❌

Normal view

How Uruguay built a national care system from the ground up

20 November 2026 at 12:00
an image of young children playing on a jungle gym with elements of the Uruguayan flag and the US flag overlayed atop

Imagine a family with two working parents who can drop off their 2-year-old at a neighborhood childcare center for the workday for little to no fee. Their 4-year-old goes to a free public preschool nearby. Across town, the mother’s 82-year-old father, who can no longer bathe or dress himself, is visited by a personal assistant the government mostly pays for, 80 hours a month.

It’s not a daydream, it’s just a normal day for many families in Uruguay. 

And it is not just for lower-income households. A little more than a decade ago, Uruguay passed a law declaring that care for children, seniors, people with disabilities, and caregivers themselves is a right, and has been working to make good on that promise ever since. The resulting National Integrated Care System, known as SNIC (Sistema Nacional Integrado de Cuidados), has become a model around the world for treating care not as a privilege but as public infrastructure.

Across the country of about 3.4 million people, the system now provides early childhood care for some 78,000 children, subsidized home assistants for more than 6,000 people with severe disabilities, and day centers and emergency call services for older adults — through a network of community-run childcare centers, certified care workers, and a national agency that coordinates it all.

The undertaking has been huge, and the buildout is still in process. But the reasons for it echo across other high-income countries right now, including the United States, namely: falling birth rates, an aging population, and generations of women who are no longer willing or able to provide care for free. 

Key takeaways

  • Uruguay was the first Latin American country to make care a legal right, with one national system covering children, older adults, people with disabilities, and caregivers themselves.
  • It took decades of feminist organizing, so the plan was ready when a sympathetic government took power.
  • Writing it into law helped it survive a change in government, but Uruguay is still working out how to pay for broader access.
  • The US faces the same demographic squeeze and has started building some of the same pieces, from Washington’s long-term care insurance to universal childcare in New Mexico.

Uruguay sees this sprawling care system as a matter of rights but also as an economic investment, creating paid care jobs and enabling more women to enter formal employment, where they can then pay into the pension and health systems that an otherwise shrinking workforce needs to support. (The law itself lists among its goals changing “the current sexual division of labor” — the fact that care work falls overwhelmingly on women and is usually unpaid.) Leaders now describe SNIC as the “fourth pillar” of its social protection system, alongside education, social security, and healthcare. 

“It’s the closest thing I could find globally to an idea that family care — not unlike Social Security and Medicare — could be addressed through social insurance,” Ai-jen Poo, co-founder of US-based advocacy group Caring Across Generations, told me. Although Uruguay describes this care system as a right rather than an insurance program, she said, “the material manifestation is very similar.”

Poo isn’t the only care activist in the US looking to Uruguay’s example. Holly Milburn-Smith, the co-executive director of the City Hub and Network for Gender Equity (CHANGE), which works with cities on care policy, told me Uruguay’s appeal is partly that its example can’t be waved away the way policies in Nordic countries often are for relying on high taxation rates Americans would be hard pressed to accept. “We’re not talking about Scandinavian countries, we’re talking about Latin American countries,” she said. And in Uruguay, “they have found a way to do something that we haven’t.”

Uruguay’s system is neither perfect nor finished. It still mostly serves children, the waitlist for home assistants is long, and its leaders are still fighting over how to fully pay for it. But the country has built something with lessons for all of us, revealing both the promise and the challenges of treating caregiving as a public good.

How did Uruguay get this done?

Uruguay’s ambitious public care system was decades in the making. The country has had both the needs and many of the means to make it happen. It has one of the oldest populations in the region, and its fertility rate is estimated at just 1.2 children per woman, well below the roughly two needed for each generation to replace itself. So Uruguay has more older people who need help, fewer workers to pay for it, and smaller families to fall back on — the same squeeze the US is heading into. The country is also among the most wealthy and most economically equal nations in Latin America, and has had a proud welfare state tradition dating back to the early 1900s, with left-leaning governments for most of the last two decades. 

But Argentina, Brazil, and Chile all also had left-wing governments in the late 2000s and early 2010s, and none of them built a national care system then. What set Uruguay apart was “decades of political organizing” by feminist organizations, researchers, care advocates, and public officials who built a shared agenda, Michael Touchton, a political scientist who has spent two decades studying Latin American governance, told me. 

The feminist organizing was fueled by data. Sociologists at the Universidad de la República, the country’s public university, ran the country’s first time-use survey in 2003, which aimed to identify the kinds of unpaid care work and household labor that so often goes unmeasured and unnoticed in economic analyses. Led by researchers Rosario Aguirre and Karina Batthyány, the survey found that women in Montevideo and its metropolitan area were doing about two-thirds of all unpaid work, and that once paid and unpaid work were added together, women were working six hours a week more than men. 

(The US launched its own first national time-use survey the same year and found a similar pattern: For example, in homes with a child under 6, women worked on average 2.7 hours a day on childcare to men’s 1.2.) 

Following that early research, feminist organizations, other academics, union members, and female legislators in Uruguay spent the late 2000s pushing care onto the national agenda, holding public forums, and working through a cross-party caucus of female legislators ahead of the 2009 election. Their pressure was successful, with all four parties that had seats in parliament ultimately mentioning care in their platforms. But it was women inside the Frente Amplio, the left-wing coalition that had governed Uruguay since 2005, who got their party to commit to something more concrete. Frente Amplio’s 2009 platform promised “a truly comprehensive system of family care,” and when the party won again that year, it finally had a mandate to build one.

Still, it took six more years. After a national debate over what “care” even meant — teachers didn’t want to be lumped in with care workers, and feminists fought to keep gender at the center of the legislation — the law passed in 2015, with support across party lines. 

These coalitional fights helped shape what the law itself ultimately said, with three decisions standing out. First, the SNIC would provide services rather than cash to families, out of concern that paying families would simply subsidize the status quo, with women still doing the lion’s share of the work. Second, the SNIC would treat care as a right for everyone rather than a benefit for the poorest — a break from the means-based approach Latin American welfare states have usually embraced. And third, Uruguay’s care infrastructure would be written into law rather than left to regulation, which is harder to overturn.

The first big fight had been won. The next was turning the law into something real — and that would last.  

Inside Uruguay’s care system

The Scandinavian countries are often held up as the pinnacle of public caregiving, with childcare and eldercare guaranteed as entitlements and funded by some of the highest taxes in the world. Uruguay, however, does not have such markedly high tax rates as northern Europe. It has instead positioned care as what the law calls a “co-responsibility,” in which the state regulates and helps fund care but shares the jobs with families, communities, employers, and private providers. 

To do this, the government pulled existing services into a single system. In practice, this looks like neighborhood childcare centers run by community organizations under contract with the state, home assistants hired by families and subsidized on a sliding scale by income, and, for example, a childcare center for construction workers’ children funded by the industry’s employers under an agreement with their union. 

Uruguay’s care infrastructure remains a work in progress. The country spends less than 0.1 percent of its GDP on long-term care (ongoing help with daily life for older adults and people with disabilities), but a government-convened commission estimated that universal coverage would require roughly 10 times that. More than 7,000 people are currently on a waitlist for subsidized personal care assistants.

Part of the challenge is the National Integrated Care System has no dedicated revenue stream, unlike pensions (funded by mandatory wage contributions), healthcare (which runs through social security), or education (which has its own budget). When it was originally passed, the funding came from a combination of general revenue set aside in the national budget, the existing budgets of agencies already running childcare and preschool, and sliding-scale payments from families using the new home-assistant program. 

But funding remains fungible. “When the battle comes regarding resources, it usually gets the short stick,” Fernando Filgueira, a sociologist who helped design Uruguay’s care system and now heads the UN Population Fund, told me. The system is “absolutely underfunded.”

Activists say getting SNIC into law was important to help it survive a more conservative government that was elected in 2020, which didn’t repeal the care law but kept SNIC spending flat. Yes a law can be starved of money, Touchton said, but “unless you pass a new law — and that’s not easy to do — you have the old system in place, and it’s just likelier to survive.” Nevertheless, activists acknowledge laws alone are not enough. 

Carmen Estrades, an economist at the Universidad de la República, told me that she urges policymakers to see spending on care as “investment, not expenditure” because the country gets returns. In one recent study, she and colleagues projected that a major expansion of SNIC through 2050 — one that would cover every person with high care needs, extend public childcare to most children under 3, and raise care spending from about 0.1 percent of GDP to 1.8 percent — would produce a larger economy, higher household incomes, about 2,000 more jobs a year (most of them for women), and a system that pays backup to a fifth of its cost in tax revenue alone, even before counting any long-term benefits to (and other increased productivity from) the families themselves.

“We are trying to make the case to policymakers, but it’s still hard [for them] to think about the long term,” she said. “The problem is that here the government cycle is only five years.”

But the system is working for a large number of Uruguay’s households. Around 90 percent of 3-year-olds are now in an educational program, though some credit for that goes to falling birth rates. And there are the roughly 6,000 people with severe disabilities who have a paid helper for 80 hours a month under the personal assistants program, with the state covering all or part of the cost depending on household income. 

The SNIC model has inspired leaders all over the world, including in Colombia’s capital city. Over the last five years Bogotá has opened more than two dozen “care blocks” — pioneering neighborhood hubs where women can drop off laundry, finish school, see a lawyer or a psychologist, or just rest, while their children or elderly relatives they care for are looked after on site. These are run by the city’s government, which has put about $1.3 billion into them since 2020, largely by repurposing existing buildings and budgets. Brazil passed a national care policy in December 2024, and Chile’s own national care system became law in February. Both countries cited Uruguay as providing a blueprint. 

“The way that a lot of people refer to Uruguay in Latin America is it’s the laboratory for all these social policies,” said Eloisa Cardona, who previously worked at Bogotá’s Secretariat for Women’s Affairs where she helped build her city’s care infrastructure. Could the experiment also travel north? 

Could the US build a similar family care system?

Efforts in the US to roll out national care systems have repeatedly stalled in Congress, most recently in 2021, when the Build Back Better bill’s childcare, pre-K, and home care provisions failed to pass the Senate. 

The US is of course a very different country from Uruguay — from its size to its government system to its politics. But the US has been developing many of the same ingredients, and some of the momentum, that would be key to its own  national care system. 

For example, state and federal lawmakers in the US have also been thinking more about care infrastructure in recent years, and the US does have an increasingly well-funded, and well-organized movement pushing for reform. In 2019, Washington became the first state in the US to pass a public insurance program to help families afford long-term care. And in 2025, New Mexico became the first state to offer universal no-cost childcare. 

At the federal level, the Build Back Better bill would have created universal pre-K, capped childcare costs for most families, and put $150 billion into home care for older adults and people with disabilities. At the time, President Joe Biden explicitly called the investments “care infrastructure.” More recently, the Republican sponsor of a bipartisan federal immigration bill, the Dignity Act, pitched her legislation partly as an answer to U.S.’s aging population, arguing the country can’t meet its care needs without more paid care workers — many of whom are immigrants — for seniors and people with disabilities.

And other policy proposals abound. Poo, of Caring Across Generations, has spent years arguing that care in the US should be thought of in a more comprehensive way. Back in 2019 she proposed a policy idea for a new social insurance program that would provide childcare, paid leave, assistance for people with disabilities, and eldercare all together. She told me her group is now exploring ways to bring that universal family care pitch back to the national agenda.

In red and blue states alike, there’s also growing recognition that care should be understood, as in Uruguay, as a responsibility shared among families, government, and the private sector. More companies are stepping up on employer-child care programs, and more cities are viewing the dearth of childcare options as a threat to their local economies.

One of the big transferable lessons, Milburn-Smith of CHANGE said, “is this question of how we want to organize our shared and collective life — and exposing that our economies and our societies are completely dependent on a labor that is largely invisible.” Bringing care into the light and broadening it from being seen only as an individual responsibility, she said, “is absolutely the first step.”

Uruguay shows the road is winding, but with a law behind it and a movement willing to relentlessly defend it, a system that lasts is possible.

This story was supported by a grant from Arnold Ventures. Vox had full discretion over the content of this reporting.

How big should Democrats go on childcare? We asked a potential 2028 contender.

28 October 2026 at 15:15
Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear
Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear, who is weighing a presidential run, told Vox that he believes Congress “should take action to make sure that every state provides pre-K for 4-year-olds.” | KC McGinnis/Bloomberg via Getty Images

The midterms are racing to their conclusion, but the presidential contest is right around the corner. As the next primaries begin to take shape, how Democratic hopefuls intend to address childcare is already shaping up to be a major question. 

Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear, who is weighing a run for president, is one of the potential contenders with hands-on experience around this issue. Facing Republican opposition in the state legislature, he recently redirected federal funds to launch a pre-K pilot program, standing up 3,000 new seats since May. And he believes national Democrats should be making a push to expand access to preschool as well.

We wanted to better understand not only how Beshear is thinking about early childhood initiatives, but also his approach to spending on new federal programs more broadly, and what he’s learned from past efforts to expand access to families that failed. On Tuesday, we spoke with Beshear remotely about his work in the state — and his message to Democrats outside of it. Our conversation has been lightly edited and condensed for clarity.

Since 1991, Kentucky has supported voluntary preschool, yet today still only about a quarter of 4-year-olds can attend the state-funded program. Why has it been so hard to make preschool available to every family who wants it?

Well, it shouldn’t be hard. You know, pre-K is an opportunity for every child to get off to a good start. And right now in Kentucky, because of the history you just mentioned, over half of our Kentucky children show up not ready for kindergarten. So before they’ve ever walked into a public school they are already behind. 

So why has it been hard to make that happen?

Well, so at least in my tenure, somehow pre-K has become political. You know, 4-year-olds aren’t registered to vote. They’re not Democrats or Republicans. But I’ve pushed every year to get this in the budget. We can easily fund it given that I’ve produced a surplus every year I’ve been governor, yet our Republican leadership simply will not let it happen.

So, as you mentioned, there have been attempts at expanding this before. What have you learned from those earlier attempts, and what are you doing differently now?

So it’s interesting you bring that up. The same leadership that will not pass pre-K funding in our current budget cycle voted for it under the last Republican governor, but won’t vote for it under me. The last Republican governor vetoed the expansion, and they expressed their displeasure. So the only thing that’s changed here is the party of the person in charge. And what I hear is our Republican leadership saying they don’t want to give me a win, but they’re willing to hand a loss to all of these 4-year olds.

But for me as governor, I don’t get to accept excuses. So what I’ve done is I’ve taken flexible workforce training funds called WIOA funds, which you can use for a lot of different things. They’re used in a number of states for pre-K. And we have launched five pilot programs in different parts of the Commonwealth that are already a stunning success. 

The smallest county in Kentucky is called Robertson County and has zero childcare. You have to drive 40 minutes one way or an hour another way just for any form of child care. It’s one of the places we started this and just to see the parents and the impact that it has on them — most of those parents don’t share my political party — but this is a great opportunity for them that they’re embracing. 

It sounds like it’s gotten pretty polarized in your state. When you talk with Republican lawmakers privately, what do they tell you about why they won’t support expanded preschool?

Well, many rank-and-file Republicans in our state legislature want pre-K, and a number of them helped us to push for it this time. But leadership that’s been here for far too long and gotten far too partisan is simply blocking it at this point. What we need is for it to get to a vote, because this is the top polling education issue among Republicans. Again, because it’s not political.

If we had ballot measures and we put this on there, it would pass 80-plus percent because everyone wants that opportunity for their children. My hope is now that we have started these pilot programs, including one in Franklin County, which is where the seat of government is, that they can go and see how good this program is and not allow the next set of 4-year-olds or the next set of 4-year-olds or the next set of 4-year-olds to miss out on it. But I’m gonna do everything I can with the funding that I can find to provide as much of this opportunity as possible.

So there’s a lot of speculation about whether you might run for president. Without asking you to make any announcements here, I wanted to ask how you’re thinking about these issues nationally. You recently called yourself a more “practical” candidate when explaining your concerns about Medicare-for-all. When you look at something like childcare or pre-K from a federal perspective, what does being practical mean?

I think it means that there is a role for the federal government, and I’m supporting a number of congressional candidates right now and talking to all of them about pre-K. When people talk about the different sides of the Democratic Party — which I think is an overblown story, but still — like when Elizabeth Warren and I get together, we try to find some different things that we both agree on that we could work together on, and pre-K is one of those areas, so is housing.

“I do believe that Congress should take action to make sure that every state provides pre-K for 4-year-olds.”

I do believe that Congress should take action to make sure that every state provides pre-K for 4-year-olds. That’d be something that would be good for the United States that could actually bring Democrats and Republicans together and lift up people in all 50 states. And wouldn’t that be nice? To do something that is the right thing, that is the smart thing, and to do it in a nonpartisan way.

I know you mentioned pre-K for 4-year-olds. What do you think parents should be able to count on from the government before their kids turn four?

I believe that there is a role for government in childcare, and we’re working on it right now in Kentucky. We launched our first childcare center for state employees, and we’re learning a lot from it. Now I admit that the child care challenge is complex. You know, we have private childcare, we have public childcare, we have nonprofit childcare, and making sure we can get in and understand the real cost drivers of that.

What we would do as a state, or what the federal government could do, is develop an effective understanding of all those different parts and pieces. But just pre-K could put 70,000 more people into our workforce in Kentucky, so think about what better childcare could do to the workforce in our country. And it’s something that we could afford because we would see more dollars coming back in terms of tax revenue from that many more people in the workforce than we would ever pay out in child care.

Representative Ro Khanna recently proposed a federal program that would cover childcare costs for nearly all families with kids under age six, including care by relatives and neighbors, and offer a thousand dollar a month to parents who stay home with children under three. Would you support that kind of program?

Yeah, I haven’t seen the details of it. I think that that would present some real challenges with our current system as it is. What I would see is getting into the complexities of each of the forms of child care and how we can augment it, how we can build out on the system that we have right now, but also to address those child care deserts that I’m not sure this plan would fix. I mean, we’ve got counties that have no options — public, private or nonprofit. 

And so I agree that it’s a challenge. I think it’s going to take us being both surgical on the micro and adopting policies on the macro. And I believe it probably won’t all happen at once, even though that sounds great. It’s how do we make improvement after improvement after improvement and expand and expand more as we understand the underlying mechanics better.

When I talk to people about why childcare and universal pre-K fell out of Joe Biden’s Build Back Better agenda, some say that Democrats tried to do too much and that they needed to narrow their agenda and prioritize specific issues more. Others, like Senator Elizabeth Warren, say that Democrats didn’t fight hard enough for child care, for universal pre-K.

What lessons do you take from the last federal child care push?

The federal government has to act with more urgency. We get in a lot of these debates about whether a plan is perfect or if a plan’s only 80 percent perfect. Listen, take the 80 percent and start working it. Provide the American people with some help which they need.

Now, the Biden administration could have had an imperfect plan. But if they’d implemented that imperfect plan, there would be more childcare options right now. And I admit as a governor, I’m practical. You know, getting stuff done is incredibly important. I want to provide relief to all families, but if I can provide relief to a lot of families, let’s start there and then let’s get bigger.

Just to clarify that, what would you have done differently? What would it look like if you had been part of the conversation?

“If it were me, I would push for universal pre-K for 4-year-olds immediately. That is the immediate relief that takes 25 percent of that burden off of working parents.”

If it were me, I would push for universal pre-K for 4-year-olds immediately. That is the immediate relief that takes 25 percent of that burden off of working parents and then I’d work on a bill that addresses childcare, that makes sure that we have all the stakeholders at the table.

Something that I hear in DC while reporting on childcare is that Democrats in Congress are working to make big new plans for 2027 and 2028. But we know they’d also face real pressure to restore things like the billions cut in Medicaid funding.

As you think about the future, where does childcare or universal pre-K fall on your list of priorities?

It’s high on the list of priorities because my priorities are the American people, their well-being, and the ability to chase that American dream. Right? That American dream is about having a job where you can support your family, being able to see a doctor when you’re sick, driving safe roads and bridges, getting your kids the best education possible, and feeling safe in your community. And so pre-K and childcare falls right there. I believe that.

When Democrats retake Congress or when they retake the presidency, we have got to be laser focused on people’s lives and how hard they are right now, but also do it in a smart way that increases the size of our workforce when there are people that want to go back to work, but simply can’t afford to because of the cost of childcare or a lack of those education options.

You recently praised Bill Clinton for running a budget surplus. Do you think that bringing down the deficit should be a priority for the next Democratic president?

Yes, and and I believe that you can and should run a surplus in that job. Now I think what you do is you grow the economy and that helps you pay for those services, but you’ve got to be careful about new spending. That doesn’t mean that you don’t engage in it because there are some things that you could spend on, I believe, like childcare and pre-K that would result in more federal revenue coming in that would allow you to run that surplus. But over time, we’ve got to start addressing the national debt.

Did the Biden administration’s experience with inflation change your thinking about how much the federal government should spend?

Well, I believe the Biden administration was attempting to get us out of the recession that was Covid. Now you saw a huge recession in Covid, and they put these policies in place that shot us out of that recession faster than anyone ever thought was possible, but it probably overshot that target. I think we should have been communicating to the American people about how we had gotten our economy back on track in record time, but it had gone a little too far, and that we were going to make it through. That could have even been a patriotic call because I believe it was a patriotic time. You know, defeating a pandemic that came to kill as many of us as possible.

You’ve talked in this conversation and elsewhere about being pragmatic, acting with urgency, not being overly ideological. A lot of Democrats today make the case now that the pragmatic thing to do is to go big on new programs, push for universal childcare, push for universal health care, abandon these half measures and incremental steps.

I’d love to hear you talk about that. Is that your instinct? 

Well, I’d have to see a program that would actually work. You know, it’s great to talk about a massive program, but then you’ve got to get down in the details, and will it deliver on day one? Or will it crash a system that is imperfect but is delivering to a degree and could deliver more? I’m not against the big idea, but what I’m against is throwing something out there that in the practical real world can’t work.

What role do you see for employers in building out our childcare and early education systems? 

I think that employers have a big role to play. And I see families where an employer has childcare, excited to go to work, knowing their kid is in the building or or close by, the convenience that that provides. They can go down and have lunch with their kids, which is something that I’ve missed out on in my work life. so I think it is critical. 

What we’ve seen in Kentucky is our large employers, we can work with them on it and we can get it done, but it’s midsized employers that we have to rise to that challenge. You know, places that only have a couple hundred employees, or maybe even 12 or 15, how we can band together for those businesses to be able to provide it. And I believe the federal government should be working directly with those companies, because we’ve got to make the economics work. The federal government, in coordination with those employers, could get this right, create a lot more slots, and help people get back to work.

❌