From left, Russian President Vladimir Putin, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and President Donald Trump take part in a trilateral meeting in Shenzhen, China. | Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images
This story appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.
President Donald Trump is on his way back from China after a four-day Asia trip that included taking in a surreal cover of “Y.M.C.A.,” heaping praise on a noted kleptocrat, and making earnest — if slightly cringe! — declarations of star-crossed presidential friendship.
But the highlight of the trip was surely Trump’s unprecedented trilateral meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, the first between those countries’ leaders.
The three men sat around a comically large and reflective roundtable to discuss issues like reforming the United Nations, increasing the world’s supply of petroleum, and reducing the risk of nuclear war, which they all thankfully agree would be a bad idea.
A major nuclear treaty between the US and Russia lapsed nine months ago, and China has been a sticking point to negotiating a new one. In fact, all three countries are — in one realm or another — major obstacles to each other’s geopolitical ambitions.
Accordingly, no breakthroughs were reached during their hour-long chat. But they did agree to keep chatting…including about nuclear proliferation.
How, exactly, did we get here? To find out, I reached out to Rose Gottemoeller, the chief negotiator of the New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty, or New START — that US-Russia nuclear deal that just recently expired.
The original START was signed in 1991, just before the collapse of the Soviet Union. For the first time, the two countries agreed not just to stop growing their nuclear arsenals, but to actively reduce their strategic weapons.
New START slashed their stockpiles even further: to 700 missiles, 800 launchers, and 1,550 deployed warheads, Gottemoeller said. (When you consider that the world had roughly 70,000 nuclear warheads at the peak of the Cold War, it’s a pretty massive accomplishment.)
But New START was negotiated during a brief, shining, Obama-era moment of optimism for nuclear arms control. Then Russia started getting grabby in Ukraine, and that optimism curdled.
The treaty was extended once, in 2021, about a year before Putin began a full-scale invasion. Since then, neither country has been in a particularly diplomatic mood. On the contrary, both Trump and Putin have at times signaled they might be a little nuke-curious.
The good news, of course, is that neither president ever acted on that curiosity. And in fact, the lapse of New START earlier this year hasn’t triggered a buildup. “So far Russia and the United States are sticking with the status quo limits,” Gottemoeller told Vox.
The bad news is that either country could reverse course, and there are complications to negotiating firmer limits in the future. One of the biggies is China, which is rapidly building up its own nuclear stockpile — and thus disincentivizing Russia and the US from cutting theirs back further.
That’s the context for this morning’s trilateral, where Trump spoke explicitly about nuclear arms control before heading into the closed-door meeting. Gottemoeller, for her part, said she was “hopeful” the summit would “be a catalyst for new talks with the Russians [and] also nudge open the door to first talks with the Chinese.”
We’ll have to wait and see about all that. But the three leaders did release a vague post-summit statement that reaffirmed “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought.” That, crucially, is a callback to a statement that US and Russian leaders released in 1985 after a summit that reinvigorated nuclear arms-control talks.
One link for later
➨ Talk to more strangers. That occasionally awkward but ultimately life-affirming small talk helps you feel connected to other people. And according to University of Kansas researcher Jeffrey Hall, it boosts your entire community, too. By offering “dignity to another person…and by stretching yourself outside just the people you know well, you’re actually building a healthier environment for all of us,” Hall says.
Before you go…
Did you know…that almost 15 percent of adults suffer from tinnitus — a persistent, often ringing sound in their heads? It was once believed to be psychosomatic, but new research suggests it’s the result of a very specific type of hearing damage.
Today’s trivia: Which popular therapy method was influenced by Buddhism? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in tomorrow’s edition.)
Yesterday’s trivia: Yesterday we asked you for the name of the US soccer player who scored the game-winning penalty kick at the 1999 Women’s World Cup. That would be Brandi Chastain, who famously — iconically! — fell to her knees and tore her jersey off in celebration.
Former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang sits for an interview with Bloomberg News in London on October 14, 2026. | Bloomberg via Getty Images
If you didn’t know a lot about Nvidia a month ago, what you know now is salacious, essential, and probably a little bit misleading.
The multitrillion-dollar chipmaker has primarily been in the news because its co-founder and CEO Jensen Huang had a few affairs — one with a possible spy — and resigned. This has been a huge story, not just because of the sex scandal but also because Nvidia has been propping up the entire AI industry, as its primary chip supplier and frequent financier, and, by proxy, propping up the global economy.
The downside risk is almost catastrophic: If Huang brings Nvidia down with him, the whole economic house of cards could collapse.
That doesn’t mean it will avoid a reckoning, But the reckoning is much broader than the Huang storyline — and if it comes, might even be beneficial.
Nvidia is facing a raft of investigations and potential new regulations as a more AI-skeptical Congress prepares to take power, not to mention growing competition from tech giants, like Google, that have started making their own highly advanced chips for AI. There are also signs that the chips that made Nvidia so profitable won’t be as critical in the next chapter of the AI era. So maybe Nvidia was already in trouble before the world learned more than it wanted to about Jensen Huang’s sex life.
More broadly, a shakeup in the apparently very precarious AI industry could end up being a good thing. Free market capitalism tends to thrive when there’s more competition. And, just maybe, we stand to benefit from more scrutiny into tech giants like Nvidia and their executives. There’s reason to believe real shakeup at Nvidia — even a fall from its exalted perch and its role as the money factory of the AI world — could turn out to be the right thing for consumers, healthy for the market, and useful in the event of the AI bubble bursting.
Why Nvidia matters to normies (yes, even you)
You might be wondering what any of this has to do with you. Nvidia’s top chips can cost more than a car, and precious few humans have ever even seen one. Why should the escapades of a leather jacket-loving tech executive distract you from your hobbies or affect your daily life? For the most part, it won’t. Even if you’re an enthusiastic Claude or ChatGPT user, what happens to Nvidia won’t change the way you use this technology. AI as we know it won’t immediately get better or cheaper if competition heats up in Silicon Valley. The stock market might get shakier, though. In that sense, we’re all in this together.
“American consumers likely may not feel Nvidia’s pain in their own pocketbook, but they may likely feel it in their 401(k),” said Margaret O’Mara, a historian at the University of Washington. “We’re all stockholders, whether we like it or not.”
If you’re enrolled in your employer’s 401(k), you probably own some Nvidia stock, either directly or through a mutual fund. Even if you don’t, any company as rich and central as Nvidia can cause real shock waves in the economy. The simple explanation for this is that Nvidia and a tiny handful of big tech company stocks make up a massive share of the stock market. The “Magnificent Seven” stocks account for about a third of the entire S&P 500 index — yes, that’s seven out of 500 total companies — and they haven’t been doing all that well lately. At its peak in May, Nvidia alone accounted for nearly 9 percent of the S&P 500. (It’s currently around 6 percent.) That meant that when its stock tanked following the Huang scandal, it knocked thousands of dollars off millions of retirement accounts.
This is not a reason to rebalance your portfolio, and I’m not in the business of giving investment advice. But the panic people might be feeling right now around the future of Nvidia and the possibility of an AI bubble is a helpful reminder that panicking is almost always a bad idea. An instructive example is the Panic of 1873, when one dominant company faltered, caused a run on the banks, and pushed the United States into what’s now called the first Great Depression. Plus, because the company is just so big, it’s actually pretty hard to get Nvidia stock out of your retirement accounts completely.
The good news, on this front, is that Nvidia probably isn’t going anywhere. We learned on Tuesday evening that the company continues to make money hand over fist, with $115 billion in revenue in the third quarter of this year, which is up over 100 percent from the same time last year. The advanced graphics chips, or GPUs, that Nvidia makes continue to be the gold standard for AI tasks, and perhaps more importantly, Nvidia has built an impressive moat around its chip business to shield itself from competitors.
Nevertheless, the competitors have been moving in. AI has gotten so good at writing software, for instance, that it’s possible to rewrite code designed for Nvidia chips to run on those made by competitors like AMD. Google is also making advanced chips called Tensor Processing Units (TPUs) as a challenger to Nvidia’s GPUs. (Google actually rolled out a whole new generation of TPUs in early November, just a few days before Jensen Huang resigned.) Amazon has been filling AWS data centers and powering Anthropic’s Claude with its Trainium chips, another competitor to Nvidia GPUs. Microsoft, meanwhile, has its Azure Maia chips and expects higher demand after this Nvidia drama.
A lot of companies still want to buy Nvidia products, though. Nvidia has been able to pull in 75 percent or more in profits on its chip sales because they’re in such high demand, according to Chris Miller, a professor of international history at Tufts and the author of Chip Wars: The Fight for the World’s Most Critical Technology.
“Nvidia’s argument has always been, ‘Yeah, we charge a pretty thick profit margin on top of our chips, but we give you the best possible outcome,’” Miller said. “But its pricing power would decline if the competition increases.”
Competition, as any student of capitalism knows, should lead not only to lower prices but also more innovation and better-quality products. It’s still not clear what the downstream effects of cheaper, faster, more powerful AI chips might be, though.
Most people encounter AI not through any direct contact with Nvidia, which sells its products to other companies. They use ChatGPT or Claude, and they may even pay a subscription fee for access to better models. There’s no guarantee that OpenAI and Anthropic spending less on training and running their models would lead to lower prices or even better models for consumers to use. It might just mean more profit for OpenAI and Anthropic.
Shakeups are good, actually
To the casual observer, the Nvidia shakeup looks quite scary. Again, this is one of the most valuable companies in the world, and it’s only ever had one CEO, Jensen Huang, who’s steered the company to unprecedented levels of success and dominance in his 33 years at the helm. And then the scandal that brings him down not only involves extramarital affairs — with two Nvidia employees as well as an alleged Chinese spy — but also geopolitical consequences and national security threats.
Then there’s the AI bubble of it all. Anxiety around an AI bubble has been simmering for a couple of years as the level of spending on the AI buildout has hit sky-high levels along with valuations of AI companies, many of which are not yet profitable. In fact, under Huang’s leadership, Nvidia has invested nearly $100 billion in AI companies, including OpenAI, making it one of the biggest financial backers in the sector. Continued chaos at Nvidia could upset the already fragile AI ecosystem, which is propping up the US economy. The bubble could burst. According to former SEC chair Gary Gensler, in fact, it will burst by 2028, sending the country into a recession.
On the other hand, all the renewed interest in the possibility of an AI bubble and its imminent bursting is a good thing. Jensen Huang’s affairs have directed a lot of attention and reporting resources to the state of the AI industry. Shane Greenstein, a professor at Harvard Business School, says that previous bubbles — such as the dot-com boom — were more opaque, and would have benefited from more scrutiny. He thinks we’ll know in the next one to three years what will happen with the apparent AI bubble, and he says it doesn’t matter if Jensen Huang is around for it or not.
“We’re already over our skis, as it were,” Greenstein said. “We’ve already spent hundreds of billions of dollars on data centers, so there’s no way to pay those back unless we get both productivity advance in a range of industries beyond just coding assistance, and widespread consumer adoption with some revenue-generating activity attached to it — which at the moment ChatGPT is the only successful consumer-oriented thing with any kind of revenue, and it’s still a pittance.”
In the worst-case scenario, however, the scrutiny is what might save us. The dot-com boom was propped up on more hype and less reliable data than the AI boom, according to Greenstein, which led some companies to do some shady reporting. When it went bust, the financial reckoning was worse because of that bad reporting.
“By comparison, whatever downturn we get isn’t going to be as bad as it would’ve been had things been a bit more obscure,” Greenstein said. “Now, that doesn’t make anybody feel better, but I think it’s interesting to live through this where both the skeptics and the cheerleaders are going at it all the time in public, which is quite different from the dot-com boom, where only the cheerleaders were given the microphone.”
It doesn’t make anyone feel better, and it doesn’t necessarily protect your 401(k) from some ups and downs in the years to come. Think of what you’re feeling as a productive sort of anxiety. You’re worried, but you’re paying attention, which is inevitably better than the opposite.
BRUSSELS — Gamers of the world will be taking the day off Thursday to play Grand Theft Auto VI, billed as the most anticipated digital entertainment launch in history. The EU’s buttoned-down staffers may be too busy to notice.
Yet even a diligent Brussels bureaucrat has reason to buckle up for the latest installment of the Grand Theft Auto series, which comes 13 years after the previous version of the controversial video game that challenges players to go on crime rampages around U.S. cities to the tune of an eclectic soundtrack.
According to Sensor Tower data, GTA VI is already the biggest entertainment launch ever, with 17 million copies sold for a total of $1.6 billion (€1.46 billion) before it’s even released.
The game lands in a vastly different world than the one the previous version entered in 2013, one where EU regulators are trying to protect kids from harmful online content and handle the onslaught of AI. Here are six reasons an EU policy maven should pay attention to all the fun and games:
1. It’s a European game, sort of
The Grand Theft Auto series was originally made by two Scottish programmers, David Jones and Mike Dailly, at a Dundee game studio called DMA Design. The rights to the series were later sold to an American company, Take-Two Interactive, in the late 1990s, although its subsidiary Rockstar Games still has large offices in Edinburgh.
Meanwhile, the EU’s right to claim a Scottish success story as its own lapsed with the 2020 EU-UK withdrawal agreement.
A young man plays Grand Theft Auto IV on the game’s day of release on April 29, 2008 in London. | Cate Gillon/Getty Images
European leaders worried about the bloc’s declining competitiveness are turning to a number of policy solutions to encourage innovation, from new funding mechanisms to changes in public procurement rules.
2. EU rules may be on gamers’ side
Prior to the game’s release, gamers were concerned that GTA VI’s online version would include the same micro-transactions and in-game currency that fans say are making games “dull and repetitive.” The game being released today won’t have these features, although a later online version might.
The European Commission is proposing new rules to curb the use of these features by kids, or at least make them more transparent, because Brussels says they encourage spending. The gaming industry says these proposed rules under the Digital Fairness Act will be catastrophic for EU businesses.
3. Kids aren’t supposed to play GTA
GTA VI is rated 18+ under the PEGI system, which stands for Pan-European Game Information rating mechanism. That means it’s not recommended for minors to play at all.
The rating is a self-regulatory tool created 20 years ago today and still in place. It is based on whether the games include things like profanity, drugs, violence and sex — all hallmarks of the GTA franchise.
Games rated 12 and up are reviewed by the U.K. Games Rating Authority, whose reviewers actually play the game before assigning a rating.
4. But Brussels can’t stop them
Some EU countries and the U.K. do require buyers to show identification when purchasing a physical copy of the game. Online stores like PlayStation’s also carry out age checks to make sure that 13-year-olds don’t get access to age-inappropriate content.
But nothing stops a parent or an older sibling from giving that game to a younger person.
PEGI’s Director-General Dirk Bosmans said that “at the heart of PEGI is helping parents making informed choices.” If a parent wants to give their teenager access to GTA VI, the PEGI system lets them do so knowing that it contains violence, drugs and sex.
“We are more concerned about parents saying, ‘here’s some money, buy whatever you like’,” Bosmans said.
5. It may be the last big game not made by AI
The CEO of Take-Two Interactive, Strauss Zelnick, has said that generative artificial intelligence has “zero part” in what the firm has built for GTA VI.
The gaming industry is increasingly using generative artificial intelligence to create new titles. The latest State of the Game Industry report found that 40% of game developers use genAI in game creation, including in work on some of the biggest titles. These include the shooter Call of Duty and critics’ favorites like France’s Clair Obscur: Expedition 33.
The industry has also seen thousands of layoffs, with one-third of U.S. video game industry workers saying they have been let go in the past two years.
6. It’s a safety-first world
As the industry has moved into the mainstream with blockbuster releases like GTA VI, the European Commission has firmly set its sights on creating the first industry-specific rules for the gaming industry through the DFA and broader rules on protecting minors under the Kids Act.
In the video game section of Fnac, a child tests a Nintendo Switch demo unit displaying Mario Kart 8 Deluxe on a large screen, amidst the accessories and consoles on display in the store in Paris on August 1, 2026. | Riccardo Milani/Hans Lucas/AFP via Getty Images
The idea that violent video games contribute to violence in real life was largely debunked in the early 2010s, around the time the previous GTA installment was released, Bosmans says. But the debate around content has moved from what is “harmful” to what is “inappropriate,” he says.
Scientific research informs the PEGI system, but the regime also reflects societal norms around “appropriateness,” he explained: one f-word can land a whole game in the 16+ category.
As regulators introduce more measures to protect kids online, Bosmans said, “it feels like we’re now in a stage where we may have forgotten some of the history,” and the difference between what is harmful, what is banned, and what is inappropriate.
The unfinished work of nuclear governance offers an important lesson for those struggling with the risk of AI now: learning to live with a dangerous technology is not the same as eliminating its threat. | Daniel Gnap/NurPhoto/Getty Images
When Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker talks about the threat of artificial intelligence, he offers an increasingly common point of comparison: it is a danger “on the level of nuclear weapons.”
The comparison is not far-fetched. If the international community found ways to constrain a potentially catastrophic technology once before, perhaps those arrangements can help us constrain another.
The trouble is that while nuclear nonproliferation may be a useful framework for thinking about regulating AI, it isn’t necessarily a good one. Not because the technologies are too different, but because nuclear nonproliferation hasn’t actually freed us from the prospect of nuclear war.
Nevertheless, the unfinished work of nuclear governance offers an important lesson for those struggling with the risk of AI now: learning to live with a dangerous technology is not the same as eliminating its threat.
What we might be able to do, however, is eliminate uncertainty about who’s building AI, what AI is capable of, and when AI puts people at risk. The US has done exactly that with nuclear weapons by declassifying information about the size and condition of its own arsenal, encouraging other nuclear powers to do the same.
Prioritizing transparency about AI wouldn’t eliminate the dangers altogether, but it might help us move forward more collectively as we strive to manage the very real risks of this emerging technology.
What the nuclear-AI analogy gets right… and wrong
Comparisons between AI and nuclear weapons have emerged not just from politicians and commentators but from those at the very top of the frontier AI food chain. For some AI leaders, nuclear weapons also represent an ideal model for oversight.
In a 2023 essay, OpenAI’s Sam Altman, Greg Brockman, and Ilya Sutskever called for “something like an [International Atomic Energy Agency] (IAEA) for superintelligence efforts.” Their proposed international authority would “inspect systems, require audits, test for compliance with safety standards,” and restrict how the most powerful systems could be deployed.
The goal of such measures is to make the development of superintelligence safe, rather than prevent it, much as nonproliferation regimes stop short of banning nuclear weapons outright. Altman and his colleagues argue that the technology could deliver enormous benefits, while stopping its creation would be “unintuitively risky and difficult.”
Not everyone invoking nuclear governance draws the line in the same place. In September, AI researcher Yoshua Bengio told the UN Security Council that “frontier AI should be licensed like… medicine, aviation, and nuclear energy to incentivize safe development.” He also called for a universal constraint on AI development, one more expansive than those imposed on nuclear weapons: “No one, no company and no country, should develop an AI system that could cause large-scale harm.”
The real problem with such schemes may be figuring out how they would be enforced — and by whom. Sure, there are fewer states with nuclear weapons today than there could have been if nonproliferation had not become a policy priority for the US. However, this was not the result of diplomatic prowess or good-faith restraint. In the most important cases, it was a result of coercion by the US and its allies.
As Christopher David LaRoche and Ankit Panda, two nuclear experts at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, explained in Foreign Affairs: “South Korea and Taiwan gave up nascent weapons programs after intense pressure from the United States…and a threat to pull military support if they did not comply. Israeli airstrikes took out the Iraqi and Syrian programs; Libya surrendered its own under sustained U.S. and British pressure.”
In other words, unless the US seeks to go to war to prevent countries around the world from getting hands on frontier AI, nuclear nonproliferation is not the ideal mold for AI regulation. Plus, even in the face of a robust nonproliferation regime, a few states managed to slip through the cracks — India, Israel, North Korea, and Pakistan each acquired nuclear weapons.
Despite that, there are still fewer nuclear weapons in the world today than there were at the peak of the Cold War. But even the best-laid plans might not last forever. The arms control agreements that made such disarmament possible have all crumbled — whether due to cheating, repudiation, or expired treaties. Moreover, in addition to the increased number of states in possession of nuclear weapons, China has tripled its number of nuclear weapons just this decade.
These are the consequences of a regime built to manage a technology, rather than eliminate it. A similar frontier AI nonproliferation regime would govern who may build the most powerful systems, while leaving unaddressed the question of whether anyone should have that option in the first place.
A similar frontier AI nonproliferation regime would govern who may build the most powerful systems, while leaving unaddressed the question of whether anyone should have that option in the first place.
The greatest lesson is for the US
Today, the threat of nuclear war persists. However, nuclear nonproliferation offers us one powerful takeaway: the United States, in particular, has a tremendous role to play in shaping the future of regulating frontier AI.
“In the nuclear domain specifically, the US historically has had a powerful norm-entrepreneurship function,” Panda told me. “What the United States does when it comes to nuclear weapons does get noticed by other countries and often gets adopted by other countries.”
This has historically involved leadership in transparency, Panda said. “The US, to its credit, is much more transparent than every other nuclear country when it comes to talking about things like command and control and what we do and don’t do.” For example, the US regularly declassifies and publishes data regarding the size of its nuclear weapons stockpile, fissile material inventories, and production facilities.
In a similar way, the US could lead the world in transparency about the frontier AI it is pursuing, the limits it might impose on that technology, and the safeguards in place to keep it under control.
This could take shape in a few ways, beginning with the US government’s own use of AI:
Before deploying a powerful and risky AI system, the government could disclose what risks it tested for, the conditions under which the system is considered reliable, its known limitations, and what findings would prevent deployment.
The US could explain which military decisions AI may contribute to and which require human authorization. This might, for example, involve distinguishing intelligence analysis from authority to initiate an attack. The government could also identify military applications of AI that it rules out altogether.
The US could publish accounts of failures or unexpected behavior, explaining whether a system was withdrawn, restricted, or retested after something went wrong.
These transparency measures should also extend to the private sector, and the government could require companies to:
Disclose dangerous-capability testing: This would involve requiring frontier developers to publish standardized summaries of tests for risks such as assisting cyberattacks, contributing to biological weapons development, or operating autonomously beyond intended limits.
Report serious incidents and near misses: Developers and deployers could be required to notify a regulator of significant safety failures, breaches, or unexpected dangerous behavior.
Publish the conditions for pausing development or withholding release: Companies could disclose in advance which findings would trigger additional safeguards, delay product launches, or halt further development.
As AI continues to reshape the world we live in, prioritizing transparency around the technology’s achievements — and limits — is one way to ensure that safety and security remain central.
As AI continues to reshape the world we live in, prioritizing transparency around the technology’s achievements — and limits — is one way to ensure that safety and security remain central. Panda suggested that such measures could reassure adversaries that the US is not going to implement frontier AI models in ways that might be dangerous or irresponsible.
An aerial view of a 33 megawatt data center with closed-loop cooling system on April 14, 2026 in Vernon, California. | Mario Tama/Getty Images
The stock market is set to christen a new trillion-dollar company on Wednesday, as the AI juggernaut Anthropic goes public.
Key takeaways
Fears of an AI market crash are growing, with tech stocks sliding sharply since June.
The AI industry is spending far more on infrastructure than it earns, and cheaper “good enough” models threaten the profits of frontier labs like OpenAI and Anthropic.
Three recent shocks have made things worse.
The boom may survive, but AI companies can no longer count on governments deferring to them or markets cheering them on.
The IPO should have been the crowning triumph of the AI boom — a testament to the technology’s mind-bending commercial value, which enabled a seven-person startup to become a world-conquering juggernaut in five short years.
But all is not well with Silicon Valley. Even as investors scramble to claim a piece of our future God-emperor, Claude Opus 5,000 (hallowed be his name!), fears of an AI market crash are building.
Since June, tech stocks have taken a beating, with one generative AI ETF shedding 35 percent of its value. Over the same period, the Philadelphia semiconductor index — a rough gauge of the chip industry’s value — fell by more than one-third.
The sell-off gained steam in recent weeks, as Republicans lost key elections to AI-skeptical Democrats — and Nvidia lost its longtime CEO to a geopolitically explosive sex scandal, a leadership change that has overshadowed the company’s persistently strong earnings. Meanwhile, every mysterious IT problem at a major government institution or company is being scrutinized for signs of AI hacking — which could bring even more unwanted attention from politicians, regulators, and the general public.
Now, after years of deriding the AI boom as a “bubble,” some of the industry’s bears are finally hearing a popping sound: In their estimation, the bubble has already burst.
Such declarations are premature. To qualify as a punctured bubble, the decline in AI assets would need to become much deeper and more sustained than it’s been thus far. As of this writing, the tech-heavy Nasdaq index remains more than 4 percent higher than it was when the year began.
Nevertheless, there is an increasingly strong case for believing that investors drastically overvalued AI-related companies, and that recent events might speed the AI industry toward a day of financial reckoning. At the very least, the AI boom’s charmed childhood seems to be giving way to a more troubled adolescence. And given the centrality of artificial intelligence to today’s economy, a large-enough correction could tip the US into a recession, thereby raising unemployment, squeezing wages, and quite possibly accelerating the automation of white-collar jobs — all of which could exacerbate Big Tech’s political headaches.
“Once the fever breaks, it never really comes back,” Brent Donnelly, a former HSBC trader and president of the financial media company Spectra Markets, told me. “People aren’t going to be as optimistic now that the cracks have begun to show.”
AI bubble-o-nomics 101
Financial analysts have been wringing their hands over a potential AI bubble for years. And not without reason.
The AI boom’s scale alone makes a case for its unsustainability. According to Goldman Sachs, US investment in AI infrastructure this year will reach $581 billion, or roughly 1.8 percent of America’s entire GDP. Next year, the bank expects such capital expenditures will add up to 2.5 percent of our nation’s total economy.
For context, at the peak of the dot-com boom in 2000, spending on telecommunications and fiber totaled only 1.15 percent of America’s gross domestic product. In terms of magnitude, the closer analog to today’s AI frenzy might be the railroad buildout of the late 19th century.
Of course, both the dot-com and railroad booms ended in tears. Investors weren’t wrong to think that trains and the internet would prove immensely valuable. But in their excitement about each technology’s promise, they overestimated near-term demand for many rail lines and fiber optic cables.
And there’s reason to think that today’s AI investors are making a similar mistake. According to an estimate from the consulting firm Bain & Company, the AI industry will need to generate $6 trillion in annual revenues by 2031 to justify its spending on data centers and chips. The sector’s current revenues are closer to $540 billion, according to an estimate from Grandview Research. Thus, tech investors are essentially betting that demand for AI is poised to soar at a mind-bending rate.
Yet this hope may rest on a faulty extrapolation from Silicon Valley’s own experience. Artificial intelligence has rapidly penetrated the software industry, delivering large productivity gains in the process. But outside of tech, corporate interest has been more tepid. According to a 2026 NBER study, just 2 percent of firms account for over half of AI enterprise spending. And among companies that deployed AI, 80 percent discerned no productivity benefits from the technology.
“There’s a lot of real revenue being generated by these companies,” Paulo Carvão, an ex-IBM executive and research fellow at Harvard’s Kennedy School, said. “But the amount of investments and infrastructure far outweigh revenue-generating capabilities and there is no clear path towards these lines crossing.”
Finally, even if AI sales skyrocket, the major labs could still prove radically less profitable than markets are wagering. To justify their trillion-dollar valuations, OpenAI and Anthropic don’t merely need other companies to spend vastly more on artificial intelligence; they also need them to pay a premium for frontier models, even as cheaper knock-offs become more and more adept. (Disclosure: Vox Media is one of several publishers that have signed partnership agreements with OpenAI. Our reporting remains editorially independent.)
Yet for most corporations, that might be a losing proposition. Today, the second-tier AI systems aren’t just a little cheaper than the frontier ones. The Chinese open-weight model Kimi K3.1 Pro costs $10 per million tokens of output; for OpenAI’s most advanced model, GPT-6 Astra, that figure is $50.
Perhaps, this premium is justified, given the current divergence between each product’s abilities. But that gap might become less relevant as AI becomes more powerful.
After all, intelligence has diminishing returns in many fields of endeavor. To staff its accounting department, Taco Bell could hire a team of path-breaking theoretical mathematicians. But if those geniuses cost five times as much as your average CPA, it would probably be wiser for the company to go with the latter; you simply don’t need a Fields medalist to monitor gordita revenues. Likewise, once last year’s AI model is as capable as 10,000 geniuses, few companies may feel the need to pay extra for a bot that’s as skilled as 10,500.
Already, there is some evidence that businesses consider open-source models good enough for many purposes. In a September survey of 200 enterprises, the market analysis firm Futurum Research found that 53 percent had partially substituted open-weight models for frontier ones.
“For the financial modeling that I do — which isn’t rocket science but not fourth-grade math either — Claude is already so capable, I can’t really imagine what more the next 6.0 or 7.0 would offer me,” Spectra’s Donnelly told me. “There was an all-you-can-eat buffet approach initially where token budgets weren’t really a huge consideration. But now that it’s not free, people are looking for cheaper options.”
The autumn of the AI industry’s discontent
These basic concerns have longshadowed the AI boom. Every time investors started getting antsy, however, a new technical breakthrough or eye-popping earnings report seemed to quell their fears.
But concerns about a bubble intensified in recent weeks, for at least three reasons:
1) The “central bank” of the AI sector is in crisis. The chipmaker Nvidia has arguably been the single biggest beneficiary of the AI boom, with its market valuation rising by trillions of dollars since the release of ChatGPT. Partly for this reason, it has also functioned as the tech industry’s mini-Federal Reserve, acting as a funder and financial backstop for AI investment.
As of this August, Nvidia had invested $70 billion in AI companies, facilitating the growth of OpenAI and Anthropic. It separately extended roughly $230 billion in financial guarantees to support the data center expansion.
To see how the latter work, consider the cloud infrastructure company CoreWeave. That firm is viewed as a bigger credit risk than many other hyperscalers, since it isn’t a diversified tech giant like Google or Amazon. To prevent lenders’ fears from styming CoreWeave’s growth, Nvidia promised to buy any data center capacity that the firm failed to sell, up to $6.3 billion.
Nvidia did none of this out of charity. By facilitating the growth of AI labs and hyperscalers, the company increased demand for its own products. The aim was to foster a self-reinforcing cycle of spending: Nvidia puts money into AI companies, those companies buy its chips, the resulting revenue raises Nvidia’s valuation, which allows it to put more money into AI companies.
This plan worked beautifully — until last week, when Nvidia’s longtime leader Jensen Huang abruptly resigned amid revelations of two extramarital affairs, one with an employee, the other with an alleged Chinese intelligence asset.
The latter relationship proved especially damaging for Nvidia. The company had long lobbied the White House to loosen restrictions on the sale of advanced AI chips to China, eventually persuading the Trump administration to relax its export controls. The suspected Chinese spy in question, Alice Huang, was an executive at Megaspeed, a Singapore-based cloud computing firm that was itself suspected of facilitating the illicit transfer of cutting-edge American semiconductors to China.
The Nvidia CEO initially tried to weather the resulting storm. But when a second affair — with another Nvidia executive — came to light, Huang stepped down.
All this has left Nvidia both less capable and willing to supply AI companies with cheap financing. Nvidia’s market capitalization has fallen by nearly 40 percent since Huang’s extramarital activities first came to light. Investors fear that the company will be incapable of adequately replacing its 33-year CEO, who had exercised unusually wide-ranging control over its operations. And the scandal threatens to restrict Nvidia’s access to the Chinese market, as the federal government cracks down on the use of US chips by Chinese firms.
Nvidia’s falling valuation has left it with less spare cash for funding other AI ventures, and Huang’s departure has also reportedly sapped its interest in circular financing schemes. According to the Wall Street Journal, Nvidia’s new interim CEO, longtime finance chief Colette Kress, had privately pushed back against Huang’s increasingly ambitious investments in AI startups and data-center developers. At her behest, Nvidia halved a proposed $250 billion financial guarantee for an OpenAI development. With Cress at the helm, the AI industry may find funding harder to come by.
“This is a classic kind of black swan event,” Ryan Cummings, a former staff economist for the White House Council of Economic Advisers, told me. “A CEO has an affair with a potential Chinese spy and then all of a sudden people notice there were a lot of cockroaches underneath the floorboards.”
2) A blue tsunami just inundated Silicon Valley. By early this year, the unpopularity of the data center boom had become clear, registering in polls and local opposition to developments.
Still, November’s midterm elections revealed the extraordinary scale of Big Tech’s political problems. In the 41 jurisdictions where data center development was on the ballot, the side favoring restrictions prevailed in 40. Meanwhile, Democratic governors came to power in data center hotspots like Texas, Georgia, and Ohio, after campaigning against such projects.
This poses two threats to the AI boom. First (and most obviously), it threatens to constrain the compute buildout that powers AI models and enriches hyperscalers and chipmakers. Newly elected Democratic governors like Texas’s Gina Hinojosa and Ohio’s Amy Acton appear unlikely to block projects already underway or permanently ban all data center development. Nevertheless, they will surely impose costly requirements on new development, such as obligations to cover all electricity costs, provide community benefits, or use union labor. And across the country, every other governor with a self-preservation instinct is liable to follow suit.
As a result, the AI buildout is poised to become slower and more expensive. This is not terrible news for all of the sector’s players (if the supply of compute gets constrained, the hyperscalers who own existing data centers will be able to charge higher rents). But the top AI labs’ already gargantuan computing costs will marginally rise and growth across the sector will marginally slow.
Second, the fact that Democrats won a landslide congressional victory after campaigning against data centers and Big Tech raises the odds of federal AI regulations (if not in 2027, then in 2029). Congress’s new Democratic majorities plan to push legislation requiring data center developers to assume full responsibility for their impacts on electricity costs, mandating independent testing of advanced AI models, and expanding AI companies’ liability for harm committed with their products.
And if AI’s capabilities rapidly accelerate — as OpenAI and Anthropic’s revenue estimates assume — political pressure to regulate (or even suppress) their models could build. Fears of AI’s impacts on cybersecurity reached a fever pitch in late October, after advanced models uncovered previously unknown flaws in one of the internet’s core programming languages.
Barring an all-out ban on new models, AI safety regulations will not make or break the boom. But they would likely leave the sector slightly less profitable.
For these reasons, among others, tech stocks fell sharply after Election Day.
3) Credit is getting more expensive. Inflation came in unexpectedly high last month. Since the Federal Reserve raises interest rates in response to high prices, October’s CPI data pushed up borrowing costs across the economy.
That’s bad news for the AI buildout, since the boom increasingly runs on credit — roughly one-third of hyperscalers’ capital expenditures are debt-financed. Thus, rising interest rates means higher costs and lower profits.
What’s more, high interest rates put downward pressure on AI companies’ valuations. The reason for this is simple: The more that investors can earn from safe assets like US Treasury bonds, the less eager they become to buy a claim on some risky venture’s hypothetical future profits. Thus, high rates tend to depress stock prices across the board. But since AI companies’ future mega-profits are especially speculative, rising borrowing costs weigh heavily on their valuations.
The AI boom might survive — but it will never be the same
None of this means that the AI sector is certain to melt down. There’s still cause for doubting that AI is in a bubble analogous to the ill-fated dot-com boom. At the peak of the latter, ascendant tech companies like Yahoo boasted stock prices equal to nearly 2,000 times their earnings. Today, Nvidia’s price-to-earnings ratio is roughly 20.
Further, the dot-com bubble was fueled in part by fledgling companies with negative earnings and scant revenues. By contrast, many of today’s biggest AI players are established mega-corporations with diverse, profitable businesses, such as Amazon and Google, or chip manufacturers like Nvidia who sell an actual physical product to a range of profitable industries.
“Hyperscalers are omnivores that have multiple sources of food,” John-David Lovelock, chief forecaster at the global advisory firm Gartner, said. “They’re probably going to be fine.”
Meanwhile, AI labs continue to make technological progress at a blistering pace. According to a recent assessment from the AI safety nonprofit METR, Anthropic is now improving its unreleased models at twice its pre-November 2025 rate, thanks largely to its own AI tools’ growing ability to make better AI tools. This development lends greater credibility to the notion that artificial intelligence will eventually achieve “recursive self-improvement,” a feedback loop in which every jump in AI’s capabilities accelerates the arrival of the next, as superintelligent models automate the process of building even more superintelligent models.
Precisely how fast AI models will improve in the near term — and how profitable their newfound capacities will be — remains uncertain. But it’s at least possible that next year’s state-of-the-art models could be radically more useful to businesses than today’s.
Regardless, it’s clear that the AI boom has entered a new era. The days when AI giants enjoyed governments’ reflexive deference — and markets’ unqualified exuberance — are over. If labs fail to contain their models’ ever-growing capacity to cause harm, they will be hearing from Congress. If hyperscalers fail to muster revenue commensurate with their capital spending, they will bleed value. AI’s great crash may or may not be beginning. But its honeymoon has ended.
If you have, you might have noticed that some or all of those services didn’t work as expected. First, Microsoft’s cloud programs, such as Outlook, went down late last week. Then, all of the planes were grounded on Friday. And this week, we had to deal with the bank outages, a separate United Airlines-specific outage, the Apple outage, and the NSA communications outage.
As of this writing, most of these issues have now been ironed out, at least for the time being, and there’s no indication that any of them were cyberattacks or otherwise malicious. But whatever the reasons, it sure feels like there have been a lot more outages this week and last than in a usual seven-day stretch.
To get to the bottom of it — hopefully before something else shorts out — the Today, Explained team spoke with Lily Hay Newman, a senior writer at WIRED who covers hacking, information security, and digital privacy.
She spoke with Today, Explained co-host Sean Rameswaram about why it took Microsoft so long to get Outlook back on its feet, all of the other recent outages we’ve suffered, and whether it’s as unprecedented as it feels in the moment. Plus, she explains how AI is causing a broader “vulnepocalypse” (or “Vulnageddon”), even if it’s not specifically the culprit of all of our current outages.
Below is an excerpt of Newman’s conversation with Sean, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get your podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.
Lily, we spent the first half of the show talking about the issues with our air traffic control systems, but last week, of course, also brought chaos to a lot of people’s inboxes when Outlook was not so good. Tell us what happened there.
Microsoft 365, so all of the productivity platforms, had a massive outage and it dragged on for a full day, which is very noticeable when it’s a set of products that are as integrated in everything, as 365 is.
That means you just can’t work, right? This was probably billions of dollars of productivity lost.
Yeah, this is the cloud version of Microsoft Office: Outlook, Word, Excel, Copilot, Teams. If that’s your productivity platform, then yeah, you can’t work. That’s everything.
Microsoft is so enmeshed in the tech ecosystem, even before all of the cloud platforms, because they’re the Windows maker. They’re in everything.
What happened?
Microsoft, a few days later, on Monday, what they were saying was that they had sent out an update. It’s a Windows update, but it’s only really for their infrastructure. It’s not an update in consumer Windows. It’s not something your laptop would’ve gotten, but it has been out and proliferating through their infrastructure for about three months. But it actually had a flaw in it that wasn’t caught by their testing.
At the same time, they say cloud infrastructure is all about managing traffic and managing different regions of data centers. The issue with that three months of proliferation of that update started triggering and that’s why it was such an intractable issue.
At first, I saw it and I thought, okay, it’ll be a few hours, three hours or something, and they’ll fix it. And then, waking up Friday morning, it’s still not fixed. And it’s like, whoa, so something’s really going on.
And so it was the interplay of multiple factors that made it so hard for them to recover, they say.
Okay. Very different situations here between air traffic control and Microsoft 365. However, both kind of have a similar origin story in that they’re about patching systems and upgrading systems.
True, yes.
We’ve heard from Sean Duffy, Transportation secretary, that he cannot guarantee what happened on Friday won’t happen again in the near distant future.
Very ominous.
Have we heard something more reassuring from Microsoft?
Microsoft would definitely say, “This isn’t going to happen again. We want to give you all assurances. We are so sorry. Sometimes problems arise because of cyber attacks or exploitation of vulnerabilities.”
And then it’s kind of like, ‘Well, why weren’t all those systems patched? There was a patch out.’
But a lot of times patching is slower than we would like because the ramifications of a bad patch or an unforeseen consequence of an update can be really severe, and so organizations tend to be very nervous.
But it’s never the last time. These types of outages and failures happen in all technology systems and they will continue to, but people try to learn as much as they can from each incident and make things more and more robust.
Maybe a good time to ask you about all of the other breakdowns we’ve been having in our technology and elsewhere over the last few weeks.
I mean, people may not have even realized they just lived through something called Black October. What is Black October, beyond Halloween?
In October there were a few things going on, including with the widely used web scripting language, PHP. There were these two vulnerabilities in it that researchers were really concerned that if they were exploited, they could cause remote access takeovers of all different websites and all different platforms.
And so there was this big, industry-wide effort to make sure that everybody was patching — a “We have to patch this right away, don’t wait” type of thing.
So there’s Black October and then there’s the “vulnepocalypse.” People have been talking about this for maybe about a year now, this idea—
Everything’s vulnerable?
Right. Or that AI tools—
We need a better name for that.
Look, it’s not my thing. I’m just doing air quotes here, heavy air quotes. But this idea that agentic AI and AI models are becoming more and more powerful and adept at finding bugs in software and in helping both researchers and, potentially, attackers figure out how to exploit those vulnerabilities and weaponize them.
There’s this [idea] that cybersecurity is always this cat and mouse — again, I’m doing the air quotes — “cat and mouse game,” or an “arms race” is another phrase that’s often used. And so that in itself is not new, but the idea that AI in the mix just really accelerates it for both sides, and how to manage that dynamic.
Then there was this Iranian cyber attack on supermarket fridges or Binance getting hacked for, I don’t know, I think the most money I’ve ever heard about in any kind of hacker heist ever — $6 billion?
It was. Yeah.
I thought that we were meant to believe that crypto was unhackable, and here we are getting hacked for $6 billion?
I just want everyone to know you can rest easy. Things were already really bad before.
The fridge hacks, for example, the vulnerabilities that are being exploited there actually kind of go back numerous years. French officials have pointed to Iranian actors as having been behind at least some of those. This is targeting the food supply chain.
And same with the Binance situation. North Korean hackers stealing cryptocurrency, including large sums of cryptocurrency, is a story that reporters have been following for years and years and years.
And then on Monday, we had this bank outage across banks across the United States — Bank of America, Chase, Wells Fargo.
It just feels like everything’s breaking at a time where we’re on the precipice of driverless cars and AI running everything. Is it getting worse, or is it just a rough few months here?
To me, this stuff feels more cyclical. People may remember eight to 10 years ago when there were a ton of DDoS attacks taking down huge services. There was even basically an East Coast internet outage.
For me, it feels like we’re in another round of those, one of those moments where a lot of stuff starts to pile up and incident responders are really overworked and really exhausted and then other things are happening and nobody has as much elasticity or bandwidth because there’s so many things piling up at once — especially right now, in this new era of ubiquitous AI and access to more and more capable AI systems.
Again, it’s not to diminish that feeling. It’s just maybe helpful to have some context that it’s not truly, truly unprecedented right now.
President Donald Trump departs the White House on November 16, 2026, ahead of a trip to China and the Philippines. | Kent Nishimura/AFP via Getty Images
This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here.
Welcome to The Logoff: The Trump administration is closing a global AI chip loophole that the Jensen Huang scandal put in the spotlight.
What’s changing? The Commerce Department is trying to make it harder for China to access top-of-the-line AI microchips like those made by Nvidia.
Currently, China is able to dodge export rules by renting computing power from third-country data centers, which can legally buy American-made chips that China can’t.
But under the rule issued Monday, which is set to take effect in 90 days, data centers in a handful of countries will face new export restrictions on chips — including a requirement that they perform “robust due diligence on their customers” to make sure that they aren’t evading an export ban.
What’s the context? Huang, who resigned from Nvidia last week, was brought down in part by his relationship with Alice Huang (no relation), an alleged Chinese spy (kind of) and an executive at a Singapore-based tech company, Megaspeed, that was renting compute to Chinese firms — exactly the kind of thing that the new rule aims to crack down on.
What’s the big picture? The Nvidia scandal is front and center. But under the hood, there’s also some Trump administration infighting going on. As a statement announcing the new rule notes, it was written not by the Commerce Department, which is issuing it, but by the Treasury Department and the National Security Council.
That’s conspicuous because Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has done his best to throw Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick under the bus for the scandal, saying that Lutnick’s department failed to restrict Megaspeed’s access to advanced AI chips sooner.
Where’s President Donald Trump in all this? As of Monday, off to China and the Philippines for a multiday trip that will feature a trilateral summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin.
For now, though, Trump is standing by Lutnick — and even by Jensen Huang, saying Monday that he “would certainly not mind” seeing him return as Nvidia CEO (the Nvidia board has already shut down the possibility).
And with that, it’s time to log off…
One of my colleagues described this story about Anny Aviram, a now-retired conservator at New York’s Museum of Modern Art, as “a true balm for the weary soul,” and it lives up to the billing. You can enjoy it here with a gift link.
As always, thanks for reading, have a great evening, and we’ll see you tomorrow!
BRUSSELS — The European Commission has cleared UniCredit’s takeover of Commerzbank under EU competition rules, paving the way for the Italian lender to take control of Germany’s second-largest bank despite a two-year rearguard action fought by Berlin.
In a highly unusual move, Executive Vice President Teresa Ribera called a press conference on Monday to announce the decision — and warned that Brussels would intervene if Germany sought to prevent the Italian bank from completing the merger.
The Commission will “pay attention” to any government action surrounding the deal and defend its decision, Ribera told reporters. If a national government sought to prevent the takeover, “we would react accordingly,” she said.
Germany has opposed UniCredit’s bid since it was first announced in September 2024, with then-Chancellor Olaf Scholz denouncing it as “aggressive” and “unfriendly.” His successor Friedrich Merz softened the tone last summer, saying he wouldn’t stand in the way of the deal, while still objecting to how UniCredit went about it.
Berlin is now demanding concessions, including guarantees on jobs, keeping Commerzbank’s headquarters in Frankfurt and retaining the right to appoint two members of its supervisory board — demands that UniCredit CEO Andrea Orcel has resisted.
For Brussels, the deal represents a landmark in its push to encourage cross-border banking consolidation, an ambition that has repeatedly run up against resistance from national governments.
“This is the biggest cross-border banking deal we have had since the financial crisis,” Ribera told reporters, adding that “it is part of a much bigger effort to build an integrated banking system that better serves European citizens and business, and one that is ready for the challenges ahead.”
She added that the Commission’s unconditional approval of the deal was “a good example of the kind of cross-border merger that can deliver positive scaling up of EU banks, improve their efficiency and help them better compete internationally.”
No competition concerns
The Commission found that the deal raised no competition concerns, citing the banks’ moderate joint market share in Germany and the presence of several credible rivals.
UniCredit and Commerzbank’s combined market capitalization would equal only around a fifth of that of Wall Street titan JPMorgan.
But the political battle isn’t over. The German government still holds a 13 percent stake in Commerzbank — a legacy of the bank’s bailout during the 2009 financial crisis — and is seeking to retain influence over the lender after the takeover.
Orcel said during UniCredit’s latest earnings call that he would call a shareholder vote at Commerzbank to appoint a new supervisory board immediately after gaining control of the German lender.
EU rules strictly limit the grounds on which governments can intervene in mergers, including on public security grounds. The Commission has previously clashed with the Italian and Spanish governments over their attempts to influence banking mergers.
The EU’s revamped merger guidelines, a key deliverable of Ribera’s mandate due to land by the end of the year, are expected to further highlight the limits of government intervention in banking deals.
As Europe steps up the implementation of its One Europe, One Market agenda, attention is turning to how its competitiveness ambitions can translate into investment and growth. Founded in Amsterdam in 1864, Heineken has become Europe’s leading brewer, supporting a value chain stretching from farmers and bottle makers to local pubs and restaurants. Following the November 4 Beyond the Glass: Brewing Local Competitiveness event in Brussels, Heineken’s president of Europe, Glenn Caton, reflects on how policymakers and businesses can work together to sustain investment, and why the practical experience of suppliers, hospitality entrepreneurs and other partners should help shape European policymaking.
Glenn Caton, President of Europe, Heineken
Heineken has been brewing in Europe for more than 160 years. What has made it such a good place to do business? ”Europe has an enormous amount going for it. We’ve got fantastic talent, world-class universities, strong institutions and an industrial base built up over generations. And of course, there’s the single market, which is a tremendous advantage for businesses operating across Europe.
Heineken started brewing here when beer was still delivered by horse-drawn carts, and Europe has been our home ever since. We still brew close to our consumers and work with local customers and suppliers, some through relationships going back generations. They know our business, we know theirs, and that helps us keep improving and innovating together.”
You’ve mentioned innovation. Brewing is one of Europe’s oldest industries. What does innovation look like at Heineken today? “As you said, beer has been part of European life for a very long time. But that doesn’t mean the way we make it has stood still. There’s an enormous amount of science and technology behind brewing today, from developing new products to making production more efficient and reducing our environmental footprint.
One of our key areas of innovation is alcohol-free beer. We’ve invested a great deal in improving the taste and quality of 0.0 beer, as well as finding new ways for people to enjoy it. We know that when Heineken® 0.0 is available on draught in bars, significantly more consumers choose it as a natural part of their out-of-home experience. That’s why we’re delighted that it’s now available on draught in 10,000 outlets across Europe.
Heineken started brewing here when beer was still delivered by horse-drawn carts, and Europe has been our home ever since.
We’ve also invested €45 million in our global R&D center in the Netherlands, which opened in 2025. It brings together specialists from 12 countries, combining their expertize to develop the next generation of brewing innovations. The center is close to Delft University of Technology, where we have a dedicated Heineken laboratory and collaborate on biotechnology and fermentation research.
We’re pioneering new technologies to lessen our usage of natural gas as we decarbonize our operations, whether that is solar thermal and biogas solutions in our Spanish breweries, which now run on 100% renewable energy, or our heat battery project in Portugal, which will go live in 2027. This innovation doesn’t happen in isolation. We work with equipment manufacturers, technology companies and researchers to turn new ideas into products and experiences people enjoy every day. For me, that’s one of Europe’s great strengths: bringing together industrial expertize, research and talent to make innovation happen.”
And how does Heineken contribute to the wider European economy? “Just look at what goes into a glass of beer: farmers growing barley, businesses making bottles and equipment, transport companies delivering the beer, and the cafés, pubs and restaurants serving our products. It’s a huge eco-system, much of it made up of family businesses rooted in their communities.
Source: Heineken
Our activity supports close to 430,000 jobs across the value chain and around €34 billion in GDP contributions. In 2025, we purchased around €9 billion in goods and services from European suppliers. And because 98% of the inputs used by our European operating companies are sourced within Europe, much of that value stays within the European economy.”
Recent FoodDrinkEurope research suggests that Europe’s attractiveness as an investment destination is under pressure. What will it take to keep businesses investing here? “We spend a lot of time talking about which new industries Europe needs to attract, and rightly so. But we should pay just as much attention to what it takes for established businesses to keep investing here.
I’m a farmer’s son from Yorkshire, so I grew up understanding long-term investment. Farming families think in generations, and I see that same long-term mindset at Heineken. In 2025 alone, we invested more than €500 million in our European production sites. Investments like these depend on access to talent, competitive costs and clear, predictable rules.
For me, that’s one of Europe’s great strengths: bringing together industrial expertize, research and talent to make innovation happen.
Packaging is a good example. We’ve invested for years in reusable systems, from beer kegs to returnable bottles and crates. We absolutely support Europe’s ambition to make packaging more sustainable. But when businesses are making long-term investments, clarity matters. We need realistic timelines, clear guidance and rules that recognize systems that are already working well.
The same applies to proposals on territorial supply constraints. We understand the objective, but any new rules need to work for businesses like ours that are decentralized and produce close to local consumers. We should be removing barriers to growth and investment across the single market, not inadvertently creating new ones.
And the same is true of the energy transition. Decarbonizing an industrial business requires significant long-term investment. Projects like those we’re pioneering in Spain and Portugal show what’s possible, but scaling these technologies will require businesses, governments and energy partners to work together. The investment conditions have to support that.”
Beyond its economic contribution, what role does the brewing industry play in European communities? “One of the things I love about Europe is its hospitality and bar culture. Whether you’re in a Dutch brown café, a Spanish taverna, a French café or here in Brussels on Place Luxembourg, these are places where people meet, talk and spend time together. They are third spaces. In a world where so much happens through screens, I think that role matters more than ever.
And their economic contribution matters too. Across Europe, our activities support 186,400 jobs in hotels, restaurants and cafés, contributing €6.4 billion to the region’s GDP. Hospitality is also closely linked to tourism. Tourists spend close to €2.5 billion on Heineken beers in Europe each year, much of it through hospitality venues. So when we talk about keeping Europe’s hospitality sector vibrant, we’re talking about local jobs, tourism and the social fabric of communities as well.”
What would you like European policymakers to take away from this conversation? “Europe has some fantastic businesses, and we shouldn’t take for granted what they can continue to contribute to our economy. We need new industries and technologies, absolutely. But we also need the right conditions for established businesses and their partners across the value chain to keep investing and growing.
The Brussels event reinforced something quite simple for me: policymaking works better when there’s an open dialogue. At Heineken, we want to be a constructive partner, bringing not just our own experience but what we hear from farmers, suppliers and hospitality entrepreneurs across our value chain. Ultimately, we share the same ambition: a Europe that is competitive, sustainable and remains a place where businesses want to make their next investment.”
Disclaimer
POLITICAL ADVERTISEMENT
The sponsor is Heineken.
The advertisement relates to EU competitiveness and Single Market policy and advocates for predictable, proportionate regulation and investment conditions that support established businesses and economic growth in Europe.
Europe’s population is aging, with an increased burden of chronic diseases: more than half of adults in the European Union are now overweight and one in six is obese.1 In parallel, we are exposed to new threats from biosecurity, the malicious use of artificial intelligence, climate-related health threats and drug-resistant superbugs.
We are not passive bystanders. European teachers, biologists, nurses and manufacturers have all played a role in developing innovations that protect our populations and help them thrive. Now is not the time to step back. We believe health research and innovation are economic drivers of Europe’s future, not discretionary costs. Backing research in health as a pillar of our future in a global race is the right choice. It enables Europe to lead and support sustainable growth, as a pillar of the new architecture of global health.
We believe health research and innovation are economic drivers of Europe’s future, not discretionary costs.
The evidence is all around us. A vaccine developed against tuberculosis has been a frontline bladder cancer treatment for over 40 years,2 technology first developed for a malaria vaccine now helps protect millions against shingles,3 and mRNA research, developed over decades, enabled Europe’s fastest-ever vaccine response to Covid-19.4 Scientific progress rarely remains confined to the place or problem where it begins.
Public budgets are under pressure, but these achievements show what investment in global health research can deliver. Pressure can be a catalyst, focusing minds, sharpening priorities and turning constraints into innovative breakthroughs. Too often, the debate is framed in terms of what Europe gives. Too rarely is it framed in terms of what Europe and its people receive in return. With commitment, we can find pragmatic ways to maximize our investments as a union.
Building on its strengths in life sciences, Europe can advance its health sovereignty and seize the emerging opportunities in scientific discovery, next-generation vaccines and biomanufacturing. Basic and applied research become new technologies, intellectual property, skilled jobs and revenues that protect European health, growth and wealth. Together, these returns are Europe’s Health Dividend.
Europe’s health, security and prosperity depend on its ability to contribute to, and benefit from, global networks of research and innovation. Retreating from global research would not reduce vulnerability; it would increase it. Investing and engaging beyond our borders is a strategic imperative for Europe.
Retreating from global research would not reduce vulnerability; it would increase it. Investing and engaging beyond our borders is a strategic imperative for Europe.
At a time when public investment must deliver its value, we can find ways to maximize the impact of European money by working and funding a shared agenda together, not as disjointed nations. Health research remains one of the clearest examples of an investment that strengthens Europe’s future while delivering benefits today.
Kluemper A, Morris K, Mellon MJ. From plague to the promise: The journey of Bacille Calmette–Guérin. Bladder. 2024;11(4):e21200022. https://doi.org/10.14440/bladder.2024.0035
The advertisement is linked to investment in global health research and development and its contribution to Europe’s health, security, resilience and economic competitiveness.
Jensen Huang at a state dinner for Chinese President Xi Jinping and first lady Peng Liyuan in the East Room of the White House on September 24, 2026 in Washington, DC. | Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images
TORONTO — When a company is building technology that could totally transform the world — technology so high-stakes and secretive that it may underpin the future of geopolitics — you might expect its leaders to have a handle on the basics of security.
Basics like, say, not having an extramarital affair with an alleged Chinese spy. Basics like not selling the tech to someone who may help smuggle it to a top foreign adversary.
Instead America got Jensen Huang, the CEO of AI chipmaker Nvidia, who resigned Thursday after admitting that he’d had just such an affair. The woman in question, Alice Huang, worked for a company called Megaspeed, which was buying billions of dollars’ worth of chips from Nvidia. Megaspeed is under investigation for allegedly smuggling chips into China.
The spy scandal raises serious questions about security in the AI corporate world. How is it possible that an alleged Chinese spy so easily embedded into Nvidia, one of the world’s most valuable companies and a huge strategic asset to America in the global AI race?
What’s even more disturbing, however, is that Nvidia is just the tip of the iceberg.
In fact, just as the Huang story was breaking, some of the world’s top AI researchers were gathered in Toronto for the Hinton Lectures, where “godfather of AI” Geoffrey Hinton was hosting AI alignment pioneer Paul Christiano for a series of talks. I was in attendance and, strikingly, I didn’t hear Huang’s scandal mentioned once. The focus was on how the frontier AI companies are racing ahead on building this incredibly powerful technology even though they can’t keep it safe or secure it. For months now, OpenAI and Anthropic have been having their own embarrassing security problems, including corporate espionage and cyber breaches.
“We are not able to adequately secure AI developments,” Christiano, who recently joined the OpenAI nonprofit board, bluntly acknowledged at the event. “We need to be able to defend models and algorithms from theft.”
Ironically, national security is a big part of the large AI companies’ rationale for how they operate in the first place. OpenAI and Anthropic, backed by White House policy, both justify their blistering speed in the AI race by saying that the US can’t afford to let China win. And Anthropic recently justified heavily redacting a key independent report on its AI progress by claiming that it can’t afford to let China glean its secrets.
But that may be the equivalent of worrying that you’ve left the window open a crack when your front door is swinging wide open.
“I’m frustrated with a lot of the companies because they simultaneously use security as an all-purpose cudgel with which to withhold information — even information that’s very much in the public interest to know — and yet they have terrible security,” Daniel Kokotajlo, a former researcher at OpenAI who became a prominent whistleblower, told me. (Disclosure: Vox Media is one of several publishers that have signed partnership agreements with OpenAI. Our reporting remains editorially independent.)
While the story of Huang’s affair has fired up imaginations, the real lesson to be taken from his spectacular downfall is not that he was uniquely weak on security, but that he was remarkably similar to the other big players in AI. They are asking the world to trust them as they claim to be building a machine god — and, in the case of Anthropic, chasing a $1.4 trillion IPO on that basis — yet they haven’t gotten ahold of basic security.
Are OpenAI and Anthropic practically giving away their secrets due to bad security?
OpenAI revealed last month that it had found a recording device in a conference room where sensitive discussions take place. Abdulrahman Alfozan, a Saudi national working as an engineer at OpenAI, is alleged to have plugged the recorder into the USB port of a television and simply wrapped it in toilet paper. Another recorder was found in a bag in another room. Questions about how to build a device that records continuously and encrypt data also showed up on his spouse’s chatbot account.
“At this time, we have no indications of this individual inappropriately accessing or exfiltrating model weights, source code, or customer data,” OpenAI said last month, adding, “Our security program is designed to protect against a wide range of threat actors, from insider risks to cybercriminals to nation states.”
But the incident was worrisome. Alfozan had been working at OpenAI since June 2025. The recording device was sitting in that conference room for a couple of days before OpenAI discovered it. Maybe Alfozan wasn’t sophisticated enough to steal model weights — the billions of numbers that shape how an AI system turns input into output — but what if he’d been just slightly more careful or clever?
OpenAI has also had security weaknesses of a different kind — and no, it’s not just this summer’s notorious Hugging Face incident. Of the ones we know about (sometimes these are only revealed later), a recent example stands out: A group of “white-hat” hackers, who aim to find vulnerabilities but not to do a company harm, discovered a way to access OpenAI employees’ ChatGPT accounts, where sensitive research is potentially being done. The whole operation took just 72 hours.
Over at Anthropic, a group of ex-DOGE staffers who founded an AI startup called Cathedral managed to breach Anthropic’s internal systems in under 12 hours. They reportedly accessed the company’s Slack, where employees trade messages discussing the company’s state-of-the-art models, as well as meeting transcripts.
“My guess would be that the Slack would contain enough information to get a good sense of what the company is doing and how they’re training their AIs — basically, the juicy secrets would be there,” Kokotajlo told me. “And I would say getting the algorithmic secrets is like 80 percent as good as getting everything, including the model weights.”
Alleged spies (like Alice Huang or Abdulrahman Alfozan) and cyber breaches (like those targeting OpenAI and Anthropic) are obviously different types of security issues that demand very different types of internal controls. But for Kokotajlo and others, it makes sense to think of them all under the same umbrella — weak security. And it all points to a trend that seems common among the most powerful AI companies: They’re prioritizing rapid technological advancement over the perhaps more boring and slower process of ensuring their work is secure.
“They show that the companies are very far from having security adequate to protect themselves from a well-resourced state actor,” Kokotajlo said, adding: “If China wants to get the stuff, China will get the stuff.”
This is all happening against the backdrop of China’s aggressive distillation of US models, which involves training a new model on the output of a more advanced one. It’s a way to gain powerful capabilities without having to incur the real cost — a bit like cheating on a test by copying off a better student. For example, Anthropic found that the Chinese lab DeepSeek has been using Claude to improve its models, which is not a breach per se but illustrates how vigorously China is taking advantage of American companies’ research.
Kokotajlo also emphasized that there’s another bucket of security incidents we should be worried about: the hacks perpetrated against companies by their own misaligned AI models. Many people forget that in the Hugging Face incident, OpenAI agents didn’t only hack into Hugging Face — OpenAI’s own systems were breached, too. The sandbox meant to contain the agents was far from airtight, and they broke out.
“You should consider the AIs as an insider threat,” Kokotajlo said. “And it doesn’t feel like these companies have that locked down very well either.”
The top AI companies can’t keep using the security practices of a startup
There are three main reasons why security at the frontier AI companies hasn’t been up to snuff, according to David Robinson, who led transparency work for OpenAI’s safety team until he left in September.
One is the fact that the companies are building AI agents so capable that it can be genuinely hard — even for their creators — to keep them from doing damage. “We’re training systems to be good at conducting attacks of the kind that the labs internally are now also trying to defend against,” Robinson told me. “That is a challenging situation.”
There’s also a cultural problem. “If you look back with 20/20 hindsight at the Hugging Face incident, it’s clear that at the time OpenAI had underinvested in cybersecurity controls, and I think part of the reason for this was that there’s a [higher] level of cachet associated with working on alignment,” or the problem of how to get AIs to do what humans want them to do, Robinson said. “Some of the day-to-day practical questions about our cybersecurity posture — even though the people working on those questions are extremely good — I think it was not the same kind of organizational priority as it needed to be.”
Finally, there’s the fact that market incentives push AI companies to race ahead on developing the tech as fast as they can.
“Time pressure on the company,” Robinson said, “made it very difficult to be sufficiently careful.” And although researchers still at OpenAI now say the company has gotten dramatically better on security, Robinson noted that those competitive pressures “continue to exist.”
This is a well-documented trend at the company. “OpenAI’s security seems to be about what you’d expect from a research lab that scaled at a blistering pace over four years and focused more on beating its competitors than securing its infrastructure,” Joshua Saxe, the chief technology officer of the AI security firm Abundant Security, told the New York Times after the Hugging Face incident.
OpenAI itself has implicitly acknowledged that improving security measures sometimes comes “at the cost of research velocity,” as it wrote in a public memo after the incident.
But if a company cuts corners on security, it can’t ultimately protect its lead over others. If anything, it just ends up helping its adversaries race against it even faster.
As Kokotajlo and his colleagues at the AI Futures Project recently warned when writing about the companies’ quest to build a superhuman AI researcher (SAR), an AI that’s as good as the top human researcher: “If we train SAR in the immediate future, the algorithms will probably leak to China, and maybe the model weights too. AI companies have very poor security right now, and so we are on track for SAR leaking to China.”
And it’s not just that poor security can make it self-defeating for American companies to keep racing forward. Their security weakness could also make it harder for them to slow down even if they themselves want to.
In his lecture this week in Toronto, Christiano asked all of us in the audience to imagine a scenario that he said currently looks likely: We arrive at a point when further progress on AI seems risky. There’s a demand in the US to slow down. But there’s also a high probability that the AI models or algorithms have already leaked to an adversary like China.
“We now face a dilemma between either proceeding with a technology we believe to be unsafe — or risking competition from an adversary who has the same resources, who has taken those algorithms, and perhaps is willing to tolerate higher risk,” Christiano said, as the hundreds of people seated around me seemed to visibly tense up. “I think that is one of the most likely ways that we end up in an extremely bad situation.”
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang at the Nvidia/Japan AI Ecosystem Reception in Tokyo on July 16, 2026. | Philip Fong/AFP via Getty Images
Former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s sudden downfall is in a sense shocking, considering his wealth, global fame, and role leading what was until recently the world’s most valuable company.
But Huang’s immense influence in Washington — and particularly in President Donald Trump’s Washington — has long been intensely controversial among a surprisingly diverse cross-section of the political, business, and tech advocacy world. And his ouster not only drives a wedge through Trump’s second-term coalition, it could usher in a major change in how the US steers the AI revolution.
Huang — who resigned this week after allegations he’d had affairs with twoNvidia employees and one Chinese businesswoman who some US officials claim was spying on him for the Chinese government — has been crucial in helping shape the Trump administration’s AI policies. That’s perhaps no surprise, given that Nvidia’s advanced chips are crucial to the AI revolution.
His many critics, however, say Huang’s influence has been deeply harmful. Their main objection? They believe the Trump administration hasn’t been doing enough to stop China from getting or accessing advanced AI chips — in part because of Huang’s lobbying and sway with the president.
This coalition of Huang critics spans the political spectrum. It includes right-wing China hawks and the bipartisan foreign policy establishment, who want to win an AI race against China. It includes economicpopulists in both parties, who resent China’s economic sway. It even includes some leading members of the Trump administration itself — Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent have reportedly pushed for tighter chip restrictions.
It also contains some even odder bedfellows. The coalition includes people who want to slow down the AI race, like the tech safety advocates who warn that advanced AI could cause human extinction. Yet it also includes two major US frontier AI companies, OpenAI and Anthropic, who hope to impede the growth of Chinese competitors by limiting their access to chips.
All of these disparate groups come together around the core idea that the US urgently needs to do more to stop advanced chips from getting to China. Selling AI chips to China is like “selling nuclear weapons to North Korea,” Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei has said.
Standing against them all — and often getting his way with Trump — has been Jensen Huang.
Beyond the obvious — Nvidia’s business is selling chips, and Huang wants to be able to sell more chips in more places — Huang is associated with a camp in the AI policy debate that some have dubbed with “let it rip.” Along with former White House AI czar David Sacks, Huang has scoffed at warnings that AI could cause human extinction, calling them “irresponsible” and “doomsday narratives.” He’s also dismissed some national security concerns, saying that being a “China hawk” was a “badge of shame” and said that the bigger risk to American influence over AI would be US companies losing market share around the world.
So Huang’s ouster and the claims of Chinese espionage around it have opened up an opportunity for a shakeup in US policy — and a rare chance for those China hawks to potentially investigate, undermine, and push out their rivals, while seizing the policy reins around chip exports.
Trump administration officials who want tougher restrictions havetheirknives out for Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, a frequent ally of Huang’s. There’s a bipartisan push in Congress for new export controls legislation before the end of the year. Congressional Republican committee chairs are demanding Huang and Lutnick come in and testify in the coming weeks, before Democrats take over Congress.
Plus, there are the partisan incentives for Democrats to dig into the question of what Trump knew about all this (he was reportedly briefed on the spy concerns last fall). And there are political incentives for ambitious Republicans to find an issue on which they can distance themselves from an unpopular administration without antagonizing their conservative base.
With so many different forces invested in the outcome, you can bet this topic will continue to dominate headlines for months to come — with unpredictable results for both the new Democratic Congress, the future of the GOP, and the AI boom.
The many critics of Jensen Huang’s influence on the Trump administration
In Washington itself, the most influential faction opposed to Huang is the bipartisan national security establishment, most of whom strongly believe in the necessity of competing with China for global influence.
These “China hawks” were influential in the Biden administration and have historically been dominant in GOP administrations and on GOP-controlled congressional committees. And many of them have been flabbergasted at Trump’s policies toward China and Chips this term.
“I don’t think we should be using any American technology to uplift China’s capabilities in AI given how era-defining this technology will be in national security and in our economy,” Vivek Chilukuri of the Center for a New American Security, a center-left think tank, told me. “A company’s going to argue for this, that’s what companies do. But the interest of any one company should not be trumping the national security of the United States.
Moving further right, there’s a MAGA-aligned faction that is skeptical of foreign wars such as Trump’s conflict in Iran — but even some of them are still quite antagonistic to China.
Take, for instance, Trump’s onetime campaign manager and White House adviser Steve Bannon. He’s been furiously protesting Huang’s influence on the administration for more than a year — in September 2025, he argued that Huang should be arrested for being “an agent of influence of the Chinese Communist Party,” and argued we needed to “shut down” China’s “access to technology, chips, and training.”
Advocates and politicians focused on economic issues and reining in corporate power also have long criticized Nvidia. Oren Cass of the center-right group American Compass wrote an article titled “Break up Nvidia” last year, arguing that “its excessive concentration of power is exactly what antitrust law intends to combat.”
Meanwhile, the left, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), a longtime critic of Big Tech, has frequently suggested Huang was corruptly influencing the Trump administration. At a hearing in June, she mentioned that Huang or his company had donated to Trump’s inauguration and his White House ballroom project. “If it’s not plain old-fashioned bribery, it sure smells like it,” she said.
Many in the AI safety advocacy world have also long criticized — and feared — Nvidia. That’s in part because they hope slowing down sales of AI chips abroad could slow what they view as a dangerous race to superintelligence. Additionally, after AI safety fears hit the mainstream in September due to Anthropic researcher Jacob Coxon’s resignation and viral warnings, Huang took an increasingly public role in dismissing such fears.
Other AI safety advocates cite the company as having a chilling effect on public debate. “For months now, I’ve heard about widespread fear among think tank researchers and policy experts who publish work against Nvidia’s interests,” AI safety researcher Steven Adler wrote last year. “If you speak with people in-the-know at AI companies, fear of retaliation from Nvidia is a major concern when staking out policy positions.”
Indeed, OpenAI and Anthropic are highly dependent on Nvidia for its chips, so open criticism of the company is not common. Yet those big two US AI labs have been at odds with Nvidia in urging the Trump administration to do more to crack down on Chinese access to advanced chips, and to more heavily scrutinize Chinese “open source” AI models.
But to Huang and others in his camp, the growth of Chinese AI is a feature, not a bug. Sacks, for instance, has repeatedly argued that “open weight” or “open source” models — which make their parameters publicly available, in contrast to the proprietary models of OpenAI and Anthropic — would help avert “an unsafe and dystopian future where advanced AI capabilities are centralized and controlled by only a few hands.” The leading open weight models are currently from Chinese companies.
Huang has also used a more straightforward argument: that what’s good for Nvidia is good for the United States of America.
“American technology has to win across the world at every single layer,” he said in May. “If we can export chips, we should.”
Now it will be left to Nvidia’s interim CEO, Colette Kress, to carry that message, instead of a rock-star founder with a global cult following that’s drawn comparisons to Steve Jobs at his peak at Apple. Her first task: taking stock of all the powerful actors across the political, advocacy, and business world rooting for her to fail. Perhaps DeepSeek could help make a list?
An under-construction data center in Saline, Michigan, on October 6, 2026. | Jim West/UCG/Universal Images Group via Getty Images
Republicans weren’t the only big losers in last week’s midterms: Across the country, voters also backed restrictions on data centers and elected candidates promising tougher oversight of AI companies. Out of 41 local ballot initiatives limiting the data center buildout, 40 of them passed, according to the New York Times.
The AI industry knows it was a tough cycle: Chris Lehane, the chief global affairs officer for OpenAI, told Today, Explained co-host Sean Rameswaram that “I could take my shirt off and show you my [metaphorical] bruises if you want.”
Now, OpenAI is figuring out how to move forward. Lehane talked with Sean from rural Texas, where he said he was on a “listening and learning” tour of communities around the site of a massive OpenAI data center. They discussed the lessons of the midterm election, why OpenAI would prefer that we call data centers “compute campuses,” and why Lehane thinks the 2028 presidential election will largely revolve around AI — just not in the same way that 2026 did.
“I just don’t think it’s going to be good enough for a candidate from either party to emerge from their primary by simply being the person who’s against things,” Lehane said.
Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.
You guys at OpenAI, in the wake of this shellacking, put out this big document saying that you’re going to be listening, you’re going to be learning, you’re going to be empowering local people and bringing jobs.
You’re also, in this document, rebranding data centers to “compute campuses,” which when I say it, I have trouble not laughing because it sounds like a bit of a joke to meet everyone’s concerns with a rebrand. Please tell us why you think this could work or why it’s a good idea.
We were very intentional in actually using that phrase. And we did it with the full knowledge that people would potentially be skeptical of it. But I do think there’s an intent behind provoking this conversation.
Data centers have existed for 20-odd years and at some level they’re the proverbial empty box in a pasture. And they’re called data centers because that’s in fact what they were. When people talked about the cloud, this is actually where the cloud was housed, where you would load data if you were streaming a video, if you were ordering something from a delivery service. These AI facilities are really fundamentally different.
What is being generated at these facilities is something called compute. And compute is just the raw computing power that it takes to train AI systems and then run AI tools and products when you’re using them.
Second of all, they’re different because [of] the amount of jobs that do get created directly. This is not half a dozen people in that empty box. These are real jobs, these are six-figure jobs. They are also huge opportunities for economic transformation if a community approaches it in a really strategic way and companies like ours do our part to work with those communities. We’re not just building in the communities, we’re building with the communities.
You’re out there in Texas because essentially, data centers and artificial intelligence have a PR problem. Seventy percent of the country, maybe more than that, says that they’re against data centers, or “compute campuses,” as you’re now calling them.
Why do you think it is that data centers have such a public relations issue in this country right now?
There’s a variety of factors, but before even jumping into those, I do think it’s worth noting and worth emphasizing that we have roughly six of these projects up and running in the country. They’re in different stages of being built out and developed, but each and every one of them is moving forward. I do think that there is a right way to build these and perhaps a wrong way and we can get into that.
Do you think that you guys were doing it the wrong way before?
This goes to why I think we’ve actually been able to get approvals for each of the projects that we are doing.
I think each of the individual projects themselves have been some version of a laboratory of democracy, where you actually learn from each project and apply those learnings to the next project. But I do think we got the fundamental insight right at the beginning, which is to actually go on the ground, listen, learn, hold yourself accountable and take the feedback and build your facility with the community.
I think that for a lot of communities, folks were coming in, they were building data centers, they were then transferring the electricity costs to the public, they were potentially impacting their water, they weren’t necessarily doing the type of community investments that you should do if you’re going to be building with a community.
Where we’ve really tried to differ ourselves — and again, we’re not perfect, we’re learning every step of the way — but I do think that we have successfully applied the baseline as we’ve gone through this, which is, we make sure we’re paying for our own electricity, our own energy.
Point two is that we make sure we’re preserving water. We have something called closed water loops. I know this is getting a little bit technical, but think of these as sort of large radiators. You fill it up once and therefore you’re able to preserve the water.
One thing that seems clear from the election results is that there’s just not a lot of trust. Now there’s going to be a new Congress, and various components of said Congress are pledging to do more to regulate AI and tech.
It wasn’t so long ago that the head of your company, Sam Altman, was calling for Congress to get more involved. Does that call still stand now that it’s a different Congress that might be more inclined to come down hard on AI?
When it comes to data centers, these are typically state or local issues. We envisioned that as state legislation that would actually make these requirements for folks who are building data centers to help give the public confidence that there’s going to be a real material benefit for them.
I think what you’re referring to was our call as OpenAI for there to be national-level mandatory safety requirements for the frontier labs who are building AI. We thought about that and called for it before the election. We think it’s more important than ever.
Back in early September, I had a blog post out there that talked about this idea that the policy window was opening up to create a real opportunity to pass those mandatory safety requirements. And the reason I talked about the policy window being opened up is that you could clearly see where the politics were going, what was likely to happen with the election.
You’re in Washington, DC. At some level, you have to be a romanticist to believe that you can actually get legislation passed. But what is happening is the politics are coming into alignment with the policy. I actually think both parties do recognize the importance of having mandatory national safety standards that would be good for the country. It would also put us in a position to be able to create international standards, which we also think is very important.
It’s funny, because we just had New York [state] assemblyman Alex Bores on the show. He was trying to be a congressperson, but a super PAC partly funded by OpenAI co-founders and some other Silicon Valley tech types spent a lot of money — millions — to defeat him.
We asked him, if Democrats in Congress could do one thing to regulate AI, what would it be? And he said banning full recursive self-improvement, ban the practice of letting AIs build the next AIs without any human in the loop. Would OpenAI be open to that kind of regulation immediately?
The version that we have talked about is some version of broadly defined speed limits. I’ll use an analogy: As we were building out the automobile, ultimately we built out speed limits. Now, those speed limits changed over time, but the idea was to make sure that humans could actually have both hands on the wheel and be able to control the car and the car should not be able to go at a speed where a human would not be able to control it.
Our north star in everything when it comes to AI is that people should be in control of this technology. The technology itself is accelerating, the capabilities are becoming stronger. And so I think there is a world here where we do need to build out a framework, potentially a regulatory framework, through legislation that effectively imposes some version of a speed limit.
If you think of speed limits being applied in the context of your question about recursive self-improvement, that’s a place where you could see the speed of the technology getting so strong that actually humans do lose control over it.
I’m not sure it’s quite as binary as saying you do or do not do RSI. But I think spiritually, a similar concept, which is making sure that at the end of the day we have a lot of confidence that humans are actually in control of this, able to monitor it, able to make sure that it is not getting out of their control.
Before you worked with companies like OpenAI or Coinbase or Airbnb, you worked in government and you worked specifically in [the] Clinton White House.
I wonder, in the wake of this election — which people are calling the first big American AI election, and are saying that AI is going to be an even bigger issue for the presidential election in 2028 — what do you think companies like yours and all the other big-frontier AI companies need to be doing to flip the script in the United States, maybe around the world?
I think of 2026 as the trailer to 2028. AI was an issue. It wasn’t a top issue, but it was certainly an issue and an issue that was moving up the charts as we got closer and closer to the election. I think there is a decent chance, maybe even a strong chance, that AI is the issue in 2028.
First and foremost, how do we make sure that people are actually in control of this technology? Who’s actually putting out an idea and a vision and approach to give people confidence that they’re going to actually be able to control this?
I do think the 2026 election now sets up 2028, frankly for both parties, to have a conversation that I just don’t think we’ve had in this country for a long, long, long time. And that is, what does this social contract look like? Who actually has a big idea about how we’re going to make sure that the American dream actually exists in this country? And as part of that big idea, what is the role of AI going to be in that?
I just don’t think it’s going to be good enough for a candidate from either party to emerge from their primary by simply being the person who’s against things. I think they’re actually going to have to have some real ideas of what they are for. And at the core of that is, how are they going to address this anxiety that the American people have? And at the center of that anxiety is their ability to control their lives and make decisions about their lives.
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang in October 2026. | Joel Saget/AFP via Getty Images
The first big sex scandal of the AI era has taken down Jensen Huang, Nvidia’s co-founder and longtime CEO. Nvidia’s board of directors announced his resignation on Thursday morning and named CFO Colette Kress as interim CEO.
Huang has been making headlines all week after news broke Friday that he had an affair with Alice Huang (no relation), an executive at Singaporean tech firm Megaspeed who the US government alleges was also a Chinese spy.
The revelation Wednesday of a second extramarital affair, this time with an Nvidia employee reporting to Huang directly, added to the pressure, and another affair came to light later on Thursday after Huang’s ouster.
The scandal has implications far beyond one company: Huang’s central role in the AI race can’t be overstated. It was his vision of an AI future that led him to pivot Nvidia from a small company making video game chips into the dominant player in making the chips that serve OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google’s computing needs.
Huang is close friends with President Donald Trump’s and a leading voice in resisting efforts to slow AI progress. And he has pushed for the US to take a less hawkish position toward China’s own AI goals, a stance now called into question by his relationship with an alleged Chinese spy. Among its other impacts, the news has revived efforts on Capitol Hill to further restrict chip exports to China.
To break down the national security implications of Huang’s departure, how the Trump administration is involved, and what it says about US AI industry writ large, Today, Explained co-host Sean Rameswaram spoke with Garret De Vynck, a technology reporter at the Washington Post.
Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get your podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.
Nvidia has been called the central bank of AI, which is why it’s so important that we figure out what Jensen Huang may have disclosed to this alleged spy. How long has the president known about this, as far as we know?
As far as we know, the president has known about the fact that Jensen Huang was in a relationship with someone that the US government thought was a spy for about a year. This circulated within the administration, and the decision was made not to tell Jensen.
That doesn’t necessarily mean that it was automatically some kind of corrupt decision of President Trump protecting Jensen Huang. There’s all sorts of reasons why you might not want to tell someone they’re being spied on, the number one being that they might blow up the operation. Maybe you want to learn more. Maybe you suspect that the person themselves knows that they’re being spied on and is willingly sharing information and you need some more time to gather that. It’s unclear why the US government specifically chose not to pull in Jensen Huang.
It’s also a little bit unclear whether he knows he was being spied on, or whether maybe he was told through some kind of back channel. He has said that he did not know that she was a spy and he is admitting to the affair, to the infidelity. He’s admitting to essentially breaking Nvidia’s code of conduct by sleeping with one of its customers, but he is not admitting at all to knowing that she was a spy and definitely not admitting to sharing any information willfully.
It feels like this is the kind of thing that the government would investigate. There’s been reporting that the Commerce Department was involved with some kind of investigation, but that investigation came to an end and no one really knows why.
The context here is that the United States and China are in an AI race. Going back to the first Trump administration, there’s been pretty aggressive export controls saying, “We don’t want China to get our tech so that they can develop AI.” And the Biden administration continued that. He increased the export controls on China. China was complaining very loudly about this. They said, ‘We don’t care. We want to win AI and we need to slow you guys down.’
When Trump came in, he actually lifted his foot off the gas a little bit. They didn’t throw the gates open and say, “You can have whatever you want. All American companies can sell whatever they want to China.” But he said, “Some AI chips that are less powerful than the state of the art. We can send those to Chinese companies.“
The other thing that national security experts have pointed out is that the Trump administration could theoretically have been doing more to stop the smuggling of computer chips to China. And that’s where this story gets so important for national security.
Megaspeed is accused of essentially being a front for Chinese companies to get access to computer chips. Journalists have gone to Megaspeed’s office in Singapore where it’s based, and there were only a couple of people working there. It didn’t really seem like there was a lot going on. Nvidia has said all through this process over the last couple of years that, “No, we’ve checked it out, Megaspeed is a legitimate company and we’re not breaking the law when it comes to this.”
There are a lot of questions and what everyone is focused on finding out, both journalists and I would say congressional Democrats when they come into office in the new year is, is there something more going on here? Is there something where the Chinese either convinced Jensen Huang to sell more chips to them or Jensen Huang himself, who has been advocating for selling more chips to China, essentially did this himself?
“I think there’s this real question of: Do we see a much stronger push to actually ramp up controls on China and how does Trump respond?”
He’s been pressuring the president, he’s been donating to him, he’s been glad-handing with the president and the president has been listening more to this corporate executive who is his friend and who donated him a bunch of money rather than listening to China hawks or national security experts who say we should be limiting what China is able to access.
That’s really where the locus of this investigation is going to be. It’s not so much that Jensen Huang had an affair. It’s more the fact that he himself is someone who has said we need to sell more computer chips to China and he was involved with an alleged Chinese spy, and he’s very close to the president and had influence on the president.
You mentioned the Democrats. Have they said anything? Are they going to call him in front of Congress for an investigation?
Going forward, there are two big things here. One of them is these investigations into Jensen Huang and this whole situation. The company is likely going to continue to investigate. Maybe more information will come out there. Jensen Huang has been called to speak later this month in Congress. And congressional Democrats have also said that when they come into power in January, they will be asking him.
The second big thing that comes out of this is, what does America do when it comes to China and AI? Now that one of the biggest advocates for being a bit more friendly towards China when it comes to selling them things that they need for AI is out of the room and completely discredited, I think that the China hawks, those who say we need to crack down more aggressively, we need to limit China’s access to AI computer chips, they’re really coming into ascendance here and they’re in the Republican Party, they’re in the Democratic Party, some of them, people like Marco Rubio, are even in the Cabinet.
I think there’s this real question of: Do we see a much stronger push to actually ramp up controls on China and how does Trump respond? There’s all sorts of geopolitical things that could sort of spin out of this CEO affair.
I’m old enough to remember when a board tried to get rid of Sam Altman and then he was just back a week later. Elon Musk is already offering Jensen Huang a job. Is there a fair chance that he just goes somewhere that’s not that concerned about espionage affairs or getting with your VP of health or whatever it is? Is he just going to go work for China?
I don’t think he’s going to go work for China. This is definitely the wildest corporate story since Sam Altman was fired as CEO and brought back three or four days later. It’s a very different situation. That was a startup where you essentially have five or six investors who get to make the call about who the CEO is, and the employees at that company overwhelmingly wanted to bring Sam Altman back. I think they wanted more continuity of the company, but they also wanted to make sure that their company didn’t go under and go bankrupt and get disappeared, which was sort of on the table at that point in time.
Nvidia’s not going anywhere. Obviously employees have lost a lot of money in terms of the stock value already coming down due to the situation. So employees are probably shocked. They’re probably upset. Jensen Huang is broadly loved at Nvidia, and so I can definitely see that employees would be doing petitions, asking for him to return.
But this is a giant public company and the board makes a decision here. Jensen Huang was untruthful publicly and I think that also will make other public companies hesitant before rushing to bring him on as CEO.
As we’ve talked about many times in the show, half of our economy is staked on AI at this point. How concerned should we be that one of the most important people in this industry was so easily duped in this honeypot situation? Are these the people we should be trusting with the future of our society?
It’s a really good reminder that people are people. I think that we like to lionize individuals and say that they are the ones who are going to take us into the future and they are inventing the future and it’s so incredible. And I do think Jensen Huang gets a lot of credit for making sure that the companies kept up in AI, but at the end of the day, it was also a lucky break for them that the computer chips they were making just happened to work well for the math that is required by artificial intelligence.
I do think that this speaks to something that a lot of people across the country and maybe even the world really feel. They do not want to sign off the future to a dozen dudes in Silicon Valley and their collaborators in the Trump White House. I think that is a view that a lot of people increasingly have. I think it was one of the factors in the midterms, maybe not the most important one, but people are concerned about concentration of power. They’re concerned about AI and they don’t see it as something that they themselves have control over.
I think that this is just going to be another thing that sort of adds skepticism to the idea that people like Jensen Huang should be the ones making the final decision when it comes to artificial intelligence.
BRUSSELS — Australia’s Industry Minister Tim Ayres formally signed the country up to Horizon Europe on Thursday, giving the country’s researchers access to the EU’s €95 billion research and innovation program.
Australia will join Pillar II of the program, which funds research into areas including advanced computing tech, critical minerals, health, climate and clean energy. From January, Australian organizations will be eligible for funding on the same terms as EU countries and will be able to lead project consortia.
The move will be a “boon for Australian science, research and innovation,” Ayres said in a statement, adding that “the big challenges facing Australia and the world cannot be solved by any one country working alone.”
The signing formalizes negotiations concluded in June. Australian organizations have already taken part in 239 Horizon Europe projects, with nearly one in four applications selected, according to the European Commission.
ANTALYA, Turkey — World leaders and industry must make electric cars and heat pumps affordable if they are to ensure “people on all incomes” can “make the green transition,” U.K. Prime Minister Andy Burnham told the COP31 climate summit.
During a flying visit to this year’s U.N. conference in Turkey, Burnham — who has made affordability his core domestic political focus — reaffirmed the U.K.’s commitment to the goal of net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.
But he warned that the world had “not moved as quick as I had hoped in the past five years” to show citizens that climate action and electrification have cost-of-living upsides.
“The last of these meetings I attended was COP26 as the mayor of Greater Manchester,” Burnham said, referring to the 2021 summit hosted by the U.K. He warned at the time that the climate movement must not lose sight of the “struggles of ordinary families.”
“The world feels very different now, and we need to adapt,” Burnham said. “Electrification in transport, heat and industry is how we make clean power, cheap power.”
While voicing support for COP31 hosts Turkey and Australia’s electrification push, Burnham stopped short of backing the specific target of 35% of global energy use shifting to electricity by 2035.
But he emphasized the benefits the switch could bring, while urging industry to help ensure it helped all consumers.
“If you drive a new electric car today in the U.K., it costs less than a petrol equivalent. Get on the right tariff and a heat pump can be cheaper to run than a gas boiler. These technologies are becoming cheaper, but they are not available to everybody on all incomes,” he said.
“As a government, we are doing our bit by investing in innovation and subsidizing upfront costs for the public. But we need industry to play their part too, and help people on all incomes to make the green transition.”
The focus on EVs and heat pumps comes despite Burnham’s government cutting the subsidy pot for heat pumps at last month’s budget. Ministers are also weighing proposals to water down industry EV quotas.
Nonetheless, Burnham reiterated the U.K.’s over-arching strategy to cut dependence on fossil fuels.
“The climate crisis is not a distant threat. It is upon us all now, devastating lives and livelihoods everywhere. Meanwhile, two wars across two continents have sent fuel prices and gas bills soaring for families and businesses across the world,” he said. “The common thread running through all of this: our dependence on fossil fuels.”
He announced the U.K. would use its G20 presidency next year to “put climate resilience back on the agenda, with debt, development, and insurance as key issues.”
Burnham’s government has also created a new role of special representative for climate security, appointing former head of the Joint Intelligence Committee Chair Madeline Alessandri to the post.
BRUSSELS — Top global gaming companies have blasted new EU consumer regulations they say would “cripple the competitiveness of Europe’s world-leading video games industry.”
The European Commission unveiled a new set of rules Wednesday on consumer protection, including the Digital Fairness Act, that is part of the first-ever sector-specific limits on the video-game industry, alongside the EU’s mid-September regulation to protect children online.
Under the proposed DFA, which still has to be negotiated with other EU institutions, video games would no longer be able to earn money by offering minors micro-transactions to advance in the game, known as pay-to-win or pay-to-progress. There are also restrictions on “loot boxes,” which contain surprise virtual items that players can buy with real money. The law also stipulates that in-app virtual currencies must be turned off by default for under-18s.
The Commission says these practices encourage overspending, which is especially dangerous for vulnerable consumers like kids. Violating the rules can lead to fines of up to 6% of global revenue in cases that affect more than two-thirds of the EU population.
“We want the European gaming industry to continue to thrive,” said Michael McGrath, the commissioner for consumer protection, announcing the measures. But competition, McGrath added, should be based “on creativity, innovation, and quality, and not on practices that exploit consumers.”
In a joint statement, the European Game Developer Federation, an association representing EU firms, and Video Games Europe, which includes global juggernauts like Sony and Epic Games, say that the proposed definition of pay-to-win is “fundamentally flawed, lacks clear definitions and would create huge confusion for players and developers alike” since it could cover “any purchase.”
Angry Birds & friends
While Europe has struggled to keep up with the U.S. and China in several tech sectors as AI and social media, the bloc is home to developers of some of the world’s most popular games such as Angry Birds and The Witcher. Video game spending in the bloc topped €27 billion, accounting for 17% of the global market, last year, according to the European Audiovisual Observatory.
The gaming groups argue that the industry already does a good job regulating itself with parental controls and the content rating system PEGI, which the DFA doesn’t take into account.
“Effectively, the DFA moves all decisions from parents and children to the Commission,” they wrote.
The DFA aims to regulate a slew of other industries, cracking down on manipulative practices in online commerce such as addictive design, dynamic pricing and making it difficult to unsubscribe from a digital subscription.
Cancer claims 10 million lives each year, the global shortage of health workers runs into the millions, and in some parts of the world, a single mosquito bite can be fatal.
These challenges may seem very different. Yet they share a common element in how many health systems operate: risk is often recognised only after it has become illness, outbreak or crisis. By then, a disease may have advanced, transmission of disease may be under way, or an already stretched workforce may be managing consequences that earlier action could have reduced.
The opportunity is to move that point of intervention earlier. This is what anticipatory health means in practice: using signals that already exist, at the bedside, in communities, and in routine health data, to help people and health systems act sooner. It is not prediction for its own sake. The value lies in connecting early and everyday signals to a timely, practical response.
Finding practical routes to earlier action
That principle sits at the heart of the Future Health Impact Challenge: Building Anticipatory Health Systems through Population Sensing, launched by Future Health – A Global Initiative by Abu Dhabi in collaboration with MIT Solve. The Challenge received 393 submissions from 68 countries. ThinkMD, VectorCam and Huna emerged as its three award-winning solutions: ThinkMD received the grand prize, with VectorCam and Huna recognised as distinguished finalists.
Future Health Impact Challenge: Trailer
The Challenge was designed to identify practical solutions with evidence of impact and potential to scale. Each of the three selected teams demonstrated their approach to using technology to turn an early signal into decisions that support anticipatory actions a health system can take.
Frontline care as a population signal
ThinkMD starts with the interaction between a frontline health worker and a patient. Its offline mobile platform guides structured assessments aligned with clinical protocols, supporting providers where doctors, connectivity, and diagnostic tools may be scarce. Almost 10,000 frontline health workers across 885 facilities are now using it.
Each consultation also creates structured data. Across facilities, that information can reveal changes in symptoms and service demand. In Zambia, analysis of around one million encounters identified symptom patterns several months before a confirmed cholera outbreak. In Kenya, deployment data showed improvements in identifying danger signs in infants and prescribing antibiotics correctly for childhood pneumonia.
It is not prediction for its own sake.
“The utilisation of AI in healthcare is an absolute game changer. Not only can we increase access for patients, but we can also increase access to information to make correct and appropriate diagnoses and give the right treatment to the right patient at the right time. Future Health has been a really critical platform to be able to accelerate our mission of moving from reactionary to anticipatory care,” said Dr Jackie Rabec of ThinkMD.
The award has given ThinkMD support and visibility as it works to expand into new health systems and strengthen how frontline data becomes timely intelligence for decision-makers. That is one measure of the Challenge’s impact: helping proven solutions move towards sustained, wider adoption.
Earlier signals from the environment and routine data
VectorCam begins with the environment around a community. Using a low-cost smartphone imaging device and offline AI, community health workers can photograph and identify mosquitoes in the field. Each observation generates time- and location-based data that can help authorities see changing vector risk as the first signal of disease patterns, before a spread in local communities and populations.
The value lies in connecting early and everyday signals to a timely, practical response.
Field evaluations show data completeness rising from approximately 60% to more than 90%. With support from the Future Health Impact Challenge, VectorCam aims to strengthen its early-warning capability, integrate additional data sources and expand into national surveillance programmes.
Huna looks for earlier cancer-risk signals in information that health systems already generate. Its platform analyses routine complete blood count data to identify people with an elevated risk and prioritises them for screening. It does not diagnose cancer from a blood test; it helps direct limited screening capacity, and supports patients and healthcare professionals through the next steps.
In Brazil, Huna’s deployments have screened more than 500,000 people and detected hundreds of cancer cases. Its experience also highlights a critical ‘last mile’: identifying risk is not enough if a person does not complete the diagnostic pathway. Recognition and funding from the Challenge could help support further validation across new populations and facilitate new international partnerships.
Innovation is only the starting point
Together, these solutions show that useful signals can come from a variety of sources – including clinical encounters, environmental surveillance, and routine diagnostics. They also show that anticipatory approaches can be built where connectivity, specialist capacity, or access to screening is limited, and that innovation developed in those settings can share insights that can be localised and adopted globally.
But a successful technology or pilot is not the same as system-wide impact. Scaling requires local validation, integrated into existing workflows, responsible data governance, sustainable financing, workforce training, and evidence that earlier insight changes decisions and outcomes.
A successful technology or pilot is not the same as system-wide impact.
“The solutions emerging from this Challenge reflect both the urgency and the opportunity facing health systems globally. By bringing innovators together with policymakers, funders and implementers through platforms such as Future Health, we can help accelerate solutions that are locally grounded and capable of delivering impact at scale,” said Hala Hanna, Executive Director of MIT Solve.
From recognition to system-level impact
The Future Health Impact Challenge is part of Future Health’s wider role as a year-round platform for action. Together with our partners and colleagues across diverse sectors and geographies, Future Health identifies promising solutions, supports their development, builds international connections and brings together the policy, clinical, research and investment expertise needed to move from proof to concept to measurable impact.
The Future Health impact documentary film is now available to watch, and shares personal commentary from the founders of the three companies, local stories of the solutions in action, and commentary from the Challenge owners and collaborator.
Watch the full Future Health Impact Challenge Film here.
Jensen Huang, CEO of Nvidia, pictured at the Invest in Germany Summit on October 19, 2026 in Berlin. | Thomas Koehler/Photothek via Getty Images
Editor’s note, November 12, 3:35 pm ET: This story was originally posted on November 9 and is being republished today in light of Jensen Huang’s resignation as Nvidia CEO.
The movie version of Jensen Huang’s jaw-dropping affair basically writes itself.
Cast BD Wong as 63-year-old Huang, the CEO of one of the world’s most valuable companies and a close friend of President Donald Trump. Kelly Hu can play Alice Huang, Jensen’s paramour and — even better — a purported agent of the Chinese government.
The role of Trump himself, who reportedly knew about Huang’s undercover girlfriend but on Sunday said Huang “probably has an excuse for it,” can be played by Alec Baldwin. (Or a flightless duck — your pick.) However you cast it, this whole sordid affair has “serialized Netflix drama” written all over it.
Nvidia supplies much of the computing power behind the AI boom, giving it enormous influence over the broader economy. “If they sneeze, everybody else catches a cold,” the writer and economic commentator Kyla Scanlon told Vox’s Today, Explained podcast last year. That makes this whole episode a little more weighty than your standard billionaire’s affair.
Nvidia is the most valuable company on Earth — but in many households, it’s still not a household name.
Huang and two other electrical engineers founded the now-$4.5-trillion company in 1993 with the fairly niche and nerdy goal of making high-powered chips that could render the 3D graphics for a new generation of video games.
Then, in 2006, the company released software tools that let programmers use its chips for other demanding computing tasks, like mining cryptocurrency and training AI models. When companies like OpenAI began developing tools like ChatGPT, they immediately turned to Nvidia.
That made the company a cornerstone of America’s AI buildout and a major economic force. In 2024, Nvidia alone accounted for more than a fifth of the S&P 500’s total return. And the rush to build out AI infrastructure has accounted for much of America’s recent economic growth, according to St. Louis Fed researchers.
Nvidia’s influence extends to the White House, too, where Huang is a regular guest of Trump. The two became fast friends after having dinner together at Mar-a-Lago last year, and Huang has said Trump regularly calls him late at night to discuss topics like “protecting national security” and “creating more jobs.”
But Huang’s ambitions have run up against one major obstacle: US restrictions on selling Nvidia’s most advanced chips to China. US officials worry that their enormous computing power could help Beijing develop weapons, strengthen its military, expand surveillance, and otherwise rival US military and technological dominance.
That helps explain why China (allegedly) sicced a spy on Huang: They really want these chips. The New York Times reports that China’s top intelligence agency recruited Alice Huang both to learn more about America’s advanced chip industry and to potentially influence Nvidia’s push to lift export restrictions. Alice Huang, it should be noted, was a data center executive in her own right, and her company has been investigated for purportedly helping to smuggle Nvidia chips into China.
All these investigations will hopefully, eventually, reveal whether their affair compromised anything beyond Huang’s marriage. They may also test how dependent Nvidia is on his leadership.
With Huang out as CEO, uncertainty over the company’s future could unsettle investors and trigger wobbles in the wider market. That’s the problem with concentrating so much power in any one person or company: One person’s (very) personal business can somehow become everybody’s problem.
One link for later
➨ Get a hobby. But not just any hobby: something that’s intentionally imperfect, unproductive or unquantified. There’s a tendency in American culture to try to optimize or commodify our leisure, the writer Jenny Odell explains. But that undermines some of leisure’s biggest benefits — like cultivating a sense of joy, wonder, or learning.
Before you go…
Did you know…that Alexander Graham Bell reportedly wanted people to answer the phone with a cheerful “ahoy”? Alas, Thomas Edison’s preferred greeting — “hello” — won out instead.
Today’s trivia: Cleopatra was killed by what animal, according to several contemporaneous accounts? (You can find this and other brain puzzles in Vox’s daily crossword. Look for the answer in tomorrow’s edition.)
Yesterday’s trivia: Last week we asked you for Ricky Martin’s biggest hit. That would be “Livin’ La Vida Loca,” the 1999 bop that’s widely credited with launching the Latin pop explosion of the late 1990s and early 2000s.
This post intially appeared in Today, Explained, a daily newsletter that helps you understand the most compelling news and stories of the day. Subscribe here.
When was the last time you had to call customer support with a problem? Can you remember how it went?
If you’re like most Americans, the answer is “probably not very well.” And that may be understating it: As of 2025, according to the “National Customer Rage Survey” — yes, it’s a real thing — nearly 80 percent of Americans ran into a “product or service problem” in the past year, and nearly two-thirds experienced “rage” in attempting to resolve it.
We have, in short, entered into a rage economy, where high prices and inflation have made everyday products unaffordable at the same time as our experiences buying those products have filled us with fury.
The landscape isn’t really improving, either: As a consumer, you’re faced with terrible customer service, unhelpful chatbots, and products that are worse than they used to be.
If you listen to the big AI companies, however, there’s a light on the horizon: AI agents, which can step in and do the things you don’t want to (like waiting on hold or dueling it out with aforementioned unhelpful chatbots). But are AI agents really the key to fixing our rage economy? Or will they just be what brings it deeper into chaos?
Charlie Warzel, a staff writer at The Atlantic, recently went deep on what happens when we bring AI agents into our already contentious consumer experience (along with his colleague Matteo Wong).
Today, Explained co-host Sean Rameswaram spoke with Warzel about how AI agents are being used for the grating parts of our lives, what happens when companies use their own AI agents to deal with consumers, and where this all might leave us.
Below is an excerpt of their conversation, edited for length and clarity. There’s much more in the full podcast, so listen to Today, Explained wherever you get podcasts, including Apple Podcasts, Pandora, and Spotify.
Charlie, we spoke about how the economy and how customer service works is making everyone rage out. Are AI agents going to make it better or worse?
In the early time, it’s probably going to make it a lot worse. What we are essentially seeing right now is that these agents are inundating the internet with persistence.
These are relentless things that are tasked to do the onerous activities that we don’t want to do. And they’re already flooding call centers. They’re flooding restaurant reservations. They’re flooding plumbers and people who run small businesses with requests and queries. And they’re not people.
It’s going to make a lot of people feel, honestly, pretty awful. The world has all of a sudden become very inhuman or there are these inhuman burdens being put on the humans who don’t have agents yet to work on their behalf. And that imbalance is going to make a lot of people pretty mad.
You wrote for The Atlantic that we are not ready for our coming AI agent future. How are we not ready for this?
If it reaches a critical mass, the argument is that we aren’t ready for it because the economy is built off of, and in a lot of ways thrives off of, inefficiency — off of the fact that people aren’t paying perfect attention to everything.
People aren’t moving their money from savings account to savings account every day because they’re getting the margins on a slightly better interest rate or something like that. This entire subscription economy is based off of inefficiency. You don’t cancel the thing that you don’t use for a long period of time or it lays dormant for a while.
But what these AI agents offer in their most idealized fashion is that they pay perfect attention to everything, all the time. They are hypervigilant and able to act on your behalf in inhuman ways. And if a large portion of the population is using these to do their banking, to do their e-commerce, and at the same time you have these large organizations like banks, healthcare companies, platforms like Amazon and Walmart, you’re going to see just incredible amounts of chaos.
The economy would, in that way, start to behave more like the stock market, where prices fluctuate on the order of milliseconds. And from watching the stock market over decades, I don’t know if we want diapers to behave like securities.
One of the more speculative but also illustrative ideas here is what people refer to as an agentic bank run. This is the idea that, say, 5 million people are using the same agent to do all of their banking and they all identify at the same time that there is a high-yield savings account that everyone should be in. So they move money en masse: millions of agents pulling money out of one account to the next, and then those banks are struggling because they’ve just lost all of these deposits at once. It’s theoretically possible that something like that could happen all of the time.
Is this a two-way street? Are the companies also adopting agents into every part of their processes and consumer relations?
Yes. It’s slower on that end, but I like to think of this as an arms race.
A lot of retailers, especially Amazon, have blocked a number of these agents from accessing their platform. Because even though Amazon can make good money off of these sales, they don’t yet want these companies to have access to their backend infrastructure.
There are a lot of corporate secrets like inventory and who’s buying what and who’s selling what. These agents can act as really good intelligence gatherers if they’re granted access to these platforms.
What you’ll see eventually is that the retailers are going to have demands: “You guys can let the agents on the platform, but you can’t undercut our prices in this way.” It will just be something that you have to trust that your AI agent company is making a deal in your best interest.
I think that that’s really interesting because you could end up having this future where everything feels really good as a consumer because it’s frictionless: “My agent’s going to do all this stuff for me while I sleep or while I’m hanging out with my family or whatnot.” And in reality, what’s going to happen is you’re just having someone do something for you, but nothing else has really changed. You’re not getting a better deal. It’s not that much more helpful to you because these companies have taken care of themselves first.
But that is the promise. That is what Sam Altman and Mark Zuckerberg are trying to sell us.
Do you think it’s a pipe dream or do you think there is some reality, one day, when we as a society will say, “This consumer-facing AI agent world of ours is better than the one we had a hundred years ago”?
Something that I think is really funny is Meta, with Muse, has really dominated the conversation about these AI assistants. And this is the company that wanted to connect the world, that says that us being together is this universal good, it is strengthening the bonds of humanity.
This is a tool that is fundamentally antisocial. You don’t have to interact with those people if you don’t want to. I’m not trying to romanticize running really annoying errands when you’re busy and your kids are sick and you’ve got work deadlines and things, but there’s also the experience of interacting with people on a day-to-day basis that is foundational to our humanity and these things basically want to automate that away.
That’s a real thing that we need to think about and grapple with. And the other part of this is, what are we freeing this time up for?
I’m always wondering that myself, because that’s what they keep promising. You’re going to have so much time…to do what? To then just spend more time scrolling your platforms?
To spend more time scrolling your platforms, spend more time working. There is a lack of thought about what a human is for if we fully embrace automation in all these different ways, right? It’s one thing to say, “I wish it was easier to buy paper towels on Amazon.” It’s another to say—
It’s pretty easy, though.I don’t do it that often, but I’m pretty sure it’s really easy.
It is. I think it’s good to have those interactions and it’s okay to sand down some of them, but this future suggests, what if you never had to do anything you didn’t want to do? And I don’t know if they’ve thought that through.