❌

Normal view

Trump’s looming nominations crunch

18 November 2026 at 23:15
Sen. Bill Cassidy, a clean-shaven white man wearing a suit and tie, walks down a hallway in the US Capitol carrying an iced coffee and a notebook.
Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-LA) in the US Capitol Building on November 10, 2026. | Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images

This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.

Welcome to The Logoff: President Donald Trump is running out of time to get his nominees confirmed. 

What’s happening? On Wednesday, outgoing Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy blocked Trump’s nominee to lead the National Science Foundation, Jim O’Neill, from confirmation. And last night, the White House pulled another nominee, would-be FDA commissioner Heidi Overton, from consideration ahead of a Wednesday committee vote. 

Both come at the worst possible time for Trump, who’s facing a dwindling legislative calendar with a Republican Senate majority on its way out. 

Cassidy, a physician, chairs the Senate health committee, which is responsible for approving both nominations before they go to the full Senate. On Tuesday evening, he wrote in a social media post that “unfortunately, with the limited time left, confirming a permanent FDA Commissioner will fall to Senate Democrats.”

What’s the context? A new Congress will be sworn in on January 3, in about a month and a half, and Democrats will hold sizable majorities in both chambers.

In reality, though, the Senate has less time than that to deal with new nominations: Not only are the holidays approaching, but Congress has other big-ticket priorities on its plate, including heading off another government shutdown and potential deals on permitting reform and the debt ceiling. 

Why does this matter? Trump loves an acting appointment, but those officials can often only serve for so long in a role without Senate approval, which will be an uphill battle in a Senate with a 56-seat Democratic majority. (For perspective: Even with Republicans in control, some of his most controversial nominees, like Pete Hegseth and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., barely made it through. And incoming Sen.-elect Annie Andrews (D-SC) ran on impeaching Kennedy.)

The new Senate is also near certain to spell the end of Trump’s ability to confirm judges to lower courts or the Supreme Court for the remainder of his presidency. 

In other words, time is of the essence and failed nominations like O’Neill and Overton are a particularly big deal. If Trump wants to fill those jobs, he’ll need to find a nominee that a new Democratic majority in the Senate is willing to confirm — I won’t be holding my breath.

And with that, it’s time to log off…

Here’s a useful column from Gabe Bullard, writing for Vox: Big Tech loves to use convenience as a selling point, especially in an age of AI agents that can do things like book your flights and shop for your groceries (as long as you’re willing to tolerate the possibility that something with access to your credit card can go badly awry). 

So how can we tell when these products are actually worth it, and when are they just locking us into a new set of hassles? Gabe breaks it all down here, and you can read it with a gift link. Have a great evening and we’ll see you tomorrow!

Trump trifft Putin und Xi: Was bedeutet das für den Ukraine-Gipfel in Berlin?

18 November 2026 at 05:30

Während der Kanzler die Koalition der Willigen morgen zur Ukraine-Unterstützung in Berlin versammelt, inszeniert sich Donald Trump heute schon am anderen Ende der Welt. Beim Gipfel im chinesischen Shenzhen trifft er auf Xi Jinping und Wladimir Putin, während seine Sondergesandten Steve Witkoff und Jared Kushner im Kanzleramt weitgehend schweigen müssen. Was dieses geopolitische Schattenspiel für den Westen bedeutet, analysiert Vize-Chefredakteurin Annett Meiritz zusammen mit Rixa Fürsen.

Wie blickt Europa auf dieses Dreiertreffen der Weltmächte, bei dem die EU nicht dabei ist? Marie-Agnes Strack-Zimmermann, Vorsitzende des EU-Verteidigungsausschusses, erklärt im 200-Sekunden-Interview, warum es paradoxerweise ein gutes Zeichen ist, dass in China nicht über die Ukraine gesprochen wird und welche Rolle der Iran in Trumps globalem Machtpoker spielt.

Nach elf Jahren hat die Bundeswehr ihren Einsatz im Irak beendet, auch die US-Truppen sind abgezogen. Nun reist Entwicklungsministerin Reem Alabali Radovan nach Erbil, um den Fokus auf wirtschaftliche Zusammenarbeit zu lenken. POLITICO-Reporterin Carlotta Diederich berichtet vor Ort, wie fragil die Sicherheitslage im irakischen Machtvakuum zwischen IS-Überresten und pro-iranischen Milizen tatsächlich ist.

Das Berlin Playbook als Podcast gibt es jeden Morgen ab 5 Uhr. Rixa Fürsen, Maximilian Stascheit und das POLITICO-Team liefern Politik zum Hören – kompakt, international, hintergründig.

Für alle Hauptstadt-Profis: Der Berlin Playbook-Newsletter bietet jeden Morgen die wichtigsten Themen und Einordnungen. Jetzt kostenlos abonnieren.

POLITICO Deutschland – ein Angebot der Axel Springer Deutschland GmbH
Axel-Springer-Straße 65, 10888 Berlin
Tel: +49 (30) 2591 0
information@axelspringer.de
Sitz: Amtsgericht Berlin-Charlottenburg, HRB 196159 B
USt-IdNr: DE 214 852 390
Geschäftsführer: Christoph Eck-Schmidt, Carolin Hulshoff Pol, Mathias Sanchez Luna

Exclusive: 38 Million Low-Income People Could Be Excluded From Census Under New Trump Admin Rule, Report Finds

17 November 2026 at 12:00

As many as 38 million people could be left out of the population count, independent of immigration status, if the Census Bureau finalizes its proposed rule to redefine how it identifies where people live. 

That’s according to a new report from the Coalition on Human Needs using the Census Bureau’s own data.

The Coalition on Human Needs is an organization made up of of public interest groups and think tanks, including the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, United Way, AFSCME, and the Southern Poverty Law Center, that advocates for policies that would benefit low-income populations.

“It became very clear that if you’re trying to tie being counted in the census to whether or not you have an address in your tax record that matches, that if you don’t file taxes in the first place, you won’t be counted,” Christopher Kang, executive director of the Coalition on Human Needs, told TPM. 

The Census Bureau did not respond to a TPM request for comment.

The Commerce Department on September 9 proposed a new rule that sought to make foundational changes to the 2030 census, a change that could erase most noncitizens from the 10-year census count for the first time in the survey’s history. 

The proposed rule would try to accomplish the exclusion of immigrants in part by using tax records as an indicator of a census participant’s “usual residence.” While the Census Bureau has used federal administrative records like tax data to fill in information gaps on past decennial censuses, using the records as the primary means of determining where a person lives is unprecedented.

Previously, the census defined a person’s usual residence as where a person “live[s] and sleep[s] most of the time.” Under the new rule, the census would narrow that definition to the place “consistent with, and evidenced by, their tax records.” 

Though the Constitution mandates that a state’s congressional representation reflect “the whole number of persons in each State,” Republicans have long sought to shift political power from blue states to red states by excluding immigrants from the population count used to determine representation. Republican activists contend that Democratic states tend to benefit politically from larger immigrant populations, an argument that was the basis for a lawsuit filed by Alabama ahead of the 2020 census. (It was dismissed in 2021.) Excluding immigrants from the count used for congressional representation would also impact the Electoral College.

It’s part of an overall effort by the Trump administration to increase Republican power by manipulating all aspects of the democratic process, of a piece with its push to redraw congressional districts that favor Republicans (which backfired during the midterms) and its unfounded claims about various forms of alleged voter fraud.

The proposal drew sharp and immediate rebuke from data policy experts, various kinds of advocacy groups, states, localities and tribal nations. Now, citing the Census Bureau’s own research, the Coalition on Human Needs report found that a whopping 11.5% of the population doesn’t have “any IRS” forms.

People with an annual household income lower than a certain federal threshold are not legally required to file federal income taxes. That could include gig workers who make less than $20,000 and don’t reach 200 transactions, and other kinds of self-employed small business owners. There’s an additional tax form that people who receive  Medicaid, the Children’s Health Insurance Program, or a certain block of SSI benefits might have filed, but vagueness in the Census Bureau’s seismic proposal makes it unclear which forms will be used. 

And since the Bureau’s rule only specifies utilizing “e.g., tax returns, W-2 forms,” it’s even unclear what kind of taxed workers could be at risk of exclusion under the proposal.

The report also found that Census Bureau research showed as many as 30 million people “had no matching addresses between the IRS records and the 2020 Census.” Taken together with the 38 million people who do not file federal income taxes, the Coalition of Human Needs report calculated that this proposal risks undercounting around 20% of the entire population, regardless of immigration status.

“Overall, this proposal is so broken, you can’t even tell which 20% of the country is going to be left out,” Kang said.

Of the nearly 150,000 comments submitted on the Bureau’s proposed rule, the overwhelming majority — 88% — opposed the rule, according to data from a coalition of data policy organizations and experts called Hands Off Our Census. Most comments opposed the parts of the Bureau’s rule that would eliminate the collection of race, ethnicity, and sexual orientation, and that would exclude most noncitizens. But the proposal’s unprecedented changes to where the decennial census counts people brought opposition even from within the federal government, TPM reporting found.

Before the proposed rule was published, officials from the Treasury Department pushed back on the proposal and suggested that the Commerce Department — under which the Census Bureau falls — use tax information only for “corroborating evidence of an individual’s residence.” Treasury advised that “no particular tax record is controlling, and the evidentiary weight assigned to such information should reflect the purpose, timing, and reliability of the particular data element.” Commerce ignored the guidance.

“I think it’s important to put this proposal in context of everything else that is going on in the administration,” Aravind Boddupalli, senior research associate in the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, told TPM. “The overall picture is pointing to the use of the tax system for services beyond tax collection and tax enforcement towards other priorities such as immigration enforcement.”

If filed, tax returns are not legally required to record a person’s home address because they’re designed to ensure the IRS can contact filers, not for the census purposes of enumeration.

“Fundamentally, there would always be an undercount of how many people show up on our tax system,” Boddupalli said.

The Census Bureau has long used administrative records in its data collection, said John Iselin, associate director of economic analysis at the Yale Budget Lab. But use of the records have to be cognizant of their limits.

“There are real cases where because of the complexity of that matching process…you might not be able to make that match work,” Iselin told TPM. “And all those would mean that real information about someone that might be found through a decennial census process would be missed.” 

Das Verhandlungsfinale um Strom und Sprit

17 November 2026 at 05:30

Kommt die Einigung zur Stromsteuer.Vor dem Koalitionsausschuss zeigt sich Friedrich Merz optimistisch, doch die SPD pocht auf eine harte Gegenfinanzierung. Während der Kanzler in Rücklagen greifen will, stehen Subventionen wie das Dienstwagenprivileg auf der Kippe.
Ein Kampf um Milliarden, der auch die Rente erfassen könnte, wie Maximilian Stascheit und Rasmus Buchsteiner diskutieren.

Im 200-Sekunden-Interview macht Philipp Rottwilm von der SPD klar, woher das Geld für geplante Entlastungen kommen soll. Er nimmt ineffiziente Subventionen von Kerosin bis zu Privatjets ins Visier und ordnet ein, wie viel Spielraum tatsächlich für den Abbau der kalten Progression bleibt.

Alarmstufe in Washington: Wegen angeblich drohender Anschläge aus dem Iran müssen US-Minister in Sicherheit gebracht werden. Die Vize-Chefredakteurin von POLITICO Deutschland, Annett Meiritz, analysiert die Eskalationsgefahr im Nahen Osten und erklärt, warum Donald Trump nun als Ablenkungsmanöver ein Gipfeltreffen mit Xi Jinping und Wladimir Putin plant.

Das Berlin Playbook als Podcast gibt es jeden Morgen ab 5 Uhr. Rixa Fürsen, Maximilian Stascheit und das POLITICO-Team liefern Politik zum Hören – kompakt, international, hintergründig.

Für alle Hauptstadt-Profis: Der Berlin Playbook-Newsletter bietet jeden Morgen die wichtigsten Themen und Einordnungen. Jetzt kostenlos abonnieren.

POLITICO Deutschland – ein Angebot der Axel Springer Deutschland GmbH
Axel-Springer-Straße 65, 10888 Berlin
Tel: +49 (30) 2591 0
information@axelspringer.de
Sitz: Amtsgericht Berlin-Charlottenburg, HRB 196159 B
USt-IdNr: DE 214 852 390
Geschäftsführer: Christoph Eck-Schmidt, Carolin Hulshoff Pol, Mathias Sanchez Luna

Trump Is Not Going to Pin Nvidia Blame on Lutnick — For Now

16 November 2026 at 23:40

‘No, He’s Done a Very Good Job’

President Trump is continuing on with the delusion that administration officials did their jobs perfectly, and did not egregiously fumble their oversight of Nvidia.

Trump over the last year and a half has become close with the now-ousted Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, a relationship possibly helped by the fact that he had a more than $60 million stake in the company before news of the honeypotting affair broke. Over the last two weeks, the gradually unspooling details of Huang’s romantic relationship with a potential Chinese intelligence asset destabilized the global economy and created a geopolitical scandal for the ages. While Huang resigned from Nvidia after news of the affair broke and Trump initially called for Huang to be replaced with Apple’s Tim Cook, the president recently backed calls for Huang to be reinstated.

The Nvidia implosion is also stirring a rare, out-in-the-open feud among members of the Trump administration. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has been publicly blaming Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick for the administration’s lax, at best, oversight of the company’s relationship with China, prompting questions about whether Trump would somehow punish Lutnick. (If you are dumb about this stuff like me, the “chips” that Nvidia creates are advanced computer components that help run AI tasks rapidly. The U.S. has restrictions on exporting these chips to other countries, but especially China, as Trump and the Silicon Valley types pulling his strings contend that the U.S. must become a global superpower on AI development, lest a foreign adversary like China surpass us.)

Trump closes an AI loophole

16 November 2026 at 23:50
Donald Trump, swathed in a black overcoat and scarf, stands outside of the White House.
President Donald Trump departs the White House on November 16, 2026, ahead of a trip to China and the Philippines. | Kent Nishimura/AFP via Getty Images

This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.

Welcome to The Logoff: The Trump administration is closing a global AI chip loophole that the Jensen Huang scandal put in the spotlight.

What’s changing? The Commerce Department is trying to make it harder for China to access top-of-the-line AI microchips like those made by Nvidia.

Currently, China is able to dodge export rules by renting computing power from third-country data centers, which can legally buy American-made chips that China can’t.

But under the rule issued Monday, which is set to take effect in 90 days, data centers in a handful of countries will face new export restrictions on chips — including a requirement that they perform “robust due diligence on their customers” to make sure that they aren’t evading an export ban. 

What’s the context? Huang, who resigned from Nvidia last week, was brought down in part by his relationship with Alice Huang (no relation), an alleged Chinese spy (kind of) and an executive at a Singapore-based tech company, Megaspeed, that was renting compute to Chinese firms — exactly the kind of thing that the new rule aims to crack down on. 

What’s the big picture? The Nvidia scandal is front and center. But under the hood, there’s also some Trump administration infighting going on. As a statement announcing the new rule notes, it was written not by the Commerce Department, which is issuing it, but by the Treasury Department and the National Security Council.

That’s conspicuous because Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has done his best to throw Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick under the bus for the scandal, saying that Lutnick’s department failed to restrict Megaspeed’s access to advanced AI chips sooner.

Where’s President Donald Trump in all this? As of Monday, off to China and the Philippines for a multiday trip that will feature a trilateral summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. 

For now, though, Trump is standing by Lutnick — and even by Jensen Huang, saying Monday that he “would certainly not mind” seeing him return as Nvidia CEO (the Nvidia board has already shut down the possibility).

And with that, it’s time to log off…

One of my colleagues described this story about Anny Aviram, a now-retired conservator at New York’s Museum of Modern Art, as “a true balm for the weary soul,” and it lives up to the billing. You can enjoy it here with a gift link.

As always, thanks for reading, have a great evening, and we’ll see you tomorrow!

Donald Trump loves Jensen Huang. Everyone else…

16 November 2026 at 16:00
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang at the Nvidia/Japan AI Ecosystem Reception in Tokyo on July 16, 2026. | Philip Fong/AFP via Getty Images

Former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s sudden downfall is in a sense shocking, considering his wealth, global fame, and role leading what was until recently the world’s most valuable company.

But Huang’s immense influence in Washington — and particularly in President Donald Trump’s Washington — has long been intensely controversial among a surprisingly diverse cross-section of the political, business, and tech advocacy world. And his ouster not only drives a wedge through Trump’s second-term coalition, it could usher in a major change in how the US steers the AI revolution.

Huang — who resigned this week after allegations he’d had affairs with two Nvidia employees and one Chinese businesswoman who some US officials claim was spying on him for the Chinese government — has been crucial in helping shape the Trump administration’s AI policies. That’s perhaps no surprise, given that Nvidia’s advanced chips are crucial to the AI revolution.

His many critics, however, say Huang’s influence has been deeply harmful. Their main objection? They believe the Trump administration hasn’t been doing enough to stop China from getting or accessing advanced AI chips — in part because of Huang’s lobbying and sway with the president.

This coalition of Huang critics spans the political spectrum. It includes right-wing China hawks and the bipartisan foreign policy establishment, who want to win an AI race against China. It includes economic populists in both parties, who resent China’s economic sway. It even includes some leading members of the Trump administration itself — Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent have reportedly pushed for tighter chip restrictions.

It also contains some even odder bedfellows. The coalition includes people who want to slow down the AI race, like the tech safety advocates who warn that advanced AI could cause human extinction. Yet it also includes two major US frontier AI companies, OpenAI and Anthropic, who hope to impede the growth of Chinese competitors by limiting their access to chips. 

All of these disparate groups come together around the core idea that the US urgently needs to do more to stop advanced chips from getting to China. Selling AI chips to China is like “selling nuclear weapons to North Korea,” Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei has said.

Standing against them all — and often getting his way with Trump — has been Jensen Huang.

Beyond the obvious — Nvidia’s business is selling chips, and Huang wants to be able to sell more chips in more places — Huang is associated with a camp in the AI policy debate that some have dubbed with “let it rip.” Along with former White House AI czar David Sacks, Huang has scoffed at warnings that AI could cause human extinction, calling them “irresponsible” and “doomsday narratives.” He’s also dismissed some national security concerns, saying that being a “China hawk” was a “badge of shame” and said that the bigger risk to American influence over AI would be US companies losing market share around the world.

So Huang’s ouster and the claims of Chinese espionage around it have opened up an opportunity for a shakeup in US policy — and a rare chance for those China hawks to potentially investigate, undermine, and push out their rivals, while seizing the policy reins around chip exports. 

Trump administration officials who want tougher restrictions have their knives out for Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, a frequent ally of Huang’s. There’s a bipartisan push in Congress for new export controls legislation before the end of the year. Congressional Republican committee chairs are demanding Huang and Lutnick come in and testify in the coming weeks, before Democrats take over Congress.

Plus, there are the partisan incentives for Democrats to dig into the question of what Trump knew about all this (he was reportedly briefed on the spy concerns last fall). And there are political incentives for ambitious Republicans to find an issue on which they can distance themselves from an unpopular administration without antagonizing their conservative base. 

With so many different forces invested in the outcome, you can bet this topic will continue to dominate headlines for months to come — with unpredictable results for both the new Democratic Congress, the future of the GOP, and the AI boom.

The many critics of Jensen Huang’s influence on the Trump administration

In Washington itself, the most influential faction opposed to Huang is the bipartisan national security establishment, most of whom strongly believe in the necessity of competing with China for global influence. 

These “China hawks” were influential in the Biden administration and have historically been dominant in GOP administrations and on GOP-controlled congressional committees. And many of them have been flabbergasted at Trump’s policies toward China and Chips this term.

“I don’t think we should be using any American technology to uplift China’s capabilities in AI given how era-defining this technology will be in national security and in our economy,” Vivek Chilukuri of the Center for a New American Security, a center-left think tank, told me. “A company’s going to argue for this, that’s what companies do. But the interest of any one company should not be trumping the national security of the United States.

Moving further right, there’s a MAGA-aligned faction that is skeptical of foreign wars such as Trump’s conflict in Iran — but even some of them are still quite antagonistic to China.

Take, for instance, Trump’s onetime campaign manager and White House adviser Steve Bannon. He’s been furiously protesting Huang’s influence on the administration for more than a year — in September 2025, he argued that Huang should be arrested for being “an agent of influence of the Chinese Communist Party,” and argued we needed to “shut down” China’s “access to technology, chips, and training.”

Advocates and politicians focused on economic issues and reining in corporate power also have long criticized Nvidia. Oren Cass of the center-right group American Compass wrote an article titled “Break up Nvidia” last year, arguing that “its excessive concentration of power is exactly what antitrust law intends to combat.” 

Meanwhile, the left, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), a longtime critic of Big Tech, has frequently suggested Huang was corruptly influencing the Trump administration. At a hearing in June, she mentioned that Huang or his company had donated to Trump’s inauguration and his White House ballroom project. “If it’s not plain old-fashioned bribery, it sure smells like it,” she said.

Many in the AI safety advocacy world have also long criticized — and feared — Nvidia. That’s in part because they hope slowing down sales of AI chips abroad could slow what they view as a dangerous race to superintelligence. Additionally, after AI safety fears hit the mainstream in September due to Anthropic researcher Jacob Coxon’s resignation and viral warnings, Huang took an increasingly public role in dismissing such fears.

Other AI safety advocates cite the company as having a chilling effect on public debate. “For months now, I’ve heard about widespread fear among think tank researchers and policy experts who publish work against Nvidia’s interests,” AI safety researcher Steven Adler wrote last year. “If you speak with people in-the-know at AI companies, fear of retaliation from Nvidia is a major concern when staking out policy positions.”

Indeed, OpenAI and Anthropic are highly dependent on Nvidia for its chips, so open criticism of the company is not common. Yet those big two US AI labs have been at odds with Nvidia in urging the Trump administration to do more to crack down on Chinese access to advanced chips, and to more heavily scrutinize Chinese “open source” AI models.

But to Huang and others in his camp, the growth of Chinese AI is a feature, not a bug. Sacks, for instance, has repeatedly argued that “open weight” or “open source” models — which make their parameters publicly available, in contrast to the proprietary models of OpenAI and Anthropic — would help avert “an unsafe and dystopian future where advanced AI capabilities are centralized and controlled by only a few hands.” The leading open weight models are currently from Chinese companies.

Huang has also used a more straightforward argument: that what’s good for Nvidia is good for the United States of America.

“American technology has to win across the world at every single layer,” he said in May. “If we can export chips, we should.”

Now it will be left to Nvidia’s interim CEO, Colette Kress, to carry that message, instead of a rock-star founder with a global cult following that’s drawn comparisons to Steve Jobs at his peak at Apple. Her first task: taking stock of all the powerful actors across the political, advocacy, and business world rooting for her to fail. Perhaps DeepSeek could help make a list? 

Democrats’ plan to scrap the Electoral College is finally within reach. One of its architects is having second thoughts.

12 November 2026 at 12:45
An older man with a graying beard with glasses testifies
Yale University law professor Akhil Reed Amar testifies during a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing in September 2017. | Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call

The 2026 blue wave could end up washing away the Electoral College.

In addition to winning Congress, Democrats won full control of state governments in Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin.

That means that a two-decades-in-the-making plan to switch our presidential elections to a popular vote system — a plan 18 states have already approved— could cross the threshold that would make it a reality.

The plan is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC). A state signing on to the compact agrees that, rather than awarding its electors to the presidential candidate who won statewide, it will allot electors would to the presidential candidate who won the national popular vote. The catch is that each state will only do so if enough other states have signed on to determine the outcome.

To clarify: There are 538 electoral votes, and it takes 270 for a majority. So if states that have 270 or more electoral votes agree to award them to the national popular vote winner — that person wins. Effectively, the country would be fashioning a makeshift popular vote system.

States with 222 electoral votes have already agreed. So if states representing 48 more electoral votes join them, the threshold is crossed. Pennsylvania plus Michigan plus any two of Arizona, Nevada, and Wisconsin would get there.

Skeptics have historically doubted that crucial swing states would voluntarily give up the power they’ve enjoyed under the Electoral College. But Democrats have turned harshly against the system — especially after the last two Republican presidents won an election without a popular vote advantage — arguing it is profoundly unfair to have the presidency determined chiefly by how a few narrowly divided states happen to break.

Early signs suggest this will be a major topic of debate for new Democratic state governments next year. Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro signaled his support for reform over the weekend, saying, “I think Pennsylvania can still play a massive role even in a national popular vote.”

So it could actually happen — the Electoral College could be effectively abolished before 2028.

And that’s making Yale University law professor Akhil Reed Amar nervous.

One might think he’d be thrilled about this, because, back in 2001, Amar co-wrote an article advancing something close to what became the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. Earlier this year, he told me he considered the idea “my baby — maybe not mine uniquely, but my baby.”

But then he used some different analogies: “This is like Doctor Strangelove. I created this doomsday machine, like Edward Teller. Well done, Amar — you just destroyed the universe!” That’s because Amar has come to believe the compact has some very serious flaws — flaws that could set the stage for a nationwide electoral disaster.

So, now that Democrats have gained enough governorships and state legislative majorities to make it a reality if they so choose, I wanted to talk again with Amar — who’s also spoken about this on his podcast — to understand his misgivings.

Why has Amar turned against the idea? What are the flaws that concern him — and are they fatal ones? Our conversation, which has been condensed and edited, follows.

How Akhil Amar started off as an Electoral College critic

You’ve been thinking about this idea of Electoral College reform, and in particular this unusual route of reforming the Electoral College without a constitutional amendment, for a long time. Walk me through how it started for you.

The week before the 2000 election, I taught a class at Yale. Cable news came to my class and heard me predict that there was a great possibility that there might be an inversion between the Electoral College vote and the popular vote. And I said, the inversion could favor either party.

There was indeed an inversion. The New York Times called me, I think, on Wednesday and asked if I had some thoughts. I said, oh, I do. I highlighted the pro-slavery origins of the Electoral College. Because of the three-fifths clause, states with lots of slaves got the benefit of their slave population, with a discount, in the electoral vote. In a direct popular election system, they couldn’t have counted their slaves.

I wanted Americans to know that because the South voted mainly for Bush in 2000, it once again benefited from the Electoral College. So that’s what I felt right after the election. 

A year passes. And on the one year anniversary of Bush v. Gore, I publish a trilogy of internet posts with my brother, Vik. In part three we floated, just as a thought experiment, a way of improvising a direct national election that wouldn’t require a constitutional amendment.

When I published this, I never thought anyone would do anything with it. I just thought, here’s an interesting idea I had in the shower. That was a version of what would later become the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.

And the core idea is: You get enough states on board to pledge their electors to the popular vote winner. You don’t need all the states, just enough for 270 votes. You don’t need to amend the Constitution. 

Fast-forward to a few years later, when this basic idea starts to get passed into law in some Democrat-controlled states.

The first time I heard that anyone was taking it seriously was in 2006, when I was visiting professor at Pepperdine, and someone showed me a copy of the Los Angeles Times describing a bill that was on Governor Schwarzenegger’s desk. 

And that’s because of John Koza, who started the group National Popular Vote Inc., which has been lobbying in the states on this for two decades now. 

His version is not exactly the version you proposed. But it’s the one that caught on, was adopted in many states, and is now near the threshold of potentially being implemented.

I believe his motivations are completely virtuous and admirable. He is putting his resources behind this plan. He’s putting his money where his mouth is. But I’ve never met him. He’s never called me up. He didn’t consult me before pushing out his version of the plan. And if he had, I would have tried to explain to him that that version is very glitchy. 

Akhil Amar’s critiques of the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact

So let’s get into what you call the glitches. What is different about and in your view wrong with the version of the compact that states have passed, as compared to your preferred version? 

Here’s one thing that I could not have anticipated in 2001: that only blue states would hop on the bandwagon. 

My thought was, the Electoral College in 2000 happened to favor Bush, but it could have favored Gore, and the next time it might favor the Democrats. So this, I thought, would not be perceived as some Democratic partisan scheme.

“If the whole idea is that the national popular vote is fairly counted, it’s hard unless there’s buy-in by the counters everywhere, including in red states.”

But in the years since then, in part accelerated by a second inversion between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump, the perception emerged, perhaps incorrectly, that the Electoral College was skewed in favor of Republicans. And if so, why should they change that?

So as more and more states have jumped on the NPVIC bandwagon, they’ve almost all been sapphire blue or blue-tinged states, with no ruby red states on board. That portends poorly to the success of the plan, because even if you got to 270, if you do that only with blue state buy-in, there could be ways in which red states might try to sabotage the system.

As an example: We have an election. It’s nationally very close in the popular vote. So we want to do a proper recount to make sure that the result goes to the popular vote winner. But some ruby red states will say, “We weren’t part of this plan ever. The election in our state wasn’t particularly close. We don’t want to pay for any recount.”

If the whole idea is that the national popular vote is fairly counted, it’s hard unless there’s buy-in by the counters everywhere, including in red states. 

That gets at what you characterize as another big glitch, which is: Under this plan, there is no centralized body to determine what the national popular vote tally is. It’s just left up to each state, to add up the vote totals from all the other states. You see this as a big problem.

My 2001 thought experiment detoured around all that by envisioning an NGO to administer this thing. You could also have a congressional statute coming up with rules for administering a national count and recount. 

But here’s a problem: A national apparatus for counting or recounting would be controlled by a president. Maybe an incumbent president running for reelection. Would that incumbent president actually act properly and fairly? Let’s imagine that incumbent president is named Donald Trump, and it’s 2020.

People say, “States do it all the time, they handle counting and recounting, why can’t the federal government?” Most state governments don’t control millions of stormtroopers, a massive army of ICE agents and the like. 

But the current proposal that states are adopting doesn’t have any national body at all to oversee the vote tally, and you think that’s a serious problem too.

Yes, it’s Scylla and Charybdis. Here are the problems on the other side.

Let’s say, California says, “Gee, let’s let 17-year-olds vote because there’ll be more Californians in the national popular vote that way.” Then Florida says, “We’re going to let 16-year-olds vote.” And then Arkansas says, “We’re going to let dogs vote. Or we’re going to let parents vote for 12-year-old children.”

Some states make it really easy to vote and register to vote, some states don’t. Is it really a national popular vote — a “one person, one vote” system — if you have huge variation in voter eligibility, voter registration, administration on Election Day, or election month as it is in some places. 

Or, states agree to this plan. They add up to 270. And then as Election Day approaches, something may happen in an individual state, and they try to back out. What’s going to happen in that situation? Or what if they don’t back out in advance of the election, but try to change their rules after election day? What happens if a state supreme court says, “That’s not consistent with our state constitution?”

What I don’t want is for a deeply imperfect, historically tainted Electoral College system — that for all its flaws, actually works — to be replaced by a possibly catastrophic, legally glitchy new system where we don’t know who’s president, where we don’t know who won the popular vote.

The one thing we really do need to avoid as the stabilizing superpower in the world is constitutional chaos. And because this is sort of a new plan, even if it’s in principle likely to be better in all sorts of scenarios, if in a certain small percentage of cases it would lead to chaos, that’s something we need seriously consider. 

Is there a better way for Democrats to make this work?

Do you have any recommendations for a way this could be passed by Democrats with some changes that would address your concerns? Or do you think they should just call off the effort?

The least glitchy version is the one I imagined in 2001. My specific proposal involves a lot of interstate uniformity, and using an independent bipartisan mechanism. But it means going back to square one in each of the states.

Do you think that kind of independent bipartisan body can be realistically set up and win credibility today?

Maybe not. Back in the day, I was imagining that everyone thinks that Jim Lehrer of PBS NewsHour is a fair and neutral guy, that’s why he was always asked to moderate the presidential debates. I was imagining a world, like my childhood, where we all looked up to Walter Cronkite. Maybe that that world doesn’t exist anymore, maybe we can’t recreate it. 

It is possible to imagine, for example, ex-presidents of both parties who have credibility — a George W. Bush and a Barack Obama or something — trying to agree on commissioners.  

Donald Trump?

You beat me to the punch. Do ex-presidents have any credibility when Donald Trump is one of those ex-presidents? Are there any institutions that can be created that would be perceived as independent, expert, and nonpartisan? 

“There’s no perfect system, and any system is going to be under great stress when elections are very, very close.”

Some states have taken the districting issue away from legislatures and given it to nonpartisan districting commissions. You might want to ask, “Have those systems worked? Are they really nonpartisan or bipartisan or are they just kind of stinky politics by other means? Is it possible to imagine this thing being administered in a way that’s seen across the spectrum as fair and not rigged?”

The answer is, maybe not. If not, then for all its flaws, and there are many, maybe we just stick with what we’ve got. Because at least we know how it works. And it has avoided catastrophe and chaos in general. 

It was really tested in 2000 because the entire country came down to Florida, and Florida itself was so closely divided, just a few hundred votes. It’s possible, alternatively, to imagine a system in which the Electoral College is pretty clear, but the national popular vote comes down to just a few hundred votes. There’s no perfect system, and any system is going to be under great stress when elections are very, very close. 

The argument that the proponents of the NPVIC make that they keep coming back to is: The public is on our side. This is popular, it polls so well. 

Once it’s in place, yes, it’s left to the states to on good faith tally up the outcomes of the other states and pledge their electors accordingly. But they’ll do it. Because to not do it would mean flying in the face of widespread public opinion.

That relies on polls of people who don’t know enough yet to have a considered opinion.

No one is more sympathetic to the idea than I am. I’m the co-inventor. But I want my fellow citizens to at least see the risks of this new system before they say, “Yep, that’s what they want.”

Let’s actually have proper hearings. And then after people see it, maybe they’ll come up with answers I haven’t imagined, that will fix some of the glitches that I’m seeing. Let’s crowdsource this.

I’m like the fellow working in AI, who says, “Hey, AI could be really great, but it also could melt down the universe. So let’s actually do this carefully.”

History has a warning for the new Democratic majority

11 November 2026 at 22:45
Annie Andrews, James Talarico, and Troy Jackson
Sens.-elect Annie Andrews, James Talarico, and Troy Jackson — all Democrats — walk through the US Capitol as they arrive for new member orientation meetings on November 9, 2026. | Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images

This story appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.

We’re a week past the midterms now and the dust has largely settled. Sure, you still have some uncalled House races in a handful of states, and we’re still waiting with bated breath to meet the next senators from Mississippi and Alaska.

But even without those final numbers, we can say a couple things for sure: First, last week’s blue wave was the largest in more than 50 years. And second, Democrats’ real work has only just begun.

This week, the incoming members of Congress — roughly seven weeks out from their official debut — are in Washington, DC, to set up their offices and meet their new coworkers. Democrats still have to choose new leaders or stick with their old ones. And once they’ve reached some sort of consensus on that, they’ll start to confront the final boss: President Donald Trump. 

“They’re in control, but they’re really not in control,” Trump told Fox News last week, of the Democrats’ prospects in a split government. “Because they can send over, you know, 50 different great bills that they’re all excited about and I send them back with a nice stamp.”

Fortunately, amid all this jockeying and post-election euphoria, we do have some precedent to fall back on. After all, this blue wave was historically big — but not totally unheard-of. Midterm elections also ushered in huge partisan majorities in the early 1970s and 1990s. And that history suggests that Democrats have won a chance…not a guarantee.

Go a little deeper

You have to go back to the Watergate era to find a blue wave as big as last week’s. The year was 1974, the vibes were alternatingly grim and groovy, and American voters were looking for change after the scandals of Richard Nixon’s presidency. 

Democrats already controlled the House and the Senate, but that year’s midterms ushered in a class of even younger and more liberal lawmakers. And these so-called  Watergate babies came to play: They helped extend a run of post-Watergate reforms that opened up congressional proceedings, required financial disclosures from senior officials, and strengthened oversight of federal agencies.

But 52 years later, the 1974 blue wave isn’t exactly remembered as an unrivaled success — for the Dems or for democracy. Ronald Reagan became president just six years later, and both he and other presidents since have weakened the reforms of the mid-’70s.

The push to make government more transparent — by inviting television cameras into hearings, for example — also arguably made Congress a more polarized and confrontational place as lawmakers were newly incentivized to be less candid, more performative, and more rigid in their ideology. 

Other, more conservative waves have also run up against the limits of congressional power. The political scientist Robert A. Strong points to Newt Gingrich’s 1994 “revolution,” which ended four decades of Democratic House control.

But that Republican sweep, far from delivering Gingrich’s vision of a dramatically smaller government in one fell swoop, triggered bitter confrontations with President Bill Clinton, including debt-ceiling standoffs and government shutdowns. When major legislation did become law, it required compromise: A sweeping welfare overhaul only passed after Clinton vetoed prior versions twice. 

In some ways, these challenges are fairly intuitive. Even when one party controls the White House and both chambers of Congress, it still has to reconcile competing factions and navigate procedural hurdles in the Senate. And when control of those branches is split between parties, as it will be soon, you end up with even bigger obstacles — like a veto-happy president. 

Given that, Democratic voters might want to temper their expectations just a little. As my colleague Andrew Prokop laid out earlier this month, Democratic bills will — even in this new, blue environment — likely only pass through compromise or fierce confrontation. 

Making electoral history is one thing, as history itself shows. But making legislative history is an altogether tougher proposition.

One link for later

➨ Reconsider convenience. “Friction-maxxing” is all the rage these days, and while I don’t endorse hassle for its own sake…it’s certainly wise to scrutinize the trade-offs of any new time-saving technology. Gabe Bullard, the author of the new book Against Convenience, suggests the following prompts: What does this tool save me? What does it cost me? And what problem does it solve?

Before you go…

  • Did you know…that the word “computer” originally described people? Before they were machines, computers were workers (often, women) who completed tedious mathematical programs by hand or on analog calculators. 
  • Today’s trivia: The singer Leontyne Price is renowned for her work in which musical genre? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in tomorrow’s edition.)
  • Yesterday’s trivia: Yesterday we asked you for the botanist supervillain in Batman. That would be Poison Ivy, who first debuted 60 years ago in 1966.

Tino Chrupallas Alleingang

11 November 2026 at 14:41

Ein Video über Donald Trump bringt Tino Chrupalla in der eigenen Partei massiv unter Druck. Weil der AfD-Chef die US-Migrationspolitik als zu hart kritisiert, erntet er offenen Widerspruch von Alice Weidel und einen Richtungsstreit in der Fraktion.

Exklusive Einblicke in geleakte Austritts-Mails zeigen zudem, warum einst loyale Mitglieder der Partei frustriert den Rücken kehren. Die internen Dokumente offenbaren eine tiefe Entfremdung. Es geht um zunehmende Radikalisierung, Intrigen und einen pro-russischen Kurs, der langjährige Unterstützer abschreckt. Der Blick in die Postfächer zeigt schonungslos, wo die rote Linie für viele an der Basis verläuft.

Außerdem gibt es eine überraschende taktische Wende in Sachsen-Anhalt: Der AfD-Kandidat Ulrich Siegmund würde bei der Ministerpräsidentenwahl womöglich doch mehrfach antreten. Welche Rolle die CDU bei diesem Manöver spielt und was das für die künftigen Machtverhältnisse bedeutet, ordnet diese Folge präzise ein.

„Inside AfD“ ist der POLITICO-Podcast über die umstrittenste Partei des Landes. Trotz Radikalisierung und Beobachtung durch den Verfassungsschutz wächst die AfD weiter. Wie ist das möglich? Was treibt ihre Anhänger, Strategen und Gegner an? Wie funktioniert das Innenleben der Partei? Und was bedeutet ihr Aufstieg für das politische System Deutschlands?

Antworten liefern immer mittwochs Pauline von Pezold von POLITICO und Frederik Schindler von WELT — unaufgeregt, aber kritisch.

Fragen und Feedback gern an insideafd@politico.eu.

POLITICO Deutschland – ein Angebot der Axel Springer Deutschland GmbH
Axel-Springer-Straße 65, 10888 Berlin
Tel: +49 (30) 2591 0
information@axelspringer.de
Sitz: Amtsgericht Berlin-Charlottenburg, HRB 196159 B
USt-IdNr: DE 214 852 390
Geschäftsführer: Christoph Eck-Schmidt, Carolin Hulshoff Pol, Mathias Sanchez Luna

Politicians Love to Praise the Troops. But US Law Actually Treats Them as Tools.

11 November 2026 at 13:20

This book excerpt is part of Cafe, TPM’s home for opinion and news analysis. It was adapted from Saira Mohamed’s What a Country Owes Its Soldiers.

Despite Donald Trump’s promises that he would be the peace president, the United States continues to be very much at war, from the forcible abduction of the Venezuelan president to the devastating conflict in Iran. As ever, the country professes its support for the troops, but we hear little about the military personnel in these operations — a day or two of stories on the horrendous conditions on board the USS Lincoln or the losses of American service members in the war in Iran. Typically, the deaths and the injuries are accepted as inevitable, perhaps as tragedies. War is necessarily life-threatening for those who fight it — theirs but to do and die, in Tennyson’s words. Such is the nature of military service, right? And so we thank soldiers for their service and call what they endure a profound sacrifice.

But this is not the only way to think about the military. In some countries, there’s a limit on what military personnel are expected to endure, and governments have a duty to take care of their service members — not just as veterans, but during the course of their service. There’s a basic understanding that even though war is necessarily life-threatening, not all threats to the lives of soldiers are necessary.

Here in the United States, by contrast, there is no such understanding. During these last two decades of war, hundreds of U.S. service members have died in accidents outside of combat, from rollovers of armored vehicles to collisions of ships to crashes of deteriorating aircraft. Untold numbers suffer traumatic brain injuries when they fire their own weapons because commanders won’t implement safety protocols. They develop deadly cancers because of toxic gases their leaders knew were spewing from the burn pits on bases. These are injuries and deaths that even the military admits are preventable. And this is to say nothing of those who have lost their lives in the Iran war (the number of which the Pentagon refuses to disclose), an avoidable conflict for which the administration cannot articulate a coherent rationale). In a country that claims to honor its service members, these kinds of harms should be staggering. But instead, they’re hardly noticed.

Hegseth escapes impeachment — for now

11 November 2026 at 00:55
Pete Hegseth, wearing a suit, walks toward a stage past a blue curtain as reporters look on.
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth arrives to a news conference at the Pentagon on November 10, 2026. | Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.

Welcome to The Logoff: Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has narrowly escaped impeachment — for now. 

What’s happening? On Tuesday evening, the House voted to refer an impeachment resolution against Hegseth to committee, functionally dooming it. 

The vote, which fell along party lines with the exception of Republican Rep. Thomas Massie, who joined Democrats in voting against the referral, is a victory for Hegseth. The defense secretary’s future at the Pentagon has been under intense speculation since voters resoundingly repudiated President Donald Trump and the war with Iran in last week’s midterm elections. 

Prior to Tuesday’s vote, Hegseth had been facing impeachment as early as tomorrow on eight articles filed against him by Massie on Monday.

Why did Massie want to impeach Hegseth? Broadly speaking, it’s because Hegseth is the public face of the extremely unpopular war with Iran, now in its eighth month, and he appeared vulnerable as even some Republicans voiced their dissatisfaction (though not, evidently, enough dissatisfaction for them to support impeachment). 

Specifically, Massie charged Hegseth with:

  1. Waging war in Iran in violation of the War Powers Resolution (three total charges); 
  2. Disregarding laws intended to minimize civilian casualties; 
  3. Committing extrajudicial killings by carrying out missile strikes on alleged drug boats in the Caribbean and the Pacific; 
  4. Suppressing free speech by trying to retaliate against Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ), a retired Navy captain, for a video by Kelly and other Democratic lawmakers reminding service members that they have a responsibility to refuse illegal orders; 
  5. Kidnapping former Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and his wife earlier this year; and 
  6. Waging an unlawful war in Yemen last year.

What’s the big picture? Hegseth escaped, for now, with the support of Trump and Vice President JD Vance, as well as newly installed White House chief of staff Stephen Miller. 

But he could face another impeachment effort in the new year, with more than enough votes in the incoming Democratic House majority to see it pass (though not enough in the Senate for conviction and removal). 

If that occurs, Hegseth will become the third Cabinet secretary in history to be impeached — and the second in less than three years.

And with that, it’s time to log off…

Vox’s Unexplainable podcast sat down with author Emily St. John Mandel (of Station Eleven fame) to talk about how she deploys science in her fiction. It’s a great conversation, and you can listen to it here. 

Plus, a quick programming note: I’ll be off tomorrow for Veterans Day! One of my excellent colleagues will be standing in here, and I’ll be back Thursday. Have a great evening!

Christians are now getting freaked out by Trump

10 November 2026 at 00:25
Donald Trump sitting in a chair opposite Ross Douthat, who is interviewing him in the Roosevelt Room of the White House.
In his first sit-down interview since the midterm elections, President Donald Trump speaks with Ross Douthat in the Roosevelt Room at the White House. | CBS News via Getty Images

Every week, millions of Christians gather to worship and remember the tenets of the faith: belief in God, in Jesus Christ as his son and their savior, and in the Holy Spirit. Many utter the words of the Lord’s Prayer each week, and in doing so, ask that God forgive our sins, as we forgive those who trespass against us.

These are the ABCs of the Christian faith — and they should theoretically be an easy answer to offer if, like President Donald Trump, you’re asked what might happen when you die, and what you might do when Judgment Day comes.

And yet, when asked last week by Ross Douthat on 60 Minutes where Trump thinks he’ll go when he dies — and if he could forgive his political enemies if his salvation depended on it — Trump was brutally honest.

“Well, I’m a religious person, so in theory I go to heaven,” he said. “I hope so. I don’t want to go to hell.”

Could he forgive opponents like former FBI Director James Comey and former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi?

“Well, then I wouldn’t be real, would I? I mean, if I said to you, sure, the easy answer to that is ‘Oh, yes, I could forgive,’” Trump told Douthat. “The answer is no. I want to be honest, no.”

Even if God asked it?

“Before the judgment, no,” he said. “I do hate some of my enemies…I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies and I always will.”

“I'm a religious person, so in theory I go to heaven,” President Trump says, discussing what he thinks happens after death. “I don't want to go to hell.” https://t.co/8o5y8hcqtY pic.twitter.com/5LexpK2jEP

— 60 Minutes (@60Minutes) November 9, 2026

The statements shook many Christians who watched clips or heard him say this on CBS. Perhaps the most interesting reaction has come from the religious right, from evangelicals, Catholics, and other Christians who have long sided with the president over the last decade of MAGA. 

They’ve long defended him, seeing him and his movement as a vehicle to spread the Christian gospel and win policy victories, like banning abortion, restricting IVF, and fighting back against the rising tide of social progressivism. But in the wake of stunning losses for Republicans in last week’s midterm elections, when Trump’s grip on the GOP seems most tenuous, another crack seems to have emerged in his alliance with the Christian right.

And that’s because his answers essentially removed the plausible deniability of the argument that many Christians have used to justify their votes for Trump: that though an “imperfect vessel,” he was still a Christian, had received the gospel, and wants to be saved.

His close ally, the evangelical pastor Franklin Graham, explained the importance of the question (but did not directly address Trump’s forgiveness response) in a post on X: “Heaven has borders. Heaven has unique and very strict entrance requirements. To enter Heaven, the Bible tells us that you must acknowledge your sins, turn from them in repentance, and receive Jesus Christ by faith.” Trump’s response to the question about heaven, though, showed no understanding of these requirements.

“Religion can’t save you — only a relationship with the Savior, Jesus Christ, can save you,” Graham continued. “Do you have that assurance?” 

In unambiguous terms, Trump basically said he doesn’t.

Why conservative Christians are actually divided over Trump this time

That someone like Graham, one of the most widely respected American evangelical leaders, would weigh in at all this time shows how serious the concerns are among conservative Christians. In previous moments this year, when Trump has similarly tested the religious right, it was easier to dismiss blasphemy, in part because it was directed at Catholics like Pope Leo XIV and his bishops (with whom politically conservative Catholics tend to have disagreements) , or could be dismissed as a joke — as when he shared AI art of himself as Jesus Christ. After strong backlash from evangelicals over that meme, he backed down and deleted the post.

This time, the criticism is coming from all over — from theological conservatives like the Eastern Orthodox Rod Dreher, from evangelicals and other Christians, from Catholics — and that’s because there are multiple problematic layers to his most recent polemic.

For the longest time, it was easier for Trump allies to say that though he was an imperfect sinner, Trump could still be saved, could still do good for their movement, or argue that he was still a Christian.

But that’s much harder to do when he is failing multiple tests — including the most important one for evangelicals: having and declaring a personal relationship and belief in Jesus Christ is kind of the main thing, the key to being able to call yourself a Christian and have hope of being saved at the hour of judgment. Being “religious” doesn’t get you to heaven; being saved by grace through faith in Christ does.

Graham summed it quickly when describing what it means to “receive Jesus Christ by faith”:

“That means, believe that Jesus Christ is God’s Son, that He paid the penalty for your sins by dying on a cross, was buried in a tomb, raised to life on the third day, and walked out of that tomb.”

I watched @CBS @60Minutes tonight, and Ross Douthat interviewed President @realDonaldTrump. Toward the end of the interview, they talked about something far more important than politics. He asked the President, at 80 years of age and after surviving multiple assassination…

— Franklin Graham (@Franklin_Graham) November 9, 2026

That Trump was unable to say this to Douthat throws a wrench in one of the common defenses of the authenticity of Trump’s faith. And to some evangelicals, the fact Trump wasn’t able to say this was revelatory: a sign that none of the ministers, priests, pastors, or faithful who work for him have been able to convert his heart or help him be born-again.

The evangelical theologian Al Mohler, the president of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, put it this way on his podcast on Monday: “It’s also very clear that [Trump] certainly needs to hear the gospel.”

He continued to say that he will be “praying for him, with a renewed sense of urgency, that he has an experience of grace that he comes to know the Lord Jesus Christ as savior, that he knows the forgiveness of sins.”

It’s that second point about forgiveness that got Trump in trouble with more Christians — forgiving your enemies, and praying for them, is one of the core tenets of the Christian faith, and of gospel teachings.

Dreher also referenced this part in his X post when he referred to “the pettiness and hatred in that man’s heart. He is literally a character in Dante’s Inferno. Despite being given so much in life, he hates his enemies more than he fears God.”

Now, none of this is to say that Trump has fully lost the Christian right — most of the evidence points to evangelical Christians and a collection of other Protestant, Mormon, and other Christians still backing him and the GOP in polling and elections, albeit by smaller shares than before.

But for the first time in the decade-long Trump era, his hold on this movement is precarious. After appearing to compromise on a range of priorities for them, he and the GOP have suffered a once-in-a-generation loss. Trump is now digging into a nihilist, “post-Christian” identity, in Dreher’s words, demonstrating he is unrepentant even in defeat. This all puts the religious right in uncharted waters.

Years ago, Douthat himself pondered what American politics and society might look like if the right gave up on God. Now, in the wake of political devastation for the right, he has presented a new question: What might the religious right look like if it gave up on Trump?

Trump’s mixed messages on immigration

10 November 2026 at 00:10
Donald Trump, out of focus and wearing a white baseball cap, is seen on the right side of the frame; behind him, Stephen Miller sits in the presidential limo, looking down.
Stephen Miller waits in the presidential limo as Donald Trump speaks to reporters in West Palm Beach, Florida, on November 6, 2026. | Samuel Corum/Getty Images

This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.

Welcome to The Logoff: Is Donald Trump’s immigration agenda about to get even more draconian — or less? 

What’s happening? As of Monday, immigration hardliner Stephen Miller — and if anything, “hardliner” undersells it — is Trump’s new chief of staff. 

Miller, who was also a senior aide in Trump’s first term, is an ideologue and the force behind many of Trump’s harshest immigration policies, such as a 3,000-arrests-per-day quota for ICE officers; broadly speaking, his elevation forebodes an even darker and more aggressive final two years of Trump’s presidency.

It’s also sharply in contrast with Trump’s recent comments on immigration in his first sit-down interview since his party’s midterms wipeout. 

What did Trump say? In an interview with 60 Minutes’s Ross Douthat that aired Sunday, Trump not only conceded that some of his immigration policies “might be too tough” and had hurt his party at the polls, but he floated the possibility that a bipartisan immigration deal could be “actually doable.” 

“There’s a large part of the country that thinks that they should be allowed to stay if they’re good people working in a landscaping company or working in a hotel or doing something,” Trump told Douthat. 

What’s the context? Trump has occasionally flirted with immigration legislation, including a first-term proposal pairing a citizenship deal for DACA recipients with border wall funding and legal immigration cuts that never went anywhere. More recently, in June 2025, he expressed similar concerns about the impact of immigration enforcement on hospitality and agriculture, but the change didn’t live out the week. 

Will anything come of this? Anything’s possible, especially with powerful Democratic majorities incoming. But it hasn’t happened yet, and with Miller in the chief of staff’s office, it remains unlikely, to say the least. (Plus, some very loud parts of his own party absolutely hate the idea.)

On Monday, House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, the likely next speaker of the House, said Miller “is a stone-cold racist. … I’ve got zero interest in working with that kind of individual.”

And with that, it’s time to log off…

Have you seen an “Ask me about metro” hat out in the wild recently? What about an ugly Christmas sweater with a train on it? 

If so, you’re not alone: Public transit merch, The Atlantic reported, has been experiencing a boom lately. (I’m not immune to it: I have an Amtrak poster on my wall.) You can read all about the trend with a gift link here. 

Have a great evening, and we’ll see you tomorrow!

Why the Nvidia CEO’s resignation is so important

12 November 2026 at 21:35
Jensen Huang on a panel of speakers holding a microphone
Jensen Huang, CEO of Nvidia, pictured at the Invest in Germany Summit on October 19, 2026 in Berlin. | Thomas Koehler/Photothek via Getty Images

Editor’s note, November 12, 3:35 pm ET: This story was originally posted on November 9 and is being republished today in light of Jensen Huang’s resignation as Nvidia CEO.

The movie version of Jensen Huang’s jaw-dropping affair basically writes itself. 

Cast BD Wong as 63-year-old Huang, the CEO of one of the world’s most valuable companies and a close friend of President Donald Trump. Kelly Hu can play Alice Huang, Jensen’s paramour and — even better — a purported agent of the Chinese government. 

The role of Trump himself, who reportedly knew about Huang’s undercover girlfriend but on Sunday said Huang “probably has an excuse for it,” can be played by Alec Baldwin. (Or a flightless duck — your pick.) However you cast it, this whole sordid affair has “serialized Netflix drama” written all over it.

But in all seriousness…the possibility that one of the world’s most powerful men was targeted by Chinese intelligence is a big deal on multiple scores. Nvidia has opened its own investigation into whether Huang was compromised, and congressional leaders have requested he brief them in a closed-door session.

Nvidia supplies much of the computing power behind the AI boom, giving it enormous influence over the broader economy. “If they sneeze, everybody else catches a cold,” the writer and economic commentator Kyla Scanlon told Vox’s Today, Explained podcast last year. That makes this whole episode a little more weighty than your standard billionaire’s affair.

Go a little deeper

Nvidia is the most valuable company on Earth — but in many households, it’s still not a household name.

Huang and two other electrical engineers founded the now-$4.5-trillion company in 1993 with the fairly niche and nerdy goal of making high-powered chips that could render the 3D graphics for a new generation of video games. 

Then, in 2006, the company released software tools that let programmers use its chips for other demanding computing tasks, like mining cryptocurrency and training AI models. When companies like OpenAI began developing tools like ChatGPT, they immediately turned to Nvidia. 

That made the company a cornerstone of America’s AI buildout and a major economic force. In 2024, Nvidia alone accounted for more than a fifth of the S&P 500’s total return. And the rush to build out AI infrastructure has accounted for much of America’s recent economic growth, according to St. Louis Fed researchers.

Nvidia’s influence extends to the White House, too, where Huang is a regular guest of Trump. The two became fast friends after having dinner together at Mar-a-Lago last year, and Huang has said Trump regularly calls him late at night to discuss topics like “protecting national security” and “creating more jobs.” 

But Huang’s ambitions have run up against one major obstacle: US restrictions on selling Nvidia’s most advanced chips to China. US officials worry that their enormous computing power could help Beijing develop weapons, strengthen its military, expand surveillance, and otherwise rival US military and technological dominance.

That helps explain why China (allegedly) sicced a spy on Huang: They really want these chips. The New York Times reports that China’s top intelligence agency recruited Alice Huang both to learn more about America’s advanced chip industry and to potentially influence Nvidia’s push to lift export restrictions. Alice Huang, it should be noted, was a data center executive in her own right, and her company has been investigated for purportedly helping to smuggle Nvidia chips into China. 

All these investigations will hopefully, eventually, reveal whether their affair compromised anything beyond Huang’s marriage. They may also test how dependent Nvidia is on his leadership. 

With Huang out as CEO, uncertainty over the company’s future could unsettle investors and trigger wobbles in the wider market. That’s the problem with concentrating so much power in any one person or company: One person’s (very) personal business can somehow become everybody’s problem. 

One link for later

➨ Get a hobby. But not just any hobby: something that’s intentionally imperfect, unproductive or unquantified. There’s a tendency in American culture to try to optimize or commodify our leisure, the writer Jenny Odell explains. But that undermines some of leisure’s biggest benefits — like cultivating a sense of joy, wonder, or learning.

Before you go…

  • Did you know…that Alexander Graham Bell reportedly wanted people to answer the phone with a cheerful “ahoy”? Alas, Thomas Edison’s preferred greeting — “hello” — won out instead.
  • Today’s trivia: Cleopatra was killed by what animal, according to several contemporaneous accounts? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in tomorrow’s edition.)
  • Yesterday’s trivia: Last week we asked you for Ricky Martin’s biggest hit. That would be “Livin’ La Vida Loca,” the 1999 bop that’s widely credited with launching the Latin pop explosion of the late 1990s and early 2000s.  

This post intially appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.

Die Kür der Ilse Aigner

9 November 2026 at 05:30

Heute Mittag werden CDU und CSU also Ilse Aigner als ihre Kandidatin für das Bundespräsidentenamt vorschlagen. Gordon Repinski saß kurz vor der offiziellen Nominierung mit Aigner im Flugzeug und ordnet ein, wie die Politikerin nun die nötige überparteiliche Unterstützung gewinnen will.

Um tatsächlich Staatsoberhaupt zu werden, ist Aigner auf die Stimmen der politischen Konkurrenz angewiesen. Im 200-Sekunden-Interview erklärt die Grünen-Co-Fraktionschefin Britta Haßelmann, warum sie den Findungsprozess der Union für unwürdig hält – und warum ihre Partei der ersten Frau im höchsten Staatsamt voraussichtlich trotzdem zur Mehrheit verhelfen wird.

Währenddessen bahnt sich in Abu Dhabi eine neue diplomatische Dynamik an: Bei anstehenden Gesprächen zwischen der Ukraine und Russland sitzen US-Vermittler am Tisch, während Europa erneut außen vor bleibt. Hans von der Burchard analysiert, welche weitreichenden Pläne das Umfeld von Donald Trump schmiedet und was diese neue Sicherheitsarchitektur für den Kontinent bedeutet.

Das Berlin Playbook als Podcast gibt es jeden Morgen ab 5 Uhr. Rixa Fürsen, Maximilian Stascheit und das POLITICO-Team liefern Politik zum Hören – kompakt, international, hintergründig.

Für alle Hauptstadt-Profis: Der Berlin Playbook-Newsletter bietet jeden Morgen die wichtigsten Themen und Einordnungen. Jetzt kostenlos abonnieren.

POLITICO Deutschland – ein Angebot der Axel Springer Deutschland GmbH
Axel-Springer-Straße 65, 10888 Berlin
Tel: +49 (30) 2591 0
information@axelspringer.de
Sitz: Amtsgericht Berlin-Charlottenburg, HRB 196159 B
USt-IdNr: DE 214 852 390
Geschäftsführer: Christoph Eck-Schmidt, Carolin Hulshoff Pol, Mathias Sanchez Luna

**(Anzeige) Eine Nachricht von YouTube: Verlässliche Finanzierung für Qualitätsjournalismus: Damit unabhängige Berichterstattung im Netz wirtschaftlich tragen kann, braucht es faire Erlösmodelle. Laut einer Studie von Oxford Economics geben 76 % der Medienunternehmen mit YouTube-Kanal an, dass die Plattform eine wichtige Einnahmequelle für ihr Geschäft darstellt. Hier klicken für mehr Informationen zum wirtschaftlichen Beitrag von YouTube.**

Did the midterms kill MAGA?

8 November 2026 at 13:00
JD Vance, seen at an angle, gives a thumbs-up as he stands behind a podium.
Vice President JD Vance gestures as he takes the stage at a campaign rally in Swanton, Ohio, on November 2, 2026. | Tom Brenner/Getty Images

In 2015, Donald Trump descended a golden escalator and launched a presidential campaign that reshaped American politics. More than a decade later, with his record-low approval ratings and the US embroiled in a war with Iran, he asked voters to treat the 2026 midterms as a referendum on him. 

“Please pretend I’m on the ballot. Because in a way, I am on the ballot,” Trump told a crowd in North Carolina last month.

As it turns out, voters did as Trump asked: Democrats won in a landslide, taking control of both chambers of Congress with victories in Republican strongholds like South Carolina and Kansas. Now, Republicans have to decide what those losses mean for the future of the movement Trump built. 

As Vox’s Andrew Prokop reported, there are already competing explanations for the losses that are taking shape on the right. “The reason we lost is the war,” Vice President JD Vance posted on social media. The conservative commentator Erick Erickson offered a longer list of reasons for the GOP’s failure: “It was also the corruption. The incompetence. The tariffs. The playing nice with Russia. The impression of cruelty. The overly aggressive deportations.” Others emphasized affordability. “Life is too expensive,” right-wing commentator Benny Johnson wrote. “Especially for young people.”

Whoever defines what went wrong will likely help determine which parts of Trump’s politics survive, and who gets to lead the presidential ticket in 2028.

The conservative writer Rod Dreher has a stake in that debate. He supported Trump in 2024. He’s friends with Vance, and he shares the vice president’s interest in combining social conservatism with economic policies that support families. His critiques come from someone who wanted this administration to succeed. 

Today, Explained co-host Noel King spoke with Dreher about whether the midterms mean the end of MAGA, what might replace it, and whether Republicans can move past a president who still has two years left in office.

Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.

Before the midterm results even came in, you wrote that Republicans were likely to be shellacked and that they had nobody to blame but Donald Trump and themselves. What do you think it is your fellow conservatives need to admit today? 

That MAGA is over. It’s done. It’s been a failure. It brought Trump to power twice. I think there were some good ideas in MAGA and certainly the old Republican establishment, the pre-Trump establishment, needed to go. 

But MAGA couldn’t deliver on good government. And if you can’t deliver on good government, it doesn’t matter how charismatic the leader is. It’s not going to work. And I think that there can be no doubt after this week’s election that it was a complete referendum on Donald Trump and he failed. And we have to build from there.

You supported Trump in 2024. At the time you wrote that you were aware of some of his failings. I think many people who voted for Trump were aware of some of his failings, but he had a mandate. 

He had the popular vote, he had the House, he had the Senate. Why couldn’t MAGA, his movement, deliver on good government? 

“But MAGA couldn’t deliver on good government. And if you can’t deliver on good government, it doesn’t matter how charismatic the leader is.”

I think that it all comes down to the fact that Trump made decisions based not on rational calculation, by listening to expert advice, but on gut instinct. 

I think that the wheels began to fall off of the Trump train on April 2, 2025. That was the so-called Liberation Day when Trump announced these wide tariffs. They weren’t thought out at all. They just came out of his gut. And that set a pattern for the way that Trump made decisions. Plus. he promoted people not based on competence, but based on loyalty to him, personal loyalty. 

I think this administration has gone from one crisis to another because of that, because Trump doesn’t have a theory or practice of governance. When he came into office, he signed a bunch of executive orders. Some of them did things that I thought were really good, but he didn’t turn them into legislation. This is a guy whose party held both houses of Congress and the White House, yet he just sailed right along as if he was going to be president forever. 

And then of course, this gets us to the Iran war, which was another gut instinct thing by Trump, which became the symbol for all of the disasters of Trumpism. 

Can MAGA be divorced from Donald Trump? Can it exist without Donald Trump? 

No, MAGA is Donald Trump. Donald Trump himself said so. The challenge is going to be, how does the Republican Party rebuild and regroup for 2028 with Trump still in the White House? 

I mean, think about it. They’re fighting a two-front battle now. You’re going to have to fight the Democrats, who are energized, who are going to come in and make the next two years — justifiably, I would say — about investigating Trump administration corruption. 

But they’re also going to have to fight Donald Trump himself. Sitting in the White House, he’s not going to shut up. He’s not going to do what is best for his party. He’s going to try to salvage his legacy.

What is the next conservative movement? Where do conservatives go from here? 

The next few months are going to be really interesting in this respect. Until now, everybody on the right has thought that JD Vance, the vice president, is Trump’s natural successor, even though he hasn’t announced whether or not he’s going to run. I think that has now been called severely into question. 

I say this as someone who’s a personal friend of the vice president and would like to see him be president one day. Nevertheless, even though he strongly opposed the Iran war from behind the scenes, he and Marco Rubio and everyone else in this administration are tied to it and all the other failures of Trumpism. 

So who does that leave on the outside? I was very surprised, in the past 24 hours, to see and hear Gov. Ron DeSantis, the outgoing governor of Florida, who as we all remember, ran against Trump for the Republican nomination and never stood a chance. He’s not charismatic. He’s super competent, but not charismatic. And so Trump won the 2024 nomination. 

Well, now DeSantis is coming out making strong, clear, rational critiques of MAGA and Trumpism. And I think that DeSantis could be the outside candidate who has the best [chance] because he’s the only national Republican politician not tainted by Trumpism. 

JD Vance is a friend of yours. He’s credited you with getting him involved in politics. You say you’d like to see him be president. I think a legitimate question following what we’ve seen over the past two years and then last night is why? 

Why do you want JD Vance to be president? 

JD Vance has been associated with the national conservatism movement, as have I — the movement started by Yoram Hazony, which has been about prioritizing national sovereignty, national interest, a cultural conservatism that is also in favor of economic reforms to make it easier to raise families. 

JD Vance has been the avatar for that sort of conservatism. I see the bones of this kind of conservatism within Trump and MAGA, but it got completely crushed by Trump’s own obsessions. If JD can go back to the man I think he is deep down and start to champion this sort of thing — more of a pro-family economic liberalism with social conservatism and no new wars — if it’s possible for any Republican to claim that now, then I think that he could have a chance. 

I think he is a good man. I have criticized him publicly, in print, as a friend for not separating himself from the bigots on the dissident right — the antisemites and the white nationalists. This extremist crowd is going to make a bid for power in the rubble of MAGA. And I think whether it’s JD or whoever becomes a Republican standard bearer is going to have to face them down. 

We’ve talked about JD Vance. We have talked about Ron DeSantis. They represent different things within conservatism. Tucker Carlson represents something else within conservatism. I think it’s something you don’t like very much. And, um, and then there’s Marco Rubio, who represents something that we were all familiar with from the early aughts. 

What do you think of these two other boldface names as we head into 2028? 

Tucker Carlson has beclowned himself, and it’s really sad. As someone who used to be friends with him, I thought he was a sensible, interesting commentator who often said a lot of common-sense things. But sometime in the last couple of years, he lost his mind and became antisemitic and just a crazy conspiracy theorist. 

A lot of people are worried about his influence on the vice president because they’ve been close for years. Tucker was key in getting Donald Trump to choose JD Vance as vice president. I have no inside knowledge of that at all, but it worries me as well. I think JD is his own man, but it’s going to be very hard for JD going forward to maintain viability as a potential Republican Party leader until and unless he addresses the Tucker Carlson problem. 

I don’t think Tucker’s going to run for president. If he did that, he could only be a spoiler, and I don’t think he actually wants it. 

In Marco Rubio’s case, he’s been a real chameleon. He was against MAGA. He was the neocon’s neocon for a while, but he has been a faithful servant and executor of Trump’s foreign policy. And for some reason, it doesn’t seem to have stuck to him the way it has stuck to JD Vance. I’m not sure why that is, but with all of these guys who have been part of the Trump administration, it’s gonna be very, very hard to cut that albatross from around their neck. 

One of the dynamics that we’ve seen in the Trump era over the last decade is that Republicans in Congress don’t want to stand up to Donald Trump. They don’t want to cross him.

What should Republicans in Congress do? Should they finally grow a spine and say, “Look, we don’t have to obey every single thing that President Trump says”?

Absolutely. I mean, what do they have to lose now? 

Trump has never been loyal to anybody who’s pledged loyalty to him. Greg Abbott, the three-term governor of Texas who lost his bid for reelection — no sooner had the election been called and Trump put out a statement calling him a RINO. 

Trump is not loyal. And so there is nothing in it left for Republicans to stick with him. He’s not going to be a factor in 2028. Maybe they want his endorsement in the 2028 primaries. Really? After this? That would be the kiss of death. 

Republicans are now, and Congress is now, going to have to find a spine and stand up and establish some independence. If they had done that earlier, we might not be in the situation today.

Trump doubles down on everything that lost him the midterms

7 November 2026 at 00:20
Donald Trump, out of focus in the foreground, leans through a door on Air Force One to speak to reporters; in the background, Stephen Miller and Karoline Leavitt watch.
Donald Trump speaks to reporters on Air Force One as Stephen Miller and Karoline Leavitt watch on July 29, 2025. | Andrew Harnik/Getty Images

This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.

Welcome to The Logoff: President Donald Trump is doubling down after a midterm annihilation. 

What happened? On Friday afternoon, Trump announced that longtime aide Stephen Miller would take over as White House chief of staff, replacing Susie Wiles. In a post to Truth Social, Trump said that Miller would start on Monday, but the change appears to be effective more or less immediately — Wiles has already resigned. 

Why the change? Trump was reportedly angry with Wiles over the GOP’s collapse in the midterm elections, which saw Democrats winning up and down the ballot even in traditionally deep-red parts of the country. 

Trump, for his part, told reporters on Friday that Wiles had “done a very good job.” But, he added, “we gotta make moves. Sometimes in life, you have to make moves.”

What should I know about Miller? Miller is currently the White House deputy chief of staff for policy, as well as homeland security adviser. More importantly, he’s the architect and engine of some of Trump’s most vicious immigration policies, including family separation (during the first Trump term) and ICE’s current campaign of indiscriminate, militarized immigration enforcement. 

He’s also an ally of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who has to be feeling a little bit better about his imperiled job (though it won’t keep Hegseth from facing impeachment in the near future).

What does this mean for the Trump presidency? More of the same, cranked up to 11. Miller is as hardline as they come, and he’s certain to push Trump to be even more aggressive on immigration and attempts to use the machinery of government to attack their shared political enemies. 

It’s all going to be extraordinarily unpopular, if Tuesday’s midterm results are anything to go by — but with just over two years left in the White House, there’s little reason to believe that Miller and Trump won’t try to push the power of the presidency to its breaking point.

And with that, it’s time to log off…

Let’s end the week on a high note with this piece from my colleague Christian Paz, who writes that “the decency was the point” for voters and Democratic candidates alike in the 2026 midterms. You can read it here with a gift link.

If you’d prefer something even lighter to head into the weekend, I also recommend the Smithsonian’s cheetah cam. Enjoy, have a great weekend, and we’ll see you on Monday! 

❌