❌

Normal view

Uganda in talks to host EU migration hub

17 November 2026 at 18:32

VIENNA — Uganda is in talks with European Union countries about hosting a hub for rejected asylum-seekers, a senior official from the African nation told POLITICO.

On Monday, five EU countries — Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands — announced plans to start deportations to a center in Rwanda from next year.

On Tuesday, Vincent Waiswa Bagiire, permanent secretary to Uganda’s foreign affairs ministry, confirmed that his country was interested in hosting a return hub.

Bagiire said Uganda had a “discussion” with the Netherlands but “we haven’t got far.” He didn’t say which other countries Uganda had been speaking with but said the talks were not that advanced: “Let me say that the discussion is at a stage of a cup of coffee.”

In June, European diplomats said Uganda and Uzbekistan were being discussed as potential locations for EU migration centers. However, Uganda has three criteria that need to be met before it can host a hub, Bagiire said on the sidelines of a conference in Vienna hosted by the International Centre for Migration Policy Development.

“If we are to establish a hub, it will be strictly for people of African origin; they should not have a criminal record; [and] no unaccompanied minors,” he said.

He added that the discussions involve “no more than 50” people, who would be sent to open facilities. “No detention, they’re not prisons — at all. People can integrate within the communities … they’re free to do whatever they need to do. The same way we treat our refugees,” he said.

Rwanda hits back at asylum-seeker return hub criticism

17 November 2026 at 14:50

VIENNA — Rwanda’s interior minister has rebuked criticism of a plan by five European Union countries to deport failed asylum-seekers to his country.

Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands on Monday announced a partnership with Rwanda to set up a deportation hub. They aim to send the first asylum-seekers to the African country in 2027.

The plan comes after the EU adopted legislation that allows countries to negotiate deals to build such “return hubs” outside the bloc — as long as they meet human rights standards. The announcement led to a storm of protest from civil society and human rights groups, which said the fundamental rights of people sent to Rwanda cannot be guaranteed.

Rwanda’s interior minister, Vincent Biruta, disagreed.

“Human rights in Rwanda are respected and granted to everyone and specifically to refugees who choose to come to our country,” Biruta said Tuesday, speaking on a panel at a conference in Vienna hosted by the International Centre for Migration Policy Development.

He argued his country’s migration policies are among the “most progressive” as they allow refugees to work and start a business.

In a joint warning against the plan Monday, 47 organizations pointed to a 2023 court decision that slapped down the United Kingdom’s plans to process asylum seekers’ claims in Rwanda. It cited “substantial grounds” to believe that people sent to the African nation would be exposed “to a real risk of ill-treatment by reason of refoulement” — referring to a practice whereby people are forcibly moved to countries where they face real threats. Under a 2013 deal with Israel, people sent to Rwanda “were routinely moved clandestinely to Uganda,” the court added.

Biruta said he was “not surprised” by NGOs’ warnings and said the government faced “the same issue” when it was making plans with the U.K. Those plans “didn’t work but … helped to improve our asylum system,” he added.

NGOs “always … say that nothing is working, that our human rights record is bad,” Biruta said, “but I’d like them to come forward with an alternative solution.” 

EU ministers repeatedly stressed Monday that their partnership with Rwanda would meet international and European standards. Biruta said his country would put in place an independent monitoring mechanism and that it wants to involve the International Organization for Migration and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.

Details about such mechanisms and cooperation, as well as how the EU countries and Rwanda will divide responsibilities for the refugees’ wellbeing, have not yet been revealed.

“There are still some technical things that have to be solved, including where [the responsibility of ] Europe ends and where Rwanda starts,” Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen told POLITICO after the plan’s announcement.

Human rights groups don’t believe the countries can come up with a framework that will guarantee migrants’ rights are respected.

Rwanda has an abysmal human rights record, is responsible for serious abuses and war crimes in eastern Congo and engages in transnational repression, Judith Sunderland, senior associate director in the refugee and migrant rights division of Human Rights Watch, told POLITICO.

“No amount of nominal safeguards will be sufficient to mitigate the risks of serious human rights violations, particularly as there is unlikely to be any way to implement effective monitoring or seek accountability,” she said. “Given its track record, the fact that Rwanda was even considered, much less chosen, justifies deep skepticism about EU rhetoric about respecting people’s rights.”

Nektaria Stamouli contributed reporting.

What the EU can learn from Mark Carney on digital sovereignty

At Davos earlier this year, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney offered a compelling response to a world increasingly shaped by great-power rivalry. Middle powers need greater strategic autonomy, he argued, but they cannot secure it by retreating behind their borders.

Instead, they need to build their own capabilities while working more closely with like-minded partners. On technology, he reasoned that countries should cooperate so they are not ultimately forced to choose between “hegemons and hyperscalers.”

At the recent EU-Canada Summit, that philosophy began to translate into policy. Canada and the EU launched an “Alliance for the Future” based on closer economic, technological and strategic cooperation. They also concluded negotiations on a Digital Trade Agreement designed to support a “secure, open and trusted digital environment”​ resilient economic relations​,​ and trusted cross-border data flows.

That principle matters not only for Europe’s new relationship with Canada, but for its approach to other trusted partners.

Sovereignty without isolation

Like Canada, Europe has diagnosed its technology problem correctly. It depends too heavily on a handful of providers for the cloud, computing power, digital infrastructure and ​artificial intelligence (​AI​)​ models underpinning its economy and security.

Reducing those dependencies will require Europe to put its money where its mouth is, including by unlocking more diversified private investment. Mario Draghi estimated that the EU needs an additional €750 billion to €800 billion of investment each year until 2030. The European Commission, meanwhile, wants to mobili​z​​​e €200 billion for AI and at least triple Europe’s data cent​er​​​ capacity within five to seven years.

Europe cannot expect investment on an unprecedented scale while narrowing the field of companies able to provide it.

But Europe’s approach risks moving in the opposite direction. ​ ​It could exclude some of the businesses investing most heavily in the continent and building European capabilities, while favo​ring others that remain dependent on non-European technology.

That is the risk confronting policymakers as they shape the Cloud and AI Development Act. The legislation seeks to influence not only how Europe expands and secures its technological capabilities, but also which companies can take part.

Herein lies the core trade-off.​ ​ Europe cannot expect investment on an unprecedented scale while narrowing the field of companies able to provide it. Whether it closes its technology gap will depend partly on its ability to draw on the capital and expertise of experienced, trusted partners.

Look beyond ownership

The debate over digital sovereignty therefore needs to move beyond the simplistic question of ownership or headquarters.

A definition based principally on corporate nationality could exclude trusted companies with decades of investment, infrastructure and employment across Europe. It could also protect nominally European suppliers without necessarily making Europe more secure or resilient.

Effective sovereignty should mean that Europe can keep essential services running during a crisis, protect critical systems and retain a choice of secure, trusted suppliers. Assessments should therefore examine who controls data, encryption, operations, security and continuity.

Corporate nationality is relevant, but it cannot answer these questions on its own. A cloud provider may be EU-owned yet rely on processors, software and security tools developed elsewhere. Another may be headquartered outside the EU but operate European data cent​er​​​s, employ European engineers, place data and encryption keys under European control​,​ and comply with demanding European regulation. Any nationality test alone tells policymakers little about which arrangement provides greater sovereignty.

​​ ​In practice, sovereignty done right depends on who can access critical systems, where operational decisions are taken, whether data and encryption remain protected and, ultimately, whether services continue when normal arrangements fail.

Nationality should carry the greatest weight where a provider is controlled from a country that presents a recognized security threat, or where the relevant jurisdiction has the capacity and record of exploiting technological dependencies. ​​The strictest restrictions are justified where foreign interference could threaten national security, including defense, law enforcement and the most essential public services.

Countries such as Switzerland, Canada​ ​and the UK should not automatically fall into the same category as recognized security threats. Where the security conditions do not apply, nationality-based restrictions risk becoming protectionist rather than protective.

Instead, Europe should apply three tests for trusted partners and domestic firms alike: whether operational control rests in Europe; whether the service can continue during a crisis; and whether the provider makes a substantial, long-term contribution to Europe’s technological capacity.

​​In practice, sovereignty done right depends on who can access critical systems, where operational decisions are taken, whether data and encryption remain protected and, ultimately, whether services continue when normal arrangements fail.

Telecoms is a case in point. Regardless of where they are headquartered, operators must keep essential services running through cyberattacks, power failures and supply-chain disruption while protecting the confidentiality of EU data.

A company’s registered address answers none of those operational questions.

Build with trusted partners

This matters beyond the Cloud and AI Development Act. The approach Europe takes to sovereignty could shape policy toward​ ​telecommunications, satellites, semiconductors and other strategic technologies.

Rules that exclude trusted foreign investors primarily on the basis of nationality risk fragmenting the market and deterring some of the capital and experti​se Europe is trying to attract. They could also encourage reciprocal restrictions on European companies operating abroad.

The better approach is the one Carney has begun to articulate: build domestic capability while deepening cooperation with countries that share your security interests and can contribute technology, infrastructure and investment.

The EU should therefore provide a route for British companies that meet demanding security, control and resilience requirements to receive equivalent treatment as trusted providers.

The EU’s developing relationship with Canada shows that this is possible. Its new Alliance for the Future explicitly combines closer economic integration with technological cooperation, security and resilience, while the Digital Trade Agreement seeks to remove unjustified barriers while maintaining strong safeguards.

If deeper integration with Canada can strengthen European sovereignty, the same principle should apply to other trusted partners that meet equally demanding standards.

The obvious next test is the UK.

Britain sits outside the EU’s institutions but remains closely connected to Europe’s economy, technology sector and security. Infrastructure, investment and supply chains cross the Channel, while the UK and EU face many of the same cyber and geopolitical threats.

​​The EU should therefore provide a route for British companies that meet demanding security, control and resilience requirements to receive equivalent treatment as trusted providers, with reciprocal arrangements for qualifying European companies in the UK.

Strategic autonomy does not require strategic isolation.

The second UK-EU Summit on 20 November provides an opportunity to turn that principle into practice.

Leaders should establish a UK-EU Digital Partnership, covering the mutual recognition of trusted providers, coordinating rules affecting cloud and AI infrastructure, and the removal of unnecessary procurement barriers before they become embedded.

Such a partnership would support both sides’ sovereignty objectives by distinguishing genuine strategic dependencies from relationships that add to their resilience and security.

Europe is right to seek greater control over its technological future. But ​​Carney has identified the crucial distinction:​ ​strategic autonomy does not require strategic isolation.

Canada and the EU have begun to show what trusted partnership can look like. The UK should be next.


Disclaimer

POLITICAL ADVERTISEMENT

  • The sponsor is Vodafone Group Services Limited.
  • The political advertising is related to the EU’s Cloud and AI Development Act and the development of EU-UK digital cooperation.

More information here.

5 countries announce plan to deport failed asylum-seekers to Rwanda

16 November 2026 at 17:57

VIENNA — Five European Union countries plan to open a deportation hub in Rwanda for rejected asylum seekers, Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker said Monday.

“If people without the right of residence in the EU cannot be removed, our entire asylum system is made a mockery of. And we are not going to allow that,” Stocker said.

Stocker, Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen and government ministers from those two countries plus the Netherlands, Germany and Greece announced the plan at a press conference. The ministers stopped short of confirming they had cemented a deal, but said the hub would become operational during 2027.

There are still some “technical things” that have to be “sorted out,” Frederiksen said. “But the framework, the idea and the partnership is now in place.”

A reform of EU legislation adopted earlier this year made it possible for countries to negotiate deals to set up such deportation centers — as long as they comply with fundamental rights obligations.

The five countries plan to transfer people to Rwanda who have already gone through full asylum proceedings and were ordered to leave the EU.

The countries said they intend to target adults without children, and specifically people who don’t cooperate — or whose home countries don’t collaborate — in the deportation process. 

“For me, today marks a crucial step towards a new migration system; a system that safeguards the cohesion of our societies and answers the concerns of our citizens. To put it very short, it needs to be a democratic decision who can enter and who can stay in our societies,” Frederiksen said.

Staying in Rwanda

The five countries want to set up a reception center with the capacity to register and process 100 people at a time. Rejected asylum seekers who decide to stay in Rwanda rather than return to their country of origin would be given a residence permit and support to find a job and learn the language.

Rwanda’s Interior Minister Vincent Biruta said he expected few would opt to stay, but insisted that those who do “are not going to be kept in a camp … they’ll be integrated in our society.” 

“Those transferred to Rwanda will have the opportunity to settle, integrate into Rwandese society and build a new future,” said Dutch Foreign Affairs Minister Tom Berendsen.

When sending migrants to Rwanda, their protection would remain a “key priority,” he said. The partnership would also have to meet the principle of non-refoulement, which forbids countries from forcing people to countries where they might be under threat, as well as other principles of international and European law, Berendsen added.

Rwanda has “considerable experience in hosting refugees” and a “strong track record of working with international organizations, including the International Organization for Migration (IOM) and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees(UNHCR),” the Dutch minister said, adding that the five countries want to continue working with these organizations.

It’s not yet clear whether the IOM will be involved. In a statement Monday, the U.N. organization confirmed it had received a request from Rwanda to support EU return hub arrangements. “IOM has indicated that it can support in principle, provided its mandate and international standards can be upheld,” the organization said.

Civil society groups are not convinced.

In a joint reaction, 47 human rights, civil society and trade union groups warned that European authorities had previously reported “torture in detention, arbitrary arrests and impunity within the security services” in Rwanda, as well as a “real risk” of refoulement.

EU countries’ partnership “signals that Member States accept the risk of serious human rights violations against one of the most marginalized groups in society, in return for a deterrence goal that evidence clearly suggests they will not reach,” they wrote in a call on the EU to protect human rights. 

“I think we need to go beyond the existing cliché,” Biruta said on Monday. Rwanda is hosting more than 150,000 refugees “from as far as Afghanistan, from Sudan, Congolese, Burundians, and their rights were respected,” and it’s asking for a return hub system that meets “international law, European law and our national laws.”

The country wants to bring on board international organizations and put an independent monitoring mechanism in place, he said: “Everyone will be welcome to witness and monitor what’s happening.”

But civil society groups are worried return hubs would move vulnerable people far away from genuine oversight. 

“Looking at what we know from previous agreements with third countries, it has proven to be very difficult to guarantee any kind of human rights standard,” Meron Ameha Knikman, senior EU advocacy adviser at the International Rescue Committee, said ahead of the announcement. “It doesn’t matter what you put on paper — as long as it’s not under your jurisdiction, it’s extremely difficult if not impossible to enforce … any kind of guarantees.”

More hubs to follow

The ministers indicated that a deal with Rwanda could be the first in a string of return hub partnerships. “We are already exploring other partner countries, and I think other European countries will participate as well,” Frederiksen said.

Return hubs aren’t just about ramping up deportations, but also about sending a signal, she argued, adding that if people don’t assume they’ll get to stay after entering the EU irregularly, many would rethink their decision to attempt it. 

Frederiksen also pushed back against human rights concerns in the partnership with Rwanda.

“You have to remember that we are talking about people who don’t have a legal reason to be in Europe. It’s people who have entered illegally and that have no right to be protected in Europe or to stay,” Frederiksen said in a response to a question from POLITICO.

“What is the alternative? Is it to continue the system we have today?” she asked. “Because if you believe in human rights, I don’t like the current system. It’s broken. I have been to refugee camps outside Europe and seen with my own eyes that some of those who are most fragile … will never come to Europe because it demands a lot of money and strength to travel.”

“If the prospect of dying in the desert, being raped and tortured in Libya, or drowning at sea doesn’t deter people, it’s hard to see how the possibility of being sent to Rwanda would dissuade people,” Judith Sunderland, senior associate director in the refugee and migrant rights division of Human Rights Watch, told POLITICO.

This article has been updated

Brussels clears UniCredit takeover of Commerzbank over Berlin’s objections

16 November 2026 at 11:38

BRUSSELS — The European Commission has cleared UniCredit’s takeover of Commerzbank under EU competition rules, paving the way for the Italian lender to take control of Germany’s second-largest bank despite a two-year rearguard action fought by Berlin.

In a highly unusual move, Executive Vice President Teresa Ribera called a press conference on Monday to announce the decision — and warned that Brussels would intervene if Germany sought to prevent the Italian bank from completing the merger.

The Commission will “pay attention” to any government action surrounding the deal and defend its decision, Ribera told reporters. If a national government sought to prevent the takeover, “we would react accordingly,” she said.

Germany has opposed UniCredit’s bid since it was first announced in September 2024, with then-Chancellor Olaf Scholz denouncing it as “aggressive” and “unfriendly.” His successor Friedrich Merz softened the tone last summer, saying he wouldn’t stand in the way of the deal, while still objecting to how UniCredit went about it.

Berlin is now demanding concessions, including guarantees on jobs, keeping Commerzbank’s headquarters in Frankfurt and retaining the right to appoint two members of its supervisory board — demands that UniCredit CEO Andrea Orcel has resisted.

For Brussels, the deal represents a landmark in its push to encourage cross-border banking consolidation, an ambition that has repeatedly run up against resistance from national governments.

“This is the biggest cross-border banking deal we have had since the financial crisis,” Ribera told reporters, adding that “it is part of a much bigger effort to build an integrated banking system that better serves European citizens and business, and one that is ready for the challenges ahead.”

She added that the Commission’s unconditional approval of the deal was “a good example of the kind of cross-border merger that can deliver positive scaling up of EU banks, improve their efficiency and help them better compete internationally.”

No competition concerns

The Commission found that the deal raised no competition concerns, citing the banks’ moderate joint market share in Germany and the presence of several credible rivals.

UniCredit and Commerzbank’s combined market capitalization would equal only around a fifth of that of Wall Street titan JPMorgan.

But the political battle isn’t over. The German government still holds a 13 percent stake in Commerzbank — a legacy of the bank’s bailout during the 2009 financial crisis — and is seeking to retain influence over the lender after the takeover.

Orcel said during UniCredit’s latest earnings call that he would call a shareholder vote at Commerzbank to appoint a new supervisory board immediately after gaining control of the German lender.

EU rules strictly limit the grounds on which governments can intervene in mergers, including on public security grounds. The Commission has previously clashed with the Italian and Spanish governments over their attempts to influence banking mergers.

The EU’s revamped merger guidelines, a key deliverable of Ribera’s mandate due to land by the end of the year, are expected to further highlight the limits of government intervention in banking deals.

This article has been updated.

EU chief diplomat Kallas blasts Russian peace demands as ‘absurd’

16 November 2026 at 11:24

BRUSSELS — EU chief diplomat Kaja Kallas blasted Russian demands for concessions in its war against Ukraine as “absurd” on Monday, arguing that it’s up to Moscow to move first to end a war that it started.

“The Russian demands are maximum demands and really absurd,” she told journalists on her way into a gathering of foreign ministers in Brussels. “They are using this usual playbook that they have where they present a lot … and then even put additional asks so that when they walk back from them they seem reasonable.”

Russia’s demands to end its five-year war include getting Ukraine to fully withdraw from the Donbas region, permanent neutral status for Kyiv and forcing NATO to pull back to its 1997 borders — similar demands to those Moscow put forward just before its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, per several reports.

EU leaders and foreign ministers, by contrast, insist that Moscow must accept a ceasefire as a first step in any negotiation, while Finland’s defense minister has blasted suggestions that his country would withdraw from NATO as “absolutely outrageous.”

“We have to be very clear-eyed,” Kallas went on. “Whoever is the team that is negotiating, we should ask them, did you ask for something in return? Not only what we can offer. We have leverage that is the sanctions and … the frozen assets,” she added, referring to more than €200 billion in Russian immobilized assets currently being held by Belgium-based Euroclear.

The comments come after EU leaders settled on a negotiating team including representatives from Poland, Germany, Italy, France and the United Kingdom, plus the European Council and Commission, to represent them in future Ukraine peace talks. 

Kallas, whose job description includes foreign and security policy, is not part of the team. Officials close to the talks argue that the high representative isn’t involved because her U.S. counterpart, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, is not involved and the talks are not happening at foreign minister level but among national security advisers.

Asked what role she and the EU foreign ministers could play in the talks, she pitched her European External Action Service as crucial support for the negotiators. 

“The leaders decided so it’s their decision,” she said when asked about her absence from future talks. “I have the foreign ministers every single month. I have the experts in the EEAS that know the previous negotiations, that are experts on Russia, so I can continue working on the substance.”

Lithuanian Foreign Minister Kęstutis Budrys voiced support for Kallas being on the team: “We will see what the final lineup will be, so to speak, because it wasn’t agreed who specifically. I am convinced that the high representative is perfectly suited.”

Now that the EU has agreed on its negotiating team, capitals must decide on a mandate for them before the next round of Ukraine talks, which is expected after a meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, China, according to senior EU officials.

Austria circulated a paper, seen by POLITICO, spelling out 15 points as a potential basis for such a mandate, including proposals for limited ceasefires paving the way to a larger truce, “strategic use” of EU leverage with sanctions and an international ceasefire-monitoring framework.

Still, other foreign ministers are doubtful about the negotiations’ chances of success.

“To be completely honest, I don’t have high hopes [on the talks]. Russia is still not interested in discussing peace in a serious way … we must change Putin’s calculus by increasing support to Ukraine and increasing pressure on Russia,” said Swedish Foreign Minister Maria Malmer Stenergard.

EU foreign ministers are due to discuss upcoming sanctions on Russia as well as a possible mandate for the negotiating team at the Foreign Affairs Council meeting.

Europe’s moment to lead: Backing research in a global race

16 November 2026 at 05:00

Europe’s population is aging, with an increased burden of chronic diseases: more than half of adults in the European Union are now overweight and one in six is obese.1 In parallel, we are exposed to new threats from biosecurity, the malicious use of artificial intelligence, climate-related health threats and drug-resistant superbugs.

We are not passive bystanders. European teachers, biologists, nurses and manufacturers have all played a role in developing innovations that protect our populations and help them thrive. Now is not the time to step back. We believe health research and innovation are economic drivers of Europe’s future, not discretionary costs. Backing research in health as a pillar of our future in a global race is the right choice. It enables Europe to lead and support sustainable growth, as a pillar of the new architecture of global health.

We believe health research and innovation are economic drivers of Europe’s future, not discretionary costs.

The evidence is all around us. A vaccine developed against tuberculosis has been a frontline bladder cancer treatment for over 40 years,2 technology first developed for a malaria vaccine now helps protect millions against shingles,3 and mRNA research, developed over decades, enabled Europe’s fastest-ever vaccine response to Covid-19.4 Scientific progress rarely remains confined to the place or problem where it begins.

Public budgets are under pressure, but these achievements show what investment in global health research can deliver. Pressure can be a catalyst, focusing minds, sharpening priorities and turning constraints into innovative breakthroughs. Too often, the debate is framed in terms of what Europe gives. Too rarely is it framed in terms of what Europe and its people receive in return. With commitment, we can find pragmatic ways to maximize our investments as a union.

Building on its strengths in life sciences, Europe can advance its health sovereignty and seize the emerging opportunities in scientific discovery, next-generation vaccines and biomanufacturing. Basic and applied research become new technologies, intellectual property, skilled jobs and revenues that protect European health, growth and wealth. Together, these returns are Europe’s Health Dividend.

Europe’s health, security and prosperity depend on its ability to contribute to, and benefit from, global networks of research and innovation. Retreating from global research would not reduce vulnerability; it would increase it. Investing and engaging beyond our borders is a strategic imperative for Europe.

Retreating from global research would not reduce vulnerability; it would increase it. Investing and engaging beyond our borders is a strategic imperative for Europe.

At a time when public investment must deliver its value, we can find ways to maximize the impact of European money by working and funding a shared agenda together, not as disjointed nations. Health research remains one of the clearest examples of an investment that strengthens Europe’s future while delivering benefits today.

Back Europe’s Health Dividend. Sign the declaration.

SIGNATORIES

Europe’s Health Dividend is funded by the Gates Foundation and Coefficient Giving.


References

  1. Eurostat. Over half of adults in the EU are overweight. 4 September 2026. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/w/ddn-20260904-1
  2. Kluemper A, Morris K, Mellon MJ. From plague to the promise: The journey of Bacille Calmette–Guérin. Bladder. 2024;11(4):e21200022. https://doi.org/10.14440/bladder.2024.0035
  3. Impact Global Health. From malaria research to protecting aging populations: AS01 Adjuvant in Shingrix. https://www.impactglobalhealth.org/insights/report-library/shingrix-vaccine
  4. European Medicines Agency. EMA recommends first COVID-19 vaccine for authorisation in the EU. 21 December 2020. https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/news/ema-recommends-first-covid-19-vaccine-authorisation-eu

Disclaimer

POLITICAL ADVERTISEMENT

  • The sponsor is Europe’s Health Dividend.
  • The advertisement is linked to investment in global health research and development and its contribution to Europe’s health, security, resilience and economic competitiveness.

More information here.

Estonia to close border with Russia after ‘sabotage attack’ on defense firm

15 November 2026 at 15:32

Estonia says it will close its border with Russia from the start of December after accusing Russia’s military intelligence service of ordering an attempted arson attack on an Estonian drone maker.

Intruders were found at Threod Systems in Viimsi, outside Tallinn, shortly after 3 a.m. on Saturday trying to break into the building with the aim of setting it on fire and causing an explosion, Prosecutor General Astrid Asi said Sunday.

Following the incident, Estonian Foreign Minister Margus Tsahkna wrote on X: “Following clear evidence that Russia’s military intelligence service GRU ordered a sabotage attack against an Estonian defense industry company, Estonia will close all Estonian-Russian border crossing points as of 1 December.”

He added: “Russia must understand that hostile actions against Estonia come with consequences. Attempts to intimidate, destabilise, or undermine our security will not go unanswered.”

Threod’s security staff stopped the attack before it could cause significant damage, authorities said. Eight suspects, all residents of neighboring Latvia, were detained. Five have been remanded in custody.

Estonia’s Internal Security Service, known as KAPO, said intelligence gathered by its officers showed the attack was commissioned by Russia’s GRU military intelligence agency. Threod makes long-range reconnaissance and attack drones.

Estonian Prime Minister Kristen Michal said Sunday: “This is part of Russia’s broader hybrid war against Europe, with the aim of decreasing support to Ukraine and pressure on Russia. We will not be intimidated.”

The Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs has been contacted for comment on the allegations.

The latest attempt follows an August arson attack on Milrem Robotics, which supplies unmanned ground vehicles to Ukraine. Estonian authorities formally blamed Russian intelligence for that incident in September.

KAPO has warned that Russia is increasingly targeting European defense manufacturers to disrupt military production and deliveries to Ukraine. The investigation into Saturday’s attempted attack remains ongoing.

This article has been updated.

Ukraine claims thousands of Russian casualties and a slowing Kremlin advance

15 November 2026 at 04:00

DNIPRO, Ukraine — Heavy Russian losses are one of the reasons for Moscow’s slowing advance in Ukraine this year, the commander of the country’s Air Assault Forces said.

“Even though the Russian offensive continues, the enemy is not demonstrating rapid operational successes that would allow it to advance quickly. They are slowing down,” Maj. Gen. Oleh Apostol told a group of journalists in a secure location on Tuesday.

“If they capture a single tree line in a month, that hardly constitutes an operational success upon which further gains can be built,” Apostol said.

Russian casualties are rising, according to the commander and to NATO officials.

“In the past few months, Russia has been losing more than 40,000 troops — killed or seriously wounded — every month. The United States in 14 years, in Vietnam, lost 56,000. Here in one month, Russia, dead or seriously wounded, 40,000. And in October, early reporting indicates this number may have climbed to over 50,000,” NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte said this week.

Neither Ukraine nor Russia publishes their exact military losses.

The Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies this summer estimated that Russian forces had suffered about 1.4 million casualties, including 400,000 to 450,000 fatalities, from the start of the full-scale invasion through June 2026. It estimated Ukrainian casualties at 525,000 to 625,000, including 125,000 to 150,000 fatalities, over the same period.

Despite rising casualties, the Russian military continues to press forward but is making few lasting gains, Apostol said. He estimated that Ukrainian forces had retaken more than 800 square kilometers from Russian forces this year as the result of two local counteroffensive operations.

Ukraine’s offensives have both a military and a political meaning as they show Kyiv is successfully resisting Russian pressure, Apostol said.

In his view, successes on the battlefield provide additional arguments for continuing military aid from Kyiv’s allies, while a lack of positive momentum could increase external pressure to negotiate.

“Ukrainian counter-offensive actions refute Russian claims regarding the impossibility of further resistance and strengthen Ukraine’s arguments in its engagement with international partners,” the general said.

Apostol said that many of Moscow’s claimed successes are propaganda efforts that do not mark real territorial gains and that lower-level commanders may mislead their superiors about the actual situation on the battlefield.

When it’s impossible to demonstrate real success, Russian forces use individual soldiers with flags to film proof of control over entire areas, Apostol said, adding that such soldiers are usually quickly killed by Ukrainian forces.

“A Russian flag at a given position does not necessarily mean that the location has actually been captured and is being held,” he said.

Claims and counter-claims

During the latest round of U.S.-led peace talks this week, Russia claimed it had occupied half of the territory in the Donbas that is currently under Ukrainian control, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said.

“So the Russians think and they share that they really occupied half of the territory of Donbas, which we control really,” he said, adding that Russian leader Vladimir Putin was being misinformed and that Kremlin negotiators were trying to use exaggerated territorial claims to influence the U.S.

“I think that Putin lives a little bit in different information,” Zelenskyy said. “It’s a different reality. And of course, he is sharing with America.”

Russia is claiming that it has taken 6,500 square kilometers of Ukrainian territory this year, while the Institute for the Study of War think tank estimates that the real total is a Russian net gain of only 73 square kilometers.

Putin is “trying once again to breathe life into the myth of inevitable Russian military victory in order to persuade the United States and other supporters of Ukraine to compel Kyiv to surrender,” ISW wrote.

Apostol underlined that Ukraine is being very careful in its operations to try and minimize troop losses because of its lack of manpower.

“You must attack where success is possible,” Apostol said, adding that Ukraine favors localized attacks instead of a massive counteroffensive. In many cases, the goal is to stabilize the frontline and not to take more territory. “Launching an offensive against a well-prepared enemy force that holds a numerical advantage may fail to yield the desired outcome,” he said.

Ukraine has a much smaller population than Russia and has had difficulties in recruiting new forces and preventing soldiers from deserting.

“If a person is treated like a dog, they might go AWOL,” Apostol said.

Finland rejects reported Russian demand to leave NATO as part of peace talks

14 November 2026 at 10:57

Finland has rejected a reported Russian demand that it leave NATO as part of Ukraine peace talks, with Defense Minister Antti Häkkänen saying its membership in the alliance wasn’t up for negotiation. 

“Such matters are in no way a matter for negotiation. Russia knows that. This is absolutely outrageous to even suggest such a thing,” Häkkänen told reporters on Friday, according to Finnish broadcaster Yle. Finland, which shares a 1,340-kilometer border with Russia, joined NATO in 2023 in a foreign policy U-turn prompted by the full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

German newspaper Bild reported that a Russian proposal made during talks in Abu Dhabi this week included Moscow keeping occupied Ukrainian territories, gaining control of new swathes of land, demilitarizing ports in Ukraine, removing NATO bases from the Baltics, and Finland leaving NATO.

Russia proposed withdrawing its nuclear weapons from Belarus and refraining from stationing intermediate-range missiles there in exchange, Bild reported. 

But it remains unclear which proposals Russian President Vladimir Putin would support after discussions between intermediaries, according to the report. 

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said a new security framework for Europe for after the war raised by the Americans “can be dangerous.”

“Russia certainly cannot make decisions on behalf of all the societies that are members of NATO,” he told reporters on Friday.

Zelenskyy’s comments were not in direct response to the demands reported by Bild, but came after a meeting between Zelenskyy and U.S. envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner on Thursday in Dublin. 

“Putin’s desire to change borders in Europe is a fact. I am sure this is part of his concept of revising security guarantees in Europe. This is dangerous because, in my view, it is precisely things like this that lead to wars or escalations,” Zelenskyy said.

EU countries to announce deportation hub deal with Rwanda

EU countries are set to announce a deal on Monday to send rejected migrants to a deportation hub in Rwanda, three people familiar with the scheme confirmed.

Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands have been meeting regularly to lay the groundwork for a deal with to set up centers outside EU territory to which they can deport migrants without a legal right to stay in the EU. The deal is part of a broader push by the bloc to gain greater control over who enters the EU — and who gets to stay.

The anticipated deal, which is set to be announced in Vienna, would only apply to asylum seekers who have already run through all of their options for securing legal residence in the EU and were rejected.

The countries previously confirmed that they aim to close the first deals to set up the off-shore centers in 2026, with plans to make them operational as of next year.

The deportation hub in Rwanda would function as a pilot project and deals with other countries and involving other EU countries are likely to follow.

A recent reform of EU rules made it possible for EU members to cut deals to set up such deportation hubs with other countries on the condition that they meet international human rights standards.

Specifics of the scheme, including the nationalities of the people that would be moved to the hubs, their living conditions there and oversight of the deal, all depend on the agreement countries cut.

But human rights groups have warned that the hubs risk opening the door to human rights abuses, far removed from EU oversight or recourse.

Plans by the Conservative British government plans to deport asylum seekers to Rwanda were slapped down by the U.K. Supreme Court in 2023, which ruled the scheme unlawful. After coming into power in 2024, the Labour government shelved the plans, with then-Prime Minister Keir Starmer calling the Rwanda plan “dead and buried.”

The U.K. had aimed to move people to Rwanda to process their applications remotely, whereas the incoming deal of the EU countries would target people who have been ordered to leave the bloc’s territory.

Seb Starcevic contributed to this report.

Pluralistic: The EU should go big and hard over border IT failure (10 Nov 2026)


Today's links



Two men in 1960s business-wear peer into the guts of a refrigerator-sized computer cabinet. In the foreground is a huge crowd of 1930s-era people, jostling to get in. Behind the scene is a 1950s airplane on a runway. Floating in the sky are warped, fuzzy EU flag stars.

The EU should go big and hard over border IT failure (permalink)

If the EU has a future as a political project, it will have to be as a living, breathing repudiation of Ronald Reagan's maxim that "The nine most terrifying words are 'I’m from the government and I’m here to help.'"

In other words, the EU's future depends on its ability to publicly perform competence and capacity. The EU is a technocratic project, and the one trait technocrats must show is undeniable technical competence. This is the secret of Zohran Mamdani's administration: being seen in public, constantly fixing things that are broken, and making things that work even better:

https://www.nyc.gov/content/100days/pages/

This is a goal that is largely incompatible with charismatic megaprojects, and unfortunately, that's the EU's favorite kind of project: something big and splashy and worthy of the extreme effort required to squeeze anything through the Byzantine EU approvals process:

https://backofmind.substack.com/p/the-planning-system-system

Even more unfortunate is that the EU isn't just a technocratic project, it's a neoliberal technocratic project, so when it does embark on one of these megaprojects, it almost always does so as a "public-private partnership" that sees vast sums transferred to private firms to carry out public works. Since megaprojects are always over-budget and behind schedule, this creates the perfect conditions for absolute banditry, in which private companies overcharge and underdeliver, and before you know it, you're billions poorer and back in Reagan's "most terrifying words" territory.

Here's a perfect example: Schengen is a region of (mostly) EU countries who have opened their borders to one another. Once you've crossed into any of the 29 Schengen countries, you can generally stroll into any of the other Schengen countries without showing a passport or having your bags searched:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area

This is an awfully convenient system…once you're inside of Schengen. But the Schengen agreement means that each of the member states is trusting the other states to manage a common border, a task that is made all the more urgent by the fascist international, whose far right parties have whipped millions of otherwise sensible people into a xenophobic frenzy over migration. This has led to a kind of bureaucracy-shifting exercise that removed all the complexity from inter-Schengen borders and concentrated it at the borders between each Schengen country and the rest of the world.

Under this system, every Schengen country must accurately log the passage of every non-Schengen person into and out of the region. If you fly into Rome and out of Helsinki, then both the Italian and Finnish border guards must be cognizant of that fact and correctly log it. To make matters even more complex, visa-free access to Schengen is restricted to 90 days in the entire region out of any given 180-day period. For example, last month I was stranded in Frankfurt overnight thanks to a canceled flight. If I had totaled 90 days out of the previous 180 in Schengen, I would not have been allowed out of the airport's secure area until midnight, when the day ticked over and now my total would be 89 days out of 180 (thankfully, I was able to leave the airport and stay in a crummy airport hotel instead of sleeping on the floor of the airport).

To manage this system, the EU commissioned several giant IT companies to build a networked, biometric border-crossing system. Under the spec, the system would track those 90-day windows for everyone who passed in and out of Schengen, using fast fingerprint/facial scans to move people swiftly through any border crossing in the 29 Schengen countries.

It is a gross understatement to call this system behind schedule and overbudget. The Entry Exit System (EES) was supposed to roll out in 2022, but it didn't go live until October 2025 – whereupon it completely, catastrophically failed, despite having doubled its budget:

https://www.theregister.com/security/2025/09/25/eu-to-register-fingerprints-faces-for-short-stay-visitors/1141501

It's been more than a year since EES went live and it is still an absolute disaster. Travelers arriving or leaving Schengen are frequently hit with multi-hour delays. Numerous flights have been canceled, and airlines who fly without waiting for passengers in the immobile, snaking lines must rebook those passengers and endure their wrath. At major airports, it's routine for border guards to simply suspend their use of the EES system, waving through passengers without registering them in the system:

https://eesqueue.com/

EES is a disaster for aviation operations and border crossings. Any true reckoning with its costs wouldn't stop at the hundreds of millions of euros paid to private sector partners, but also the hundreds of millions more in costs borne by travelers and airlines, to say nothing of the opportunity costs paid by travelers who made it through the checkpoints through the brute-force expedient of leaving hours of extra time for a broken border formality.

Which means that the disaster isn't merely a logistics crisis, it's also a credibility and legitimacy crisis. A year (and counting) of headlines about this dismal failure of an IT system has further eroded public confidence in the EU's technical capabilities. How can the EU claim to be a sound technocratic steward of the vast administrative challenges facing a 27-state transnational entity when it can't make the computers work, and when those failures produce the very visible phenomenon of gigantic queues of fuming passengers?

(Not just fuming, either: when I was stuck in Frankfurt last month, there were at least half a dozen travelers who were loudly sobbing as they realized they were going to miss their flights home.)

The contractors for this nonfunctional, grossly overbudget, years-late project (IBM, Atos, and Leonardo) are now being sued, but – incredibly – the EU kept the lawsuit a secret. The only reason we know that IBM, Atos, and Leonardo are facing the EU in court is that the FT spotted an inconspicuous note in the annual financial statements for eu-LISA (the European Union Agency for the Operational Management of Large-Scale IT Systems in the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice):

https://www.eulisa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/documents/fy2025_eu-lisa_faa.pdf

The secrecy of this lawsuit is another mark against the EU's technical competence. Any administrative system that relies on private-sector outsourcing to carry out its essential projects must have a core competency in overseeing those private partners, which includes loudly and mercilessly punishing those partners when they fail.

By keeping the suit secret, the eu-LISA telegraphs that the fault lies with the EU, not with IBM, Atos, and Leonardo, who racked up hundreds of millions in fees and delivered a very broken, very late system that ruined the days (and voyages) of millions of travelers:

https://www.theregister.com/public-sector/2026/11/10/eus-212m-border-it-project-lands-ibm-and-atos-in-legal-water/5308669

Anyone who's ever watched a large IT consultancy firm run one of these large projects knows that this kind of bungling and gouging is par for the course. The old adage that "no one ever got fired for buying IBM" does not mean that IBM can deliver a functional IT system; it means that when IBM fucks up your project, you can escape any blame because they're the gold standard for fucking up.

Every time the EU lets these companies off the hook without a big, splashy public reckoning, they reinforce Reagan's "most terrifying words" maxim. As Voltaire wrote, "Sometimes you must execute an admiral to encourage the others." The EU should be dragging these IT bandits in public, every day, naming the top executives who oversaw the project.

They should do this every time there's a problem with a private contractor, but EES is especially ripe for this kind of treatment. That's because EES whacked a ton of rich, powerful people. Those are the sort of people who might otherwise run cover for giant, bungling, wildly profitable IT consulting firms, but who are also the most reliably pissy, vindictive dickheads about anything that affects them personally. These are the sorts of people you definitely want inside your tent, pissing out – but in hiding its lawsuit under a bushel, the EU has invited them to stand outside its tent and piss in.


Hey look at this (permalink)



A shelf of leatherbound history books with a gilt-stamped series title, 'The World's Famous Events.'

Object permanence (permalink)

#20yrsago Toothpick sculptures https://web.archive.org/web/20061107232205/https://landmarksofsf.com/photoindex.html

#20yrsago Computer-human interaction that gives hands their due respect https://worrydream.com/ABriefRantOnTheFutureOfInteractionDesign/

#15yrsago Warner Bros admits it sends takedown notices for files it hasn’t seen and doesn’t own https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/11/warner-admits-it-issues-takedowns-for-files-it-hasnt-looked-at/

#15yrsago Understanding McDonald’s as a commodities broker with a restaurant sideline: the McRib https://www.theawl.com/2011/11/a-conspiracy-of-hogs-the-mcrib-as-arbitrage/

#15yrsago Why we get the future of tech wrong https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUXh-GPa5dI

#15yrsago Fake British WWII passport for Hitler https://web.archive.org/web/20120608185357/https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/museum/item.asp?item_id=46

#15yrsago French court sends EDF execs to jail for hacking, spying on Greenpeace https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-15683090

#10yrsago Trump Administration: a climate denier for the EPA, a Goldman-Sachs banker for Treasury https://www.politico.com/story/2016/11/who-is-in-president-trump-cabinet-231071

#10yrsago How science fiction can help us survive Trump’s America https://www.nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/the_prospect_be/

#10yrsago Clinton’s data-driven “ground game” sucked in exactly the same way “targeted ads” suck, for the same reason https://web.archive.org/web/20161111084125/http://tomewing.tumblr.com/post/152963356681/polls-etc

#10yrsago The first transgender suicide hotline: 877-565-8860 https://translifeline.org/

#5yrsago Risk compensation considered harmful https://pluralistic.net/2021/11/10/elfin-safety/#mene-mene-tekel

#1yrago "Flexible labor" is a euphemism for "derisking capital" https://pluralistic.net/2025/11/10/zero-sum-zero-hours/#that-sounds-like-a-you-problem


Upcoming appearances (permalink)

A photo of me onstage, giving a speech, pounding the podium.



A screenshot of me at my desk, doing a livecast.

Recent appearances (permalink)



A grid of my books with Will Stahle covers..

Latest books (permalink)



A cardboard book box with the Macmillan logo.

Upcoming books (permalink)

  • "The Post-American Internet," a geopolitical sequel of sorts to Enshittification, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2027
  • "Unauthorized Bread": a middle-grades graphic novel adapted from my novella about refugees, toasters and DRM, FirstSecond, April 20, 2027

  • "Enshittification, Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It" (the graphic novel), Firstsecond, 2027

  • "The Memex Method," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2027



Colophon (permalink)

Today's top sources:

Currently writing:

  • “Once Is Enemy Action,” a science fiction novel about the origins of modern technofascism. Today's words: 526 (34498 total).
  • "The Post-American Internet," a sequel to "Enshittification," about the better world the rest of us get to have now that Trump has torched America. Fourth draft completed. Submitted to editor.

  • A Little Brother short story about DIY insulin PLANNING


This work – excluding any serialized fiction – is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. That means you can use it any way you like, including commercially, provided that you attribute it to me, Cory Doctorow, and include a link to pluralistic.net.

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Quotations and images are not included in this license; they are included either under a limitation or exception to copyright, or on the basis of a separate license. Please exercise caution.


How to get Pluralistic:

Blog (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

Pluralistic.net

Newsletter (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

https://pluralistic.net/plura-list

Mastodon (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

https://mamot.fr/@pluralistic

Bluesky (no ads, possible tracking and data-collection):

https://bsky.app/profile/doctorow.pluralistic.net

Medium (no ads, paywalled):

https://doctorow.medium.com/

Tumblr (mass-scale, unrestricted, third-party surveillance and advertising):

https://mostlysignssomeportents.tumblr.com/tagged/pluralistic

"When life gives you SARS, you make sarsaparilla" -Joey "Accordion Guy" DeVilla

READ CAREFULLY: By reading this, you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies ("BOGUS AGREEMENTS") that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.

ISSN: 3066-764X

US demands a seat for Europe at Ukraine peace talks

10 November 2026 at 04:37

ABU DHABI — European governments’ long-running and sometimes bad-tempered debate over who should represent them in Ukraine peace talks just became urgent. 

Donald Trump’s envoys are pressing Russia to allow Europe to join the next round of negotiations aimed at resolving the Ukraine war, according to U.S. officials granted anonymity to discuss sensitive matters. 

Trump’s son-in-law Jared Kushner and special envoy Steve Witkoff will push the case for Europe to have a direct role in future talks as they mediate the first trilateral discussion with Russia and Ukraine since February in Abu Dhabi on Tuesday, the officials said. 

European governments and EU institutions will likely not have long to decide who they want at the negotiating table on their behalf. Kushner and Witkoff want to step up the pace of the talks and for this week’s meeting to be the last without Europe’s full participation, the same officials said.

“We need Europe at the table,” one of the officials said. “So our proposal is to bring the Europeans into the discussion after this trilateral.”

The officials welcomed the fact that the leaders of Finland and Norway called Russia’s Vladimir Putin directly on Oct. 27 and said more outreach is necessary. “We need a lot more European discussions with Russia so that they could be hearing what we’re hearing and the message that they’re conveying to us they could be conveying to Russia directly.” 

The question of who speaks for Europe — and whether Ukraine’s European allies should even be speaking to Putin at all — has been deeply divisive. EU leaders will discuss the topic at an informal summit in Dublin later this week. 

Ever since Trump returned to the White House last year, EU officials and diplomats have been fretting about being left on the sidelines while the U.S. talks directly to Russia to negotiate an end to the war.

Senior European officials are due in Abu Dhabi for the meetings this week but, although Kushner and Witkoff are expected to consult them, they will not be involved in the main negotiations due to Russian objections. Those present include security advisers from the U.K., Germany, France, as well as officials from Italy, NATO, the European Commission and European Council. 

The U.S. officials said Day 1 of the talks would focus on security guarantees for Ukraine and the potential reshaping of the security architecture of Europe. Day 2 would look at territorial issues — where the borders and boundaries should be drawn — and other questions. 

European governments fear that Trump may be preparing to agree to longstanding demands from Putin to roll back NATO’s influence in the region. But the U.S. officials insisted that NATO would still be central to Europe’s collective defense, while refusing to back away from the need for a fundamental rethink of the continent’s relations with Russia. 

“Obviously something’s not working,” the same official said. Europeans have “a lot of baggage” about redrawing the security architecture because Russia had proposed various changes in the past and previous arrangements had failed, the official said. “We have to build something new that works today.”

The officials said NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte had been heavily involved in the discussions with the U.S. administration and in sharing ideas for reforms. 

On the most difficult question of all for Ukraine — the fate of Russian-occupied territory — both sides have shown “flexibility” in private, the officials said. The aim of this week’s talks is to keep up the momentum of recent weeks, rather than to deliver a final ceasefire, they added. 

But the two main tracks in the talks — territory and future security arrangements for Ukraine and Europe — must run together and be resolved together, the U.S. side said. 

Additional reporting by Scott Waldman.

Ukraine slams French far-left presidential hopeful Mélenchon

9 November 2026 at 16:32

PARIS — The Ukrainian government clapped back at French presidential hopeful Jean-Luc Mélenchon on Monday after the far-left leader said a vote could settle territorial disputes.

“‘Referendums’ under occupation are a tool of annexation, not an expression of the people’s will. No civilised, democratic country would ever accept this for its own borders, so it should not be proposed to Ukrainians,” the foreign ministry’s spokesperson Heorhii Tykhyi posted on X. He added that Ukraine previously voted in 1991, and Russia is now looking to change borders with a war.

The backlash came after Mélenchon said at a France Unbowed political rally Saturday that, if in power, he would not back territorial concessions in the war-torn country “without asking the people affected whether they agree to be on one side of the border or the other.”

“The people of Donbas … have the right to decide whether they want to be Ukrainian or Russian,” he argued, referring to a region in eastern Ukraine that is the central territorial dispute of the war with Russia.

It’s not the first time Ukrainian top officials have spatted with France’s presidential front-runners in recent weeks: Last month, the war-torn country’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy also directly replied to far-right candidate Marine Le Pen’s pledge to cut financial aid to Kyiv.

France’s staunch support for Ukraine could be dramatically overturned if Mélenchon or Le Pen wins next year in a high-stakes presidential election to replace Emmanuel Macron. According to polls, the two politicians could face off in the second round.

Like Le Pen, Mélenchon is often accused by political opponents of being soft on Moscow — accusations that are intensifying as the presidential campaign heats up.

After Saturday’s political rally, centrist Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot described the far-left leader as a “Kremlin spokesperson.” Mélenchon dismissed the accusations.

Muriel Domenach, a former French NATO ambassador now working on the campaign for center-left candidate Raphaël Glucksmann, also slammed France Unbowed’s recently released presidential platform that calls for leaving NATO and mentions Ukraine only briefly. France Unbowed lawmaker Bastien Lachaud replied, saying his party has always backed aid to Kyiv until a peace agreement is reached.

“We have made it clear from the outset of the conflict that, as long as these negotiations remain unresolved, aid to Ukraine must continue without reservation,” he said.

❌