when it starts to go wrong, you can explain away some of the earlier problems. But the challenge is over time, when you say, “Hey, we won back in April,” and yet you still have vessels getting hit all the time. 

The Strait of Hormuz, they say it’s open. There are still vessels getting through, but it’s under duress. There’s still missile fire coming at a lot of vessels. This is not easy. This is not going normally. Everything is a drain. 

There has been an increasing finger-pointing within the government, within the military where people say, “Hey, Hegseth is a participant in this. He’s a player in this.” There is at least a discussion of whether or not the president got the information he should have got, whether or not there was some gilding of the lily there in terms of what the US military could effectively do.

And I think there are military officers there who are caught in the middle. Do you gussy it up on the front end or leave out some of the information that’s a little difficult for the president to digest in the first weeks of the war? And is that a factor on where we are now?

Is anyone seriously talking about just ending this very unpopular quagmire situation of a war we’ve got in Iran?

Certainly people are talking about it. And I think how you get there is the challenge in it. I think when you’re looking at things like whether or not to strike again, are we talking one big night, a couple of days? 

Most of the people I’m talking to who are tracking this issue that are still in government say they can’t do this for weeks on end. So this is not going to be a return to what we saw in March and April. 

There are people telling the president, “Quit now, declare victory and get out.” There are people telling the president, “Do these handful of things, then declare victory and get out.” And there are other people that say, “Keep going.”

Who wins that argument? I think it remains to be seen. And that’s one of the reasons that you had the election landslide you had, because now you’re going to have pressure from the Congress in a way you simply have not for the last two years.

  •  

Van Hollen Throws His Hat in the Ring

Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) entered the race for Senate majority leader Thursday night, officially challenging current Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) for the position.

Van Hollen said he had been getting an overwhelming number of calls to run for the position. Earlier this week, he had left the door open for a run, saying he was in “listening mode”

In a statement responding to Van Hollen’s bid, Schumer said he welcomes any discussion about the future of the caucus but that he believes he has the votes to continue serving as Democratic leader.

Follow along with us as we navigate the lame-duck session:

  •  

Rahm Emanuel knows how congressional Democrats can keep winning

Rahm Emanuel, wearing a navy suit with a white shirt, holds a microphone in his right hand and gestures toward the camera with his left hand outstretched.
Former Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel speaks at the Obama Presidential Center in Chicago, Illinois, on October 8, 2026. | Kamil Krzaczynski/AFP via Getty Images

Democrats had a better night than anyone expected on Tuesday, winning sweeping majorities in both the House and the Senate as voters turned away from President Donald Trump and the Republican Party. Now, they have to figure out how to govern and contend with two more years of Trump’s presidency — and gear up to hold onto their new majorities in 2028.

It’s a familiar situation for the party: Two decades ago, voters unhappy with President George W. Bush and the Iraq War propelled Democrats to congressional majorities in the 2006 midterms. Two years later, President Barack Obama won his first term and Democrats won even more seats in the House and Senate.

Rahm Emanuel — a former US ambassador to Japan, Chicago mayor, White House chief of staff, and member of Congress — was there to witness it. He led the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee in 2006 when it led the charge for a Democratic House majority, and helped steer that majority from 2007 to 2009 as Democratic caucus chair.

On Wednesday, he spoke with Today, Explained co-host Sean Rameswaram about how Democrats should think about their midterms success, what they should — and shouldn’t — do with their new power in 2027, and what all of that means for 2028.

Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.

You’ve been here before personally, way back in 2006. It was a different Congress, a different president, certainly a different time. But can you tell people who don’t remember what position you were in back then?

In 2006, I was chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee and led the effort to take back the House. Nancy Pelosi became speaker and I became caucus chair. I also helped in the 2008 cycle, where we added another 20 seats. So Democrats were in around 254 seats when President Obama put his left hand on the Bible.

And to put a finer point on it, George W. Bush is president in 2006. You guys win control of the House and Senate, and then use that control to notch another win in 2008. What did you do? What was the play?

Let’s pull back a little, take a wider lens. One, this is a repudiation of the Republicans, not a vindication of the Democrats. I always thought that we were going to have a blue wave. This is a tsunami. These are Watergate numbers. But what we do in 2027 will determine whether we have won.

The voters voted for change, not a Democratic version of more of the same. You have a broad-based coalition where non-MAGA Republicans and independents are giving the Democrats a second look. Solidify this as a working coalition. Make the election transformational, not transactional. Power-wash all of Washington, all three branches. Ban stock trading, ban prediction market participation, mandatory blind trust, mandatory term limits and/or retirement age.

And then what I call the Jared Kushner rule. No foreign money while in government and no foreign money two years after. No Saudi and Qatari blind trust for you. Do the hearings, but produce a piece of legislation that acts on the hearings.

Second, everything’s going up in price. What hasn’t? The minimum wage. The last time it went up, Nancy Pelosi was speaker. Pass a minimum wage, $20 by 2030.

Third, repeal all these tariffs that are driving prices up. Everything I just told you, you’ll get bipartisan votes. And it puts Trump in a position: You sign it, we win; you veto it, we win.

There’s obviously this tension between “legislate” and “investigate” right now. Based on last night, people want “legislate.” But a lot of the base wants justice. They want [Defense Secretary Pete] Hegseth out.

They want their pound of flesh.

Tell me how you think Democrats should balance the two.

It’s not an either/or. You should do the investigations. Where is the Venezuela oil money? Where is Jared Kushner’s secret account with the Qatari money and the Saudi money? And what was he doing for them for that price?

I’m all for that, but that’s not change. That’s the predicate. I’m against impeachment because it’s one person and you won’t get it done. All three branches need cleaning, not just one man. What about his Cabinet? Clean it all up.

The job of the Democrats is to roll up your sleeves and get to work. Some Democrats may think that this is a vindication vote. I think it’s a repudiation vote and we will earn the victory in 2027 by producing change.

Earn that trust, solidify that winning coalition that went from Texas to Maine. Solidify it. And I think if you listened to [House Democratic leader] Hakeem Jeffries last night, if you listened to [Senate Democratic leader] Chuck Schumer, they understand that the test is about to come. It isn’t behind us, it’s in front of us.

Hakeem Jeffries feels a little unknowable sometimes. What do you think of him as speaker of the House?

Well, it’s unfair because I’m close to him.

So tell us what we don’t know about him.

Pretty much all our conversations first start with what? Checking in on each other’s families. Now, we rush through it so we get to politics, but he takes his family seriously and his role as a parent very seriously.

But now he’s very important to the country.

I respect him for that. He’s also very observant and serious about his faith because I’ve gotten a number of texts back, “I can’t talk, I’m in service.” So I said, “Put the phone down, listen to the sermon, you’re going to need it.”

The other thing is that he’s a consensus builder, but he does know what he wants to get done.

He’s a consensus builder in a time where the Democratic tent feels like it’s never been bigger. Karl Rove’s in the tent now. How do you manage that tent?

I used to say to Speaker Pelosi — when I was caucus chair and we were counting votes and trying to move X or Y — that Rep. Mo Udall used to have a great joke: “What is the difference between a cactus and a caucus? In a cactus, the pricks are on the outside.”

With the numbers Hakeem will have, nobody can hold him hostage. When you’re at 221, everybody’s a kingmaker and they’re going to sit there and hold you hostage. When you’re at 250, Hakeem has the liberty to say, “When you walk out of here, make sure the door doesn’t hit you.”

You told Democrats that they should go after Republicans in 2028. And there are people who hear you say that and they go, “Absolutely.” And there are people who hear you say that, they want to reach through their TV screens and choke you because they’re hearing this 2024 “Let’s go campaign with Liz Cheney” mindset that did not work.

This is not a hypothetical. Go tell Kansas Sen. Adam Hamilton, who’s a former Republican. Neil Bush, who gave everybody a permission slip in Texas, said, “I’m voting for Talarico.”

That’s an opening. What Kamala Harris did — they ran around talking about democracy. I’m talking about people’s pocketbooks. Having helped Sen. Hamilton, having helped Nancy Lacore, the [admiral] who just won in Charleston, South Carolina. Those are people that built a winning coalition.

The fact is, to flip red to blue, you had to get Republican votes and independents. If you want to keep going and keep winning and solidifying this coalition, you have to know who was part of it. If you think you’re going to go into 2028 just on the backs of Democrats, God bless you. Swing voters in swing states swing presidential elections.

I’ll give you an example. This will get me yelled at. President [Joe] Biden made a pledge in 2020 to govern and bring America together. He spent a good portion of his presidency bringing the party together, not the nation. And I think it cost him politically.

Who do you like as a candidate in 2028? And you can’t pick yourself.

I’m not going to do that. I’m not going to answer that. Because here’s the good news for you. In 2024, let’s be honest, the party didn’t have a choice. We were told who our nominee is.

In 2028, you’re going to have Baskin-Robbins — 31 flavors. And if I decide to do this, you’re looking at Rocky Road.

  •  

Let the Shift Begin

Democrats flipped control of both the Senate and House on Tuesday. Though we’re still waiting on some results from places like Alaska and Mississippi, losses there wouldn’t take much away from the very comfortable margins Dems secured in both chambers until the end of President Donald Trump’s term.

Now comes major shifts in Congress.

Besides the obvious majority-minority flip, we’re already seeing dynamic shifts in caucus leaderships. Outgoing House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA) announced he would not be running for Minority Leader in a private call `Wednesday. That job will be up for grabs.

There will, of course, be a new speaker. Likely Hakeem Jeffries, who would make history by becoming the first Black Speaker of the House.

Follow along with us as we enter into GOP’s last chance for passing anything for the foreseeable future — the lame duck session — and some possible internal races for majority and minority leadership positions in both chambers.

  •  

What the midterms mean for 2028

United States senator-elect El-Sayed in front of the American flag
US Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed greets supporters during a midterm election night watch party on November 4, 2026, in Detroit. | Salwan Georges/Getty Images

Welcome to The Midterms, Actually. Every week I’ll be writing about two things: one big idea or trend I see forming, and one thing I’m hearing from a voice on the ground. Let’s get into it.

One big idea

Tuesday night, in a midterm election for the ages, Democrats notched sweeping victories across the country. They took back both chambers of Congress, and possibly broke the spirit of a Republican Party that has been firmly in President Donald Trump’s grip for the last decade.

Early race calls in Georgia and North Carolina. Finally ousting Sen. Susan Collins in Maine. Historic wins in Texas and Iowa. Surprise wins in Kansas, South Carolina, and (maybe) Mississippi?

This was a bloodbath. A tsunami, not a wave. And it was a vindication for pollsters who had been flagging signs of Republican underperformance all year.

Most importantly, it was the clearest message the American public could send to Trump’s administration: This president, his priorities, and his war of choice in Iran are out of step with public opinion. Trump wasn’t on the ballot, but he repeatedly told people to vote like he was. Americans accepted the challenge and largely retired the GOP candidates functioning as his proxy.

Thinking about our reporting on America, Actually, where we’ve been charting the path to America’s post-Trump future one episode at a time, here are five lessons I’m taking from the results. They apply to the coming legislative fights in Congress and to the 2028 presidential primary.

1. It really was a populist backlash

Throughout the year, candidates from James Talarico to Abdul El-Sayed said this election wasn’t about right versus left, but top versus bottom. The results bore that out.

For two years, Republicans and their allies claimed Trump’s 2024 coalition was a firm realignment, a fundamental break from Democrats by working-class voters. Fast-forward to this week: The New York Times’ voter analysis shows every big demographic moved toward Democrats, including men (17-point swing, Latino voters (28-point swing), and Asian voters (17-point swing).

Two things drove this. First, Trump flopped, breaking his promises to lower prices and avoid foreign conflicts, among other things. Second, Democrats refocused their message, especially after Zohran Mamdani’s 2025 mayoral win in New York City, on affordability and tangible economic concerns. That brought back voters they lost in 2024, and reinforced the multiracial coalition they needed to overcome Republican advantages: a GOP-leaning Senate map, heavily gerrymandered districts, and a massive spending edge driven by big donors.

None of it mattered.

2. Issues that won: Affordability, anti-corruption, anti-data centers

So how did Democrats drive the bottom-versus-top message? Universally, with affordability, and by highlighting the choices Republicans made to follow Trump into the political abyss. Tariffs were the original sin. The Iran war made things worse.

When we were at a Speedway in battleground state Pennsylvania, even Trump voters were frustrated with the price of gas. Everyone, and I mean everyone, could draw the line between the war in Iran and the cost at the pump. When Pennsylvania voters are talking about the Strait of Hormuz, that’s a problem. It’s also a clear sign the GOP plan to blame the 2026 economy on former President Joe Biden wasn’t working.

Here’s what one voter said: “I blame the president because he indicated to us he’s gonna drop all these costs. I know it can’t happen overnight, but when is it gonna happen?… It’s outrageous.”

Two other issues carried the populist mood:

Corruption

Democrats across the country began hammering Trump on corruption earlier this year, and there’s real evidence the message was potent. We heard it in Virginia, and candidates like Jon Ossoff and Talarico made it their calling card. It wasn’t just that Trump was for sale. It was that he and his family were profiting from big business while things got more unaffordable for you.

Data centers

The third ingredient in this populist stew. Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa in Texas, Senate candidate Annie Andrews in South Carolina, and House candidate Will Lawrence in Michigan made a data center moratorium central to their campaigns. All three won. Data center moratoriums went an astounding 43-1 when put directly in front of voters, a sign of just how unpopular the issue has become.

And like affordability and corruption, the data center message was never about just one thing. Voters were mad about the secretive process. Anxious about what artificial intelligence means for the future of work. And particularly enraged that big technology seemed to be profiting at their expense.

All of that came out at the polls.

3. Issues that lost: The GOP culture war

The GOP had a huge spending advantage this cycle, and so much of that money went into ads painting Democrats as extreme, particularly on social and cultural issues. “Talafreako” in Texas, who they portrayed as an effeminate vegan. The Hasan Piker obsession in Michigan and the openly anti-Muslim and bigoted ads and rhetoric there and in places like Minnesota as well. And repeated hammering of a tactic that worked for Trump in 2024: stoking panic about transgender rights or “biological males” in women’s sports.

It flopped in 2026, and there’s no way around it. The spending spree didn’t just fail to pan out; they seem to have lit their money on fire, given how roundly Americans rejected the pitch. To the electorate, the most offensive thing wasn’t progressive overreach or nonbinary pronouns. It was Trump’s attacks on diversity and inclusion, and his party’s refusal to align its priorities with those of everyday Americans.

The GOP also had a timing problem: They ran a 2024 playbook against a 2026 Democratic Party that was much better positioned to beat back the caricature of progressive zealots.

  • Beau Bayh in Indiana and El-Sayed in Michigan made direct appeals to the “bro” vote with weightlifting videos.
  • Talarico in Texas and Adam Hamilton in Kansas, both religious liberals, put faith at the center of their campaigns.

These weren’t coastal elites. They were tailored to the district and the state. They spoke to the everyday person, not the Ford Foundation. And in doing so, they wrote a playbook against GOP attacks.

4. Standout demographics: Latino and rural voters

Two groups stood out to me: Trump’s collapse with Latino voters, and Democratic gains with rural voters.

Latino voters

The numbers are staggering. The Times estimates Hispanic voters were D+39, a 28-point swing leftward from 2024. Results in Texas, Nevada, and Arizona, and even the tightness in Florida, show the impact of Trump’s collapse with the all-important swing demographic. As we reported this summer, two issues drove Latino voters away from Republicans: the administration’s credibility collapse on the economy, and a backlash to the interior push for deportations.

Here’s what Stephanie Valencia of Equis Research said: “It’s the economy, it’s the war, and it’s immigration. It’s those three things.”

Rural voters

When we covered the stakes in state legislature races, and specifically Democratic efforts to win trifectas (governor plus both chambers) in states like Wisconsin and Nevada, rural voters were front and center. 

Democrats pulled off the trifecta in Wisconsin: Gov.-elect David Crowley, plus a flipped Senate and Assembly, the first Democratic trifecta there in 16 years. By early tallies, they also won trifectas in Michigan, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, and Nevada.

It reminds me of what Francesca Hong told me when we met her on her tour of rural Wisconsin a few months ago: The midterm stakes weren’t just federal but state-level. Democrats won both.

5. 2028 winners and losers

Caveats apply: We should pump the brakes on extrapolating too much from the 2026 midterms to the 2028 presidential primary. But I think there are some things we do know.

Winner: Non-Vance Republicans

If you’re Ron DeSantis, Marco Rubio, Ted Cruz, or another Republican with credentials in Trump’s orbit who has also kept some distance, last night’s result helps make your case. Trump dragged the party down in Texas, South Carolina, and Ohio, where he and Vance defended Vivek Ramaswamy’s deplorable ad featuring his opponent’s estranged mother.

Going forward, Vance has to walk a tough line between acknowledging the country’s Trump distaste and not angering the president he serves under. His initial reaction to the midterm losses was to blame the Iran war first and foremost, notably without saying whether it was the wrong decision by his boss. But he’s spent the last two years all in on Trump mimicry, even defending the ICE shootings in Minnesota earlier this year. Is that a winning message anywhere? I’m not so sure.

Winner: Fresh faces on the Democratic side

Whether moderate or progressive, Democrats embraced younger candidates with new messages and bold ideas that match the scope of voters’ problems. That’s bad news for candidates who represent a specter of the past, mainly former Vice President Kamala Harris, who has courted speculation about another run through a series of media interviews.

There is no way to read these results as a desire to relitigate the same fights of 2020 or 2024. It’s a call to write a new story entirely. 

One thing I’m hearing

In an election night full of surprises, perhaps the biggest of them all was in Mississippi, where Democratic Senate candidate Scott Colom is poised to possibly win his race against Republican Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith, with the two separated by just dozens of votes with thousands more left to count as of this writing. We reached out to Mississippi Today reporter Michael Goldberg, fresh off covering a press conference with Colom on Wednesday, to walk us through what happened. 

Mississippi barely seemed to be on the national radar until the final weeks. What signs did you see in your reporting that this result was possible?

Colom began to pick up steam rapidly as the election entered its closing weeks, drawing an infusion of resources from national Democrats and a brigade of Democratic stars filing into Mississippi for campaign events. But while the national attention ramped up in the election’s home stretch, Colom ran a tireless campaign from the beginning, crisscrossing the state for in-person events and trying to run a digitally savvy campaign that captured attention online. Also, former Democratic gubernatorial candidate Brandon Pressley came within 4 points of winning the 2023 governor’s race, and many local Democrats have been urging the national party to take Mississippi seriously ever since. 

How big a factor were the Callais decision and voting rights? How did those issues come up in your conversations with voters?

Colom campaigned with US Rep. Bennie Thompson, the lone Democrat and lone Black member of Mississippi’s congressional delegation, who would be a likely target of a future redistricting push by the Republican-controlled state legislature. Colom has called the Callais decision “a threat to our democracy” the country hasn’t seen in decades. This fall, voters packed public hearings on redistricting and expressed their anger and dismay. 

What is Scott Colom like on the campaign trail? What was most distinctive about his campaign compared with other Mississippi Democrats?

Colom campaigned hard. He traversed the state from end to end and, in the election’s homestretch, engaged in a near-nonstop media blitz aimed at galvanizing any voters tuned into traditional cable news shows or following the race on social media. In viral ads, he mocked Hyde-Smith for suggesting voters upset over the rising price of beef should “pick another protein” and riffed off the Oscar-winning movie Sinners, which is set in Mississippi.

On the ground, Colom mobilized the Democratic base through energetic rallies and appearances with high-profile national Democrats. He also tried to persuade skeptical Republicans. In one 24-hour span just over a week before Election Day, Colom roamed the line outside a Trump rally in northeast Mississippi, spoke to some of the president’s supporters, then headed to the other end of the state for a rally with former US Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.  

Mississippi is often overlooked in national politics because it’s considered so reliably Republican. What’s the biggest thing people outside the state misunderstand or don’t know?

Many this morning have argued that regardless of whether Colom wins narrowly or loses narrowly, his campaign showed that with investment from the national party and the right candidate, Mississippi Democrats have a fighting chance of winning statewide. 

  •  

How Abdul El-Sayed won the Michigan Senate race

Abdul El-Sayed
Abdul El-Sayed during a midterm election night watch party on November 4, 2026, in Detroit. | Salwan Georges/Getty Images

When Abdul El-Sayed narrowly won the Democratic nomination for an open Senate seat in Michigan back in August, it teed up the first true swing-state test for the party’s left faction, which had largely been confined to representing progressive enclaves in the Trump era.

They just passed that test. El-Sayed defeated GOP nominee Mike Rogers, and he’ll be the newest US senator from Michigan in January. 

His win is historic; El-Sayed will be the first Muslim to serve in the Senate. It also may be just the start: His charisma and ability to go viral have already made him a political star; some of his fans are already anticipating a future presidential run.

Yet his path to this point was far from easy. El-Sayed battled the Democratic establishment-backed US Rep. Haley Stevens in one of the most intense and bitter Democratic primaries in the country, and had to beat back an astonishing $30 million in AIPAC spending on Stevens’s behalf.

Then, in the general election, El-Sayed faced Islamophobic attacks from Republicans like President Donald Trump, who called him a “jihadist Muslim Brotherhood member” who would create “a nightmare of violence and terror” in the US. 

El-Sayed also maintained tense relations with some pro-Israel Democrats, who argued he was slow to criticize antisemitic rhetoric from his own supporters. These tensions came to a boiling point just two days before the election, when his primary rival Stevens stunned the political world by endorsing Rogers, saying El-Sayed hadn’t done enough to condemn an ad by a super PAC not affiliated with his campaign that had been criticized as antisemitic.

Other Jewish Democrats, however, supported and defended El-Sayed — including Sen. Bernie Sanders, a longtime supporter of his.

Indeed, El-Sayed’s political platform can be said to epitomize the next generation of the Sanders wing of the Democratic Party. Domestically, he attacks billionaire and corporate influence, backs sweeping social welfare spending like Medicare-for-all, and wants to abolish ICE. And abroad, El-Sayed supports a full arms embargo on Israel.

Platforms like El-Sayed’s had already triumphed in several deep blue states and cities. But Michigan is a classic swing state that voted for Trump in two of the past three presidential elections. So El-Sayed’s nomination tested whether a progressive as bold as he could actually win in this environment amid fears from many Democrats — exacerbated by Trump’s 2024 win — that the party urgently needed to move in the opposite direction. And despite the last-minute twist with Stevens endorsing his opponent, El-Sayed did win.

He was, of course, helped by a nationwide blue wave that benefited Democrats across the country. Critics argued that, considering that wave, El-Sayed’s performance was not all that impressive, with his winning margin likely falling short of other candidates in (until now) redder territory.

But whatever the margin, a win is a win, and El-Sayed is now headed to the Senate as one of the most high-profile and influential figures in movement politics.

How El-Sayed won

El-Sayed’s victory has been a long time coming. A Rhodes scholar, epidemiology professor, and public health administrator, he first ran for office in the 2018 cycle, in the Democratic primary for Michigan governor. He ran as a champion of Medicare-for-all, and earned the support of Sanders and new Democratic star US Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.

He lost that primary campaign to Gretchen Whitmer, who went on to win two terms as governor.  But in the years after that campaign, El-Sayed continued to be an influential voice on the left, hosting podcasts and serving as health director of Wayne County (the Michigan county that includes Detroit).

After the Gaza war broke out, El-Sayed became deeply disillusioned with the Biden administration’s support for Israel, accusing Benjamin Netanyahu’s government of perpetrating a genocide. He voted “uncommitted” in the 2024 Democratic presidential primary in Michigan, saying he wanted to send a message to Biden that his vote was in jeopardy for the fall. (El-Sayed ended up endorsing Kamala Harris shortly after Biden quit his reelection campaign.)

But when two-term Sen. Gary Peters (D-MI) unexpectedly announced that he wouldn’t run for reelection in January, El-Sayed decided to throw his hat into the open seat race to succeed him. A three-way contest between El-Sayed, Stevens, and state Sen. Mallory McMorrow took shape; El-Sayed was the candidate favored by the left, Stevens was backed by the Democratic establishment, and McMorrow tried unsuccessfully to find a middle ground between them.

El-Sayed’s candidacy quickly gained nationwide attention as one of several primaries in which left insurgents were battling establishment favorites, emphasizing their criticisms of Israel, hostility to big money corporate donors, and support of Medicare-for-all. Indeed, once Graham Platner quit Maine’s Senate race in July, El-Sayed arguably became the highest-profile left candidate in the country.

In part, that was because AIPAC was showering those tens of millions of dollars on his race. The money was intended to squelch El-Sayed’s candidacy and to back Stevens — a staunch supporter of Israel in the House. But the spending may have backfired by seeming to confirm El-Sayed’s narrative that big money was arrayed against him. 

The primary ended up being a squeaker, with El-Sayed beating Stevens by less than 1 percentage point. In the general election, however, he won the backing of top Democrats like the party’s Senate leader, Chuck Schumer, as well as Harris and former President Barack Obama.

There were, however, continuing tensions with Stevens, who had initially endorsed El-Sayed after the primary, but later voiced concerns that he wasn’t doing enough to denounce anti-Semitism from his supporters — and threw her support to Rogers.

But, up against Rogers — a former member of Congress and onetime FBI agent who narrowly lost a race for Michigan’s other US Senate seat in 2024, and who had staunchly defended Trump until belatedly seeking some distance in the campaign’s final weeks — El-Sayed emerged triumphant, boosted by the nationwide Democratic wave.

Beyond making El-Sayed the first Muslim US senator, his victory is significant for another reason: Sanders, the Senate’s left champion, is 85 years old. Now, when it comes time for him to pass the torch to the next generation, he’ll have at least one longtime ally ready to take it.

  •  

Three things that finally brought down Susan Collins

Susan Collins, left, and Troy Jackson, right, stand at podiums on a stage, with a blue backdrop.
Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME) and Democratic candidate for Senate Troy Jackson are seen during their debate in Bangor, Maine, on October 15, 2026. | Charly Triballeau/AFP via Getty Images

Democrats won a critical US Senate seat on Tuesday, as Maine Republican Sen. Susan Collins conceded her long-held seat to Democratic challenger Troy Jackson just after midnight. 

Collins, who has been serving for nearly 30 years, has for years been able to beat back rivals in her increasingly blue state, where residents valued her ability to bring home federal funds and buck her Republican Party when it seemed to count. Her ability to win even against unfavorable conditions has earned her the reputation of being something of a “unicorn” in national politics.

This year, however, she could not escape the long shadow President Donald Trump cast over her state. Collins was the only Republican senator up for reelection in a state Trump lost in 2024, and a late October poll from Marist found just 42 percent of likely Maine voters approved of the president’s performance, while 58 percent disapproved. A Fox News poll from August found that more than half of Mainers felt Collins voted with Trump too often.

While Collins did have some notable breaks with Trump — including voting to convict him after January 6 and to stop his Canadian tariffs — she lacked good answers on Mainers’ rising costs.

In the Marist poll, 46 percent of likely Maine voters said their family finances had gotten worse over the past year. The cost of living was also the top issue for Mainers in the final Times/Siena poll before the election, released this week, with 51 percent of voters trusting Jackson on it, compared with 44 percent for Collins. 

Collins’s slide could also be seen in the polls over the past few months. The Times/Siena survey had her up 49 to 46 percent in September, with Jackson leading in the latest one, 51 to 45. Collins’s favorability also dropped 3 points in that time.

Two other issues shaped the race in Maine.

One was abortion. While nationally reproductive rights played a much lower-profile role compared to 2024 and the 2022 midterms, with candidates running far fewer ads on the subject, Maine was a notable exception. As Vox reported in September, abortion rights was the second biggest focus of campaign ads in the state, after Trump and healthcare. Planned Parenthood made its biggest ad buy of the 2026 cycle there against Collins, and a super PAC aligned with Senate Democrats spent 41 percent of its TV, streaming, and digital money in Maine on abortion-related ads.

The logic was that it was the first time Collins would face voters since the overturning of Roe v. Wade, and despite identifying as pro-choice, her Senate vote was pivotal in confirming Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court. A spokesperson for Planned Parenthood Votes told me in September that abortion is “the number one negative in Maine voters’ mind,” even as fewer than half a percent of Mainers would call it their top issue. It didn’t help that over the summer, Collins doubled down on her vote for Kavanaugh, saying she did not regret it.

Throughout the campaign, Democrats made a point of emphasizing that Collins continued to confirm anti-abortion judges, as recently as this fall. While historically Maine voters have given Collins a pass on certain votes because she’s been skilled at bringing home federal dollars, advocates bet that they could convince some voters that Collins’s Kavanaugh vote revealed something important about her character and trustworthiness. One of Planned Parenthood’s ads featured a woman who voted for Collins pledging to “not make the same mistake twice.” 

The second major issue to shape the race was healthcare costs, one of the biggest issues facing Republicans nationally this cycle. Some Republicans warned last year that their party would face backlash in the midterms for gutting Medicaid, with even Trump warning his party to avoid going “too crazy” on cost-cutting.

Republicans are facing blowback for the party’s vote last year to gut Medicaid by roughly $1 trillion over the next decade, a move that the Congressional Budget Office estimates will leave more than 7 million Americans without health insurance by 2034. Though Collins ultimately voted against the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, she helped the package get to the Senate floor. When defending herself against attacks that she shared responsibility for Medicaid’s gutting, she pointed to her advocacy for including in OBBBA a new $50 billion rural healthcare fund. But critics said that the new fund does not offset the Medicaid cuts, which are estimated to strip $137 billion from rural healthcare systems. 

“Senator Collins is like an arsonist who helped set the fire, and then she wants credit for bringing a cup of water to put it out,” Troy Jackson said in their October debate. 

And it’s not just Mainers on Medicaid who are worried about healthcare costs. Employer healthcare plans are expected to rise next year by more than 8 percent, and a KFF annual employer survey found the average American worker is paying more than $600 more toward a family plan this year than in 2025. An AARP Maine poll from October found that 80 percent of voters age 50 and older said the cost of healthcare would factor into their vote. Jackson led by 3 percentage points among all voters in that survey, though Collins was ahead by 9 points among those 50 and older.

  •  

A massive blue wave just hit America. Here’s what it could bring next.

A crowd of excited people cheering.
Supporters of James Talarico react to early election results during a midterm election night watch party at Long Center for the Performing Arts in Austin, Texas, on November 3, 2026. | Ronaldo Schemidt/AFP via Getty Images

Voters just ushered the United States into the post-Trump era.

The ballots are still being counted, and key races are still being called, but here’s the short version of the midterm election: It’s a blue tsunami.

Democrats looked set to take full control of Congress; they flipped crucial seats and won state-level offices where they’d barely been expected to compete. If anything, their performance was significantly stronger than expected — even after weeks of polls showing the party surging, and President Donald Trump’s approval cratering, and mounting outrage over gas prices, the war in Iran, healthcare, and corruption. It’s quite possible this is the biggest midterm wave since Watergate, and it appears likely to send large Democratic majorities to Congress.

What happens now? The historic shift that voters signaled Tuesday goes beyond just the raw numbers. Simply put, Americans are waking up in a different country today — one in which voters have decisively repudiated Trump’s party and opened up a new era of American politics.

Democrats won back groups they lost in 2024, like Latino voters, and made previously unheard-of incursions into MAGA territory, including rural and working-class white communities. Democrats even won the governorship of Texas — Texas!

One potential takeaway is that a new version of a Democratic coalition could be emerging. A more realistic way to see this, though, might be as the latest and loudest affirmation that the politics of the post-Trump era remain highly unsettled, with no voting group or state to be taken for granted by either party. 

The incoming class of leaders is a diverse portrait of America in the 21st century, and a picture of the kind of nation that Trump has explicitly been trying to roll back. Georgia elected the nation’s first Black woman governor; New Hampshire will send the first openly gay man to the Senate; and (as of this writing) the would-be first Muslim senator was leading in Michigan. In Kansas, a megachurch pastor won evangelical voters to the Democratic ticket, sending the state’s first non-Republican to the Senate in nearly a century. In an election where the closing Republican arguments often relied on tribal fears around religion, country of origin, masculinity, and gender identity, the results were a loud rebuke to those impulses. 

Taken together, the night was also, as election analyst Sean Trende put it, “a complete collapse of the Republican coalition.” Democrats will now have a chance to carry out the mandate they’ve been handed — on affordability, corruption, and foreign policy — and convince voters they can still be trusted with greater power in 2028 and beyond. How Trump responds, and the Republicans who must now balance their loyalty to a vengeful 80-year-old lame duck against a partywide emergency heading into the presidential cycle, will be one of the defining stories of the rest of his term. 

Here’s the story of the historic shift so far, and what it will mean for the country going forward.

The House: Democrats are poised to take control in a major way

Many of the Democrats’ newly won House seats could be hard for the party to defend in future elections, but for now the results could have major implications for how the chamber governs.

Both Democrats and Republicans have struggled with narrow majorities in recent years, in which a small handful of members can threaten to withhold their votes and tank legislation or procedural votes. The new Democratic majority is big enough to avoid that problem in the next session. But it also might diminish the influence of the energetic new progressive wing, since their votes would not necessarily be crucial to pass certain measures. 

From the very first votes counted in Indiana and Kentucky, in districts that Trump had won by double digits in 2024, it was clear that Republicans’ small House of Representatives majority would likely soon be washed out by a blue wave. But as the night went on, the size of the wave became more and more clear. Democrats were flipping Republican seats across the country, without any particular geographic or regional pattern to speak of. 

They flipped Republican-held seats in Kentucky, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and North Carolina. They looked favored to win more in Arizona, Michigan, Iowa, and Virginia. 

Democratic House challengers with mainstream political experience, like Scranton Mayor Paige Cognetti (PA-8), won. So did Democrats with military experience, like Navy helicopter pilot Rebecca Bennett (NJ-7). And so did Democrats with more against-the-grain backgrounds, like farmer Jamie Ager (NC-11).

The exact size of the Democratic majority wasn’t immediately clear as races remain uncalled, but forecasts on Tuesday night suggested it would likely be enormous — something like a 60-vote edge over the GOP in the chamber.

More votes means more leeway for leadership, which could perhaps give the party’s growing progressive faction, or a soon-to-be considerable moderate wing, less leverage to make demands and more freedom to vote “no” when their conscience or local politics calls for it. 

The Senate: Some very weak Republican candidates helped Democrats beat all expectations

Control of the Senate will be hugely important in shaping the final two years of Trump’s presidency — because a Democratic majority would make it much harder for him to confirm controversial nominees to administration positions. It would also likely make it impossible for him to confirm a new Supreme Court justice, should a vacancy arise.

Furthermore, if Democrats hope to achieve their ambitions next time they control the presidency (which they hope will be in 2029), they’d have to start building a Senate majority now — only a third of the chamber is up in each cycle.

The problem for Democrats was that political analysts had long believed the Senate map they faced this year would be forbiddingly difficult. They’d have to hold their own seats, including contests in swing states like Georgia and Michigan. 

To win a majority, though, Democrats then had to pick off at least four Republican seats, and some of those would have to be in deep red territory, which meant breaking into states Trump won big, such as Ohio and Texas.

In doing this, they didn’t just benefit from a blue wave. They also got help of a kind from a surprising source: Trump, whose choices and actions often seemed designed to put safe GOP-held seats at risk. 

Trump’s attacks on Sen. Thom Tillis (R-NC) spurred the veteran legislator to retire. Trump backed a primary challenge to Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) that resulted in a flawed and scandal-plagued candidate, state Attorney General Ken Paxton, becoming the GOP nominee. And when Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) died suddenly in July, Trump decided to appoint his sister Darline, a political neophyte, to his seat.

On Tuesday, Republicans lost all three of those races. In North Carolina, the state’s popular Democratic governor, Roy Cooper, easily triumphed over former RNC chair Michael Whatley. In Texas, 37-year-old state Rep. James Talarico became a nationally viral phenomenon with his faith-inflected message and defeated Paxton soundly. And in South Carolina, a pediatrician named Annie Andrews defeated Darline Graham in one of the night’s most shocking results. 

But the GOP’s Senate woes were broader. In Ohio, a state Trump won three times, former Sen. Sherrod Brown (D) defeated Sen. Jon Husted (R), who Trump had appointed to fill JD Vance’s Senate seat once Vance became vice president. In Iowa, Republicans had viewed their candidate for the open Senate seat, Rep. Ashley Hinson, as one of the stars of the cycle, believing she did everything right. It wasn’t enough. She, too, went down to defeat, to state Rep. Josh Turek (D). In Maine, Sen. Susan Collins (R), who had long defied political gravity, finally lost to former state Sen. Troy Jackson (D).

And yet another shocker ensued in Kansas, a state that has not elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1932. Methodist megachurch pastor Adam Hamilton (D) led Sen. Roger Marshall (R-KS), a one-term incumbent whose campaign was dogged by reports that, back when he was a doctor, he’d sued patients for unpaid bills.

All in all, depending on how uncalled races in Mississippi and Alaska turn out, Democrats could end up with somewhere around 55 Senate seats — an impressive majority, particularly in a year when they weren’t expected to come anywhere close to that.

Governors: Democrats get their chance to lead

Even with significant majorities, Democrats will be limited in how much they can check Trump and enact their agenda in Congress. 

But at the state level, Democrats won major gubernatorial victories around the country, giving them an immediate opportunity to pursue policies that could directly affect hundreds of millions of Americans — including in states that they haven’t led in decades. 

In Georgia, Keisha Lance Bottoms is set to become the first Black governor, and the first Black woman to govern any state in America, after defeating Republican businessman Rick Jackson. In Texas, Gina Hinojosa rode a backlash over data centers to beat Greg Abbott, long considered one of the most politically successful and influential conservative governors in the country.

In Iowa, Democratic state auditor Rob Sand, who campaigned as a pragmatist, won the governorship. And in Ohio, Democratic public health expert Amy Acton overcame a last-ditch ad from Republican Vivek Ramaswamy that featured her own mother — who lost custody of a then-12-year-old Acton after her husband was indicted for sexual abuse — to handily win her election. 

A bright spot for Republicans is Florida, where Rep. Byron Donalds overcame a surprisingly tough race against Democrat David Jolly and is set to become the state’s first Black governor. 

Latino voters gave Democrats a second chance

Underlying some of the night’s most surprising results were powerful demographic currents — for the GOP, not unlike a wave quickly pulling back from the beach. Trump had shocked Democrats over the last 10 years by making steady gains with Latino voters, first with conservative-leaning Cuban Americans in Florida, and then in 2024 with Mexican American and Puerto Rican voters around the country moving right over concerns about inflation and border security. 

But Trump’s economic mismanagement and aggressive deployment of ICE helped spur a backlash from early on in his second term that culminated in a massive swing back toward Democrats in key races. From South and Central Florida to rural Kansas to the Rio Grande Valley, Latino voters again favored Democrats, helping power candidates to big wins.

Nowhere was the impact greater than in Texas, where exit polls found Talarico won 64 percent of Latino voters in his race against Paxton, giving Democrats a statewide victory after decades of failure. Trump had won 55 percent of the Latino vote just two years earlier. 

The gerrymanders didn’t work. In fact, they sparked a backlash.

Republicans, egged on by Trump, had a last-ditch plan to save the House: Break from the usual once-a-decade redistricting process and gerrymander seats wherever state Republicans had the ability to do so. They got an added boost from the Supreme Court, which overturned decades of Voting Rights Act protections for minority-majority districts in its Louisiana v. Callais decision. 

It didn’t work. While the new maps gave Republicans an advantage on paper, the scale of the blue wave was so big that it quickly overpowered it. In Florida, Democrats herded into Trumpier districts appeared to all survive their contests. And in North Carolina, the situation was even worse for Republicans, with the former state house speaker who masterminded the new maps, Tim Moore, trailing in his own congressional run with nearly all votes counted in what was expected to be a solidly Republican seat. 

It may have backfired in ways that went beyond the House results. There was a massive surge in Black turnout across the South, where voting rights have long been a touchstone issue, that spilled into statewide races. Democratic Senate and gubernatorial candidates not only won by wide margins in Georgia and North Carolina, but put up shockingly competitive fights in Mississippi and Louisiana Senate races that only came on the national radar late in the cycle.  

The most important takeaway: Voters are really, really, really mad 

Americans chose to overlook some pretty glaring concerns with Trump when they sent him back to office in 2024, but they did so with a clear mandate: Get prices down, secure the border, and bring a positive resolution to conflicts abroad. 

It’s clear now he blew it, and they aren’t happy. 

The scale of voter outrage was the story of the night, just two years after Democrats faced its wrath and arguably far more intense this time. Sixty-two percent of voters in preliminary exit polls disapproved of his job as president, 53 percent of them strongly; 62 percent said he prioritized his own interests more than the country’s; 65 percent believed he had made the economy worse; and 44 percent said their own financial situation had worsened since his election.

It’s a complete loss of confidence, and a sharp contrast to his — in comparison now, modest — rebuke in the 2018 and even 2020 election, when voters still credited his economic stewardship even as they rebelled against his personal behavior and broader agenda. 

Both parties now know just how poisonous the current Trump brand is. The question is whether Democrats can offer a compelling alternative vision now and — above all, after years of anti-incumbent sentiment — prove they can deliver tangible results. Even on a historic night, a majority of voters told pollsters they held an unfavorable view of the Democratic Party. 

  •  

The Christian left is here

Photos of Hamilton and Talarico.

The Democratic Senate victories in Texas and Kansas on Tuesday night were about more than just turning two red states blue — which, to be sure, is historic enough.

They also signal the rise of a new kind of Democratic politics in the late Trump era — a more explicitly religious one. 

In Texas, James Talarico, the Presbyterian seminarian, was beating Republican state Attorney General Ken Paxton by 20 points at the time of the call. And in Kansas, which hasn’t elected a Democrat to the Senate in nearly a century, the Rev. Adam Hamilton, the chief pastor of the state’s largest church, has defeated incumbent Sen. Roger Marshall.

They belong to a rising tide in American politics: the emergence of a religious left that marries moderate or liberal strains of Christianity with Democratic policy and political priorities. Their wins are the first major victories of this movement in the 2026 cycle.

Meanwhile, in nearby Iowa, two more Democratic Christians — the Lutheran minister Sarah Trone Garriott and Presbyterian minister Lindsay James — are also leading in their races to flip Republican-held House seats.

Back when Talarico won his bid to be the Democratic nominee for US Senate in Texas, I wrote that he and his opponent represented two drastically different visions of American Christianity. Talarico had emerged victorious from a bitter primary battle, betting that the best way to do Democratic politics in a red state was to expand the base by reclaiming religion, forgiving political rivals, and loving neighbors, even if they voted differently. He basically preached on the campaign stump — even saying in a recent interview that Paxton is a “child of God.” And he was doing this as a pastor-in-training, representing a dying breed of mainline Protestant Christians as a Presbyterian.

He was facing off against an avatar of the dominant brand of American Christianity today. A hard-line conservative evangelical Christian, Paxton represented the kind of religious politics that has made Christianity synonymous with conservative Republicanism in the modern era. 

Paxton had been a leading figure in the Texas GOP’s crusade to infuse the public square with a more conservative-tinged vision of Christianity, arguing last year that “in Texas classrooms, we want the Word of God opened, the Ten Commandments displayed, and prayers lifted up. … Our nation was founded on the rock of Biblical Truth, and I will not stand by while the far-left attempts to push our country into the sinking sand.”

It’s a more authoritarian-flavored variety of Christianity — some might call it Christian nationalism — and it created a perfect foil with the more tolerant, inclusive vision of Christianity that Talarico was preaching.

Hamilton did the same throughout his stronger-than-expected campaign. On the trail, as he’s done for decades as the pastor of the United Methodist Church of the Resurrection in the Kansas City suburbs, he spoke frequently about his faith journey and belief in Christ, about loving one another, and about repairing relationships ruined by Trump-era politics. Also like Talarico, he doubled down on kitchen-table issues and listed off all the ways the Trump administration had hurt Americans.

But he also told me that he viewed himself as part of this national movement of pastors, ministers, and religious people squaring off against “Christian nationalism” and showing Christians and non-Christians alike how biblical values and Jesus’ teachings might lead someone to a Democratic policy worldview.

“I want Democrats to be able to talk about faith and to do so in a way that reflects a difference from what you see in Christian nationalism,” Hamilton told me in early October when I visited Kansas for a profile of him. “Our faith reflects the ideas of justice and fairness. Two thousand verses in the Bible talk about poverty and taking care of the poor. That’s not what you hear from Christian nationalists. But it is what you hear from Christians who are Democrats.”

He told me last month that, whether he won or lost, he hoped people of faith who happen to be Democrats continue to play an active role in politics — for the sake of the Democratic Party and for the sake of Christianity. “Thoughtful Christian people have something important to add to the conversation,” he said.

Both Hamilton and Talarico faced criticism of their religious message. Detractors, including President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance, as well as average evangelical and conservative Christians, took issue with their theological interpretations, the state of their denominations, or the authenticity of their faiths (some attacks were less sophisticated, such as simply calling Talarico or Hamilton “woke”).

But their wins suggest at least that enough moderate Christians, and independent-minded Republicans, were persuaded by their articulations of their faith to side with these religious candidates. That should be an encouraging sign for Democrats moving forward to continue to expand the faith lane and think about the faith angle in future elections and coalition building. 

To remain competitive in future congressional and presidential contests, some analysts argue, Democrats must continue to make inroads with the religious vote. “At some point you’ve got to say to the loud secular left, ‘Hey, we appreciate you and we want your votes, of course, but you’re going to vote for us anyway. We need the votes of Catholics and mainline Protestants and those kinds of people,” the religion and politics scholar Ryan Burge told me. 

Historically, though, the establishment class — the donors, activists, and organizers who power campaigns — has not always been comfortable appealing to these religious groups, since they often have priorities at odds with those of the base. But Talarico’s win in deep-red country shows what can be gained if they can get more comfortable with a new kind of Democrat.

  •  

What Democrats could actually do if they win Congress

Chuck Schumer, left, in a blue suit, and Hakeem Jeffries, right, in a black suit, walk together as they talk, with Jeffries gesturing with one hand.
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) walks with Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) in May 2026 in Washington, DC. |  Win McNamee/Getty Images

The outcome of the midterm elections is perhaps the single most important factor in determining how the final two years of Donald Trump’s presidency will play out — and what impact it will have on people’s lives in the United States and around the world.

If Republicans defy the polls and hold both chambers, Trump would have the chance to pass more sweeping legislation on party-line votes, confirm more loyalist nominees to important positions, and continue remaking the judiciary, all while keeping oversight to a minimum. Democrats would have limited tools to object, Republicans would keep a free hand to run Washington, and Trump would be able to cite the results to maintain party loyalty. Practically and politically, the next two years would look a lot like the last two.

Conversely, the better Democrats do, the more power they will have to block Trump’s agenda, check his power, investigate his administration, and advance priorities of their own on issues like the economy, healthcare, the war in Iran, immigration enforcement, corruption, and more. But they’d also face significant limits on their power, from the Senate filibuster and Trump’s veto pen to White House tactics that could delay or derail oversight. 

Key takeaways

  • Even if Democrats romp in the congressional midterms this week, they won’t be able to do whatever they want; however, if they use their powers creatively, they could achieve real and meaningful accomplishments.
  • Legislative accomplishments would likely happen in one of three ways: through confrontations on “must-pass” bills, through bipartisanship, or by laying the groundwork for bills a future Democratic president could sign.
  • House or Senate majorities would give Democrats subpoena powers, but the Trump administration will likely refuse to comply; Democrats would have to think outside the box in how to make their investigations succeed.
  • A Senate majority would make it far more challenging for Trump to confirm nominees and would slow his judicial confirmations to a trickle, if that.

So what are the real midterm stakes? Which moves from a Democratic Congress would be symbolic and which could have an immediate impact on real-world outcomes? And what might prevent them from achieving their goals?  

To get a better sense of what Democrats could actually do if they won power in Congress, I spoke to current and former congressional aides as well as plugged-in outside experts. They generally painted a picture of a grim slog akin to trench warfare. Some believed the expectations of the Democratic base would far outpace what could realistically be achieved, and that frustration and disappointment were inevitable.

But some also expressed surprising optimism that, if Democrats played their cards right, they could score real and meaningful accomplishments — in driving policy change, in bringing wrongdoing to light, and in laying the groundwork for far more ambitious goals in the near future.

Whether they can do this will depend in part on politics and messaging, but also on how they use the formal tools that would be newly available to them with a congressional takeover: legislation, investigations, and — in the case of a Senate win — the confirmation process.

Legislation: How new Democratic majorities could legislate in a way that actually matters

The US Capitol is seen from above at a distance.

House Democratic leaders are proudly talking about the bills they plan to quickly pass if they win the majority on topics such as healthcare, tariffs, and the war in Iran.

But the reality is that, so long as the Senate’s 60-vote requirement for ordinary legislation to advance remains in place, such bills aren’t going to make it to Trump’s desk without winning significant Republican support. (And even if they do make it to Trump’s desk — say, via the special budget reconciliation process — he could veto them.)

Instead, for Democratic majorities to do meaningful things with legislation under Trump, they’d likely have to pursue one of the following three approaches.

1. Confrontations on the must-pass bills

Lots of bills go nowhere in Congress, but some are viewed as “must-pass.” Some have practical consequences for failure after a certain deadline: If the debt ceiling isn’t raised, the country will default on its debt with potentially catastrophic consequences; if government funding bills aren’t passed, the government will shut down, as it did for 43 days last year.

Often, if one or both chambers flip in the midterms, a bold new majority tries to use one of these bills to make policy demands on the president, believing the bill’s “must-pass” status gives them leverage. Then, a showdown unfolds, as both sides play chicken before a looming deadline.

So if Democrats win the majority, they will have to decide: Which much-pass bills do they want to make demands over, what do they want to demand, and just how hard do they want to demand it?

Experts I spoke to were skeptical Democrats would push too hard on the debt ceiling. “The Democratic position in the past has been, ‘We don’t threaten the full faith and credit of the US government,’” Bobby Kogan, the senior director of federal budget policy at the Center for American Progress, a Democratic-aligned think tank, told me. The consequences of default seem, to them, too devastating to risk, and they’re historically reluctant to legitimize Republicans’ use of the debt ceiling as a weapon under Democratic presidents.

Some sort of fight seems likelier on government funding — after all, even while in the Senate minority, Democrats used the filibuster to shut down the government late last year, demanding that Republicans extend subsidies for the Affordable Care Act. They could run that playbook again, saying they won’t fund the government unless Trump agrees to their demands on healthcare (such as rolling back Trump’s Medicaid cuts), ICE (where they’ve demanded new accountability measures and restrictions), or other issues. 

Many are skeptical that Democrats will successfully strong-arm Trump into making concessions in this way. When last year’s shutdown stretched for over a month and its consequences — for unpaid government workers and recipients of government benefits — grew more acute, enough Democrats eventually gave in even as they seemed to have the upper hand in polling. But it’s likely that the party’s base will urge them to try again — and if they do, their theory that they have more leverage over Trump this time will be tested.

2. Bipartisanship

The alternative to trying to shake the president down is to actually try and get Republican votes — passing measures with bipartisan support. 

And don’t scoff — though partisan battles will get all the headlines, there’s still a surprising amount of bipartisan action on substantive issues in Congress. During the final two years of Trump’s first term, bipartisan bills on Covid relief, energy, and trade passed. Under President Joe Biden, bills on infrastructure, semiconductors, same-sex marriage, and presidential election reform won bipartisan support. And this year, a bipartisan housing bill became law, and Congress hopes to pass an electricity permitting reform deal before the end of the year, too.

Some of these bills were standalone; others became law because they were attached to must-pass bills, such as government funding, or the National Defense Authorization Act. That’s a potential way to get something Trump doesn’t like into law — get enough Republicans on board, and hope that either Trump will conclude it’s too much of a headache to veto it, or that support in Congress is so strong his veto will fail (two-thirds of both the House and Senate can vote to override a veto). There’s precedent from this year’s bipartisan housing bill, which Trump allowed to become law without his signature.

Matthew Fiedler, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, told me that Democrats could try to add riders on appropriations bills that block certain controversial Trump administration regulatory actions. “That feels potentially achievable to me,” he said. But, to get those bills to Trump’s desk, they’d have to get the consent of Republican negotiators in Congress. 

Bipartisanship can be achieved through working with the other party and compromising with them. But another route is through political pressure — say, if a proposal is so popular and politically potent that the other party feels they have no choice but to go along. “Bipartisanship is not always the signal of a kumbaya environment,” Charlie Ellsworth, a former aide to Democratic Senate leader Chuck Schumer who currently advises the advocacy group Public Citizen, told me. 

That’s what happened with Rep. Ro Khanna’s (D-CA) bill to release the Epstein files last year; GOP leaders tried to hold it back, but the dam broke and it eventually passed with overwhelming majorities in both chambers. If Democrats win the majority, they could similarly put pressure on the GOP by forcing votes on issues where the party might be divided — like tariffs, or the Iran war.

3. Groundwork for the future 

The other route for legislating to really matter in the next session is more forward-looking — Democrats could be crafting bills that they truly intend to pass in 2029, if a new Democratic president is sworn in and the party holds Congress.

The idea here is that the next president may have a limited window to pass major legislation, so he or she will be looking for ideas to take off the shelf. And the more serious legislative work that gets done in this Congress, and the more Democratic consensus is built ahead of time, the better-prepared certain bills could be for that opportunity.

Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act last year, for instance, included several provisions that House Republicans had crafted during the Biden administration. Similarly, Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act included prescription drug provisions that House Democrats had crafted during Trump’s first term.

“There’s a lot of consequential prep work that can happen during these time periods, even when there’s not a real prospect of the legislation becoming law in this term,” Fiedler said. 

The flipside is that if Democrats flock to unworkable ideas in this Congress in order to appease an interest group or win a messaging fight, they may feel pressure to follow through in the next Congress — and problems may result. Take the first year of Trump’s first term, when he and the GOP felt compelled to deliver on their longtime vow to repeal Obamacare — but since they hadn’t come up with a specific proposal to do it that was politically viable and hadn’t seriously grappled with the many potential downsides for patients, the effort ended in failure.

“Democrats need to be cognizant that if you’re going to do a test run and draw a contrast between what Democrats are for and what the president opposes, you should expect the American people will ask you to deliver when you have the power,” Ellsworth said.

Investigations: How Democrats could think creatively to get around Trump’s stonewalling

A hearing room at the US Capitol is filled with political attendees as a panel of committee members sits on a high dais in the front of the room, backed by a huge projection screen.

Democrats say it’s urgently necessary to investigate a plethora of Trump administration scandals, from the Trump family’s crypto investments to Trump’s granting of pardons to his fundraising for the White House ballroom construction to aggressive actions by ICE, and much more.  

Winning control of either the House or Senate is crucial to these efforts because it would give them a hugely important investigative tool: congressional subpoena power. Democratic majorities would be newly able to issue legally binding requests for documents and testimony. (Currently, stuck in the minority in both chambers, all they can do is ask nicely.)

Why do investigations matter? One goal can simply be to unearth new facts about what’s been going on inside the executive branch, which can help determine their next steps. A second can be to spur criminal investigations, though this seems unlikely while Trump is in power, given his co-option of the Justice Department. 

A third can be to pave the way to impeachment if significant wrongdoing is exposed. That said, in contrast to Trump’s first term, Democrats sound far less eager to impeach him this time around, though some have floated potentially impeaching Cabinet officials. 

Finally, a fourth goal can be to use hearings and other activity to focus the press and public’s attention on certain topics and potentially build momentum for action in response. Many Democrats feel that their 2021-2022 House January 6 committee, which featured dramatic public testimony and audiovisual presentations, was an innovator here.

The catch is that the Trump administration could — and likely will — just refuse to comply with subpoenas aimed at officials or agencies. In Trump’s first term, he vowed to fight “all the subpoenas” from House Democrats, and for the most part the administration followed through, declining to cooperate or asserting executive privilege. 

If faced with this stonewalling, the usual next step is for Democrats to sue, and hope courts will compel compliance from the administration. The perennial problem, though, is that such lawsuits often take a long time to resolve — and could well stretch on into the next president’s term.

“It is unfortunately possible for the recipients of congressional subpoenas to resist and drag out these proceedings,” Tim Heaphy, the former chief investigative counsel for the House January 6 committee, told me. “And lawyers knew that, so they could run out the clock.”

Anticipating this resistance, Democrats have floated that they may focus their subpoenas on people or companies outside the government who they think might have information about executive branch malfeasance. 

These potential subpoena targets include donors to the White House ballroom construction effort, investors doing business with the Trump family, private companies that have gotten federal contracts, lobbyists that have helped secure presidential pardons for their clients, and law firms that made deals with the Trump administration.

The administration may still at least attempt to cite executive privilege to try to quash these subpoenas. “I’ve heard that there’s already some discussion about whether the executive branch would have standing to object to a subpoena handed to a government contractor,” Heaphy said. Democrats also hope to get cooperation from whistleblowers and government officials who actually want to share what they know.

But some have called on congressional Democrats to do more to try and ensure there will be consequences for defying subpoenas. For instance, Congress could theoretically assert a power known as “inherent contempt,” ordering noncompliant officials to be detained (or, potentially, fined); this power has not been invoked since 1934. If they tried to use this power against administration officials, a major constitutional battle would ensue. Others have suggested the less dramatic approach of making government funding contingent on agencies’ or officials’ cooperation with investigations.

Josh Chafetz, a Georgetown law professor and an expert on congressional power, told me that, to succeed with investigations, Democrats would have to think creatively. Simply litigating the Trump administration’s defiance, he said, was “a fool’s errand.” He added: “If they follow that playbook, they’re going to get the same results — which is, nothing will happen in those investigations over the next two years.”

Confirmations: A Senate takeover would have big stakes for how the Trump administration functions

If Democrats manage to win the Senate, there will be another major consequence — Trump will need their approval to confirm judges and many administration officials. 

Trump has nominated several extreme or controversial figures to his administration; and, because the GOP Senate majority was inclined to defer to their party’s president, the vast majority of them were confirmed. (Sorry, Matt Gaetz.) These nominations can have very real consequences: if Trump had selected someone other than Pete Hegseth, who was only one vote away from not being confirmed, as defense secretary, perhaps he would have heard more warnings about the risks of war with Iran.

A Democratic Senate would be far more skeptical of confirming particularly controversial nominees for administration positions. But more broadly than that, all Trump nominees would face tougher scrutiny. “The administration’s going to find it very hard to get pretty much anyone confirmed,” Chafetz said.

The official line from Democratic leadership is that they will be happy to confirm qualified Trump nominees — but that Trump is simply nominating unqualified people. “If the nominees are as crappy as his present ones, very few of them are going to get through,” Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) — the likely majority leader, if Democrats win the Senate — told Semafor last month.

A confirmation blockade wouldn’t lead to an urgent crisis, since Trump’s administration is full of confirmed appointees already. But as various officials leave the government — voluntarily or involuntarily — Trump will want replacements. Democrats will have to weigh just how far they want to go in slow-walking or delaying Trump nominees. Some Democrats will also want to use nominees as bargaining chips in their dealings with the administration, while others may think obstructing noncontroversial nominees is antithetical to how government should function.

Trump would likely respond by trying to rely more on “acting” appointees for key roles, as he did in his first term —  but there are legal limits on who can be appointed to an acting role, and how long they can serve there. 

Judicial nominees, meanwhile, serve for life if they’re confirmed. So a Democratic Senate majority would be most skeptical about confirming Trump’s judge picks, particularly at the circuit court level and certainly at the Supreme Court should any vacancy arise. 

For the Supreme Court, this is most consequential; conservatives currently have a 6-3 majority. But there are four Supreme Court justices in their 70s, with the oldest being 78-year-old Clarence Thomas and 76-year-old Samuel Alito. 

If Republicans hold the Senate, either could retire confident a right-wing successor would be confirmed. But if Democrats take over the chamber, they’d likely follow the precedent set by the GOP when they refused to even consider President Barack Obama’s nominee for the late Justice Antonin Scalia’s seat in 2016 — holding it open for the next president to fill.

That said, there may be a brief window for Republicans to try to confirm a justice in the final session before the new Senate majority is sworn in, if one or more do decide to step down.

The political stakes: In Trump’s last two years in power, will he be hemmed in — or emboldened?

Finally, looming above and affecting all these issues, is the political reality that the midterms will deliver what’s taken as a verdict on Trump’s second term so far. 

If Democrats’ win is huge, Republicans will engage in a frenzy of finger-pointing and blame-casting as the party grapples with what comes next for them after the Trump era, especially with a presidential contest starting up in which he won’t be on the ballot. Practically, Trump will be more hemmed in, and though he will surely stoke further controversies and crises, he will be a weakened figure facing constant challenges from Congress.

Conversely, if Trump’s GOP defies the polls and holds both chambers, he’ll likely treat it as a complete vindication of his second-term approach — and feel emboldened to plunge ahead on his most controversial agenda items, from ICE crackdowns to the Iran war, confident Congress will do little to stop him and the next Republican nominee (whether Vice President JD Vance or someone else) will take his side.

  •  

How a Democratic Congress Could Stop the Right-Wing Census Takeover

When the members of the 120th Congress take their seats come January, they will quickly have a chance to oppose — or let stand — the unprecedented changes and dramatic proposals from President Donald Trump’s administration at the Census Bureau. Those changes, if enacted, will have an enormously consequential impact on how political power is distributed in the U.S., and could grant greater representation in the House of Representatives and the Electoral College to Republican-voting states. That’s by design. 

  •  
❌